You know all those stereotypes about lawyers being nasty, money-grubbing people? Well, meet Atticus Finch and Jake Brigance, two brave and courageous lawyers who stand up for righteousness and justice rather than the majority. The two characters are both southern American lawyers and loving fathers who fight against racism in their hometowns. They are both driven by an interior strength, and both are deathly loyal to their families who became targeted by those that disagreed with what the lawyers were attempting to do. In Harper Lee’s novel To Kill A Mockingbird and Joel Schumer’s movie A Time To Kill both lawyers express the similarities and differences through the way they defend their client, their experience as lawyers and the way they …show more content…
Their difference in age and Jacks lack of experience effects the way they treat the case. Atticus is Maycomb’s most respected attorney, related by family history to most of the white community in his town. He is also acquainted with the and respected by Maycomb’s black citizen. Tom Robinson’s case comes to him at the request of Judge Taylor, who knows that Atticus will do his best to give Tom a fair trial. “Link, that boy might go to the chair, but he’s not going till the truths told…And you know what the truth is” (146). This quote shows that Atticus won’t let anything get in the way of Tom having his day in court. He is determined to tell the truth that Tom did not rape Mayella Ewell no matter if everyone in the town is against him. Atticus knows he has a lot to loose for defending Tom, but he knows that if he doesn't defend him then no one will. Jake, in contrast competes in cases that will bring his reputation up. He is an up and coming attorney who in not experienced enough and needs something to boost his reputation in the town of Clanton. Jake knows that winning Carl Lee’s case will earn him a great deal of notice, such a win would advance his career in a major way. Although this wasn’t his main reason why he took the case, but it was Jake’s motivation. Jake's main reason he took the case was "When [he] looked at [his daughter] … [he] cannot help but think about Tonya,” he didn't want the same thing that happened to Tonya happen to his own daughter.The reason he took the case in the beginning was because of selfish reasons because of his feeling of guilt, and not wanting the same thing to happen to his young daughter rather than taking the case only out of the kindness of his heart, as Atticus did. Given these points, I believe that Jake taking Carl Lee’s case bring him into the black community in a new way, increasing his understanding as a young lawyer
“You did the crime, now you do the time,” this age old adage is currently being used to describe Tom Robinson and the case against him; however, Tom will no longer serve time, considering that police officers murdered him when he attempted to flee from prison. A legion of people believes that Tom Robinson’s actions ultimately led to his demise, and that he is just another worthless human. In actuality, the father of the accuser, Bob Ewell, was the cause of Tom’s death. Maycomb’s most reclusive citizen saw an opportunity to capitalize on the town’s racist nature, and gain a few seconds in the limelight. Furthermore, this newly found fame would provide a stark difference from his everyday life of being the town’s most hated resident, and hopefully
Atticus Finch, the best lawyer in Maycomb, was sitting nervously in his chair as he waited for the town Judge to arrive in court. Tom Robinson, Atticus’s client, was scared of being proved guilty of raping Mayella ,and also beating her. As the judge came in the courtroom, you could feel how tense it was between the two defendants. The judge sat down and started talking to both of them.
“All right. He choked you, he hit you, then he raped you, that right? It most certainly is” is another example of evidence (Lee 250). Atticus never asked Mayella how Tom could have done all that with one hand. Atticus didn’t question Mayella’s questions after she answered him and if he did he could have gotten more of her mixing up the truth with the lies.
He fairly upholds Tom’s case in court even when the odds are against his client winning. While many other lawyers would scorn representing a black man, Atticus defends Tom Robinson’s with a non-racist view believing that all men should have equal rights in court. Also, he questions both the defense and prosecutor’s witnesses with a very respectful tone while Mr. Gilmer, the prosecutor, harasses the defense’s witnesses but not his own. Furthermore, his friends saw Atticus as a just man. As Miss Maudie, the Finch’s neighbor, remarked, “We’re paying the highest tribute we can pay a man.
It’s a hot and humid day and all of Maycomb is gathered to find out the truth behind what happened on the evening of November 21. The person in question is Tom Robinson an African American servant. He was accused by Mayella and Bob Ewell for rape of Mayella. The defendant, Tom Robinson, is supported and assisted by defence attorney Atticus Finch who is going against prosecuting attorney Mr.Gilmer. The courthouse was filled with people from all races, where the blacks sat in the balcony and the whites sat front and center in the lower level.
The children feel it was unfair, but then again they are naïve to the racism. Atticus appears unmoved at the verdict. Atticus, a lawyer at Maycomb, supports Tom Robinson and feels as if he is innocent. Taking on the job to help defend Tom was an act of courage, seeing how everyone else was so opposed to this man because he was black. "It's when you know you're licked before you begin but you begin anyway and you see it through no matter what.
Robinson is on trial for the rape of a young white woman named Mayella Ewell. In relation with the Emmett Till case, Robinson was set to be tried in front of an all-white, all-male jury. The truth behind the trial is that it was all a cover up for Bob Ewell, Mayella’s father who beat her up when he saw her with Tom. Tom is considered very courteous, treats everyone with respect, and strives on doing the right thing (Lee). Atticus’s cross-examination of Bob Ewell is very revealing when he asks Mr. Ewell to write his name.
This permits Maycomb to ignore the ugly truth; Maycomb fails to protect Mayella and the Ewell children from abuse and poverty. By blaming Tom Robinson, Maycomb denies any abuse ever occured and alleviates their own guilt. Atticus tells Tom he has a good chance of winning the trial, but “Tom [is] tired of [a white man’s] chances and [prefers] to
Despite racial inequalities in the South, Atticus sticks to his own morals and agrees to be the defending lawyer for Tom Robinson, a black man being accused of raping a white woman. Although Atticus’ defense in court was thorough and clearly proved Tom’s innocence, the jury was prejudiced towards black folks and convicted Tom as guilty. Nonetheless, Atticus is still a hero despite losing the case. He has the courage to stand up for what he believes in, fights with reason rather than guns, and has utmost determination, making him a hero despite being just an average human being. Ultimately, his thoughts and actions set the stage for major changes in the meaning of equality throughout Maycomb County, changing lives of numerous people.
Jem further understood the true meaning of moral courage when he saw Atticus defending Tom Robinson, a black man. Although Atticus was hugely outnumbered and even cornered by Mr Cunningham and some other people, he did not back down from them. Instead, he seemed even more determined to win the case and prove Tom Robinson 's innocence to all of Maycomb County. Almost everyone in Maycomb County had criticised Atticus and his children for taking up the case of defending Tom Robinson and they were even called "nigger lovers" by many. At first, Jem did not understand why his father chose to defend Tom Robinson when he knew that people would whisper and gossip about it and that the possibility of him winning the case was very low.
He wants Maycomb to know the truth about the case, before Tom is sent to prison or to his death,“‘Link, that boy might go to the chair, but he’s not going till the truth’s told.’ Atticus’s voice was even. ‘And you know what the truth is,’”(Lee 147) . Atticus is saying that even though Tom might face a death sentence, that truth be told as it is. And Atticus knows that telling the truth, will help Tom’s side of the case in defense.
The trial taught his kids that you can’t always win, and it also taught them that wisdom is power. Tom Robinson’s trial shed light upon how biased court cases were against African Americans. Maycomb continued to be racist after the trial, but you could tell that a few of the people who were against Tom knew that Atticus was right during the court scene. Atticus uses logic to prove his point, rather than biased opinions based around stereotypes. One example of this is when he debunks the Ewells’ accusations by pointing out the fact that Tom Robinson didn’t have the ability to attack Mayella’s face because he had lost the use of his left arm.
In Tom Robinson’s court, all the people in Maycomb County were anger that Atticus would help a black person by honestly representing Robinson in a Court as his attorney, “When Atticus makes his summation to the jury, he literally bares himself to the jury's and the town's anger: he "unbuttoned his vest, unbuttoned his collar, loosened his tie, and took off his coat.” (Jones 12) Before the start of the court, Atticus was approached by a group of people who want the intention of injuring Tom Robinson, including Walter Cunningham. But Atticus always was defending Tom; however, Tom fails in this court because of irrational decisions due
Atticus could not live with himself if he failed to give his utmost effort in clearing the accused, Tom Robinson’s, name. The lawyer feels that he has to do it. The people of Maycomb are small minded and hypocritical, Atticus Finch is not. Nothing can be done to make the towns people hear the truth. Tom Robinson, would be a free man, living with his family, if it wasn’t for the people of Maycomb.
Tom Robinson is a young African-American who's been accused of raping and abusing Mayella Ewell, a young and closeted white woman. Racial discrimination is hinted throughout Tom’s trial as Atticus Finch explains to Jem that a white man’s word will always win over that of a black man’s - "... In our courts, when it's a white man's word against a black man's, the white man always wins. They're ugly, but those are the facts of life" (220). Atticus explains to Jem that in the courts of Maycomb, a black man’s state of innocence or guilt is truly determined by a white man’s testimony.