ipl-logo

Ambiguity In The Turn Of The Screw

943 Words4 Pages

Throughout the novel The Turn of the Screw, through careful word choice and plot structure, Henry James has readers wondering whether the ghosts alluded to in the story are actually present in the house or whether they are a creation of the governesses’ overactive imagination. Throughout the book, James conveys a certain level of ambiguity that keeps readers intrigued, long after they finish reading. In the 1961 film version of the book entitled The Innocence, director Jack Clayton works to convey the same amount of obscurity in a 100 minute film that James projected within his novella. Because of the cinematic effects used throughout the movie, Clayton more effectively portrays the ambiguity of the ghosts’ presence in comparison to James’ novel.
In only one scene during the entire movie, Clayton depicts this sense of obscurity when Ms. Giddens, the governess of the family, is playing with Miles and Flora, the two children she looks after. The scene shows one of the ghosts, Quint, but only Ms. Giddens can see him. The fact that only Ms. Giddens can see the ghost depicts ambiguity because we are not sure whether he truly exists or whether is a product of Ms. Giddens’ imagination. Another aspect of this scene that renders obscurity is that the door to the house is open when Ms. …show more content…

Clayton has the ability to portray ambiguity in many ways throughout the movie, such as with cinematic effects. James has less of an opportunity to demonstrate obscurity through his writing and readers are responsible for using their imagination to decipher the ambiguity. In film version, the obscurity is much clearer because Clayton has the ability to dictate many aspects of the film including character facial expression, setting, sound, and many more. James can only portray a sense of obscurity through his writing and by reader

Show More
Related
728 Words | 3 Pages

Jeannette Walls, the author of The Glass Castle, tells her story to the world of how she became the woman she is today. Walls’ depiction of her early life is nothing short of magnificent, as she informs the reader of who her family was and how they lived. Alongside her family, Jeannette is forced to move around the country due to her dad’s inability to handle liquor in moderation. Although her dad is a drunk he was still a great father who would protect his kids and strive to great lengths to get them what they deserve in life. The novel will intrigue the reader in accordance to the story’s themes and characters.

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

For example, Irony. At the end of the book, one of the blind kids was crying and was pushing his hands in front of his face. Jonesy risked his life to save the blind child and ends up with a bullet submerged into the upper half of his body. Ambiguity is also used frequently throughout the novel. Through Birdy’s eyes, you can never tell the difference between friend and enemy.

Read More
705 Words | 3 Pages

In Robert Zemeckis’s 2000’s film “What Lies Beneath”, he shows the significance of camera angles, scores, and special effects. These all help establish boundaries and moods that are set throughout the movie without Zemeckis verbally stating them. Also, they make the scene more realistic and allow the audience to see the movie and a different view which makes for a different prospective. As well as decreasing the sense of knowing what will happen next. In Zemekis’s film “What Lies Beneath”, he is able to frighten his audience with the mysteries of a ghost which eventually revealed that her husband murdered Madison in order to keep their affair hidden.

Read More
1046 Words | 5 Pages

However what Lee did by creating an attentive notion of how Mr. Ewell was the one to beat Mayella was the revealing of these facts but not actually stating he did it. Thus a tension is built up out of these annotations but Mr. Ewell will not get in trouble creates an anger in the reader. It also explains why Mayella lied on the stand, because she was scared what her father was gonna do to her if she

Read More
1383 Words | 6 Pages

At first, Mrs. Grose goes along with the idea of ghost sightings, but soon after, she says that “she herself has seen nothing, not the shadow of a shadow, and nobody in the house

Read More
1579 Words | 7 Pages

He was able to compile all significant medical thoughts from Greece and Rome, too. In addition to that, he also incorporated his own discoveries and theories, foremost of which to Hippocrates’ work on the humoral basis of disease. This illness was thought to be the result of an imbalance of the four humors known as blood, phlegm, black bile, and yellow bile (Hajar, 2012). Galen was the one who best endorsed the four humors. He referred these specific qualities to temperament or temperature.

Read More
1165 Words | 5 Pages

The governess is insane because she is the only person at Bly to witness the ghosts of Peter Quint and Miss Jessel. During her employment, the Governess claims to experience several ghostly interactions, however no one else could relate to her sightings. For example, after claiming to see two ghosts, the Governess confides in Mrs. Grose and later says “she herself had seen nothing, not the shadow of a shadow, and nobody in the house but the governess was in the governess’s plight,” (James 24). Mrs. Grose is eliminated as a witness and cannot argue if the paranormal activity at Bly was real. Since no one can support the governess’s claims, then presumably, they were hallucinated by

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

The grandmother manipulates her son into going to an old plantation that she visited when she was young. She does this by saying to the kids “There was a secret panel in this house, she said craftily, not telling the truth but wishing she were” (935). If there was a secret panel actually in the house that would be really cool, but there isn’t one. She says this so that the kids are interested. They whine and complain, begging their dad to go to the house.

Read More
1474 Words | 6 Pages

The Governess was beginning to figure out that she is the only one that can see the ghosts and starts to question her sanity more than before. Her sanity slowly starts to crumble. This was the proof she needed. She needed to know if Miss Grose sees the ghosts too and it turns out that she

Read More
1317 Words | 6 Pages

The governess progressively believes in things around her that are pseudo and assumed. Nobody else at Bly can see the ghosts that she claims even when the children tried to believe her, they just could not see the ghosts she could see. Things slowly but surely fell apart at Bly, and it seemed to start right when the governess made assumptions about the ghosts she had met. The governess had done many things at Bly, but proving her insanity is something she could not

Read More
620 Words | 3 Pages

One reason the man may have been a ghost is when he said, “We’ve all been dead” (Oates). The man had said this when the mom apologized for asking about his mother who had passed. Nobody just says that they have been dead, which hints to the fact that he may be a ghost. When the man walked up the stairs, this is how the family described it, “It was as if a force of nature, benign at the outset, now controllable, had swept its way into their house!” (Oates).

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

Author Joyce Carol Oates ' discovery of the stories of Edgar Allen Poe and Ann Radcliff “sparked her interest in Gothic fiction”. These Gothic elements typically include gruesome or violent incidents, characters in psychological or physical torment, and strong language full of dangerous meanings. Oates herself is citied as saying that "Horror is a fact of life. As a writer, I’m fascinated by all facets of life". “Where is Here?" This story is sort of eerie and tells the tale of a grown-up man who goes back to visit his childhood home.

Read More
1605 Words | 7 Pages

The governess thinks that the kids can see the ghost too, they are just too afraid to admit it. Miles who is persuaded most by the apparition won’t admit that he see’s Peter Quint. By him not admitting that he can see the apparition the people in the household start to think that the governess is going mad. The governess tries to get everyone out of the house, so she can get Miles alone, along with the governess “was already, at the door, hurrying [Mrs. Grose] off. ‘I’ll get it out of him.

Read More
1478 Words | 6 Pages

In additional, the unexpected and twisted ending of the movie makes more sense to their viewers. Even after completing the movie, the viewers' will still be imagining about it. "The Sixth Sense is one of the few genre films that truly discuss what horror really is, by filtering it through the experience of a frightened small child. Indirectly, it is also discussing misdirection, an all-important part of an illusionist's craft, in the form of the "magic trick" of hiding the plot twist. So the qualities of M. Night Shyamalan's signature film are evident.

Read More
983 Words | 4 Pages

The most common answer to the question has always been that the ghost is the spirit of the dead king Hamlet, returning to comfort his grieving young son left inconsolable by his loss and to provide answers for

Read More

More about Ambiguity In The Turn Of The Screw

Related Topics

Open Document