ipl-logo

A Jury Of Her Peers Compare And Contrast Essay

948 Words4 Pages

Susan Glaspell’s “A Jury of Her Peers,” is a short story that was adapted from her own play “Trifles.” While the basic plot and characters are the same in both versions, there are some noticeable differences between the two. In this essay, I will consider the reasons Glaspell may have had for rewriting the play in short story form, the main differences between telling a story through narration and telling it through drama, and how the story might be different if it were adapted as another form, such as a poem or a film. One possible reason why Glaspell rewrote "Trifles" as a short story is that it allowed her to explore the characters' inner lives in greater depth. In the play, the characters are limited to what they can say and do on stage, …show more content…

For example, this is shown when Mrs. Hale is conversing with the county attorney about Minnie Foster’s appearance before the murder, "As he asked it he took out a note-book and pencil. Mrs. Hale did not like the sight of that pencil. She kept her eye fixed on her husband, as if to keep him from saying unnecessary things that would go into that note-book and make trouble. “ (Glaspell, pg. 4). This passage reveals Mrs. Hale's inner thoughts and desire to not reveal too much information about Minnie Foster that could potentially incriminate …show more content…

For example, when Mrs. Hale discovers the dead canary in the kitchen, she exclaims: "Oh, Mrs. Peters, look at it! Its neck! Look at its neck! It's all - other side to" (Glaspell, pg. 165). This dialogue reveals Mrs. Hale's horror and shock at the discovery, but it is much less descriptive and world building than in the short story version. Next, the main differences between telling a story through narration and telling it through drama lie in the way the story is presented. In a narrative, the author has more control over the pacing and can describe the thoughts and feelings of the characters in greater detail. In drama, the story is conveyed primarily through dialogue and action. What’s more, a play typically has a more limited setting and characters are often more focused on the immediate events of the story, in order for the audience to understand the

Show More
Related

Mrs. Hopewell In Flannery O Connor's Good Country People

1465 Words | 6 Pages

Hopewell’s more manipulative side also highlights Hulga’s blindness, just like the cliche expressions. It becomes clear that Mrs.Hopewell portrays herself in a particular manner when it comes to her dialogue, especially through her frequent cliches. Internally, she is more calculating and opinionated. For instance, she is described as being “able to use other people’s [bad qualities] in such a constructive way” (O’Connor 281).

Read More

A Jury Of Her Peers Rhetorical Analysis

715 Words | 3 Pages

Evidently, when Mr. Hale points out John Wright’s indifference towards Minnie’s opinions, one can see this. “I said at the same time that I didn’t know what his wife wanted made much difference to John—” (Glaspell 48). Through the

Read More

Similarities Between A Doll's House And Trifles

851 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the centuries, a commonality of time enduring plays is that they often include themes that are consistently relevant to audiences as time goes on. Henrik Ibsen 's A Doll 's House and Susan Glaspell 's Trifle are two plays that were written in 1879 and 1916, and both are still well read and enjoyed plays because of this reason. One relevant theme for contemporary viewers that can be found throughout both of these works is the character 's conflict against conformity to social norms. This struggle is relevant to present-day readers because of the increased value of the individualistic mentality that has been prevalent in our culture. By analyzing these characters during their struggle against conformity to social norms, we can discover how this theme makes these two works relevant to present-day readers.

Read More

Comparing 'The Yellow Wallpaper And A Jury Of Her Peers'

1006 Words | 5 Pages

Authors, especially female authors, have long used their writing to emphasize and analyze the feminist issues that characterize society, both in the past and the present. Kate Chopin, Charlotte Perkins Gilman, and Susan Glaspell wrote narratives that best examined feminist movements through the unreliable minds of their characters. In all three stories, “The Story of an Hour”, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, and “A Jury of Her Peers”, the authors use characterization, symbolism, and foreshadowing to describe the characters’ apparent psychosis or unreasonable behavior to shed light on the social issues that characterized the late 19th century and early 20th century. Penning many stories that demonstrate her opinions on the social issues of the era,

Read More

Emilia And Mrs. Hale In Shakespeare's Othello

857 Words | 4 Pages

Hale, the wife of Lewis Hale, is a farm wife just like a woman named Minnie. In the story, there is no real direct description of Mrs. Hale, but what shows who she really is by her behaviors that throw some clues of what she experiences in her life. Through her outspoken opinions and how vocal she is with her opinions, you can sense how she feels about her husband, Lewis Hale, being the man who is a farmer who was the only one to witness the aftermath of the murder of John Wright. It is obvious that Mrs. Hale is he husbands “right hand”, and just like Emilia, is very obedient to her husband when he asks her to collect all of Minnie’s belongings. Compared to Mrs. Peters, Mrs. Hale is the women who the one to feel free to express her feelings, though she is looked to be less “sophisticated” than the others.

Read More

Jury Of Her Peers Essay

1217 Words | 5 Pages

In “The Jury of Her Peers”, the author Susan Glaspell aims to defy traditional gender dynamics to expose the societal norms that were prevalent in the early 20th century. In the story, she skillfully employs literary elements such as setting, narrative perspective, characterization, and theme to subvert inequitable notions and shed light on the profound injustices women faced at that time, allowing readers to fully comprehend the impact of such constraints on the women’s lives. The setting of “The Jury of Her Peers” plays a crucial role in enhancing the story’s themes and serves as a reflection of broader societal constraints and established traditions that were prevalent during the early 20th century. Glaspell sets the stage right from the

Read More

Jury Of Her Peers Essay

741 Words | 3 Pages

A dead bird, a dead man, a jailed wife, and five people to investigate such things. In “A Jury of Her Peers” in order to find the guilty culprit, there was a need to find a motive. The men would spend all day searching for the reason someone would murder the Mr. Wright, and so would the women. When the women finally did find a motive, they would hide it from the men. They had the right to do so because they themselves had felt the same way Mrs. Wright did, the men were being disrespectful, and the women were dismissed from the men’s sides to look upon things with no significance.

Read More

A Jury Of Her Peers Essay

995 Words | 4 Pages

Diction is used in this short story through the different stories that each character tells to better explain certain situations. For example, after the two women found the dead canary it reminded Mrs. Peter of the boy who killed her cat when she was a young girl. This story gives better insight to the women as to why Minnie may have killed Mr. Wright. This is just one of a few instances of diction used in this short story to represent the main

Read More

A Jury Of Her Peers Essay

641 Words | 3 Pages

The irony that makes Glaspell’s short story very memorable is that the men subjugated the women throughout the entire story, however, the women outsmarted the men and were the ones to solve the murder at the end. I personally found it amusing when the men would rather “…go into [the] upstairs” room and look for incriminating evidence when the evidence was downstairs with the women (Glaspell 368). These series of ironic events caused me to enjoy the short story more because it made me interested in the plot and it showed how ignorant the men could be which make the story very memorable. I also enjoyed the ironic twist at the end and how the plot worked out by allowing the women to piece the trifles such as the dead canary, the jars and the quilt together to solve the murder. The irony of this story also taught me a important lesson to never underestimate anyone because like the women in this short story they are smarter than

Read More

Daisy Miller Compare And Contrast Essay

176 Words | 1 Pages

Examples from “Daisy Miller: A Study” the beginning of the story on page 333(second paragraph) and page 353 (Second paragraph.) On page 333, she had more gentleman friends and lady friends. She looks over to Winterbourne hoping for him to catch the comment gentlemen friends because it shows that she wants to get a reaction out of him and in that time a female with many male friends are considered up to no good. On page 353, Daisy said, “Then I am all improper, and you must give me up.” In that statement, Daisy had done something that wasn’t what the usual women would do and was talked about.

Read More

Sexism In Trifles

941 Words | 4 Pages

It is not uncommon for small events to have a huge impact. Events that may seem trivial to some, may have huge consequences for others. Many times these little happenings seem so unimportant because they go unnoticed until the last, tiny incident sets off the explosion that has been building with each occasion. In her drama Trifles, Susan Glaspell tells the story of the aftermath of a murder which was brought on by constant “trifles” that pushed one woman over the edge. First performed in 1916, Trifles explores how women’s lives were affected by the atmosphere of the timeframe of the drama.

Read More

Trifles Women

760 Words | 4 Pages

Mr. Hale believes women only worry about things with little importance. The women do not try to defend themselves and continue to let the men treat them as if they are not equal to the men. By Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters not standing up to the men, the women will only continue to be treated unequally and inferior to the men. While waiting for the men, the women discover one of Mrs. Wright’s quilts. “They return downstairs just in time to overhear Mrs. Hale commenting on Minnie's quilt pieces; the sheriff ridicules their interest in such trivial details, joking, "They wonder if she was going to quilt it or just knot it!

Read More

The Tell Tale Heart William Wilson Analysis

922 Words | 4 Pages

“William Wilson” and “The Tell-Tale Heart”’s differences outshine their similarities. “William Wilson” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” characters are akin because in both short

Read More

Trifles Character Analysis

1108 Words | 5 Pages

Small lines and actions give clear insight to the theme of a struggle for power between genders. Through lack of following the script, ignoring stage direction, and undeveloped characters the production of Trifles directed by Nancy Greening is an insufficient presentation of a

Read More

My Mother And Father Compare And Contrast Essay

704 Words | 3 Pages

Most people in the world are different in many ways. In fact, some people say no human being on earth has the same fingerprints. On a similar topic, my parents are different in many ways also. Although my mother and father are different in the ways they act, live life, and discipline children, I love them both. First off, my mother and father differ in the ways they act.

Read More

More about A Jury Of Her Peers Compare And Contrast Essay

Related Topics

Open Document