Mr. Bonilla ENG 2D1-03 June 14, 2023 The Dominance Of Fear Over Respect In Leadership In history, leaders have been stuck on the question of whether it is better to be feared or respected as a leader. While being respected is often associated with positive messages and qualities, being a feared leader proves to be more beneficial. In Animal Farm by George Orwell, The ability to strike fear in your followers allows leaders to maintain control, eliminate resistance and establish a spirit and aura of authority and mutual respect. By analyzing the novel, Animal Farm, it is clear that it is more advantageous to be a feared leader because it is effective in maintaining order and control, eliminating resistance, and strengthening the aura and …show more content…
In Animal Farm, Napoleon, the main leader, effectively employs fear to ensure he is still the most dominant among everyone. The animals fear the wrath of Napoleon knowing that if they misbehaved that it would result in severe consequences. As a result of this Napoleon's decisions are rarely questioned and he seemingly always gets his way. Squealer, Napoleon's propaganda doll, plays a crucial role in maintaining control through fear. By threatening the animals saying that Mr. Jones would come back. Squealer instills a deep sense of fear, preventing them from challenging Napoleon's authority. However, the leaders of Animal Farm do not hesitate to resort to violence to enforce fear. Any animal that is daring enough to challenge Napoleon's authority will be eliminated ruthlessly, sending a message to the rest of the …show more content…
In Animal Farm, Napoleon's dominance is supported by striking fear in his subjects. The battles fought and won under the leadership of Napoleon’s command serve as a constant reminder of how powerful and strong he is. These victories instill fear and admiration, reinforcing the authority of Napoleon and intimidating any potential challengers. Apart from this, Napoleon distances himself by purposefully avoiding meetings. He did this to consolidate his power and to. become an “Unquestioned Leader”. This behavior added to his aura, making him a figure whose power is feared. The Death of Boxer further adds to his aura. This makes it looks like he exploits and disposes of his subjects like they meant nothing to him. This sends a chilling message to the animals leaving them in fear of his
Many people in power have used fear as a weapon and also to gain control of their country and of their people. In Greg Orwell’s Animal Farm and in real-life history, someone in power used fear as a weapon. They use fear to scare their people and to have control over them. In Animal Farm Napoleon is the one who uses fear as a weapon, and in real-life history, Hitler and Vladimir Putin use fear as the most important weapon. Fear is a scare tactic that can be the most important weapon when used by those in power.
Napoleon, similarly to Stalin, utilizes this technique throughout Animal Farm to maintain his power, control the other farm animals, and make sure there is no rebellion. Along with keeping the animals from questioning his orders and how he came to power. Controlling others becomes incredibly easy when one knows their fears. Firstly, Napoleon uses fear to maintain his power on the farm.
Squealer is the main disseminator of Napoleon’s opinion, who becomes more and more isolated as the story progresses. Squealer tends to use logos in his speeches made throughout the book, but sometimes changes parts of his strategies. Earlier on, he uses vocabulary and concepts beyond most animals to bewilder them; however, later he starts to deploy tactics of carefully choosing words and rhetorical questions that the animals can understand; they then can construe what Squealer is trying to convey in his convincing talks. In Animal Farm, by George Orwell, as time goes on, Squealer develops new tactics to convince the animals the justification of the natural leadership of the pigs, and that all animals remain equal through logos.
(P. 67) Squealer is able to manipulate and control the animals' thoughts and actions, further solidifying his and Napoleon's rule over the farm. Therefore, due to Squealer’s extensive persuasive tone and language, the animals listened and believed nearly everything he
Squealer says that “No one believes more firmly than Comrade Napoleon that all animals are equal. ”(Orwell 55). Squealer is persuading the other animals that Napoleon is the model citizen and does more for the farm than anyone else. This use of rhetoric creates the idea that the other animals aren't contributing as much as Napoleon and makes them feel ungrateful. The citizens of the Animal Farm are consistently manipulated by Squealer throughout the story and do whatever is asked of them, even as conditions worsen.
There is also the aspect of Physical fear towards the end of the book, when Napoleon has ruthless and bloodthirsty dogs accompanying him at all times. The pigs use the psychological fear of Jones’s return to control the animals and make sure there is no further rebellion. Squealer, who represents the propaganda during the Russian revolution, lies to the animals about the pig’s actions. To end any argument, he uses the phrase “You do not want Jones back.”
Don’t be the enemy. Now that Napoleon is in charge life is getting a whole lot worse because is has complete power of Animal Farm. Napoleon from Animal Farm written by Orwell maintains control by using ideology, propaganda, and fear. Napoleon uses ideology of Animalism to give him more control over the animals.
In Animal Farm, Squealer, chief propagandist, attempts to convince the animals that their lives under the regime of the animals is better than that of the humans. Squealer tries to convey this message, for example, by telling the animals that the animals would better off if Napoleon made decisions for them. Squealer says, “No one believes more firmly than Comrade Napoleon that all animals are equal. He would be only too happy to let you make your decisions for yourselves.
Through the novel, George Orwell uses Squealer character to help display the egotistical traits that human carry. Although it was not bluntly shown, he did nothing to stop how the farm was being run because he enjoyed having power over the animals. Squealer was extremely good at manipulating the animals to gain this power. Squealer had managed to convince the animals that Boxer was being brought to a hospital, even though the animals had proof that he was being brought to be butchered. “ I was at his bedside at the very last.
Furthermore, Napoleon gives the other animals the impression he was the sole leader of the rebellion on Animal farm and makes Snowball -a leader who wanted what was best for the animals- seem like an enemy who was in cahoots with Farmer Jones since long before the animals took over the farm. Napoleon and Squealer (another “fat cat” pig.) always put the blame on Snowball whenever something went wrong in the farm to avoid having the blame fall on them. Napoleon is an exemplary example of just how selfish and hypocritical people can be in furthering their own aims because he continued to subtly but purposely change the seven rules put in place as the pillars of animalism. For example, Napoleon and the other pigs move into Farmer Jones’s house and sleep in his bed after commanding “No animal shall sleep in a bed”, so he changes the commandment to read “no animal shall sleep in a bed with sheets”.
Animal Farm illustrates how leaders become corrupt when they abuse their power, treat the population differently based on their status, and the leaders manipulate and oppress the working class. Over the course of the book, Napoleon and the pigs abused their power. After an announcement about trading with the humans for supplies, Squealer
Napoleon also uses manipulation to gain and maintain a firm control by changing the Commandments for the farm in ways that work to his benefit. Squealer, Napoleon’s propaganda department, Keeps the farm animals believing in Napoleon by describing what they hear and see to make it seem harmless. Using effective tactics of fear, convincing propaganda, and manipulation, Napoleon gains and maintains control of Animal Farm. “Animal Farm” has corruption and equality in a way the animals try to succeed and achieve a goal to make the farm better. Power corrupts in “Animal Farm” because the pigs have a goal which is working together and helping one another.
In addition, Squealer often threatens the animals that Mr. Jones will return if they did not follow as instructed by Napoleon to manipulate the farm animals. For instance, pigs decided that the milk and windfall as well as the main crops of apples should be reserved for the pigs alone. Ostensibly, pigs need to be in healthy state as they claimed to be the Einstein of the welfare of the farm. Here also, Squealer threatens the animals that Jones would return if they oppose the idea. Therefore, the animals agreed with
He makes them believe everything he and the pigs are doing is for the greater good of the whole farm despite the fact that it is not. Squealer controls them in many ways but the strongest or most apparent are telling the other animals Mr. Jones their neglective abusive owner will come back, lying about Boxer the horse’s death, and finally changing the unalterable commandments into one that reads “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others”. One of the very first and most used techniques Squealer uses is instilling fear in the animals. He does this by threatening Jones’s return.
“The oppressed are allowed once every few years to decide which particular representatives of the oppressing class are to represent and repress them ( Karl Marx )”. Russia was under many decades of oppression, but that only happened due to the citizens. The lack of a good leader in the Russian Revolution led to many unnecessary situations and had terrible side effects on the nation such as poverty. George Orwell used Animal Farm to represent the important situations and people. The story was based on a farm which represented Russia during the Revolution.