ipl-logo

A Rose For Emily And Andre Dubus's Killings

304 Words2 Pages
The murderers in William Faulkner's A Rose for Emily and Andre Dubus's KIllings are both motivated by love. Emily is terrified of losing the man she loves, and Matt kills Strout because of his love for his son. Emily murders Homer, the man she is about to marry, because he wants to leave her; however, Matt kills in retaliation to his own son's murder. However, the crimes are different in that Emily's is preventative and Matt's is reactive. Because Emily kills Homer due to a choice that he has every right to make, her crime is less justified than Matt's. Homer only wanted to leave Emily; although this would certainly hurt Emily emotionally, she had a chance of recovery and could return to a normal life. Strout killed Matt's son, Frank, out of
Open Document