In many ways Zora Neal Hurston discusses and uses intertextuality and language to enforce the concept of identity and gender roles within the main characters Janie and Tea Cake in Their Eyes Were Watching God. Zora Neal Hurston an American Author, Anthropologist, and filmmaker wrote and used the struggles of early 1900’s African American to explain and portray what it was like to live back then. During that time identity and gender roles within the African American community were strong topics among the people. With the system in which black people worked for white people with very little to no pay and harsh conditions, it was extremely hard for them to find their identities, and more or less grow with them. Gender roles were also strictly …show more content…
She didn’t change her mind but she agreed with her mouth. Her heart said, “Even so, you don’t have to cry about it.” This quote uses language in order to instill the idea that not only had Janie begun to find herself as a young woman but she also learned that the best way to speak as a young woman was to say nothing at all. Again, showing the concept of identity and also gender roles. During the time period, women were considered as nothing more than what they could do for a man and their house. If a woman were to step outside the margins of society during that period they were cast out and abused and it never went without a fight. From this quote, Hurston writes to women in society who still succumb to these gender roles forcing them to struggle with their identity by showing Janie’s decisions that what she says doesn’t need to be completely true. This way she could say things she didn’t mean in order to keep the peace in her marriage. This adds to who she is as a person by using language within the text that explains to readers the kind of person Janie has grown to become. This is Janie …show more content…
For example, in chapter eighteen Hurston writes “The wind came back with triple fury, and put out the light for the last time. They sat in company with the others in other shanties, their eyes straining against crude walls and their souls asking if He meant to measure their puny might against His. They seemed to be staring at the dark, but their eyes were watching God.” In this quote, the intertextuality can be found in the way Zora Neal Hurston writes the description of their eyes and souls. This gives insight into not only the personalities and identities of the characters but also assumes the male role is to seem strong and mighty, similar to that of a protector. However, another interpretation of this could be that Tea Cake is abusing his authority and abusing his role as Janie’s partner by enforcing the concept and idea he is the head and the one in power in their relationship. This, of course, could be seen from the victims' standpoint. There are multiple examples of how Hurston displays these concepts, she enforces the concept of gender roles various amount of times, and those especially sticking out consist of the constant bad talk Janie got while at home and also
In the book, Their Eyes Were Watching God, by Zora Neale Hurston, the female character, Janie Crawford, goes through the hardships of finding her true love. Throughout her life, she was in relationships between three guys but unfortunately for her, they haven’t gone so well. With the problems she faced, it shows that she is a strong female character in terms of the feminist theory. She’s a strong female character because with the problems she faced for several years, she endured the struggles of her femininity being shut down but eventually starts to stand up for herself.
During this time period, men were seen as a really powerful figure, they were expected to have full control over their wives and daughters only because they were females. Joe Starks didn’t fully have the mentality of giving orders to Janie at first, but he slowly began acquiring it as time went by. Once, Joe ‘’order[es] Janie to tie up her hair [whenever she is] around the store’’(Hurston 55). Her hair is being used to represent the power and confidence she had been born with, and Joe ordering for her to ‘’NOT show it in [public]’’ (Hurston 55) is a symbol that highlights how Joe doesn’t want her to show how powerful, independent, beautiful, and confident she can be.
Their Eyes Were Watching God is full of many topics that would still be considered controversial today. One of the most important that Hurston decides to expand upon is the gender inequality/feminism portrayed in the novel. Gender inequality, and just gender in general, is a very important theme in Hurston’s novel Their Eyes Were Watching God, and through this theme Janie has the internal conflict of whether she should be a free and independent woman or if she should stick to the traditional womanly roles that were expected at the time. Throughout the novel Janie breaks stereotypical feminine roles by marrying three times, to men who were very different from each other. During her first marriage to Logan, Janie not only had to struggle to
Janie tries to forget the chance to give a speech being taken, “but it wasn’t too easy. She had never thought of making a speech and didn’t know if she cared to make one at all. It must have been the way Joe spoke out without giving her a chance”(Hurston 43). Hurston uses Janie’s negative reaction of being deprived a chance to express herself to show her support of the value of self expression. Janie’s feeling sad when not being able to express herself shows she truly values the ideas of self expression.
A strong-willed woman refuses to be manipulated no matter the role she plays. In the novel, “Their Eyes Were Watching God” by Zora Neale Hurston and the short story, “Hills like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway, there is a common theme of independence blooming from judgment. While Hurston focuses on true development, including puberty and relationships, Hemingway highlights reproductive rights and the role of women during this time. Hurston portrays Janie as a minority, illustrating her with flawless mixed skin and beautiful long hair that symbolizes her freedom throughout the novel. Mrs. Turner says Janie is “a heaven of straight haired, thin-lipped, high-nose-bone white seraphs…
Zora Neale Hurston’s writing in Their Eyes Were Watching God, reflects the Harlem Renaissance through Janie 's individuality, and departs from the Harlem Renaissance with the common recurrence of black woman empowerment. In the novel, Hurston reflects the ideas of the Harlem renaissance with the ways in which Janie rebels and goes against norms for women.
Gender Inequality in Their Eyes Were Watching God In the novel, Their Eyes were watching God, by Zora Neal Hurston it is evident that her anthropological background influenced the way she chose to tell the story of Janie’s life. Having this knowledge really helped her gain a perspective on the issue of feminism and the way that women were treated. It also helped her case that Zora herself was an African American woman growing up around the same time period.
Wright argues that Their Eyes Were Watching God does not convey any ideas or themes of importance, but I believe that his masculinity blinds him, and he is unable to see how this novel is able to call attention to how women of color are oppressed by men. Throughout the entire story, Janie is constantly being oppressed by, not by a person, but by an idea, which was created by men. The idea that black women were at the bottom of the social pyramid, they are forced to carry the weight of the world on their shoulders, therefore they were “de mule uh de world.” Hurston communicates this idea through Nanny by writing, “So de white man throw down de load and tell de n***** man to pick it up.
When Janie and Tea Cake open their house to their new friends in the Everglades, Janie compares her life now to her life in Eatonville with Joe. She notices that, unlike Joe, Tea Cake doesn’t forbid her from interacting and conversing with the men and women they’re spending time with. Janie realizes she could “talk some herself” (134). Janie is able to use her own voice while communicating, instead of remaining silenced while Tea Cake speaks and takes control over Janie’s opinions. The speaking abilities that Tea Cake doesn’t take away from her contributes to the even split of power in Janie’s relationship with Tea Cake.
Estelle Ngobua Debra Lydon American Literature 13 April 2023 Their Eyes Were Watching God. Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neal Hurston male dominance and power is seen in the book as the author uses symbolism to explain and show how the male figure poses a threat to the female’s freedom in the relationship. This masterpiece shows how no human can stand against God or what he has in turn for you. As the protagonist's life is put together life lessons are shown in themes of power, male domination, love, inequality, discrimination sexism, teaching her things she wouldn’t have known.
Janie realizes that she needs a partner who accepts and respects her individuality and not one who wants to control
Though the novel represents many feministic ideas in relation to marriage, it should not be read and discussed solely from this perspective. This statement is commented by Ramsey who claims that the story is “both a precursor to the modern feminist agenda yet also a reactionary tale embalming Hurston’s tender passions for a very traditional male” (1994: 38). In spite of the fact that the scholar agrees that Janie gains some self-belief and self-realization in the course of time, he still perceives her as a woman who cannot survive without a man by her side who would support her. It seems that she has a strong need to have someone by her side to support her when something goes wrong. This argument is confirmed by another researcher, Jennifer Jordan, who states that the protagonist “never perceives herself as an independent woman” (1988: 115).
Jody wanted Janie to know that women were less than men and that they don’t think for themselves, he almost compares women to animals, “Somebody got to think for women and chillun and chickens and cows. I god, they sho don’t think none theirselves” (Hurston 180). Once he passed away, Janie took a more feminist stand in her life, she started doing more of what she wanted to do and how she wanted to do it. Letting her hair down is an important point in the novel because it shows strength, “Before she slept that night she burnt up every one of her head rags and went about the house next morning with her hair in one thick braid swinging below her waist”
In Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston acknowledges the idea of sexism when she addresses that Janie Starks, the protagonist, never got to fulfill her dreams. Janie’s grandmother, Nanny, wanted the best for her granddaughter so she married her off to a man named Logan Killicks, a man who had a small farm and good wealth “Janie and Logan got married in Nanny’s parlor of a Saturday evening with three cakes and big platters of fried rabbit and chicken,” (Hurston 3). Years has passed within the marriage and Janie never found love for Logan. Logan comparing her to his ex-wife, discriminated Janie’s place of position, “Mah fust wife never bothered me ‘bout choppin’ no wood nohow. She’d grab dat ax and sling chips lak
Being a woman of color in the 1920’s was no easy task. Gender and racial inequalities have made progress throughout history, however during the time of this novel, and even in our modern day world they are still present and causing conflict. This is an issue that should be focused on and taken more seriously. In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston, Janie does a fantastic job overcoming several of these inequalities in order to pursue her own happiness, overall depicting her as an extremely powerful role model for young