The creation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Research question: To what extent did fascism cause the creation of the Universal Declaration of the Human Rights in 1948?
Tea Tonejec
Candidate number: 000562-0028
Gimnazija Bežigrad
Word count: 3019 Abstract:
This extended essay analyzes the creation of the Universal Declaration of the Human Rights in 1948. It is a research of which and to what extent countries, people and events had a role in the creation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, furthermore explaining how it was in such a fast pace completed in a such well manner. In fact the extended essay deals with the relationship of fascism contributing to the creation of Human rights, therefore the question examined
…show more content…
With a vote of 48 in favor, eight abstentions and no votes against this declaration clearly passed. This is when the speculations of what was the cause for the creation of the Universal Declaration of Human rights started. As historians Roger Normand and Sarah Zaidi stated »Human rights grew out of a triumph of liberalism over its two main rivals –communism and fascism« However as Professor Huang Nansen of the philosophy department of the Beijing University states »…the lesson they [people witnessing World War II] paid for with their blood was a grave one, and made them and their governments realize the importance of safeguarding fundamental human rights«. Nevertheless the different views of the historians, both of the two sources are reliable and relevant since their justification points as well as their scope of research are fully developed and both Normand and Zaidi are long-time lectures on human rights as well as participating in many groups promoting human rights …show more content…
Meaning, avoiding any World Wars and providing people with satisfaction of some common ground. As said by Sarah Zaidi » Due to the unimaginable world catastrophe due to World War II people all over the world wanted to stop wars, massacres and oppressions«. And future massacres could be possibly prevented by defining on common ground what was common to all people in the sense of their rights. People were fed up of the disastrous World and the atmosphere they lived in, which has caused two World Wars in less than 50 years apart, not only were they both disastrous in the sense of economy but even more in the degrading of humanity due to enormous numbers of deaths. As Zaidi mentions » The huge and understandable yearning for a much better world was expressed throughout through public support that an universal system of justice at a domestic as well as global level would be formed. Citizens pushed their governments to develop such a system «. However it can be said that the result of the wish of preventing further wars was due to what they have witnessed in World War II, especially the uncivilized way people were treated under fascistic leaders, meaning that the wish for generally
The era following the Second World War was marked by a dramatic change in the world order as countries across Africa, Asia, and Central America underwent independence movements that completely upended their political systems. The war had left the world in shambles and the widespread beliefs in Social Darwinism and the concept of a ‘superior race’ that were originally used to justify European rule in foreign areas were challenged. The political climate also changed over the span of World War 2, especially in the weakening of the imperial power’s rule as well as the newfound sense of nationalism that had been sparked in dozens of countries. People wanted change to happen in their country and supported leaders and organizations that pursued independence
People were tired of suffering, and the dictators promised to end it. The people also turned to dictators during
The UN Charter also begins by affirming “faith in fundamental human rights, in the dignity and worth of the human person, in the equal rights of men and women and of nations large and small.” (………). The first major accomplishment of the UN in the case of human rights was the implementation by the General Assembly of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. The Universal Declaration was a milestone achievement in the history of the world. It was the first time that the rights and freedoms of every human being were set out in such detail (……).
The Doctrine of Fascism by Benito Mussolini claims that fascism is the best form of government compared to Socialism, Liberalism, and Democracy (Document 6). This document shows that the rise of fascist ideologies was a problem that led the world from WWI to WWII because the doctrine is claiming that fascism is the best form of government. This could be seen as propaganda and promoting the idea that fascism is the best form of government. This would lead to countries having anxiety about the countries around them with fascism and would cause tension between countries. Furthermore, a political cartoon from Punch magazine made in 1920, shows a snake named the International Strife and a rabbit named the league of nations (Document 3).
Forty-eight nations were for, none against, with eight abstentions ("Eleanor Roosevelt" fdrlibrary.org). Before the UN General Assembly debated and voted on the Declaration, Eleanor said, “We stand today at the threshold of a great event both in the life of the United Nations and in the life of mankind… This Declaration may well become the international Magna Carta that will raise human beings around the world to a higher standard of life and greater enjoyment of freedom” ("Eleanor Roosevelt" fdrlibrary.org). Indeed, for the nations who voted to adopt the Declaration and the many newly dependent countries who adopted it as part of their constitutions in the 1950s and 1960s, its concepts had helped to recognize their citizens’ individual rights. Even in nations where it was not adopted, the Declaration continues to be commonly quoted by people of all positions and social classes ("Eleanor Roosevelt"
The World War 2 is the most large scale war that had ever happened in the world history. It reflects the cruelest sides of the human beings by killing tremendous amount of innocent people. This war not just brought people’s deaths, but also resulted big financial losses to all countries that had participated in it. Many people had to spend most of their time in the underground, apart from the sun, because it was the only place that was considered to be safe. Some of them gave up their hopes, while others cried out for current safety, other than tomorrow’s smile.
I do not believe that there is a future to fascism. As time goes on people have wanted more of a say in their government, and fascism would not lead to that. A system with fascism does not ever work, and it could lead to corruption and the killings on many people. Adolf Hitler is one of the main examples of what fascism could lead you to. He led a genocide in his own country that killed jews, political prisoners, the disabled, and homosexuals.
Germany, in turn, was looking for revenge and started WW2. However a permanent peace were the blame is shared, no blame is placed or placed with consent or negotiations as well as negotiated terms with oppressed can lead to a longer peace and smaller wars. The Paris Peace Treaty, the treaty that ended WW2, is a great example of this as another world war has not taken place. Nonetheless, human nature today is charged with conflict, which is
Fascism is ideology which often uses totalitarianism and nationalism methods. The fascist leaders made people are the subject to the government, and limit the independency of the people, in order to gain the better for the nation. This is somehow similar to absolutism of western Europe during 17th and 18th century. Absolutism had given the monarch absolute power to rule over people, while fascism had given the leader and the nation the power to rule over the people of the state. Moreover, fascism had denied the democratic parliament system, and had only allowed the “elite” to rule over the country.
During the time of Roosevelt’s “Four Freedoms” speech the world
The “Four Freedoms” was the main reason why the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was developed. “The Declaration was drafted over two years by the Commission on Human Rights, chaired by former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt.” (“The Four Freedoms” 1). It was adopted on December 10, 1948 and is known to be “one of the most widely translated documents in the world” (“The Four Freedoms” 1). This declaration insists that all rights be upheld by governments and people to secure basic human rights (“The Four Freedoms”
Fascism and communism are both types of totalitarian style governments that had a great influence on the 20th century. Communism involved the emphasis on the common good by seizing private property and distributing it among the masses in order to create state-owned property, whereas fascism involved the complete rule of a dictator by forcibly suppressing the opposition with an emphasis on nationalism and sometimes racism. The most popular example of communism was the Soviet Union, but many smaller countries possessed the Soviet Union’s communist influence. The two most popular examples of fascist style governments include Hitler’s Nazism in Germany, which had an emphasis on racism, and Mussolini’s fascist state in Italy. Although many countries pursued communist style governments, fascism had a greater impact and
The Unpreventable Great War World War I was one of the most devastating and destructive events that occurred during history. It was inevitable to happen due to three main factors including, militarism, nationalism, and alliances between certain countries. However, there are other people who believe that World War I was not inevitable and could have been prevented through certain measures. This source describes that World War I could have been prevented if there were more stable and successful negotiations between countries. However, due to the lack of peaceful negotiations between certain countries, many conflicts arose because of desires to expand military and navels.
John Locke and John Stuart Mill’s dilemma in swimming to the islands of Fatherland and Bourgeouseville demand them to consider several key elements of each civilization. Each societies attitudes towards A fundamental element for Locke and Mill to consider in their decision, is the core purpose of government on each island, and the impact these different goals have on each civilization. The role of government in Fatherland, which is a Fascist regime, reflects the Fascist emphasis on government involvement in the lives of its people. In Benito Mussolini’s “The Doctrine of Fascism”, he describes the Fascist state as “the highest and most powerful form of personality, is a force, but a spiritual force, which takes over all the forms of moral and intellectual life of a man.” (pg.
Waters believed that the production and use of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights are a result of the following