The Underground Man Analysis
DISPUTATIO METHOD FORMAT Name: Zhibek Kamalbek kyzy ID: 6411 Question: Can the Underground Man stop being the ‘Underground Man’? Your Answer (just yes or no): No Opposing Argument 1: The Underground man is able to stop being the ‘Underground man’, because he is an intelligent and ‘conscious’. He relies on that fact the consciousness helps to analyze humanity’s life. If the man were conscious, he would be able to see things behind the wall. Moreover, being aware of unexpected events is helpful in the society. Underground Man can stop being the Underground Man, simply because he has an important knowledge and these listed above qualities. …show more content…
On the one hand, he desires to accomplish his weird plans, and he feels confident about himself. On the other hand, his moral courage is not strong enough to succumb his mental fear. This makes him uncomfortable, even nervous a lot. For example, when he wants to revenge on the officer, he starts planning his retreat. The officer had treated him as he was ‘nothing’, so the narrator wanted to express his bitterness in his revenge. He prearranges every single detail of his revenge. However, at the very last moment he decides to give up. Not simply because he wants to excuse, it is for the reason that he is not capable of fighting with that officer. “I should have had a physical courage enough, I assure you; but I had not the moral courage.” (The Notes from the Underground, Fyodor Dostoevsky, Part II, Book I, page 31). Overall, this man’s nature is contradicted by his own double …show more content…
He is self-critical, and self-sadistic, and he likes to critique on others as well. “A decent man is bound to be a coward and a slave. It is the law of nature for all decent people all around the earth”. (The Notes from the Underground, Fyodor Dostoevsky, Part II, Book 1, page 32). It is well known that the society accepts people whom it can bind by its laws and rules. In contrary, the narrator is not an obedient citizen. He will not be able to start obeying others. This man is coward, but not a slave. Therefore the society cannot accept him, since he does not stop being
The Disenfranchisement Of The Invisible Man And Jim Stark
422 Words | 2 PagesAt the end of his story though, he realizes that the problems of man are trivial and naive. He stops attempting to live normally and uses his invisibility
Equality 7-2521 In Ayn Rand's Anthem
335 Words | 2 PagesThose individuals do not obey. they are independent, pursuing their values, and living their own happiness. Once Equality 7-2521 makes this relization he is able to break away from his old
Richard Wright's Allegory Of The Cave And The Man Who Lived Underground
744 Words | 3 PagesIn the Allegory of the Cave, there is a group of prisoners chained to the wall of a cave all of their lives, facing a blank wall. The people watch shadows projected on the wall from objects passing in front of a fire behind them and give names to these shadows. One prisoner is freed from the cave and comes to understand that the shadows on the wall are not reality at all. Although the prisoners were experiencing something different than what was happening outside the cave, they were still in the same reality as the people outside the cave. In the Man Who Lived Underground, Fred Daniels, a young black man unjustly accused of murdering a woman, is forced into signing a confession.
Theme For Night By Elie Wiesel
185 Words | 1 PagesThe first time he showed this characteristic was when he saw his father being beaten in front of him , and did nothing. He was shocked that he had allowed himself to act like this. He was paralyzed with fear , hoping that he himself would not be beaten. When i was reading this part of the text i was wondering why he would just sit
Douglass Underground Railroad
530 Words | 3 PagesHis claim reminded people to remain silence of the secret in the Underground
Family Secrets In Tony Palmer's Break Of Day
770 Words | 4 PagesThe book by Tony Palmer “Break of Day”, is thrilling and exciting but it also tackles so influential themes. The author expresses his feelings about world issues and many other different topics. He deals mainly with the themes of family secrets, death and bravery. In the book Palmer shows that every family has secrets, that death was always very common during war times and living on a farm back when that book was set and he also expresses his feeling about how everyone shows their true bravery and cowardice in their own time and in their own way.
Resilience In Ayn Rand's Anthem
916 Words | 4 PagesHe becomes so curious to what the tunnel is, and what is inside the tunnel that he decides to follow his thoughts into the tunnel. When the main character found the tunnel he was with other men. The other men wanted to turn their findings into the City Council, but Equality did not. He says “‘we shall not report our findings into the City Council. ’” (2.10).
The Black Struggle Of Mental Illness In Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man
1269 Words | 6 PagesEllison shows the reader through his unique characters and structure that we deny ourselves happiness, tranquility, and our own being by the ridicule of other people, and that we must meet our own needs by validating ourselves from within instead of our value being a composite of the society that ridicules our being. Ellison's own struggle and connection to mental intemperance is the one of his great differences in the world to us and to see someone else's struggle puts our own life in context. In Invisible Man a single takeaway of many is that society turns us invisible, a part of its overall machine, but we have to learn not to look through ourselves in times of invisibility and not confuse our own blindness for invisibility as one may lead to the
The Underground Man Is A Hero Essay
679 Words | 3 PagesThere Is More Than One Type of Hero In “Notes from the Underground”, a fiction book by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, the Underground Man is not like the traditional main character in most other fiction books. Often books have a tragic hero where he or she either saves the days or unfortunately is killed. But that is not the case for this book, the main character shows characteristics that do not fit along the lines of a tragic hero at all. This paper argues that the Underground Man is most definitely not the tragic hero, but instead an anti-hero.
Don Delillo Falling Man Analysis
825 Words | 4 PagesFalling Man On 11th of September America was in chaos due to an event which shocked the whole world. Two towers fell and America was at war. With people suiciding by jumping from the towers and rubble, mud and debris flying around the streets of New York, chaos thrived and people panicked.
The Underground Man In Dostoevsky's Notes From Underground
1370 Words | 6 Pages‘“Let him come, if he wants to so much, “But we have our own circle, we’re friends,”. . . Maybe we don’t want you at all”’ (Dostoevsky 65). The Underground Man invites himself to an expensive dinner with his peers who do not want him present, rather than anticipating a nice evening, he torments himself about it. “I dreamed of getting the best of them, winning them over, carrying them away, making them love me” (Dostoevsky 70).
Contradiction In Fyodor Dostoyevsky's Notes From Underground
509 Words | 3 PagesLiza, for example, treasures the qualities of romantic love while the Underground Man is incapable of love. The Underground Man’s consistent theme of contradiction is exemplified throughout the story where he experiences a multitude of emotions ranging from narcissistic and egocentric to embarrassment and humiliation. Although the Underground Man envisions himself challenging those who have wronged him, he does not have the “moral courage” to stand up for himself. By remaining in the underground, the Underground Man is able to escape from reality where is able to manufacture his own world. An argument can be made that Dostoevsky used the personal aspects of the Underground Man to show the pattern of similarities between him and contemporary society.
St. Petersburg In Crime And Punishment
1052 Words | 5 PagesSaint Petersburg, the setting of Crime and Punishment, plays a major role in the formation in Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s acclaimed novel. Dostoyevsky’s novels focus on the theme of man as a subject of his environment. Dostoyevsky paints 1860s St. Petersburg as an overcrowded, filthy, and chaotic city. It is because of Saint Petersburg that Raskolnikov is able to foster in his immoral thoughts and satisfy his evil inclinations. It is only when Raskolnikov is removed from the disorderly city and taken to the remoteness of Siberia that he can once again be at peace.
The Theme Of Power In Fyodor Dostoevsky's Notes From The Underground
844 Words | 4 PagesIn the Novella Notes From the Underground , by Fyodor Dostoevsky , the Underground Man’s constant demand for power over others leads to the Underground Man losing self-control over his thoughts and actions. In part one, the Underground man believes he is superior over others due to his powerful free will, rejecting logic and the implementations of society. This is contrasted in part two, where he utilizes the stories from romantic novels he reads while in school, and applies them to real life situations with Liza the prostitute, and the Police officer. The underground man equivalates his intelligence to power in part one. His hyperconsciousness gives him superiority over the average citizens in society due to their logic based decisions since he rejects logic because he concludes that a utopian society is absolutely unreachable and absurd.
A Psychoanalytical Analysis Of The Poem 'The Wanderer'
1034 Words | 5 PagesHe realizes he is in exile and there really is nothing he nor anyone else can do about it. By accepting his life, (luck and fate in all) of being in exile, it makes for a much calmer journey(for the time that these emotions
More about The Underground Man Analysis
The Disenfranchisement Of The Invisible Man And Jim Stark
422 Words | 2 PagesEquality 7-2521 In Ayn Rand's Anthem
335 Words | 2 PagesRichard Wright's Allegory Of The Cave And The Man Who Lived Underground
744 Words | 3 PagesTheme For Night By Elie Wiesel
185 Words | 1 PagesDouglass Underground Railroad
530 Words | 3 PagesFamily Secrets In Tony Palmer's Break Of Day
770 Words | 4 PagesResilience In Ayn Rand's Anthem
916 Words | 4 PagesThe Black Struggle Of Mental Illness In Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man
1269 Words | 6 PagesThe Underground Man Is A Hero Essay
679 Words | 3 PagesDon Delillo Falling Man Analysis
825 Words | 4 PagesThe Underground Man In Dostoevsky's Notes From Underground
1370 Words | 6 PagesContradiction In Fyodor Dostoyevsky's Notes From Underground
509 Words | 3 PagesSt. Petersburg In Crime And Punishment
1052 Words | 5 PagesThe Theme Of Power In Fyodor Dostoevsky's Notes From The Underground
844 Words | 4 PagesA Psychoanalytical Analysis Of The Poem 'The Wanderer'
1034 Words | 5 Pages