ipl-logo

How Does Malcolm Gladwell Use The Straw Man Theory?

910 Words4 Pages

People’s reliance on the straw man theory is more prevalent now than ever. The straw man theory is commonly used in daily life. The straw man theory occurs by diverting the reader's attention. It occurs when someone ignores a person's position and instead exaggerates, misrepresents, or creates a distorted version of that position. Straw Man is one of the best-named fallacies, and is used in many books and/or articles. Malcolm Gladwell’s “What the Dog Saw” uses this theory as a method of persuasion. He describes this premise as being commonly used, but then knocked down; some argue if this method is effective. Gladwell incorporates the straw man theory into most of his essays; including “The Ketchup Conundrum” and “Something Borrowed” to prove how effective it is. “The Ketchup Conundrum” discusses questions such as why is all ketchup the same? Why are there so many flavors of other condiments, yet ketchup has remained the same? This article discusses the progression of ketchup taste. Jim Wigon had seen Grey Poupon’s entire mustard section, and he instantly became inspired; he wanted …show more content…

He was surprised to find out that there are many occasions where “One artist was simply replicating the work of another.” (Gladwell 235) Many artists simply change the baseline of their song and then they call it their own. Artists get their inspiration simply by viewing or listening to another artist’s work. In the beginning of the essay, he leads us to believe that plagiarism is a problem. However, after his experiences he encountered, he realizes that plagiarism is not a big problem; rather a process to creative works being published.“So is it true that words belong to the person who wrote them, just as other kinds of property belong to their owners? Actually no.” (Gladwell 231) The straw man theory helps Gladwell to build up his opinion; just for him to knock it

Show More
Related

Bag Ban Bad For Freedom By Adam B. Summerss Summary

788 Words | 4 Pages

Adam B. Summers, in his essay Bag Ban Bad For Freedom and Environment, effectively utilizes numerous stylistic and literary devices that persuade the reader. Summers utilizes facts, disproves various counter arguments and uses logical and emotional reasoning to persuade the reader to agree to his claim. However, Summers’ argument falls short due to the lack of power, as he holds no highly esteemed position of power. This, in addition to his colloquialism, intimates that he is just a layman and tells the reader that the source is not to be trusted.

Read More

Example Of Ethos Pathos Logos

1076 Words | 5 Pages

Introduction Persuasion is an art; and mastering this art requires the manipulation of the rhetorical triangles: ethos, pathos, and logos. “Ethos” deals with the credibility of the author; “pathos” refers to the emotional appeal of the text; and “logos” is the logics behind the argument; and these three fundamental appeals are the basis of persuasion. The rhetorical methods used in the two visuals, "How to Gain or Lose 30 minutes of Life Everyday" and "People Kill with Guns More Than Any Other Weapon," both by Mark Fischetti will be analyzed, compared and contrasted in reference to the broader contexts of each source. How to Gain or Lose 30 Minutes of Life Every Day The purpose of this visual is to show the effects of certain activities or habits can on life expectancy.

Read More

Is The Purpose Of Let Them Eat Dog By Jonathan Safran Foer

931 Words | 4 Pages

If you traveled to another country where the main course was a cocker spaniel, would you be so inclined as to try the meal; if so, would you then be comfortable admitting it was enjoyable? Most Americans would answer no, and with an astounded look on their face for such a crude question being asked. Author Jonathan Safran Foer pushed his audience’s emotional boundaries by proposing the idea that we do just that; eat our precious dogs. His argument within the article “Let Them Eat Dog: A Modest Proposal for Tossing Fido in the Oven” proves strong with what seems to be an unbiased, logical, and tryingly reasonable argument! Throughout this paper is a close analysis of Mr. Foer’s true argument, his tactics, and his personal style of writing.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Blink By Malcolm Gladwell

1903 Words | 8 Pages

Understanding the food tasters expertise makes it easier for the reader to

Read More

The Ketchup Conundrum Analysis

302 Words | 2 Pages

In Malcolm Gladwell’s, The Ketchup Conundrum, it describes how ketchup has evolved differently than mustard. When mustard hit the shelves of supermarkets, people used it on hotdogs and bologna. Formally known as Dijon mustard, Grey Poupon was the “magical” mustard. Jim Wigon decided to go into the ketchup business. The most famous ketchup brands include Heinz, Hunt’s and Del Monte.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Small Change By Malcolm Gladwell

1180 Words | 5 Pages

In “Small Change: Revolution Not be Tweeted” by Malcolm Gladwell , Gladwell explains his own thoughts on why even in the age of technology social media will never be the strongest way to display activism. Throughout the article the author highlights what he feels makes activism work and what he feels may not work. He thoroughly explains his reasoning for his opinions by using rhetorical strategies. For example, he notes that for a cause to be effective the people pursuing it must have a strong tie or a strong connection to it. This can tie/connection can come from experiencing the problem first hand or having multiple friends or family already involved in the cause.

Read More

Air Conditioning Will Be The End Of Us By Eric Klinenberg

571 Words | 3 Pages

In “Viewpoint: Air-Conditioning will be the end of us,” Eric Klinenberg uses counterargument, personal anecdote, and he provides solutions to help build his argument. He first supplies a personal anecdote in order for the reader to relate more towards him as well as have the reader recount a similar story. He then uses counterarguments in order to show his expertise on the topic. After both personal anecdote and counterargument are used, he follows by supplying solutions in an attempt to persuade the reader more towards his viewpoint. Klinenberg tells the reader of a event that happened to him within the week of writing the article.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Defining A Racist By Malcolm Gladwell

731 Words | 3 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis: Defining a Racist Racism has been around for as long as man has recorded history. Whether it was Israelite’s and Egyptians or Africans and Anglos, there has always been a race that feels superior to another race. As time progresses, society does become more and more accepting of other races there are those who have just stuck in their ways of racism. These people have decided to remain in ignorance and have built a life based on a superiority complex towards others. Although, what makes an action or statement racist?

Read More

Analysis Of The Ketchup Conundrum By Malcolm Gladwell

792 Words | 4 Pages

Gladwell develops this idea that some forms of plagiarism aren’t crimes by using the similarities that occur in music “he sat down at the piano again and played the beginning of both songs, one after the other; sure enough, they sounded strikingly similar... Same sequence,” and proposes that, specifically in the music industry, one cannot place ownership on notes because they are just pitches on a scale that any one can play; however plagiarism exists when a well-known sequence of notes is reproduced and replicated with full knowledge of one’s act of replication. Using examples from many different pop-culture genres (music, theatre), Gladwell provides instances in which plagiarism is overlooked as mere coincidence, as well as instances in which plagiarism results in a destroyed reputation (British playwright Bryony Lavery, Frozen), or loss of employment (Harvard law professor Laurence Tribe) in order to provoke discussion about the severity of plagiarism, and illustrate how ideas become “...part of the archive of human knowledge...and, by the time ideas pass into their third and fourth lives, we lose track of where they came from, and we lose control of where they

Read More

Malcolm Gladwell Persuasive Techniques

787 Words | 4 Pages

In the book Outliers, Malcolm Gladwell uses the persuasive techniques such as figurative language, rhetorical questions, and analogies to persuade readers that the American view of success is wrong, and that success is the product of opportunities, hidden advantages, and hard work. In Chapter Two, these techniques are used to describe his idea of “The 10,000-Hour Rule” - that belief it takes 10,000 hours to become an expert at something. Gladwell’s basis for the 10,000-hour rule is that people who are experts in their field became so good from hidden and rare opportunities that allowed them to practice their skills. One example gladwell uses are The Beatles, whom Gladwell identifies as one of the most famous rock bands ever.

Read More

Malcolm Gladwell Small Change Rhetorical Analysis

1396 Words | 6 Pages

Writers do their job because they want to express their ideas to make an impact on the readers. Sometimes they want to convince their audience through persuasion. They can do it using different rhetorical elements such as logos, ethos, and pathos. These are Greek words that mean logic, character, and emotion consecutively.

Read More

Posner's Argument

460 Words | 2 Pages

“It is the responsibility of the professor to conduct the class in such a way that maximal learning occurs, not maximal speech. That’s why no teacher would permit students to launch into anti-Semitic diatribes in a class about the Holocaust” (paragraph 5)I believe this is an Either/or fallacy. He tries to force a conclusion by pressing just two choices one which is clearly more desirable than the other. Another fallacy is “Teachers are dictators who carefully control what students say to one another.” Would this be an example of the Strawman fallacy, because of the lack of the support?

Read More

Malcolm X Argumentative Essay

795 Words | 4 Pages

Malcolm X “You can’t separate peace from freedom, because nobody can be at peace unless he has his freedom.” These words came from the mouth of Malcolm X, but who was he? Some people call him deranged, others call him too radical. But truthfully, Malcolm X was one of the most influential African Americans in history.

Read More

The Fallacy Of Pooh-Poh-Pooh Argument

165 Words | 1 Pages

“Pooh-Pooh” is a fallacy of informal logic and criticism that dismisses an argument perceived unworthy of serious consideration or as being foolish or impractical. This fallacy puts down an argument, without logically addressing it. It is a form of the Straw Man’s argument, in which an argument is purposefully misrepresented to make it easier to attack. However, whereas the strawman restates the initial claim in a distorted way and attacks it, the pooh-pooh argument does not address any arguments, but merely ridicules it. One might poo-pooh an argument outright, or agree with a point in general but then disagree about the specific case in hand.

Read More

The Steamed Bun Comparison

1401 Words | 6 Pages

I always have fond memories of steamed buns and perhaps the meal shaped my pallet preferences even in adulthood. The exists a correlation with food flavour preferences during childhood and its impact into later years. Due to the high consumption of Chinese steamed buns it has shaped part of a large part of my food preferences beyond steamed buns. My preferences of sweet and sourness levels could have been a result of a high consumption of different type of steam buns. It is interesting to note the connection between food consumption during childhood and its impact into adulthood.

Read More

More about How Does Malcolm Gladwell Use The Straw Man Theory?

Related Topics

Open Document