1. What is the main argument for arming teachers in your article? The main argument for arming teachers is that teachers will be able to protect against armed intruders on campus. 2. What was the main opposing arguments in your article? The main argument against arming teachers is that teachers should not be armed for safety reasons of doing more harm than good, and several flaws that can cause a massive incident to happen. 3. List 5 positives for arming teachers that can be supported by the article. Positives for arming teachers include: -Protecting against an intruder -Being first on the scene in the event of an intruder -Being an inexpensive option compared to hiring professional security -Always being present in the classroom unlike …show more content…
5. Do you personally feel that teachers should be armed? If so, under what circumstances? If no, why not? I personally feel that teachers should be armed; this is under the circumstance that there is an armed threat on campus, law enforcement is delayed in their arrival to assist, and the teacher is already on scene as the incident occurs, so as to prevent extensive or any damage before the intruder can deal any. Part Two You have to argue for the argument that you just read. Why is it correct? Create 5 main talking points in favor of your argument that you can defend through this argument. The argument is in favor of arming teachers, and is correct because: 1. Teachers are on scene as “first responders” when the incident happens 2. Teachers can be there to prevent the incident before it breaks out and causes too much damage 3. Teachers can protect students, other staff members, and themselves rather than being unable to do anything 4. Teacher armament is less expensive than hiring trained professionals 5. Teacher armament will decrease incidents of school shootings, and set a declining trend for any violent crimes happening on school …show more content…
(Response): There are not enough resource officers for every school in the nation, let alone high schools. 2. (Rebuttal): Resource officers can be there to prevent incidents from occurring just as well. 2. (Response): True, but resource officers are not in every classroom at every moment of every day, they may be on the campus every day, but not necessarily in each classroom – teachers, however, are in each classroom. 3. (Rebuttal): Teachers can also pose a danger to the students if not properly trained, abusive, or insane and out of control. 3. (Response): Special precautions and measures are and can be taken to ensure the individual is safe and responsible to be put into an environment where handling a firearm is extremely dangerous. 4. (Rebuttal): No one can put a price on protecting our children from threats. 4. (Response): No one except for the schools who can’t afford trained professionals. It is better to have trained teachers, who are no more expensive when armed with a firearm, protecting your kids. 5. (Rebuttal): Teachers being armed will be an invitation for others to bring weapons everywhere else, and will start trends of armament that will envelope this
“Every Teacher in America Should Have a Gun” by Steve Siebold delivers the message about why teachers should be armed with guns. Primarily he thinks that shooters will be less motivated to try to attack a school that is able to defend itself against the gunman. He also goes on to say that “Every second counts in a school shooting. Calling 911 and waiting for police to arrive isn’t good enough.” He gives us the idea that we need to take action against these shooters and potentially end school shootings once and for all.
We need to make a change and figure out why this is a problem in our amazing country. A solution for this problem of school shootings could possibly be arming teacher with gun. Teachers would have to have certain qualifications to be allowed to carry. Students would have a sense of security if teachers would be allowed to carry guns in schools. Safety in schools is a huge thing we need to focus on, not only are they innocent kids, but they are the future of the world and they will change and shape the world for years to come.
This reasoning is also a representation of how having a gun to protect oneself is a good idea. “...Policeman or other students with guns might not be able to differentiate among
In the event of a shooting, a teacher may accidentally shoot a teacher, a student, or an officer that is trying to help. During class, a teacher may carelessly leave a gun unattended where a student could get a hold of it. Armed teachers are a safety risk as proved by several recent events. A teacher with a gun attempted suicide in a high school in Dalton, and another injured a student after a gun misfired during a gun safety class. Even a principal, who was a school shooting hero for using his own gun to stop a shooter, is in agreement that it is a safety risk.
According to John R. Lott, “After the Columbine school shooting 20 years ago, one of the more significant changes in how we protect students has been the advance of legislation that allows teachers to carry guns at schools… There has yet to be a single case of someone being wounded or killed from a shooting, let alone a mass public shooting” (Lott). John also stated “Fears of teachers carrying guns in terms of such problems as students obtaining teachers guns have not occurred at all.” According to John in his article titled “Teachers Should Be Armed to Prevent School Violence”, “Just as the threat of arrest and prison can deter criminals, so can the fact that victims can defend themselves” (Lott). Evidently, schools take special precautions to make sure that a firearm does not end up in the hands of a student or a
Teachers could feel more comfortable in their classrooms if they knew they could protect themselves and their students from violent threats. Schools being a gun free zone are a target for violent
Why Should teachers be able to carry a gun. Reason #1 for teachers being able to carry a gun, protection of students. Imagine being a parent in this day and age were you have to worry about your child going to what was a safe environment in the parents age. What is now a risk for a mentally ill and damaged individual to kill as many innocent people as possible.
Over the past few weeks, arming teachers has been a controversial topic throughout the country. School shootings have taken the lives of many over the past few years, yet they are becoming more and more frequent. In today’s society children shouldn’t have to go to school worried if they are going to be safe that day. If teachers are armed it will add that extra bit of protection to the children. A big question is if arming teachers is even going to matter if an active shooter happens to be in that school.
There are those who add to America’s gun problem, and there are those who help solve the problem. Our country has many personal weapons in public circulation, this proves to be deadly. The prospect of arming educators has been widely suggested this year after many school shootings. Arming teachers will only add to America’s gun problem.
Many schools in today’s society suffer from shootings at some point while children are attending school. Shootings in schools are not a new occurrence, and America has dealt with multiple shootings in public schools in which the lives of many children and teachers have been undeservingly taken (Elliott 528). Because of school shootings, this leaves our children in danger with no way to protect themselves. Gun violence in schools is an evident problem, and there are several ways to reduce the number of incidents, such as mental health screening for owners of guns, interconnectedness of communities, and more school funding.
Firstly, the arming of students, faculty and staff should be prohibited because its unsafe. The debate on whether staff, faculty and students should carry firearms on campuses has been going for years now. Some colleges have debated that a law should be passed were staff and faculty should carry firearms on campus, but other colleges have dismissed this case because it is dangerous and unsafe. According to Jesus Villahermosa’s essay “Guns don’t belong in the Hands of Administrators, Professors, or Students” he states, “I agree that allowing guns on campuses will create problems, not solve them.” This statement is true because not everyone is capable to handle a gun or even use one.
As previously stated, not everyone in the United States wants to completely disappear the second amendment of the constitution. As we know that Texas is one of the states that is on favor of gun rights, and is less likely to get strict gun control laws. Teachers in elementary schools have the opportunity to share the importance of safety against any attacks to their elementary schools to young students. Parents have also the opportunity to approve for teachers to teach about these topics. If parents continue to ask for these teachings to help their children realize the importance of these safety educational topics, districts of these elementary schools will begging to hear the controversy, so will the government eventually.
In 2012 there was another school shooting and the state got involved and that school had to get shut down because there was one shooting and now there are several because one shooting is contagious. So that is one good reason why we need better school protection so kids can go home safely and not half to worry about a shooter around the school. Now that you know why we need better security at schools so kids can be safe in this next paragraph I will explain to you some information from the other side of the argument. (Clark
Hypothetically, a law is passed stating that teachers are allowed to carry guns in school. In a sick twisted world, the teacher becomes the school shooter. Your student is in class and their teacher pulls out their government funded school weapon and starts shooting. How is your child supposed to protect themselves if the approved district teacher starts shooting the students with a malicious intent. Teachers should not be allowed to carry guns at school.
With reaction being defined by Merriam Webster as “to behave or change in a particular way when something happens, is said, etc.” If the police cannot be there to react to an attack that leaves only the school staff, including teachers. The main controversies involving arming teachers are that: 1.) Children will find the guns and think that they are toys and will thus play with them.