ipl-logo

Aboriginal People Case Study

1192 Words5 Pages

The criminal justice system in any country should strive to ensure that all people are treated fairly under and before the law, but Canada’s legal system has undoubtedly failed Aboriginal People in this regard. This injustice toward Aboriginal People in Canada has centred around their disproportionate representation within the Canadian justice system in comparison to non-Aboriginal People. This issue has garnered attention in recent years as Aboriginal People are continuously overpoliced and overincarcerated, often without proper rehabilitation or community reintegration to prevent re-entry into the criminal justice system. The over-representation of Aboriginal People is a nationwide responsibility because it stems from Canada’s history of …show more content…

Given the current state of the issue, many Aboriginal People are guaranteed to be involved with the justice system at some point in their lives. According to Frideres (2016), approximately 90 per cent of Aboriginal People have been involved with the criminal justice system by the age of twenty-four as either a victim, offender or witness (p. 94). Furthermore, the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (1996) stated that Aboriginal People are “incarcerated in provincial jails at 11 time the rate of other Canadians; in federal penitentiaries the rate is five times that of other Canadians” (p. 40). Although the data may be viewed as a cumulation of individual cases, the rates of over-representation could also suggest that Aboriginal People are not more likely engage in criminal behaviour but instead are targets of a system deeply embedded with colonial attitudes. The statistics on this issue demonstrate a pattern of Aboriginal over-representation in comparison to other Canadians, which suggests that an examination of the social and historical influences on Aboriginal Peoples’ involvement with the Canadian justice system is necessary to uncover why they are disproportionately …show more content…

There has been a long history of conflict between police and Aboriginal People that has lead to mutual dissent and distrust from the Canadian police agencies and Aboriginal People. In the past, the Canadian government established the North West Mounted Police to further the colonial agenda by controlling the Aboriginal population within their reserves. In present times, more contemporary issues include the Starlight Tours in Saskatoon, whereby Aboriginal men that were suspected to be behaving unlawfully were taken out of the city by police and left to freeze to death (Neeganagwedgin, 2014). Operating under the guise of maintaining “getting tough on crime”, police are criminalizing Aboriginal People at an excessive rate by engaging in focused policing in areas that are highly-populated with Aboriginal People. Aboriginal People are often targets of racial profiling, which is a process whereby Aboriginal men and women are regularly stopped by the police because “Indigenous men … are suspected of being in the drug trade or in a gang … Indigenous women, on the other hand, are often perceived as sex workers” (Neeganagwedgin, 2014). Stemming from Canada’s history of systemic racism toward Aboriginal People,

Show More
Related

Webb Vs Edwards Case Study

978 Words | 4 Pages

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander customary law does not specifically receive recognition in the Australian constitution and references that allow racial discrimination by the commonwealth are still present in the constitution. Societies views are changing and the importance of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander customary law and culture is now becoming more important as it is believed that the legal system must reflect the people it serves. Customary law is still seen as the soft version of the justice system by many people so the idea of integrating it into Australian law isn’t supported by many individuals. Circle sentencing is one way that aboriginal customary law is beginning to be integrated into the legal system as it is allowing aboriginals to achieve justice in a more traditional way while still abiding by the Australian constitution. 5.

Read More

Battered Woman Syndrome

1199 Words | 5 Pages

Indigenous people are incarcerated at much higher rates than non-Indigenous in Canada and are incarcerated for longer periods of time (Cook & Roesh, 2012, p.222). Canadians have put Indigenous communities through much heartache and pain. With the colonization of Indigenous people to residential schools, Canadians continue to stigmatize and treat Indigenous people poorly. Indigenous people are more likely to suffer from drug abuse using needles because of the intergenerational trauma suffered through their parents attending residential schools in Canada (Bombay, Matheson, & Anisman, 2014, p. 327). This puts them at a higher criminal risk than others because of what they have been subjected to.

Read More

Summary Of Seven Fallen Feathers By Tanya Talaga

1226 Words | 5 Pages

This book review will define the important aspects of continued mistreatment, deaths, and alienation of Canada's First peoples in Seven Fallen Feathers by Tanya Talaga. One of the most compelling aspects of Talaga’s book is defined in an investigation of the deaths of indigenous students in the mid-20th century, and more importantly, the continued lack of government response to the deaths of seven indigenous youths in the 21st century. All of these incidents show a systemic problem with government monitoring and investigating these deaths of native peoples living in the Thunder Bay region. The tragedy of these incidents reveal an ongoing problem with racism and government non-compliance with preventing the deaths of neglected youths, which

Read More

Similarities Between Millar And Owusu Bempah

1266 Words | 6 Pages

In terms of race, the UCR-2 only accounts for Aboriginal status. Thus, both the UCR and UCR-2 are limited in racial data. An important point made by Millar and Owusu-Bempah is that based on the data they analysed that was obtained via freedom of information request, recording racial data has been on the decline in recent years (2011). Specifically, Canadian police are not only recording less data on Aboriginal status, but race overall. According to the authors, some explanations by the police include race not being a significant factor in legal matters, or the more biased reason being that it is simply not of the police’s interest because revealing such information would work against them, by revealing discriminatory police discretion and practices.

Read More

Vicki Chartrand Unsettled Times Summary

952 Words | 4 Pages

Chartrand shows how the penitentiary system has always been connected to colonialism and the mistreatment of Indigenous people. She also shed light on the number of Indigenous people, specifically women in the prison system. Indigenous prisoners are disproportionately over-represented

Read More

Summary Of 13th By Av Duvernay

1085 Words | 5 Pages

Further evidence indicates that racial bias does exist in the administration of Canadian criminal justice, and, at times, this discrimination has been supported by court decisions” (Owusu-Bempah & Wortley, 2014, p. 2). The fact that Indigenous and Black Canadians are overrepresented in correctional institutions demonstrates that the issue of overrepresentation depicted in "13th" is not limited to the United States but is a current concern in Canada. It is crucial that systemic racism in Canada is not overlooked and is approached with the same level of significance as it is in the United

Read More

Aboriginal Deaths In Custody Case Study

1583 Words | 7 Pages

In addition to this the Officers inspire Aboriginal communities to work with Police in evolving plans that overcome Aboriginal Peoples disadvantage as it relates to a policing setting (NSW Police Force, 2007, p. 2). Therefore the implementation of Indigenous Liaison Officers has been effective as it improves relations between the NSW Police and Indigenous

Read More

When Was The Australian Constitution Written In The 1890s

961 Words | 4 Pages

The census and negative media coverage have also revealed high incidence of sexual assault in some communities and gang violence in others as a result of extreme poverty and substance abuse. A recent example, mentioned by prof. Larissa Behrendt in “The 1967 Referendum: 40 Years on…” was the Federal Minister for Aboriginal Affairs Mal Brough who blamed the Northern Territory Government for not putting police into communities where violence out of control. Just as unhelpful was the response of Northern Territory Chief Minister Claire Martin in asserting that the problem was the Federal government’s failure to provide adequate housing and health and education

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Aboriginals In Canada

1240 Words | 5 Pages

Aboriginal issues are a long standing problem in Canada because Aboriginals live in third world conditions in a first world country. They struggle to obtain basic human needs such as clean drinking water, proper education, employment, and appropriate living conditions. Both Aboriginals and the Canadian government are debating over the pros and cons of awarding sovereignty to the Aboriginal people. Whether this will actually be proven to help, has created a large controversy. Aboriginals are one piece of culture that makes up Canada's cultural mosaic.

Read More

Overrepresentation Of Indigenous People Essay

1076 Words | 5 Pages

Indigenous people are more likely to be arrested and charged with offences, and once in the criminal justice system, they face harsher sentencing outcomes than non-Indigenous people for similar crimes. Racial profiling is another serious issue that affects Indigenous people in the criminal justice system. This occurs when law enforcement officers target individuals based on their perceived race or ethnicity, rather than on evidence of criminal activity. Racial profiling can result in unjustified arrests and charges and can contribute to the overrepresentation of Indigenous people in the criminal justice system. The use of excessive force by police is also a major concern.

Read More

Domestic Violence In Australia Essay

1407 Words | 6 Pages

Historically the highest risk factor of domestic violence followed colonization (Brownridge 2008, p. 355). The loss of history and way of life has caused violence against the Aboriginal women to become normalized through the pathway of poverty, lack of education, substance abuse, and the european worldview. When comparing the violence ratio of Aboriginal woman and non-Aboriginal women the Aboriginal female has an eight time greater chance to be a target of violence such as spousal homicide and severe abuse (Brownridge, 2003, p.66). Aboriginal women were noted to have a significantly higher rate of violent victimization in comparison to a non-aboriginal females. Statistics showed that one quarter of aboriginal women will have experienced partner violence in comparison to only 8% of non-Aboriginal women (Brownridge, 2008, p. 355).

Read More

Racism And Discrimination In The Criminal Justice System

1958 Words | 8 Pages

Aboriginal people are more likely than non-Aboriginal people to have interaction with the police for grave matters such as being the victim of a crime, a witness to a crime, or being arrested on suspicion of committing a crime. One

Read More

Wage Discrimination In Canada

1054 Words | 5 Pages

Over the last two decades, numerous studies have shown that Aboriginal people in Canada face a substantial earnings gap in comparison to the non-Aboriginal population. Although some of these studies offer slightly different estimates of the wage differential due to different definitions of the Aboriginal population, they all consistently find that there is a positive relationship between the size of the earnings gap and the “degree of Aboriginal identification” (DeSilva, 1999). For men, there is a gap of 50.0% and for women, 34.2% (Lamb, 2013). A large portion of the differential can be explained by the fact that Aboriginal people have lower quality of characteristics that are associated with higher pay. However, most of these characteristics,

Read More

Colonization In Canada

587 Words | 3 Pages

Corrado, Sarah Kuehn and Irina Margaritescu 2014). Additionally, studies also show that western Canadian provinces have a much greater rate of indigenous incarceration compared to the eastern provinces, such that, there is evident over-representation in the western end of Canada. One factor for the increased over-representation of Aboriginal offenders in the criminal justice system may be due to “impoverished background, unstable familial environment, substance use, and negative peer associations” (Annie K Yessine & James Bonta, 2009) Another factor accounting for over-representation of aboriginal delinquents may be racial profiling, a study conducted by Willaim Chambliss (1973) concluded that authorities have a systematic observation of the visual delinquents from a lower Socio-economic status compared to delinquents of a higher economic status, which may account for higher rates of punishable crime of lower SES delinquents

Read More

Colonialism In Canada

957 Words | 4 Pages

The implementation of the reserve system in Canada has acted as a physical barrier between Aboriginals and mainstream society and thus helped maintain a status quo in favour of white establishment. The removal of Aboriginals from their land and placing them on reserves with no compensation could possibly explain Aboriginals gang formation through Ecological theories which suggest “ Criminal activity tends to be associated with transitional zones which are typified by social disorganization, turmoil, lower property values, poverty and lack of privacy” The reserve system characteristics are in line with those described in Ecological theories as a link between criminality and geographic placement. Its safe to say then that although these closed communities have not fully robbed indigenous people of their land fully but have perpetuate racial injustices and inequalities. First nations are still considered to this day as a counter culture by the majority of Canadian population as they were willing to fight for the remainder of their lives to defy racist indian acts and seeking to maintain the tradition that gave them this strength. Although they tried their best to reject and invert the values imposed on them by European settlers, their movement had failed them and eventually led Aboriginals to participate in active deviant activity.

Read More

More about Aboriginal People Case Study

Open Document