ipl-logo

The Euthyphro Dilemma

977 Words4 Pages

In order to properly address tough questions in medical ethics, we need to ensure that we have plausible and consistent reasons for the answers we give to those questions. To do this, we need to take a step back and ask the broader question, “What makes right actions right and wrong actions wrong?” In this class, we have considered a number of possible answers to this question. Since each of these theories is inconsistent with the others, only one of them (at most) can be correct. In what follows, I consider each of these theories and argue that _________ is the most plausible. Moral subjectivism is the belief that morality is determined by an individual, it is not dependent on society but only on the individual. A moral subjectivism follows …show more content…

God created all humans, therefore he must think that every human is seen equally as worthy to be deemed beautiful. The Euthyphro Dilemma is Plato’s question concerning what is truly good and how it is determined whether a thing is good either because God says it’s good, or if God say it is good because it’s good. Most theists would agree that God himself is the foundation of morality or goodness. God is good so whatever he thinks is good must be true. They would agree that whatever is God’s will is what is good and just. But the question of whether it is good and just because God determines it or whether God determines it because it is good and just still remains. · Utilitarianism is theory that an action should create the greatest possible balance of happiness over unhappiness or of pleasure over pain. A utilitarian would follow the idea of using beauty to create happiness. The idea of increasing one’s utility by being “beautiful” would be followed by the utilitarian because it is likely that more people would be happy if people were more attractive and people would be less susceptible to feel upset or hurt by being attractive. In the end, if most people are at the maximum amount of happiness, then being beautiful would be encouraged. Being less than beautiful would be frowned upon because in society, it would not create the most happiness, it would create

Show More
Related

  • Euthyphro By Plato Summary

    423 Words  | 2 Pages

    The reading, “Euthyphro” by Plato, is a discussion between Socrates and Euthyphro, where they converse over the ideas of knowledge. In the beginning, Euthyphro has to take his own father to court. The reasoning for this is that one of his father’s slaves killed another slave, so he tied him up. While he was going to get the authorities, the captured slave died. A question that is imposed is, “What is piety or goodness?”

    Read More

  • Compare Plato's Euthyphro Dilemma

    1152 Words  | 5 Pages

    In order to examine the problems this claim is followed by, first we must assess exactly what the statement means. The specific problems that arise from claiming it to be true and different depending on whether you say it because you believe that God commanding the actions make them good, or whether God would only command actions which are good absent from his will. These two different option form the basis for Plato’s Euthyphro Dilemma in which Socrates asks Euthyphro that very question: ‘Is what is holy holy because the gods approve of it, or do they approve it because it is holy?’ , with the former being known as the Divine Command Theory.

    Read More

  • Physician Assisted Suicide Case Study

    1370 Words  | 6 Pages

    Introduction In this essay, I will argue that the distinction between a physician killing a patient, and letting a patient die, upon the untreatable patients request, regarding to physician assisted suicide is not an important distinction to make regarding morality; however, it is important in regards to how a physician killing a patient and letting a patient die is justified. I will argue this by first making a distinction, regarding to the moral justifications for physician assisted suicide, between a physician killing an untreatable patient and letting an untreatable patient die, and then argue that even though both are morally permissible, the distinction between letting die and killing is a very important distinction to make. When I am stating letting die as defined by Tom L. Beauchamp, I am referring to a person, in

    Read More

  • Belmont Report: Moral Responsibility

    1948 Words  | 8 Pages

    As a development in Deontological Pluralism, the Belmont Report offers a series of moral duties to consider in medical research and procedure. The Belmont Report considers Respect for Persons, Beneficence, and Justice to be the morals to uphold in medical research. These three moral obligations determine the morality of decisions and allow a deliberation on actions. In the scenario of Troy and Kim, I will consider each moral obligation in terms of applicability and importance in order to determine the most moral action for the couple. As a member of the medical ethics committee deciding whether it is morally permissible to refuse to remove Kim’s birth control implant, I argue it is not morally permissible primarily on the grounds of Respect

    Read More

  • The Five Dialogues: The Story Of Euthyphro

    201 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the novel The Five Dialogues the story of Euthyphro discusses two different sides of what pious and impious is and how to apply critical thinking into solving the problem. Although, the real question is what Euthyphro and Socrates think of what the true definition of pious and impious. The word pious in a society means that they are devoted to god. So when Socrates went to court of being charged of impiety by Meletus which he then encounters Euthyphro who was about to prosecute is father for accidentally killing a man who was one of his workers. Euthyphro claims that he is being holy and that he isn’t doing anything wrong about turning his father in for murder.

    Read More

  • Euthyphro Problem Essay

    1540 Words  | 7 Pages

    In the first suppose, it demonstrates that the virtue of something being pious originates from themselves and that the property of being pious is not determined by the gods if they love it for being pious. In this instance, even when gods love them, the value of holy goods cannot rise since the virtue already belongs to them and was not imparted by the will of the gods. In the second response, if anything is pious because the gods love it, then it can only be pious if it also gets their love; an object cannot be pious without the gods' love. After I discuss the original Euthyphro problem, I believe we have a basic understanding of it and can approach the Euthyphro problem for theists in a similar way. Theists, such as Christians, hold the belief that there is only one supreme being in the cosmos who is omnipotent, omniscient, and monotheistic and who both initially created and continues to influence the cosmos today.

    Read More

  • Euthyphro: One Of Plato's Classic Dialogues

    931 Words  | 4 Pages

    If the first is culled, it would implicatively insinuate that whatever God commands must be good: even if he commanded someone to inflict suffering, then inflicting suffering must be moral. If the latter is culled, then morality is no longer dependent on God, vanquishing the divine command theory. Also, if God is subject to an external law, he is not sovereign or omnipotent, which would challenge the orthodox conception of God. Proponents of the Euthyphro dilemma might claim that divine command theory is conspicuously erroneous because either answer challenges the competency of God to give moral

    Read More

  • Identify Which Moral Theories Have A Significant Influence On The Social Construct Of The Surgeon

    507 Words  | 3 Pages

    The decision as to whether it would be morally acceptable for the operation to take place, lies in the social construct of the surgeon and what influences her morals. Throughout the course of this essay I will identify theories on morality that will offer a framework as to how we think and identify which moral theories have a significant influence on the social construct of the surgeon which consequently will reveal her decision. Utilitarianism; right and wrong is determined by an outcome whereby happiness outweighs the consequences of the moral dilemma, in this case killing one man to save five. This is one of the theories the surgeon would potentially base her decision on. If the surgeon believed in this theory, her decisions would not be influenced by any personal preferences or interests, she would in turn believe it morally admissible to operate, as sacrificing the life of one person to save five people would be for the greater good, as the action may lead to overall happiness which in-turn outweighs the bad.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Tomcik V. Ohio Department Of Rehabilitation

    1010 Words  | 5 Pages

    Evans and the Ohio Department of Corrections failed Tomcik in applying basic ethical theories. Normative and applied ethics were not followed because the minimal standard of care in this case called for palpitation of the breasts, which was not done. If the physician knew that palpitation of the side of Tomcik’s breasts was the correct minimal procedure to detect cancer and he did not complete it, he failed to apply the theory of how he should behave. Deontological ethics were failed as the doctor was duty-bound to “do no harm or injustice”. (Greek Medicine, 2012)

    Read More

  • Dostoevsky's Divine Command Theory Analysis

    778 Words  | 4 Pages

    Furthermore, defenders of the divine command theory like Alston have faced the Euthyphro dilemma by says that although God’s commands make right actions right, God is morally perfect and hence would never issue unjust or immoral commandments. On their eyes, God’s nature is the standard of moral goodness, and God’s commands or words are the origin of all obligation and kindness.(Jeremy Koons, n.d.) One well-known objection to divine will/divine command moral theories is that they commit us to the view that God’s will is arbitrary, and the arbitrary will of God is not a plausible basis for morality.(Thomas,

    Read More

  • Taking Action In Plato's Euthyphro Dilemma

    1864 Words  | 8 Pages

    Imagine that you and a friend are exploring the moonlit streets of downtown Seattle on foot. As both of you approach the crosswalk, you happen to notice a car speeding down the hill that precedes the crosswalk, but your friend, being from elsewhere and engrossed in awe, fails to notice the speeding car and continues to the crosswalk with no sign of planning to stop from both your friend and the speeding car. For the sake of ease let’s assume that only two actions can be taken. The first one being that you shove your friend out of the way and you get hit by the speeding car and suffer injuries that diminish the quality of your life. The second option is that you, instead of sacrificing your well-being, allow the car to hit your friend which will result in their death.

    Read More

  • Surgical Ethics Personal Statement

    692 Words  | 3 Pages

    Through the bioethics program at Columbia University, I intend to further investigate a few areas of interest. Surgical ethics is a significant area of interest and holds importance to me. I am interested in investigating the ethics of conducting research on the decisional capacity of patients who have

    Read More

  • Hippocratic Oath Essay

    517 Words  | 3 Pages

    This topic was chosen because medical ethics is a complex topic. It gets complicated when other peoples’ wellbeing are on the line, based off your own decisions. Medical ethics involves much consideration because many choices in the medical field cannot be taken back, so the physician only has one shot to get it

    Read More

  • Ethics In Health Care Essay

    1610 Words  | 7 Pages

    The practice of health care includes many scenarios that have to do with making adequate decisions when it comes to a patient’s life, and the way they are treated. Having an ethical code in all health care organizations is very important, because it helps health care workers with reaching a suited and ethical decision when it comes to the patient. In health care, patient will always be put first, and their autonomy will always be respected. Nevertheless, when there is a situation where a patient might be in harm, or might be making their condition worse because of the decisions they made. Health care workers will always be there to

    Read More

  • Ethical Egoism Vs Ethical Subjectivism

    1218 Words  | 5 Pages

    He states that according to the theory, there is no such thing as right or wrong, that morality is just a matter of feeling rather than reason. (James Rachels, 2014). According to Rachels, Ethical Subjectivism is merely the approval or disapproval of things, in other words, if a person says that something is morally good or bad, this means that he or she approves of that thing, or disapproves of it, and nothing more. (James Rachels, 2014.

    Read More

More about The Euthyphro Dilemma

Open Document