“Their Eyes Were Watching God,” by Zora Neale Hurston, Janie had three husbands. All three husbands have similarities and differences. In the novel Janie, has dealt with abuse. The three men that she dealt with are Logan, Joe and Tea Cake. All three husbands, Janie was with them different amounts of years, but dealt with the same situation. Different men can have differences and similarities of how they treat a woman. In this novel, Nanny arranged Janie to go out with Logan, but Janie disapproved. Nanny claimed that Logan was Janie’s security because he was a hardworking man with 60 acres of land. Logan never abused Janie, but he wanted to. The only thing that stopped him was because she was white. He was not the type to show love. Every time he got threaten to be left he just brushed it off. Janie then thinks he is insensitive because he shows no emotion. Even if he wanted to abuse her he still told her “Ah wants things sweet wid mah marriage lak when you sit under a pear tree and think Ah …” (Hurston 24). After 2 years Janie complained about the relationship with Logan, so she moved on to her other husband. …show more content…
After Nanny’s death, Joe was the only person she had. Joe was not the best husband. He abused Janie almost every day. He always bossed her around and was commanding. In the novel, the narrator says “Her hair was NOT going to show in the store. It didn’t seem sensible at all. That was because Joe never told Janie how jealous he was.” (Hurston 55). Joe Starks always controlled Janie. In this relationship Janie learned to become emotionally strong, and stand up for herself. After Joe’s death, Janie gets to live her life without being controlled by someone. Joe was not the last husband she has, she meets someone who loves her for
Janie didn 't start living until Joe died and she met Teacake. With Teacake Janie felt alive, they understood and respected each other. Their marriage was full of love and compassion, two things that Janie always wanted. Her marriage with Teacake ended in a tragedy, but Janie felt like she lived a life full of new beginnings, and she was content with that. All the men in Janie’s life
Janie had no love for her husband Logan and became doleful she could ever be able to love him. Janie felt logan was treating her in a desecrated way because he was spoiling her less and demanding her to work more. After the death of Nanny, Logan was becoming more and more fractious with Janie.
The search for love is what inspires Janie’s epic journey through life. As a young girl Janie is already searching for her true love, but unfortunately her dreams are crushed by Nanny. Nanny tells Janie that she must marry now, despite not being in love. Her first marriage to an older man by the name of Logan Hillicks is where Janie first questions her role in society; Janie questions whether she belongs in the house or should be doing manual labor in the hot Florida sun. Janie soon grows unhappy in her first marriage and runs away with a man with big dreams, Jody Starks.
(46). Joe believes that he is doing Janie a favor by providing her with the life he thinks she wants, and this causes her to feel isolated. Although she is still unsure of herself, she knows that her vague idea of the life she expects does not align with Joe’s vision. Despite their conflicting viewpoints, she chooses to suffer in silence because of her fear and reliance on Joe for financial security. Janie allows him to create an uneven power dynamic in which she becomes simply a part of Joe’s image for the public eye.
Jody values Janie as a trophy wife. Leadership and dignity cause Joe to neglect Janie. This neglect is evident at the earliest stages of their relationship. When Joe and Janie are newlyweds traveling to Eatonville, Joe’s ambitions drive him. Unlike Logan killicks, Joe does not “make many speeches with rhymes to [Janie]”
Hurston emphasizes their relationship because Janie's goes against what is expected and finds happiness alongside Tea Cake and still has it when he passes, Janie reveals, “The kiss of his memory made pictures of love and light against the wall. Her was peace. She pulled in her horizon…” (Hurston
Nanny is successfully able to convince her granddaughter through her own traumatic experiences and make her feel “sympathy” as she tells Janie she doesn’t want her life to be spoiled like her own life was. At first, Janie refuses to marry Logan Killicks. Nanny being the older one, defends herself by saying “put me down easy” since she can no longer care for Janie and only her wish is for Janie to get married and be protected from the dangers she and her own daughter faced. By calling herself a “cracked plate” Nanny further elucidates that she went through many hardships in her own life and wants to do the right thing for her granddaughter by
Towards the end of the marriage when Joe started to look horrible, sick, and fat, he thought that he would try to make Janie feel bad about her looks too. This is all important to the story because these little cases was what drove the two apart permanently. Janie’s beauty was what split her and Joe up. Janie developed some bitterness in the solitude that Joe and the town gave her, that was evident in the speech she gave to Joe on his deathbed. Janie grew into a more independant women after he and Joe got on bad terms, this is what made her stand up for herself and persevere through his
Just as Joe isolated Janie from the other people in Eatonville, John isolates his wife from the outside world, believing it will help her get better. Her isolation causes her depression to develop into hallucinations and insomnia. She envisions a woman on her bedroom wallpaper that is trapped behind a set of bars, trying to get out. The trapped woman represents the speaker, whose husband locks her away from the rest of the world. Her husband also resorts to belittling her and treats her like a child in order to get her to obey him.
When Tea Cake and Janie first met, he would do things with her. The book says, “It was so crazy digging worms by the lamp light and setting out for Lake Sabelia after midnight that she felt like a child breaking rules” (102). Janie’s first two husbands, Logan and Joe would not do anything fun with Janie. Logan would have Janie working in the kitchen or the field and Joe would have her working in the store and have her as a “trophy wife” to look at. But Tea Cake was not like that.
Zora Neale Hurston once said that “No matter how far away a person can go the horizon is till way beyond you”, and in her fictional novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God Hurston takes the audience through Janie Crawford’s journey to her horizon. The novel, published in 1937 follows Janie through her three marriages to Logan Killicks, Joe Starks, and Vergible “Tea Cake” Woods. Each of Janie’s relationships move her closer and closer to her dreams symbolized as her horizon. Through her relationships with Logan, Joe, and Tea Cake, Janie gains a sense of perspective, freedom, and opportunity.
Joe treats her disrespectfully and represses her constantly. Part of the reason he does this is to show his dominance and power in the town. This is shown when she stands up for herself and embarrasses Jody in front of the town. The book explains, “Janie had robbed him of his illusion of irresistible maleness that all men cherish, which was terrible” (79). Jody’s repression was most common in the form of verbal abuse.
In the novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston, the protagonist Janie, is influenced by others to change her ideals. Hurston vividly portrays Janie’s outward struggle while emphasising her inward struggle by expressing Janie’s thoughts and emotions. In Kate Chopin’s The Awakening the protagonist is concisely characterized as having “that outward existence which conforms, the inward life which questions,” as Janie does. Janie conforms outwardly to her life but questions inwardly to her marriages with Logan Killicks, her first husband, and Joe Starks, her second husband; Janie also questions her grandmother's influence on what love and marriage is.
Janie hated Logan with a passion from deep inside her heart. The marriage between Janie and Logan was the worst out of Janie’s three marriages. On the bright side of this relationship was that Janie had the security
She is not content living the life that Nanny provided for her and longs to have a life in which she feels the happiest she has ever been. She wants to experience the feelings that she encounters under the pear tree in the beginning of the novel. In her previous relationship, Janie discovers that her life with Logan did not meet her expectations or standards. The spark that she had hoped and believed would surface never did and the realization that that was her life had set in. The love did not come and she felt trapped in a life she did not wish for herself, so her life with Logan is sacrificed.