Savage Inequalities Book Review Savage Inequalities by Jonathan Kozol is an in-depth analysis of America’s public school system and the problems that encompass it. Kozol’s book examines some of the poorest public schools in the United States and attempts to explain how the school or school district plummeted so far into the depths of poverty. Kozol believes that the biggest problem public school faces is segregation, which is still very real in many parts of the United States. Racism and a lackadaisical attitude toward the education of minority groups in America are the roots of the problems that public schools face. In his book, Jonathan Kozol visits a multitude of schools across the country, from poverty-stricken schools to affluent schools. …show more content…
Louis that Kozol visits is East St. Louis Senior High School. Not quite two years prior to Kozol’s visit, the school experienced an evacuation due to a sewage flood in the kitchen, but the school was re-opened the following morning for classes. It was stated that the flood was caused by “fumes and backed-up toilets” (Kozol 23). Several days later, the same flood occurred again, this time extending to the parking lot and the playing fields. Later during the same week, the school district called for the layoff of “280 teachers, 166 cooks and cafeteria workers, 25 teacher aids, 16 custodians and 18 painters electricians, engineers and plumbers” (2). This cut caused the classroom size to reach at least 30-35 students for each teacher in the building. The teachers began to have paychecks arrive up to two weeks late and one coach stated that the paychecks are sometimes missing altogether. Meanwhile, the teachers that did not get laid off were short on supplies, often running out of essential teaching tools such as books, chalk, and even paper. Kozol discusses the premise of a class called “Introductory Home Ec.” (27), and the teacher explains that the class trains students for the work force. When asked for what type of jobs this class trains, the teacher replies, “fast food places- Burger King, McDonald’s” (27). The conditions of the building itself are also described by the teachers as treacherous. One teacher states that the heating system has …show more content…
These schools are provided with school books, proper equipment, and sanitary conditions. The children of East St. Louis Senior High School, as well as other high schools in East St. Louis, are well aware of the existence of these schools and are obviously upset by the deplorable conditions of their own school. The next school that Kozol visits is Clark Junior High School. Kozol explains that the conditions of these schools are managed by state funding, and the governor of Missouri does not want to keep “dumping money” into the school district and believes that he cannot help a school district that will not help themselves. The children of these schools, however, realize that the money that funds their schools and the money that funds other schools in the state is very different. The taxes that come from East St. Louis are not enough to sustain the amount of schools that are in the district, and therefore account for the conditions of the schools. However, just across the bridge live more affluent and educated adults who pay more into taxes to assure that their children have a safe, healthy, and stimulating environment in which to attend school each day. The children comment on how unfair this system has become for the children of East St. Louis. One girl states that the government of the state
Michie’s “Holler If You Hear Me” and Kozol’s “Still Separate Still Unequal” are quite alike, considering they both discuss south side Chicago schools. However, the differences between the two texts far outweigh the similarities. Although there are a few similarities, such as both authors discussing and calling out the issues of segregation in their texts, there are many differences, such as Michie’s work being a narrative while Kozol’s is not and only contains anecdotes. In addition, Michie focuses on the experiences and opinions of students, instead of also discussing the physical state of inner-city schools or the strategies of teachers.
Kozol shares quotes from individuals throughout his writing where they discuss children and the affects of being illiterate. “I come out of school. I was sixteen. They said I was wasting their school paper.
LITERATURE REVIEW #1: The Prize In the book, The Prize, written by Dale Russakoff discusses the issues urban schools face with the limits of money and a top-down approach in how to run the schooling system. The book is based of Newark schools, and starts off with New Jersey politicians Cory Booker and Chris Christie who are troubled with the $100 million pledge from Mark Zuckerberg to transform the Newark school. Money is limited to reform education, even more so with the top-down autocracy of the locally elected officials who are not allowing reform to take place. The book further describes the situations in the Newark school, with the problems of poverty and violence at the forefront of it all.
Menlo Park Academy is a chaotic school with no order. The board is made of parents who only want the best for their child. Parents practically run the school and the only students who get the advanced classes are students of parents who fight the school for their child, even if other students are qualified. The school is run by parents, it 's completely chaotic. Menlo Park Academy simply takes the good, gifted from public schools, and hurts the public school system.
As Kozol writes in Savage Inequalities. “The difference in spending between very wealthy suburbs and poor cities is not always as extreme as this in Illinois”(66). Throughout the years there has been an extreme problem with poverty in East St. Louis especially in the lower part where proximately african american people live. In East St.Louis there is a fine that separates the poor and the wealthy and each stay in there own lane. In north of East St Louis where predominately white people there no problem.
“A large number of books we had in Boston were either quietly bad or subtly bad, or else just devastatingly bad only in one part,” (73). All the books they had in that school were old books falling apart. Not only that, but they contained irrelevant information and none of the books were about black people. Mr. Kozol also explains how bad some of the school building conditions are when he says, “The falling-in of a frame of windows on a class of Fourth Grade pupils was one graphic and measurable danger,” (85). This is an incredibly dangerous
These students don’t get equal opportunities as those students attending elite schools. Authors Toni Cade Bambara and Jonathon Kozol have written vivid examples on how working class students have been impacted by segregation in school. Working class schools
The text appeals to the readers for both of the examples through emotion (pathos) by describing the conditions that the students learn in and it shows how the administration doesn’t care about the well-being of the students. Mireya discusses Fremont’s academic and sanitary problems and in the court papers it states, “Some of the classrooms ’do not have air-conditioning,’ so that students ‘become red-faced and unable to concentrate’ during ‘the extreme heat of summer.’ The rats observed by children in their elementary schools proliferate at Fremont High as well. ‘Rats in eleven . . . classrooms,’ maintenance records of the school report “(Kozol 708).
Kozol pointed out that conditions such as deteriorating schools, lack of teaching materials and overcrowding of classrooms are all due to the lack of funding in less fortunate schools. Most of these less privileged schools are made up of African-American students. In The Shame of the Nation, Jonathan Kozol consistently considers the conflict theory, but one of the most powerful statements in relation to the conflict theory came in Chapter 2 of the text. Kozol describes an elementary school that was built to hold 1,000 students but was filled with 1,500 instead. In this same school, a plastic garbage bag was covering part of a collapsing ceiling.
Structurally Mr. Burns School system and the city is oppressed. AS explained earlier, it will be difficult to bring in the proper personnel to bring the city out of the oppressed cycle due to the lack of resources to attract these individuals. Mr. Burns also explained that most of the funding is being sourced to the penitentiary that is close to the school and if they could get just two percent of their funding to educate the children maybe it can reduce the incarceration
Jonathan Kozol, educator and activist, wrote “Freemont High School” in 2005 which came from his book, The Shame of the Nation: The Restoration of Apartheid Schooling in America, to draw attention to the misfortunes of this inner city school in Los Angeles, California. The learning conditions the students have at Freemont are horrendous. Being one of the poorest schools from lack of funding, the health conditions the children have to attend school in are absurd. Compared to Freemont, Maryville High School is a very nice school to attend and has much better learning conditions. The two schools are different in dramatic ways, but neither school is a perfect one to attend.
I was amazed to read that in the affluent school, some of the children mention they will rather not be rich. Rich meant that they could not work and they will rather work since they liked working. In the executive school, I was bothered by the comment that a teacher stated. A teacher associated low-income children with discipline problems. I think that teacher generalized an observation he
Rewarding schools based on proficiency allows schools that are plagued by poverty to be set up for failure. Schools that are in areas with high rates of poverty show lower academic success due to students facing difficulties in their home life can affect their performance in school. Judging schools based on proficiency levels not only reduces possible funding for schools in need, but it also gives a “false impression that all high-poverty schools are ineffective” according to the Thomas B. Fordham Institute (Petrilli, M., & Churchill, A., n.d.). Looking at the Minneapolis Public School District, as one example, we
It is also easy to be pessimistic about children and schools. I prefer to be optimistic. I learn from my failures and I let the children learn from theirs. That is how this book evolved - from my failures and from watching the anguish of my colleagues. I found that many could not establish nor maintain a consistent and effective learning climate.
Upon becoming a teacher, I would have never thought of all the possible conceptual changes I would experience. I am continuously noticing my perspective of things being changed, but thus far I have noticed one big conceptual change I have made. This would be my conception of urban schools. My misconception consisted of my thinking that all urban schools were “bad” schools, but by the end of this paper I will prove that my conception of urban vs. rural schools has drastically changed. I will do this by proving research over urban schools and my research I found within the work I have done in my EDTL 2010 class.