The Black Sox Scandal Baseball is America’s favorite pastime. People have always thought baseball was a clean game. Until the massive doping scandal that occurred several years ago. However, there was what some called the “greatest scandal in sports history” back in the 1919 World Series (1919 Chicago White Sox). The scandal all started as a way for the underpaid players to get some extra money. Specifically Eddie Cicotte and “Chick” Gandil needed money to support their family. Somehow the whole team got involved in one of the most controversial scandals in all of sports. Despite the proof some players indicted have tried to clear their names to get into the hall, but everyone who tried was unsuccessful. These players set a precedent that …show more content…
This rule has left some of the great players out of the hall of fame which has created some great debates amongst the sports writer. The eight players that were banned were: “Eddie Cicotte, Oscar Felsch, Arnold Gandrill, Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin, Charles Risberg, George Weaver, and Claude Williams” (Guide to the Black Sox…). Some of these players have tried to reinstate them to baseball but all attempts have failed. This ruling has become a precedent for all of baseball that no one in the locker room should bet on baseball, or suffer the …show more content…
Also they analysts say Pete Rose deserves to get in and lift his ban for life. Never though do they say the Black Sox players should get into the hall. However, it was once not always this way players use to advocate for them and there is other proof that one player did not play to lose the series. Joe Jackson said he played his “heart out against Cincinnati” (Shoeless Joe…). He batted a .356 batting average and did not make any errors in the outfield. This shows how much he wanted to win the series. He said that “I was innocent” so why should he be left out of major league baseball forever (Shoeless Joe…). Many great players such as Ty Cobb and Ted Williams came to the defense of two players in general “Shoeless” Joe Jackson and George Weaver. Ty Cobb said that “…they’ll never get me to believe Buck Weaver was was guilty of anything” (1919 Chicago White Sox). These players were some of the greatest players to play the game and still they were not influential enough to convince baseball to overturn the ruling of the commissioner of baseball. These events are similar to the recent events. Such as when Ken Griffey Jr. said that Barry Bonds deserves to be in the hall of fame. The players are in the hall as a team but not individually they are in there as the team that “threw” the World Series. Not exactly what baseball players want
"Titan Tribune. " Put in Pete!: Why Pete Rose Should Be in the Baseball Hall of Fame, edited by Tommy Merlo and Brendan Laurinaitis, Titan Tribune, 5 Feb. 2016, www.cbsouthtribune.com/staff/?writer=Tommy%20Merlo. Accessed 22 Jan. 2017. Epstein, Dan.
Therefore, the bottom line for being inducted into the Hall of Fame would be how well each player performed on the field during their career. When the baseball commissioner in 1989 Bart Giamatti banned Pete Rose from baseball after an investigation claiming that he was guilty of betting on baseball, what gave Giamatti the authority to ban Rose from the Hall of Fame? Although Pete Rose allegedly gambled on baseball, his overall performance in the game is something that should always be praised and remembered, which is why he should be admitted into the Cooperstown Hall of
It’s been a big debate in the sports world over recent years: “Should Pete Rose be in the hall of fame?”. The former baseball star was put on the MLB’s ineligible(banned from hall of fame) list in 1989 for gambling as a player and manager. Pete Rose should be allowed in the hall of fame because he was one of the greatest batters/ all around players of all-time and his crimes in the sport are lesser than those of others allowed in the hall of fame. Pete Rose is one of the greatest players in baseball’s history.
“Regardless of verdict of juries, no player who throws a ball game, no player who undertakes or promises to throw a game, no player who sits in conference with a bunch of crooked players and gamblers where the ways and means of throwing a ball game are discussed and does not properly tell his club about it, will ever play professional baseball again. " This statement was made official by Judge Kennesaw Mountain Landis in regards to the Black Sox World Series Scandal in from 1920-1920. The film Eight Men Out informs audiences about the Black Sox Scandal from all aspects, including: the people involved, the creation of the commissioner, and all the way until the verdict and later the death of Buck Weaver. The story behind this scandal deals with changes that would effect all aspects of baseball history,
Their argument is formed on the basis that they were not cheating during every game which makes their scandal not as bad. Where their argument fails is that it does not matter that they used it during the regular season, and only in home games. It matters because they highly benefitted during the playoffs. In the 2017 playoffs, Houston Astros star, Jose Altuve, had a batting average of .472, hit 6 HRs, and had 12 RBIs while at home. On the road, his batting average was .143, with 1 HR, and 2 RBIs.
Ryan Wanner History Dn Mr. Eichsteadt 3/1/2023 The Black Sox Scandal The 1919 Black Sox Scandal was a defining event in the history of the MLB Major League Baseball . The Scandal was started because of affairs within the Chicago White Sox, Involving the owner Charles Cominsky and 8 players that deserved better treatment. The players teamed up with gamblers to throw the world series and make some money, but it didn't end as planned. The Corrupt Gamblers and Players involved in the black sox created skepticism in the baseball community.
The critics were wrong because nowadays there is alot of black people in the mlb because of Jackie
Turns out they were doing witchcraft and got taken to court over the problem. The people included Abigale, Betty, Tituba, Marry Warren, Sussana, Sarah Good, all got caught for witchcraft. When it comes to baseball and getting caught for steroids, they all wanted to get buff at once and everyone found out. The word got around considering everybody was doing them. Alex Rodriguez used steroids as an early as highschool, and continued to used HGH even when he joined the Yankees.
Pete Rose In the Hall of Fame As any average baseball follower knows the all time hits leader for Major League Baseball, Pete Rose, is banned from baseball due to gambling charges in the 1980s that led to him also being banned from Cooperstown, also known as, The Hall of Fame. The argument I’m bringing forward is not a rare one or an educated one. It is very hard to justify not letting him when baseball players who are proven steroid users are in the Hall, see Jose Conseco, and that’s the only one that is proven, there is a 100% chance that there are more.
The Baseball hall of fame is home to amazing players that have changed the game forever, and Pete Rose should be included with these men. Yes, Pete Rose did do a bad thing, which is that he placed bets on baseball, which is against baseball rules, but this shouldn’t change everything else. Pete Rose should be inducted into the hall of fame because choices he made as a team manager shouldn’t affect how he is recognized for his skill as a player. Rose was a great player in the 23 years he played, his skills being what should get him into the hall. Pete Rose was banished from baseball for life on August 24, 1989(Lagrave, 2015) for his gambling which broke rule number 21.
He had a substantial influence on people so there were many people that “...traveled long distances to see him enter the Baseball Hall of Fame.” (Herman, 2) It is a massive honor to get into the Hall of Fame and he was able to get in just six years after he retired. Because of the extraordinary way Robinson was playing his first year, “He was named Rookie of the Year - the first one ever.” (Herman, 81) Since Robinson showed astonishing skills as a rookie, there was a new award made that year to be given to the person who played the best as a rookie, which was Jackie Robinson in 1947.
These players along with many more decided to try and cheat the game of baseball and take credit where credit was far from due. Sticking to baseball’s foundation of outstanding character and honesty will get a player far in not only life but baseball as well. Winners never cheat and cheaters never
Throughout his career he was an inspiration to many but many were saddened that he choose to do the wrong thing and when he did this he let most of his fan base down. Many think he is hall of fame worthy but his scandal might prevent
We know this is never going to happen except for in a perfect world. Pete Rose is one of the greatest players to ever step foot on a baseball field. He never had the intention of harming his career by gambling and is very regretful of doing so. The whole subject of Pete Rose getting into the Hall of Fame is very opinionated but needs to be looked at from multiple perspectives not just that he broke rule 21D and here is his consequence.
If you have taken a performance enhancing drug you shouldn’t be allowed into the hall of fame, because it takes away from the accomplishments of others who felt they didn’t need the drugs to succeed in whatever sport they were involved in. Athletes who used performance enhancing drugs do not belong in the hall of fame. What are performance enhancing drugs? Performance enhancing drugs are substances such as steroids, monkey testosterone, federally banned alcohol, and etc. These drugs help you perform in an exceptional way when you are hurt, wanted to relax during a long season, or simply just perform better.