ipl-logo

A Comparison Of Family In Once More To The Lake And Stone Soup

987 Words4 Pages

Family encompasses our whole world, whether you are a part of one or you see one from a distance. In Barbara Kingsolver’s “Stone Soup”, she speaks of her own experiences with families and her take on the original story of “Stone Soup.” On the other hand, E.B. White, who is also the author of other famous works such as Charlotte’s Web, speaks of memories he experienced in the past with his family in “Once More to the Lake”. While both pieces have a sense of family, “Stone Soup” by Barbara Kingsolver relates to the feeling of a family being as one and a strong focus on a family’s inner workings, whereas “Once More to the Lake” by E.B. White focusing on reminiscing on childhood memories and reflecting on times with loved ones.
In “Stone Soup” …show more content…

White celebrates the idea of family in the form of flashbacks. In E.B. White’s “Once More to the Lake”. White focuses on the memories of his young boyhood at a house by the lake his family would visit regularly. The author that he randomly feels the sudden urge to go back to this large, undisturbed lake. Deciding to take his son with him, the two head back to the lake. He claims he could feel himself back in the past, in his son’s spot. He can remember the many years in the Maine, summer after summer. Differing from what the author wondered about, the lake cottages had not changed much at all. He claims that as he lays in the bed of the same house he had stayed in every summer of his children, he could tell that it was going to be almost exactly the same as it used to …show more content…

The two boys go fishing, carrying White back to his childhood somehow in a form of déjà vu. Memories flooding his mind, the author speaks about how holding certain times and experiences in his life shaped who he was. Life at the lake was so different from the “real world.” The American scene had not changed as the author describes it. Just like earlier in the piece, he mentions how peaceful and “enchanted” the lake was, seeming as though you could escape for a few hours and upon your return see that nothing had changed. I guess when with family, time stops and the world is all yours and your family’s

Show More
Related
366 Words | 2 Pages

Andy Poon Ms. Gothelf AP Language and Composition 23 November 2016 In paragraph 5 of E.B. White’s “Once More to the Lake”, White is going fishing with his son at the lake. As they are fishing, he notices that the lake’s setting is practically identical to when White was fishing as a child. White is forgetting that he is now the adult and no longer the child.

Read More
1578 Words | 7 Pages

The speaker discloses that his children have been “gathered like a small cloud [and have become] . . . steam weeping on the window” (ll. 32-35). The speaker uses this final comparison of his children to weeping clouds to convince his grandpa that his life is not irredeemable and his presence is still needed in this world. In conclusion, through Gary Soto’s usage of powerful imagery, precise descriptions, and an absence of rhythm, he evokes a sense of sympathy for the community where he grew up while telling a beautiful story.

Read More
1916 Words | 8 Pages

Page # Sentence Analysis 2 “I thought of the life I had lived until the winter of 1975 came along and changed everything. And made he who I am today.” These sentences end the first chapter of the novel. The author once again mentions the “winter of 1975” to emphasize its importance; however never mentioned what happened. It shows the narrator feels that it was a critical event that has heavily impacted his life.

Read More
123 Words | 1 Pages

In the story E.B. Whites “Once more to the lake”, a story based on a father and a son who go on a camping trip, where White becomes captivated with and stuck in his own childhood. It shows that time passes and people grow of age. When white takes his son to the lake he realizes that even though the lake has barely changed, that time has changed. He has a sense of his son replacing him as he is replacing his dad. It was important to White to take his own son back to the same place because he finally comes to the realization that time doesn’t stop for anyone and that you have to move forward and one day grow old.

Read More
426 Words | 2 Pages

Children and adults rarely see eye to eye when it comes to differences in the past and present. This is because the idea of innovation is perceived differently by individual generations. In the essay “Once More to the Lake” the author E.B. White struggles with the concept of change, while his son accepts the concept of progress when returning to a family lake house. Through the use of imagery and symbolism the essay conveys how the men see the same place differently. White’s son observes the adjustments at the lake house as improvements.

Read More
878 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout human life, people experience many events which lead them to mature and come in contact with the grim realities of growing up. In the film Big Fish by Tim Burton, the characters recognize that the end of childhood comes with many responsibilities and the tragedy of this reality is unavoidable. The film guides us through the loss of innocence within the characters lives through the new experiences encounter, the movement from rosey to a greyer outlook on life and by the realization of an unconceived truth. Throughout the film, the audience is lead through the loss of innocence by many new experiences the characters face.

Read More
1237 Words | 5 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis for “Once More to the Lake” Life is fleeting and time moves quickly. In the blink of an eye, childhood becomes only a memory and the difficulties of the world become a factor of everyday life. E.B. White reflects on his earlier years in his personal essay “Once More to the Lake,” a detailed account of his childhood memories with his father at the lake. He carries on the father-son tradition by bringing his own son out to the lake, experiencing flashbacks to his youth. White lost his sense of self, as he began identifying himself as his son, feeling as though he was back at the lake with his father.

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

He reflects back to his past and compares it to the present he is in. During the first morning back at the lake, he “began to sustain the illusion that [his son] was [him], and therefore, by simple transposition, that [he] was [his] father” (White 432). White feels that everything at the lake is the same, but he is playing

Read More
691 Words | 3 Pages

A common theme of life that can be seen "Nostalgia" is remembrance. Throughout this poem Collins talks about these characters who remember a time period, "These views assume that nostalgia depends, in some way, on comparing a present situation with a past one" (Howard). The first character begins with, "Where has the summer of 1572 gone? Brocade and sonnet marathons were the rage" (6-7). The first character is remembering a time when a certain activity

Read More
1389 Words | 6 Pages

He immediately establishes the importance of the lake and how it influenced his decision to return to the lake. White is able to show his connection to his memories and how he misses how things were. He describes how he struggles to relive his memories, “I had trouble making out which was I, the one walking at my side, the one walking in my pants” (White 463). White struggles to live in the present because his attempts to relive the past fail. He struggles to live in the present because he cannot stop it from changing and shows his fear of the future.

Read More
125 Words | 1 Pages

In the passage “Once More to the Lake,” by E.B. White, White relives his most memorable childhood memories with his son, at the lake he used to visit with his father. In the beginning, White gives his reasons for going to the lake to spend time with his son. Everything at the lake remained the same from the last time White left it, which soon after brings back memories of the time he spent with his father. Throughout the rest of the passage White shows his close observation of why his memories have been triggered and what triggered them. During Whites revisit at the lake White realizes how much his son reminds him of his younger self, and how he now impersonates his father 's

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

The story “The Way To Rainy Mountain” talks about the story and the rituals of the Kiowas. However it gradually leads up to the personal relationship between the writer, N. Scott Momaday, and his grandmother. He begins to speak about his times in his grandmother’s house. How it plays a significant role in his life. The story makes the reader relate to the role of his grandmother’s home in his life.

Read More
1030 Words | 5 Pages

The three poems I chose are “Family Rite” by Howard Starks, “Night Rider” by Ron Wallace, and “The Ride” By Sony Tillis and Sam Weedman. I chose these poems, because I thought that they all had an excellent lesson about life. This is what I have taken away and interpreted from these works, In “Family Rite” by Howard Starks memories have been locked away and forgotten in the form of pictures, but are brought up and remembered at family gatherings. They bring out the old hat box of pictures that were locked in the darkness together.

Read More
479 Words | 2 Pages

They are both excited and nervous. Benson and Benjamin attempt to blend in with their surroundings, however, Alephonsion is very confused when a young adult, his new friend, buys him a drink. He doesn’t understand why the woman behind the counter gave him an empty cup when he asked for soda. Alepho does not comprehend that there is a machine where he can fill up the soda and that he must fill it up himself. Furthermore, the boys are amazed by the toilet on the plane.

Read More
787 Words | 4 Pages

Compare the ways in which the poets strikingly portray the women and their lives in these two poems; Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers and Still Life In the poems; Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers, by Adrienne Rich and Still Life, by Elizabeth Daryush; there are certain themes that are presented to the reader in a contrasting manner. The poet in the poem, Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers, uses the idea of a tiger to convey the fears and desires of Aunt Jennifer; however, the poet in the poem, Still Life, uses the idea of a breakfast table to convey the level of freedom that the young heiress has. Firstly, in the poem, Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers, the tiger is described as an active yet, beautiful creature.

Read More

More about A Comparison Of Family In Once More To The Lake And Stone Soup

Related Topics

Open Document