What impact has the social construction of crime had on fear of crime, our view of victims and offenders and resulting criminal justice policy?
The media has been influential in shaping the way society thinks about certain issues, including crime. This essay argues that social construction has a negative impact on society’s view of the fear of crime, victims, and offenders. It’ll also study how social construction affects government policy.
Social constructionism
A famous study on social construction is Stanley Cohen’s study, originally conducted in 1972, of “mods and rockers” in the UK (Cohen 2011: vi). He studied two groups of young people in the 1960s who were fighting with each other. The media made these people out to be violent: “the
…show more content…
For example, Rodney King, whose attack by police offers was videotaped, was a victim of police racism, but to many white police officers he was a threatening deviant who encouraged the attack (Lawrence 2000: 70-73). Black males have typically been coined the term “thug” by the media in the 21st century (Smiley and Fakunle, 2016), which may explain why the police think that African Americans are a threat. Therefore, the ‘deviant’ label used for African Americans has a significant impact on the police’s and the public’s view of this group. “White respondents overestimate their risk of crime victimization more than twice as much in heavily black zip codes relative to areas with few black residents” (Quillian and Pager, 2010). This shows that, through the media labelling African Americans as ‘criminals’, white people feel they will be more likely to be a victim of crime in areas where this group is heavily …show more content…
African Americans are more likely to be shown to be offenders rather than victims, despite not being reflective of statistics (Reiner, 2002). This is unfair, as it leads people to believe that if they live near more African Americans, there may be more of a chance of criminal activity, causing unnecessary fear of becoming a victim of crime. The social construction of victims is unfair on African Americans, as they’re ‘tarred with the same brush’ as being offenders. This can make African Americans feel isolated and possibly be subject to racial
Crime, Citizenship, and the Court’s analyzation of Incarceration, Inequality, and Imagining Alternatives have revealed the prevalent racial profiling that exists in the African American community. Bruce Western emphasizes the prominent levels of incarceration in minority neighborhoods elaborating on the negative effects that these rates have on families, communities, and lifestyles. He reiterates that “incarceration deepens inequality because its negative social and economic effects are concentrated in the poorest communities” (Western, 297). When we analyze Fox News media portrayals of Martin, we could begin to understand why African Americans change their methods of transportation, clothing, and routines. These men adapt to the reality of racial profiling in fear that one day, they may contribute to the high incarceration rates within their communities.
Criminal behaviour has always been an interest for psychologists, for they could never quite come to a conclusion between nature and nurture. Research concerning this topic has been organized for many years and due to the never ending debate, is still being conducted. I have decided to read and write about this myself, for I was genuinely curious about the matter and wanted to be a part of the research, as I felt responsible to do so. I believe that in order to stop something, it must be discussed and scrutinized. What effects do genes have on criminal behaviour, why do peer pressure and habitat influence a person to commit crimes and are men really more violent than women?
Categories of crime Crime is crime, right? If you break the law, you should serve the time, right? If you perform an unlawful action, you should pay your penalty. It isn’t that easy, you have the right to certain protections under due process of the law and certain pieces are written into various crime definitions and need to be proven to find you guilty in a court of law.
Another claim is that African Americans are overrepresented as criminals in the news. Therefore, the news expresses “fear” to the white community toward black communities.
American Journal of Political Science. Hurwitz and Peffley write on how stereotypes about African Americans have an effect on people’s attitudes towards crime and policy. The authors discuss the link on race and crime and how the media has a lot to do with it. This work will be helpful to my research because of the stereotype linking blacks to crime. It will support my thesis on how race is spread throughout
People of color are confined by the constructed characterizations of their race or religion whereas white people have the luxury of belonging to the human race, (Dyer, 4). There is a stark disparity in the way black victims (of police brutality) and white criminals are represented in the media. African Americans are twice as likely to be portrayed as perpetrators of crime even when they are the victims in comparison to whites. They are also more likely to have mug shots displayed on news programs than that of white offenders (Dixon, Azocar, and Casas, 499). The Lubbock Avalanche-Journal titled the story of a white professor who was guilty of killing three colleagues as “Ala. Suspect Brilliant, but social misfit” whereas AL.com titled the story of a shooting death of a 25-year-old black man in Alabama as “Montgomery’s latest homicide victim had history of narcotics abuse, tangles with the law” (Wing).
An occurrence observed by the population of Los Angeles, California conveys the existence of racism and police brutality. According to The Polls-Trends: Racial Differences in Attitudes Toward the Police, “…three quarters of blacks, but only 38 percent of whites, continued to view police brutality as a common occurrence” (Tuch and Weitzer
“In the United States, white people have long told both overt and veiled narratives of the purported danger and criminality of people of color. Sometimes known as ‘danger narratives,’ these gruesome accounts often depict the kidnapping, assault, and murder of white women at the hands of men of color. These narratives have been used to promote and justify enslavement, lynching, mass incarceration, and a host of other methods and institutions of white supremacy and racial control.” (Web). This evidence shows that True Crime poses a dangerous narrative about people of color almost always being the perpetrators of violent crimes and white people almost always being the victims.
Crime in the United States Abstract In this paper we will examine the current crime and criminal justice system in the United States. We view the current crime trend and evaluate what factors that may affect them. We will analyze the different models of criminal justice as well as one of the ways we categorize crime. We will also examine the role of police departments in deterring crime, coupled with how they work to prevent corruption within the department.
Many sociologists argue that crime is not randomly patterned; some groups within society are much more likely to be victims of crime than others. Gender, ethnicity and social class are three key characteristics that may influence the likelihood of victimisation. However, it is very difficult to measure rates of victimisation because relatively little crime is reported to the police. This means that a huge proportion of crime is hidden, which is referred to as the ‘dark figure of crime,’ and for every hidden crime, there is a potential hidden victim. Although this is true, the information we do have about victimization relates to different theories, statistics, and views.
Criminological theories are the backbone of understanding criminal behavior, and they provide insight into the reasons why individuals engage in criminal activities. Theories such as social disorganization, strain, and social learning theories, have been developed to explain criminal behavior, and these theories have played a crucial role in shaping the approaches to controlling crime. Despite the significance of these theories, there has been a tendency to overlook them in current approaches to controlling crime. My essay will explore the extent to which criminological theories have been ignored within current approaches to controlling crime. Criminological Theories and The Theories of Crime Criminological theories are explanations that attempt to understand and explain the reasons behind criminal behavior.
Making Sense of Crime, Policy and Values- Sex Offender Laws The effectiveness of sex offender registrations and what do individuals do with that information, are questions that are being raised. We know that parents often seek information on individuals who they feel may pose a risk to their children. Whether it is a babysitter or the teenage boy next door, these parents find information by frequenting the sex offender registry. Sarah Tofte, one of the authors of the Human Rights Watch suggests, that the laws are written so broadly that even individuals who have not necessarily committed a sex crime have to register as a sex offender. If an individual urinate or expose oneself in public, that individual has to register as a sex offender and will be portrayed as such to parents and other individuals who view the registry.
Crime and Punishment: Sonya, Svidrigailov, and Lebezyatnikov represent three sides of Raskolnikov. How? Which sides? In his novel Crime and Punishment, famouse Russian author Fyodor Dostoevsky aimed at solving an important psychological and moral issue sounded like to show people the failure of empty and fabled theories, as well as reveal their dangerous and destructive force.
It is an area which many great sociologists have focused some of their work around, for example Durkheim and Marx. These sociologists are considered to be the ‘founding fathers’ of sociology. They were some of the first people to use the study of society and its interactions within as an academic study. Sociologists created such terms as ‘boundary maintenance’ – society exists in solidarity and conformity within a boundary. Outside such a boundary, there are incidences of crime and deviance.
Elements of crime: rough draft: (needs to be tweaked): Actus Reus- Guilty mind * Voluntary physical element of crime thus meaning the defendent has control of their body as well as conscious choice Examples of voluntary acts- Murder Rape Robbery Harry Gurrung kills couple due to sneezing fit whilst driving: Sgt Harry Gurrung was cleared of ‘killing’ a couple in a car crash as he suffered a sneezing fit in the process. This was important in determining him ‘not guilty’ as closing your eyes whilst sneezing is seen as a natural reaction thus refuting accusations of ‘reckless driving’; because closing you eyes whilst sneezing is more of an instinct that a conscious