ipl-logo

American Voter Argument

1554 Words7 Pages

Speaker: I have found topics regarding the American voter incredibly interesting in my current research. I have also spent a significant time studying the work of my academic peers. There have been plenty of debates about the ability of the American voter to think rationally. I am not sure what people mean, exactly, by rational. However, if I were giving out grades on the basis of the ability of an American voter to formulate reasonably well-thought opinions grounded in substantive knowledge, I’d be handing out a lot of failing grades.
Ashley: You offer a powerful assertion regarding the level of knowledge the American voter has in support of their political opinions. I am hesitant to take this comment at face value. May I ask what research …show more content…

The speaker offering little insight on his assertion pushed Ashley to do her own research and decide whether or not she agreed with the key note speaker. Uninspired by the answers the speaker gave me, I decided to take his advice and analyze the works of other researchers in the field to draw my own conclusions. First, I remembered from my political psychology class that we had discussed The American Voter; the book the speaker had asked me to research. In class, we discussed how the average American votes, utilizing The Funnel Model of Voting. The book discusses how most people vote based on six attitudinal dimensions. These dimensions include: personal attributes of both party’s candidates, domestic policy, foreign policy, the comparative record of the two parties managing the government, and the groups involved as well as the group interest affecting them (“he represents the working man”). This dimension predicts voting decisions with 87% accuracy. Each of these feelings are shaped by our party identification, and our party supplies us with the cues to “properly” evaluate elements of politics through the lens of …show more content…

Speaker: Does anyone have any final thoughts regarding my presentation tonight?
Ashley: I do. Last week you told me to do my research on an assertion you made about how numerous American voters lacked the ability to formulate reasonably well-thought opinions grounded in substantive knowledge. From my experience, I agree that most Americans cannot provide much information on many issues in political debate. Based on Campbell’s, Converse’s, and Zaller’s work, it can be shown that Americans do not have a clear set of political attitudes on many issues nor do they fully understand all of the issues that pertain to their political affiliations. However, I think it is irresponsible to assert that Americans are “unable” to form knowledgeable opinions. Sniderman, Tetlock, and Elms () found that people do in fact make decisions based on all of the knowledge they have available when asked certain questions. It was not that they could not make up their mind nor that they drew opinions at random. Rather in relation to the context of certain situations, their preceding political opinions are altered or affirmed based on the situation. The question then would be, what are your standards for a knowledgeable

Show More
Related
1671 Words | 7 Pages

84) that point to the use of stealth campaigns. The account of each not only puts evidence behind her argument, the reader later discovers that these accounts go against the viewpoint she argues in her conclusion, adding depth to her argument: she states what critics think on the outside, later going into statistical analysis for the rest of the chapter to prove them wrong. Data primarily consists of table charts pulled from a survey and two case studies. The surveys, as outlined in Appendix A of the book, were taken from randomly selected school districts around the nation, and the case studies, also outlined in Appendix A, were from Fairfax County, Virginia, and Garrett County, Maryland, both counties with conservative Christians on the school board (pp. 176). The survey pool selected by Deckman is well rounded; she took into account small vs. large school districts, districts with no elections, candidates who ran unopposed, candidates with incorrect home addresses, and candidates who did not respond to the survey (pp. 176).

Read More
1437 Words | 6 Pages

The general perception of voters is that they are ill-informed and ill-equipped to vote on complex measures. Nonetheless, Ethan Rarick argues that voters generally act rationally and that they “rely on cues such as endorsements from people or organizations they trust to make their decisions.” (143). By providing more information and resources to voters, more constituents will be able to vote wisely and

Read More
740 Words | 3 Pages

In the Huffington Post article “Why Partisan Voting Makes Accountability Impossible”, Todd Phillips analyzes how social groups and political ideology heightens the response we have toward the candidate that represents our political party. Phillips states that social groups will vote for a candidate because of their loyalty to the political party, and not because of their issue advocacy. This loyalty is emphasized due their attachment to their social group. During times of an election, politicians will have different policies and stances on issues that can be seen as being more liberal or more conservative. However, this does not deter partisans from voting for their a candidate, since their loyalty lies within their attachment to their political

Read More
183 Words | 1 Pages

Concept: The Importance of Voting Article: “Patriot Connectors to Discuss Importance of Voting” My article began by introducing a group named the Patriot Connectors, and the entirety of the article expressed the group 's views on why people should vote and exactly how important voting is to American society. The group states that not voting or not even being registered to vote in essence, undermines America 's representative democracy. They attribute the lack of voters being related to the fact that many feel that their votes do not matter in a government system they see as unfair or rigged. The article relays the fact that voting is something citizens learn to do.

Read More
432 Words | 2 Pages

Now that you know about Theodore Roosevelt, will you think of him more. Some famous quotes from Theodore is, “A vote is like a rifle, it's usefulness depends upon the character of the user.” This quote means to me that it doesn't matter about the weapon or material it depends upon the person using

Read More
950 Words | 4 Pages

Definition Essay Rough Draft Government is an important aspect in today’s world, especially regarding the opposition of being either a republican, democrat, or falling somewhere in between. One may identify them self as being one or the other, but how does one come to the conclusion of being a republican instead of a democrat or vice versa? It all comes down to how a person defines government and different political parties. A person may base his or her political beliefs off of what is said in media or from what one is accustomed to, but various questions and concerns regarding what ideas one supports go into picking the “right” political party.

Read More
420 Words | 2 Pages

We often assume that the reason behind the low voter turnout in the U.S. is due to institutional challenges (i.e. voter ID laws, registration, costs). Therefore, reformers most often focus on offering and improving various forms of convenience voting to increase turnout. Skeptics such as Graeme Orr argue that “voting whenever, from wherever, is a ‘lifestyle’ option.” Another skeptic, Adam J. Breinsky, argues that convenience voting has “perverse consequences on election reform” and that encouraging political engagement is more valuable than pursuing institutional changes. Although convenience voting offers flexibility and comfort, it is imperative not to overlook what Election Day is supposed to be: a communal event.

Read More
784 Words | 4 Pages

By restraining the influence of the government on daily life, the United States will be able to return to the great nation of freedom; a nation in which its founding fathers so vehemently fought to build. Similarly, politics should not be controlled strictly according to political parties, and Coolidge urged people to support the values they believe in, not a certain political party. In today’s world, I think many politicians would benefit from acting in the way of doing the right thing, rather than supporting sides merely based on political affiliation. For this reason, I am passionate about educating myself as much as possible to candidates beliefs, and I look forward to being able to take part in my first elections in coming

Read More
678 Words | 3 Pages

The trend in congressional polarization overshadows the trends in public. While congressional moderates dissipate, moderates in the public “in the United States stands at its highest point in more than 75 years” according to polling (Smith). Many moderates ‘lean’ toward the left or right which causes the first problem in many polarization studies. Polarization means that constituents disperse from the center of the line to either or right into political parties, not necessarily radical, but many of these ‘leaners’ continue to vote on an issue to issue basis (Enns and Schuldt). Congressional polarization differs immensely; this trend appears more as sorting where partisans move to more “extreme ideologies” (Hill and Tausanovitch 1060).

Read More
683 Words | 3 Pages

They were also considered good voters because of their intelligence. According to Henry Blackwell, Voting is the authoritative expression of an opinion. It requires intelligence, conscience, and patriotism. Americans believed that with intelligence you could make a rational and better choice that you are a good

Read More
301 Words | 2 Pages

From September 1st to September 17th, I asked 17 random students from the University of Texas at San Antonio if we should abolish the Electoral College. Out of my findings, I discovered that the majority of students were for the abolishment of the Electoral College. The results were relatively close with 58.82% of the respondents for abolishing the Electoral College and 41.18% for preserving it. However, there was a margin of error of 23.76%, and a 95% confidence interval of 35.06% to 82.58%.

Read More
254 Words | 2 Pages

Today’s political arena is so tremendous that few voters can fully understand it. Policies of jobs, foreign relations and gay marriage are great factors that forge party lines and get out the vote. However, when forced to choose, voters must make sense of their vote by using very limited information and tangles of misperceptions guided by politically biased newscasts . With so many factors beyond comprehension often voters are hindered due to a limited number of sources to receive unbiased information from (Lenz, 2012) .

Read More
940 Words | 4 Pages

The United States currently faces a severe problem with one of their governmental processes. In the democratic system of the United States, politicians are elected by voting from the citizens, in most cases. The problem the United States is facing is that people are no longer voting in elections for officials. This problem is discussed in the article, “In praise of low voter turnout”, written by Charles Krauthammer. The main idea behind this article is that voters are no longer interested in politics, as they were in previous generations.

Read More
1151 Words | 5 Pages

It is clear that American voters tend to avoid local elections and off-year elections. Run-off elections are also likely to register lower voter turnout as compared to first-round elections. The larger the gap between first round elections and run-off elections, the higher the decline in voter turnout. Moreover, there are lower percentages of young people voting as compared to the older population. This is an important point to note since it highlights that young people do not have information guiding them on the importance of voting.

Read More
736 Words | 3 Pages

In the United States, people always talk about freedom and equality. Especially they want elections could be more democratic. In American Democracy in Peril, Hudson’s main argument regarding chapter five “Election Without the People’s Voice,” is if elections want to be democratic, they must meet three essential criteria, which are to provide equal representation of all citizens, to be mechanisms for deliberation about public policy issues, and to control what government does. Unfortunately, those points that Hudson mentions are what American elections do not have. American elections do not provide equal representation to everyone in the country.

Read More

More about American Voter Argument

Related Topics

Open Document