Elie believes it's better to fend for oneself rather to help one another. Elie and his father have been in Auschwitz for 3 weeks. His tent leader was had been explaining what they were to do this week. He says three days in quarantine after you will go to work and tomorrow medical checkup. He then asks Elie if he wants to get into a good unit. Elie replies of course but he adds a condition “I want to stay with my father"(Weisel 48 emphasis added). I bring this up because he was a young boy who wanted his father selfishly. He would have better chances of surviving with him. Later on while working in the warehouse his father is being beaten with a iron bar. Elie’s reaction surprises me “I kept silent. In fact. I thought of stealing away in order …show more content…
Later on the Elie is marching while the ss officers pace the jews while icy wind blows violently in their faces. Elies friend who was struggling to keep up with the pace. He no longer could keep the pace and collapsed into the snow “I soon forgot him[Zalman]. I began to think of myself again”. Elie says” I shivered with every step”(86 emphasis added)Zalman was to never be seen again. He forgets about his friend who just basically died and began to think of himself again it's ridiculous. Once arriving at Buchenwald Elies father is too weak to go on. Elies argues with his father for several minutes then he says “I listened to him without interrupting. He was right I though deep down, Not daring to admit that to myself. Too late to save your old father…”(111). Elie began to think of himself after realizing his father was soon to die and he would be alone. Elie is constantly thinking of himself instead of others. Lastly shortly after his father's death he states “And deep inside me, if I could have...I might have found something like: Free at last!…”(112 emphasis added) he felt free since he had nobody to take care of life would be easier on
The Transformation of Elie and his Father’s Relationship The Holocaust was one of the world's deadliest events in history. Before the holocaust begins Elie and his father are not close. His dad spends more time with other people and worrying about work than with his own family. The Holocaust greatly impacts their relationship.
My symbol was the block. I thought this represented the ghettos and living spaces in the camps. My first detail is that Elie stayed in a ghetto when he first got involved in the war. “Two ghettos were created in Sighet.” (Wiesel 11)
The way the officers treated the Jews made them feel like they weren't human anymore, and no better than inanimate objects. “You...you...you…” They pointed their fingers, the way one might choose cattle, or merchandise” (49). The officers acted as if the task of deciding who lived and who died was easy and required almost no thought. Again, the jewish people are not only compared to as dogs, but as merchandise.
1. After the hanging of a child, Elie hears someone say, “‘For God’s sake, where is God?’ And from within me, I heard a voice answer: ‘Where He is? This is where—hanging here from this gallows…’ That night, the soup tasted of corpses” (Wiesel 65). Though optimistic at first, Elie Wiesel, along with many others at the concentration camps, began to lose faith in God.
Elie doesn't think about his family, is what has set him free. If he would have tried to keep trying to save his dad after he got in trouble he could have been shot. Instead Elie tried to think about what could happen to him if he was to step in and so he left it alone. Elie even said, “In fact I was thinking of how to get my father away so that I would not be hit myself” (62).
Q5: After I read this book, this made me understand how much the Jews has struggled in the camps. Before I read this book, I thought the concentration camps is where Jews had to work until there numbers on their arm would be called out to get killed. They would killed them only by using the gas chambers which that wasn't the case at all. A lot of Jews were killed by machine guns. Babies were used as target practices for shooting.
“‘I wanted to return to Sighet to describe to you my death so that you might ready yourselves while there is still time. Life? I no longer care to live…but I wanted to come back to warn you. Only no one is listening to me’” (Wiesel 7).
Decades after surviving the Holocaust, Eliezer revisits the concentration camps and Auschwitz with Oprah for an interview in 2006, and is reminded that “If [he] survived this place until Buchenwald, it was because [his] father was alive, and [Eliezer] knew that if [he] died, [his father] would die” (Winfrey). This event changes Eliezer’s perspective on life, as he can realize that as long as he has someone or something worth living for, he will, unlike those who have lost all hope and reasons to live, keep living. Many of those had no motivation would not make it out of concentration camps alive, as his father and others who had lost hope did
Prologue The Holocaust was a tragedy that happened in the 1940’s . It took around 11 million lives, 6 million of them being Jews. The victims of the Holocaust went through hell. They were starved, beat, and separated from their families.
Grace Trost Night by Elie Wiesel March 30, 2015 Book 1. I would've said to him,"If there really is a God then he would send mercy as it is necessary, but if there isn't then what is the point of wanting to die to escape this place because if you see death as a relief because you would be going to heaven, but if there is no God then there is no heaven to go to. You just have to hang on and believe that God will save you when the time is right. God is just testing our faith and we need to stay strong so that he will have the joy of going to heaven and being with him once this is all over.
Discrimination against Jews “..when we were told we couldn't live in our house we had to move to a different part of Cracow, where the soldiers built a big wall and my mother and father and my brother and I all had to live in one room.” [Ch.12 p.128] Here, Shmuel recounts what happened to his family and him before moving to Auschwitz into a concentration camp. He stated that they were “told” they were unable to love in their home anymore but in one room instead; we are able to learn that they are not free and it's the beginning of their entrapment. “The train was horrible.. There were too many of us in the carriages for one thing.
This quote shows that Elie not responding to his fathers last words stayed with him after years. The guilt he felt for not responding to his fathers words never left him because part of him is angry he didn’t respond to his father that
”I did not weep and it pained me the i could not weep. But i was out of tears. And deep inside me, if i could i have searched the recesses of my feeble conscience, i might have found something like: Free at last!... ” When his father died Elie wasn't sad all he could think of was the weight that was lifted off his chest, that he no longer had to be constantly worried or tending on his
No response. I would have screamed if I could have. He was not moving"(98).This is an example of how Elie cared about his father and he is feared that he would lose him. Over
What would he do without me? I was his sole support.” (86-87) (Elie was determined to keep his father alive, which kept himself going. He only cared for his well being, since he was the closest thing to Elie.) “It no longer mattered.