In “The Hill We Climb” Amanda Gorman says that we are “striving to form our union with purpose,” “we will not be turned around or interrupted by intimidation because we know our inaction and inertia will be the inheritance of the next generation, become the future.” Bryan Stevenson is the perfect embodiment of this powerful statement. Throughout the novel, Stevenson is constantly striving to build the country with a just purpose. Regardless of the challenges, Stevenson refuses to be turned around or “interrupted by intimidation.” Stevenson proves his argument to be true, not just based on his legacy or experience but on clear proven facts and experiences of others. In “Just Mercy,” Bryan Stevenson uses the rhetorical appeals of ethos, pathos, …show more content…
Stevenson begins chapter 12 of “Just Mercy” by telling the story of Marsha Colbey, a poor woman convicted of the 1st degree murder of her Stillborn son. A Department of Forensic Sciences autopsy revealed, “that Marsha Colbey’s baby was born alive but also asserted that the child would have survived with medical attention” (Stevenson 144). A mere few weeks after the stillbirth, Marsha found herself sentenced to life in prison for the unrelated death of her innocent child. Stevenson reports that the state weaponized her economic status to forge a powerful narrative against Marsha’s character and parenting ability. The death of a child is already a horrid event, often having significant mental health results on parents and family members. The imprisonment of the child’s mother does not help resolve this issue. Stevenson argues that unfortunately, Marsha Colbey is not alone in this injustice. In the case of infant deaths, “a presumption of guilt has now fallen on thousands of women—particularly poor women in difficult circumstances—whose children die” (Stevenson 145). A deadly combination of nosy peers, a presumption of guilt, and a structural oppressive “justice” system spells the end of free life for many women in minority communities all around the United States. The problem of presumption of guilt spoken about in the first part is built on by a lack of representation endorsed and maintained by the criminal justice system itself. This dangerous statistic demonstrates how widespread this injustice is. Stevenson logically verifies this point with references to the processes used to convict these innocent women. The story of Victoria Banks is a prime example of the
A teenager mother from Mississippi, Sabrina Butler was first known as the only female offender on Mississippi’s death row who was convicted for child abuse and the murder of her infant son. On the eve of April 11th, 1989, Sabrina Butler arrived at the hospital after midnight with a nine-month-old Walter Dean Butler, who was unresponsive at the scene. She claimed that she have found the baby when he unexpectedly stopped breathing, and after multiple failed attempts to resuscitate her son, she rushed to the emergency room and seek helps from medical professionals who are more knowledgeable on the matter. Sadly, her child was pounced died by the doctors following their visit to the hospital. The next day, while Sabrina was asked to give her statements at the local police station, the prosecutors arrested Sabrina under the charges of capital murder.
In a country where people are promised equal and fair treatment regardless of their gender or racial identity, Stevenson, through McMillian, shows the gory side of the reality that exists within the United States’ judicial system. A system that offers justice to some and victimizes
In Jenkins argument it explains that , “ My younger sister was the joy of our close family. When a teenager murdered her and her husband in 1990 in suburban Chicago , she was pregnant with their first child.” These quotes explicate that both author have experience this topic in different forms but also know what they are writing about in which case make them credible. Even though these articles have similarities they also differentiate themselves by jenkins emotion take over her judgment.
In the book Just Mercy, by Bryon Stevenson, he shares the story of his upbringing as a lawyer and company Equal Justice Initiative in Montgomery, Alabama. Through his career, he was able to understand the full extent of mercy and its ability to bring out people’s humanity. Additionally, Stevenson argues how people who act upon prejudiced beliefs are just as broken as those who have been condemned to life in prison without parole and on death row, because they have all been defeated by a sense of hopelessness and animosity within their own lives. In my critique, I describe my new found understanding of the cruelty behind the death penalty. Moreso, the trauma and brutality it brings to all the players involved, especially to those who are placed on death row.
Author and lawyer Bryan Stevenson chronicles the unjust and inhumane stories of multiple prisoners throughout the South. He tries to appeal and save each individual from unethical sentences that were handed down upon them. Stevenson uses this book as way to shine a very bright light on the unfair practices and sentences that consistently happen throughout American court rooms to the mentally ill and the vulnerable. He is able to provide a prologue for each prisoner and case he encounters that provides crucial information that can potentially alter whether each client would end up dying in prison, or have the potential to see life outside of cement walls and bars. Stevenson is able to show readers the unfair practices of not only prosecutors
Assignment #1 good use of rhetoric (ethos, pathos, logos) most effectively portrays pathos and is trying to help us understand why we should care about social situations like this through emotions, credibility, and logic Logos • footnotes at the bottom adds calculations in intelligence and to support her arguments (notes to readers what she is telling us is not anecdotal evidence but rather experts agree minimum pay wage is not feasible to living) • uses of many footnotes to give statistical facts that are evidence to support the information/argument she states • Ex) "in 1991 there were forty-seven affordable rental units available to every one hundred low-income families, while by 1997 there were only thirty-six such units for every one hundred
In his book Just Mercy, Bryan Stevenson shows empathy and compassion as he puts a stop to mass incarceration for Juvenile Offenders by providing equality of justice. Stevenson works endlessly, day and night to correct a wrongful conviction of a Death Row inmate, Walter Mcmillian. When he first meets Walter, at the end of the Book, we know that he's innocent. In page 73 of Just Mercy, Stevenson meets Walter’s wife Minnie Belle Mcmillian, and his Daughter, Jackie, as they were waiting patiently for him, after he promised Walter that he’ll meet his family. This shows that Stevenson will even put in the time and effort in order to get to know more about Walter and his family in order to prove he's innocent.
This includes the imprisonment of a child who was sentenced to the death penalty after the he murdered of his abusive stepfather. The child was given death penalty without parole and placed in to a men’s prison instead of a juvenile prison. In the men’s prison the child had been sexually assaulted and raped on multiple occasions. On page 128 Stevenson states, “I told them that the child had been sexually abused and raped.” This particular scene shows the violence and neglect in the prisons of Alabama as well as the dehumanization of inmates from officers.
“There is a strength, a power even, in understanding brokenness, because embracing our brokenness creates a need and desire for mercy, and perhaps a corresponding need to show mercy (Stevenson 109) .” This bold statement is one of many as Bryan Stevenson sets the tone for his renowned award winning novel Just Mercy. As a young lawyer from Georgia, built the foundation for his company, SPDC (Southern Prisoners Defense Committee) to help convicts that are on death row or in need a second chance. Bryan Stevenson, a young lawyer from Georgia who fought for justice on the behalf of inmates on death row, showed tremendous intelligence in becoming a successful lawyer, demanding for not backing down in moments of refusal, and was an overall advocate
There are many victims of unfortunate circumstances in the world today, yet some of these results could have been easily avoided. In the novel, Just Mercy, the author Bryan Stevenson addresses many cases in which children under the age of 18 are incarcerated within the adult criminal justice system. By treating children as adults in the criminal justice system their innocence and undeveloped person, become criminalized. These children become dehumanized and only viewed as full-fledged criminals and as a result society offers no chance sympathy towards them. Stevenson argues that children tried as adults have become damaged and traumatized by this system of injustice.
In chapter four, Bryan Stevenson uses pathos to convince the audience that capital punishment is different than reading it on paper and shows the details around it. Throughout chapter four, you read about Bryan and his first case with his office, you forget everyone is a person and see the discomfort people are in the story. For example, “Believing in capital punishment is one thing, but the realities of systematically killing someone who is not a threat are completely different. ”(Stevenson 71). Bryan uses pathos in this section when he tells you about his first case.
Bryan Stevenson generated an inspiring and serious voice in his memoir Just Mercy. The novel by Stevenson is something that weighs on the reader’s heart due to the naked truth revealed in almost every case presented to the audience. The tragic and real events throughout the book are heavy and difficult to grasp, especially when all of the events happened recently. Every chapter exploits the raw corruption of the justice systems, as well as the proof that there are good and just people in the world. Stevenson tells half of the story from his perspective, and the other half as a third party narrator.
Mary Kwentus Mr. Singleterry ENGL 2250 22 May 2023 Social Unjustness In Bryan Stevenson’s novel Just Mercy Stevenson gives his first-person accounts of the social justice system in America and marginalized Americans who are unfairly punished. The novel retells the cases of Stevenson. Stevenson fights to end the justice system’s unjustness and racial discrimination. The novel follows Stevenson as he and his company the Equal Justice Initiative work to help prisoners on death row and give them the legal representation they deserve.
In Bryan Stevenson’s Just Mercy, he writes to illustrate the injustices of the judicial system to its readers. To do so, Stevenson utilizes multiple writing styles that provide variety and helps keep the reader engaged in the topic. Such methods of his include the use of anecdotes from his personal experiences, statistics, and specific facts that apply to cases Stevenson had worked on as well as specific facts that pertain to particular states. The most prominent writing tool that Stevenson included in Just Mercy is the incorporation of anecdotes from cases that he himself had worked on as a nonprofit lawyer defending those who were unrightfully sentenced to die in prison.
On February 18th of 1965 there was a big debate between James Baldwin and William Buckley. This big debate took place in the cambridge union in England. This debate was about all of the problems that were being faced with African Americans and the violent things that were happening in Birmingham and other parts of the country. There were a lot of assassinations around this time period including president JFK Malcom X and more. The main discussion was about the segregation between African blacks and white people.