The Genocidal Innocence Orson Scott Card’s Ender’s Game has sparked many controversial seminars that have produced numerous critical thinking questions. Were Andrew “Ender” Wiggin’s intentions actually good, and was his commited genocide actually guilty? Jon Kessel’s essay, Creating the Innocent Killer, brings up many points that the author of Ender’s Game tried to hide Ender’s crime by making the reader feel sympathy for his past. Many different essays argue that Ender has psychological damage from his past, has been manipulated into doing things he didn’t want to do, and also suffers from anger issue problems. In Ender’s Game, Ender is reminded of his past and his maniacal brother. Peter, Ender’s older brother often threatened Ender, saying …show more content…
The officers and students, at both battle and command school, often told Ender to do things, or kill buggers in games, and he often listened to them. Manipulation was the main underlying factor throughout the book, and adults were regularly seen to lie to Ender in order to make him believe things were right. In Jon Kessel’s essay, Kessel states that “adults or authority are never there to protect” in the story, which is true. Ender was constantly told to do the wrong thing. Many different articles state that this is the reason why Ender is innocent, but that is simply untrue. Ender had his own set of morals before he went to Battle School, and he simply ignored them when peer pressure came into play. Ender knew he was being manipulated, he just did nothing to stop it. This is yet another reason why I believe Ender is …show more content…
Ender does show his feelings of kindness and other emotions occasionally throughout the book, but we see more of his dangerous “Peter-like” side than anything. Peter always seemed to take things too far, because of his power hungry wants. Although Ender doesn’t necessarily want everyone to bow down to him, he does go a little out of hand when he gets angry. His burts could almost make the reader describe him as having a “rage disorder”, which, according to valleybehavioral.com, is violent outbursts filled with “sudden episodes of unwanted anger.” Ender takes his anger out on others when he stressed or sad, and usually, without meaning too, ends up killing someone. Or, in the case of the buggers, everyone. In Kessel’s essay, he describes how Ender knew the damage the MD Weapon would cause, just as his commanders do. That doesn’t stop Ender, however, from committing a planet wide genocide that wiped out a whole world without gathering any information about it or trying to create peace between the two planets. Ender was sometimes half-innocent in his murders, but he still murdered nonetheless, with his own two
An Analysis of the Relation between Violence and Compassion Violence is the notorious cause of conflicts around the world. This theme arises many times within the novel “Ender’s Game,” written by Orson Scott Card. Ender Wiggin is just a young boy when he is expected to save all of mankind. Through constant fear of becoming like his abusive brother, Peter, Ender unknowingly executes an entire species, known as buggers. After enduring immense self-conflict, Ender is finally able to restore his compassion, and identity.
Ender’s anger usually came in the form of “cold” anger, meaning he could use it to his advantage. When Ender learned he could exploit his anger for good, he decided that, “.... with that anger… he was strong enough to defeat them…his enemies “ ( 172). When all the pressure around Ender built up and finally came out, it was after he found out he had killed the buggers, and he had slept for “five days of the league war” (300). Ender has had smaller outbursts and reactions before this, but sleeping for five days while a post bugger-killing war is going on shows that he was really affected by his act of
Who would have thought that a boy both violent and caring could save and eliminate a species? In the book Enders Game, Ender and he was no ordinary child, and his intellect was beyond any normal child. His life started to change as his monitor, a device that tracked what he did, was removed and he was forced to face with a long-time bully of his. As Ender gets pushed around, he hits a hard blow and gives no mercy to the boy if he ever wanted it to end. Surprisingly, the people in commands recognize his unfound talents and decided to train him in a school every boy would want to attend.
“Just as the next blow was coming, Ender reached up with both hands, snatched the boy by his wrist, and then pulled down on the arm, hard.” () Card and his somewhat applaudable idea of power did not view it sufficient enough for Ender to request the aid of an adult. But did envision Ender reinforcing the agony brought upon him, promulgating his power in such a way he experiences yet another unintended consequence. “…the boy was feeling exactly the pain Ender had meant him to feel…I am Peter. I’m just like him.
“He didn’t know what to say, and he was afraid to reveal himself to be any more monstrous than his actions had made him out to be… Ender couldn’t help it, he was too afraid, too ashamed of his own acts; though he tried not to, he cried again.” (19) Ender is immensely terrified of becoming a monster; his remorse and shame caused by his horrific actions increases his fear. However, his guilt-enforced tears show that even though his actions were callous, Ender’s possession of kindness is unscathed. The humanity Ender shows through the tears he failed to stop is what prevents his worse nightmare from coming true.
Chapter Eight: Rat I. Summary The chapter begins with Graff talking with Anderson and telling him to throw Ender in unfair situations to see what he does and rank them by the increase of difficulty. Anderson disagrees and states that the game is everything at Battle School and if they change it, everything will be ruined, but Graff says that they have to prepare the soldiers for the next bugger war. Unlike Salamander Army, Rat Army has no discipline whatsoever and the commander, who is Rose the Nose, is too laid back. Dink Meeker is one of the toon leaders of Rat Army and asks for Ender to join his toon, because he thinks Ender has potential.
The whole time Ender had not been aware he had killed them, and the leaders were manipulating him for his own sake. They explain that they didn’t tell him that he actually killed both Bonzo and Stilson; so that he wouldn’t think of himself as a killer. Throughout the book Ender repeats that he doesn’t want to hurt anyone and doesn’t like that he has to be violent in order to be safe. If Ender would’ve found out, it would destroy his motivation and drive to want to be the best he can be. All in all, Ender is an overall better person because of the fact he didn’t know the
After winning many different types of conflicts, Ender is fearful of every coming battle, his mind has fallen into a “all or nothing” mindset. He tells Bean, “I can’t lose any games. Because if I lose any-” (pg.198). In this confession, we can see that Ender is cracking under pressure, he realizes what is at risk, his entire attempt to save those whom he loves. The effects of this pressure on Ender's make him vulnerable, but also turns him savage to save what he loves.
The kid whose arm he broke– Ender didn’t feel sorry for him.”(pg. 41) Ender’s leadership is shown through his ability to not have his indecision eat away at his soul. Also, Ender is ruthless, which is necessary for a leader, and a very strong ideology. He does not regret anything, because after all, Ender is the one being bullied and all he simply did was just respond.
When Ender was talking to himself he said,”the power to cause pain is the only power that matters, the power to kill and destroy, because if you can’t kill then you’re always subject to those who can, and no one will ever save you,”(Card pg.212). This shows that inaction can make people prone to lose against people who have power can have power over them because inaction leaves them open and defenseless to those they could restrain. This also shows that inaction leads to loss because Ender is referring to the fight against Stilson, Bonzo, and Bernard because if he had waited for the teachers to respond to call for help they would’ve overpowered him and he would’ve lost. After ender defeated the buggers Mazer Rackham told Ender, “you made the hard choice, boy. All or nothing.
In “Ender’s Game”, Ender was manipulated by the government into believing he was playing games to prepare him for the war against the buggers, but he was actually fighting against the buggers. This has a huge impact on Ender because he dislikes killing and he is now known as a killer across the world. Orson Scott Card also shows that if you give in to commands in the beginning, you will soon have no power, leading you to believe everything the commander says. The information the commander will later tell you will be euphemisms to the actual truth, but you would not know. Dink, one of Ender’s friends, lectured Ender that, "commanders have just as much authority as you let them have.
In the book, it is made completely clear that the system of both the Battle School and Command School are breaking Ender down, ultimately demonstrated by Ender being completely bedridden after the Third Invasion due to everything he’s endured. This also happens with the movie’s presentation of the characters, with more characters being sympathetic to Ender. This completely overrides a plot point in the book,
However, the majority of the battles he fights are constructed and orchestrated and controlled by the Adults. Ender lives in a military archetype which assumes humans are compliant, flexible, controllable pawns, tool to be used for the benefit of others. Ender’s insecurities,doubts and fears, as to why he is so isolated, how he is becoming more like petter, how he is an ostracized genius, all that sets him apart– make him diligent, sympathetic, preservant, resilient, flexible, and above all pliable, impressionable, malleable, qualities far more common in children. Supporting quote: “‘So what do we do now?’ asked Alai.
Scott Macarthy Mr. Werley English III 22 September 2014 The Destruction of Ender A utopia is supposed to be a perfect world, yet there are rarely any true utopias. Ender’s Game begins with a utopic society, where the government pits Earth against the nasty and evil buggers. Throughout Ender 's Game, written by Orson Scott Card, the reader follows the main protagonist, Ender, from his journey as a young boy on Earth to the hopes of being the next great commander in the fight against the buggers.
Calculating Judgments For someone so young, Ender is exceptionally calculating. In almost the very beginning of the novel, the author shows Ender being bullied by Stilson and his gang. Ender realizes that he must thoroughly beat Stilson so the rest of the gang wouldn’t pick on Ender ever