Playing sports is something that children in America look forward to, especially after a challenging day at school. Not only is it a way to meet new people and learn life lessons, but it is also a way to relieve stress. Students look forward to making new friends and developing relationships with their coaches. Sports should be fair and enjoyable. Sadly, that is not what is happening on a daily basis. Through the rise of transgender people feeling safe with transitioning, young children and teens have wanted to continue playing sports for the gender they identify as. Girls want to play in men's leagues, and vice versa. Though transgender children should be seen as equal, they should not be allowed to participate on high school sports teams …show more content…
The medication that people take for transitioning is called testosterone, which gives athletes an upper hand in sports. The medication gives them different muscle strengths, such as an increase in muscle mass. With the medication, the transition period takes “months to years to complete '' and people would still possess male-like features (LaChance). As males are slowly transitioning to females, they continue to have some male features, making participation in sports challenging. Alice Dreger, a professor of bioethics, explained that “male bodies come with competitive advantages in sports that reward speed and strength,” allowing them to be more athletic (Dreger). It would not make sense if men and women competed together due to their biological differences. If men competed with women, they would have an unfair athletic advantage. A student athlete at The Weber School …show more content…
The governor of Oklahoma passed a bill that states “[g]irls should compete against girls, [b]oys should compete against boys”(Stritt). However, Stritt has not been the only governor to pass a bill banning transgender athletes from playing sports; 19 other states have started passing similar bills. The Kansas Legislature approved the “ban [on] transgender athletes in girls’ and women’s sports” (Hannah). Not allowing transgender athletes to participate is so that everyone gets an equal opportunity to succeed. Putting a ban on transgender participation benefits the people who have worked hard their whole life to be able to compete and win against people of their own sex. Throughout the country, many believe that transgender kids should not be allowed to play sports. Many more states have started the process of trying to ban transgender athletes from competing in sports
Good afternoon, thank you for giving me the opportunity to address a topic of significant importance in today's sporting socitey, I will be presenting an very light shining presentation on the topic of why transgender athletes should not be allowed to compete in womens sports. For some clarity before I begin to aviod bias, I respect the identities that people choose for themselves and I only intend to consider the biological developments and advantages people have. It is crucial to understand this issue and develop the honesty of fairness for womens sport. Imagine you've dedicated years of your life to perfecting your skills in sports. You've trained day in and day out, pushing your limits to compete at the highest level.
In the article titled Face-off on the playing field By, Judith B. Stamper explains girls have their own story of support or discrimination, success also the debate of girls be allowed to compete on boys’ sports team. First, the writer Title IX explains female athletes are been treated second-class for long enough and should pass of inequalities and biases of girls. The writer also clarifies that girls doing sports make them healthier, physically, and emotionally. Other girls that don’t play sports are less likely to use of drugs. In addition, she notes a former Stanford University basketball player Mariah says, strength and independence of things girls learn from sports, the opportunities that are changing women.
In 2010 the NCAA passed a policy where transgender male (female to male) athletes with testosterone treatment can compete on men's teams, but they lose eligibility for women's teams unless the team is mixed. Whereas transgender female (MTF) athletes on testosterone suppression medication may continue competing on men's teams but must complete one year of treatment before becoming eligible for women's teams. (NCAA, 2022). Essentially, any transgender student-athletes not undergoing hormone treatment, participation in their sport is based on their sex assigned at birth. Transgender athletes who identify as female and are not undergoing testosterone treatment have the option to join either men's or women's teams, whereas transgender athletes who identify as male and are not utilizing hormone treatment are not permitted to take part in women's teams (NCAA, 2022).
I believe girls have the option to join different sports hey can join wresting, football and they also have their own league of soccer, basketball, and softball. We should not change now we raise our boys, because not every boy is the same way. In many schools they are gender neutral
In addition,Next, did you know that the arenas, courts, fields, etc., that girls play on for sports teams are often farther away and at less reasonable times than the facilities that boys get to play at? To add to this, I play hockey, and we often get put in the older or less nice facilities for games, while the boys are put in the newer facilities with their logos printed everywhere. This makes playing at these facilities undesirable and unfair to female athletes. Thus, girls are given an unequal and unfair opportunity to play
In the article, “Title IX defeats male athletes” by Ann Coulter, she says that male’s teams are being decimated in pursuit of an insane feminist dream that has morphed into feral policy: to make women’s sports equal to men’s, but really this shouldn’t have happened. Women play different sports than men do, sports are all different, and they shouldn’t have to be equal. Some sports are for men, some sports are for women, and some sports are for both. Some of the sports that are for men, could be too competitive or too complicated, but the sports that are for women exist so that women don’t have to play a sport that might be too hard for them. So in a way, men’s and women’s sports are already equal if you think about it because there is something for men to play and something for women
For example, if a high school had a boy’s football, basketball, volleyball, wrestling, soccer, tennis, baseball, swimming, and wrestling team to total nine teams, they would have to provide another nine teams for the girls to participate in. However, in sports that are catered strictly to males such as football or baseball, girls might substitute with cheerleading or softball. Then, the boys’ sports teams aren’t intruded and crowded upon, and girls that want to play sports still have other Futhermore, Title IX doesn’t discriminate against male athletes is because it decreases the stereotypes we encounter so often in today’s world. Physical sport has long been considered to be meant only for men, limiting women to other activities that don’t have the same benefits as athletics.
The Stonewall Riots are said to mark the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, and it was largely initiated by transgender women of color. Over the next few decades, legislation would be enacted to aid the cause for equality. By 1977, trans athletes could play on the teams of their gender identities, and by 1993 anti-discrimination laws were extended to transpeople in Minnesota. In the 21st century alone, transpeople were getting invited to the White House, playing in college sports, and serving as judges, all without having to hide who they were (“Milestones in the American Transgender Movement”). Hardships are still all too common, unfortunately, but much progress has been made nonetheless, and the fight continues to this
Transgender female athletes are competing against cisgender athletes so that sports are inclusive. While this is a good idea, it comes with many risks. MTF athletes pose a safety threat to physical sports, with them being built differently and stronger. Although some may argue that male-to-female athletes lose the advantage of testosterone
To this day there are still discriminatory comments made by coaches, managers, and support staff. Because of this, there has been a rapid decrease of professional female athletes continuing their athletic careers, as well as with female students cutting their sporting careers short. The Famuan researched that, “The Women’s Sports Foundation says that by the age of 14, girls drop out of sports at two times the rate of boys. An additional survey shows that 51 percent of women quit playing sports by the age of 17”. Many women and girls no longer view sports as a solid and comfortable career opportunity.
The issue of transgender athletes in women's sports requires a delicate balance between inclusivity, fairness, and safety. Lately, the topic of gender identity in sports has been controversial, particularly regarding transgender males participating in women's sports. Promoting diversity and gender equality is important, but we must also consider fairness and safety. Allowing transgender males to compete in women's sports could create potential advantages that impact opportunities for cisgender women and affect the level playing field.
I do believe that they should be able to be on the same team without the feeling of others disapproving of their choice. With that being said, I think we should make sports more open to both genders. Such as making a boys and girls volleyball team or a football team that allows both boys and girls to join. I know a change like that may not happen for a while, but why not start trying
Should girls be allowed to play on boys sports team? Girls should be able to play on boy’s sports teams for three main reasons: We already have that big problem with boys and girls being equal, Girls should be given the same chance as boys and vice versa, and Boy’s can join Cheerleading so why can’t girls join Football? “Equality is not a concept. It's not something we should be striving for. It's a necessity.
The Olympics in the 1900s were the first time women were allowed to compete but on a very limited scale. True equality didn't exist for women in sports until Title IX was passed in 1972. The new law, among many other things, is most famous for guaranteeing girls equal opportunity in sports. However, with transgender women entering the biological women's sports world, many of these athletes are losing the opportunities Title IX granted them just 40 years ago. Today, biological women are losing opportunities as they face physical disadvantages, safety concerns, and even public humiliation when they face off against biological men.
Gender neutral bathrooms will always be a topic of discussion in everyone lives, however the emotional and economic toll the restrooms would have on others could change someone’s life for the worse. If transgender male and females used their biological corresponding gender facilities, we could lessen those tolls to a minimum. The IOC has tried effortlessly to expand the opportunities for transgender athletes, but just reducing the amount of hormones in the athlete cannot change that they will always have an advantage over non-transgender competitors. One may see the tenacity and the empowerment of transgender movements unnecessary and annoying, but hopefully in future, everyone will see that these peoples stories should inspire others to stand up for what they believe