ipl-logo

An Analysis Of Tatum's The Complexity Of Identity

823 Words4 Pages

Jesri Joseph
EGL-1010
June 30 2023
An Analysis of Beverly Daniel Tatum’s “The Complexity of Identity: ‘Who Am I?’”
Understanding one's identity is a pivotal journey in life, as it encompasses figuring out who exactly we are. This journey can be complex, incorporating multiple factors and elements. In her essay, "Who Am I?" David Tatum explores this topic of identity by analyzing the diverse factors that contribute to its formation. Furthermore, Tatum focuses on the influence of power dynamics, specifically domination and subordination, and how individuals construct/present their identities based on these two factors. Throughout her essay Tatum presents multiple claims while also providing details and empirical evidence to support her claims. …show more content…

One key claim, for example, is that our identities are multidimensional rather than simplistic. She states, “This “looking glass self” is not a flat one-dimensional reflection, but multidimensional. How one’s racial identity is experienced will be mediated by other dimensions…” (Tatum 1). In other words, our identity is not solely determined by a singular factor but by multiple factors and how those factors interact with each other. Another claim made by Tatum is that people’s perception of themselves are heavily impacted by the dominant group. In her essay she writes, “The dominant group holds the power and authority in society relative to the subordinates and determines how that power and authority may be acceptably used” (Tatum 3). She continues on to explain that dominant groups set the norm and when subordinate groups portray dominant traits it is set as an important part of their identity (Tatum 3).This is understandable as our uniqueness is often the focal point of our identities, if we carry a trait that is special among our group it will be a distinct part of our identity, even if that trait may be common within other …show more content…

She utilizes personal anecdotes, research, historical examples, expert opinions, and case studies/interviews. For instance, Tatum quotes Audre Lorde utilizing her easy “Age. Race. Class. And Sex: Women Redefining Difference” Simply said, Tatum quotes the part of this essay that explains the mythical norm in America and its power, she also explains how those outside of the norms credit this norm for the oppression in America (Tatum 2-3). This evidence corroborates Tatums belief on the impacts dominant groups have on subordinates. Furthermore, by using a source from Audre Lorde who is part of multiple subordinate groups as a “Black lesbian feminist,” Tatum strengthens her point. Another instance where Tatum uses evidence is when he/she recalls a time when he/she asks a specific question during a class exercise. Tatum asks them to complete the sentence, “I am ___.” From this question Tatum reports a pattern within the student’s answers. Tatum explains how individuals usually mention the minority groups they are a part of and not the dominant ones. For example, women mentioned being female, colored people mentioned their racial/ethnic group, Jewish people mentioned their religion, etc (Tatum 2). This is a clear example of how people tend to focus on their uniqueness and backs up Tatums claim that the dominant groups take their characteristics for granted. Tatum further utilizes other expert

Show More
Related
1305 Words | 6 Pages

These sources are G. Stanley Hall, a professor of psychology, Ida B. Wells, an anti-lynching activist and journalist, Charlotte Perkins Gilman, a women’s rights advocate and Theodore Roosevelt, the 26th United States president and a member of the Republican party. These sources were perfect to prove her argument because they explore different aspects of society during this time. They explore white men as well as white women which were considered second class citizens in comparison to men and black women. She brought about a wide range of sources by choosing a variety of different educational/political backgrounds, races and genders to assist in conveying her argument. These sources are effective in facilitating her argument by giving her leverage to build up her dissertation.

Read More
103 Words | 1 Pages

Identity. Fluid like water, it can change or grow at any moment. Every individual has a unique set of influential people, places, and experiences that formed their identities. The impact outside factors can have on one 's identity is demonstrated through the memoirs Rocket Boys by Homer Hickam, Jr., and The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls.

Read More
792 Words | 4 Pages

Every type of person struggles with a thing we call, identity. Personal identity come from multiple factors from our race to our own personal beliefs. Some people say we have the choice to choose our own identity, but is that always true? No, in fact other people can affect how we look and essentially identity our self’s. In the article called.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

All throughout Tatum’s article she puts the emotional hardships for the kids in every argument she makes. Tatum uses a personal encounter from a young girl who said she always found it odd that she was the only black girl in her honors classes. (p13) This story particularly plays on the emotions because the girl adds that her school was 35 percent black. To the reader hearing that a girl is a standout in her classes is extremely sad because we all have memory of ourselves being alone and this story triggers those emotions. Knowing the girl is the only one of her racial identity in her class could be intimidating, and make her feel alone or as if she doesn’t belong, and that is what triggers the reader’s emotions.

Read More
1338 Words | 6 Pages

She details her experience realizing she was, in fact, a Black woman, which meant she was automatically considered, by society, inferior. This revelation was particularly jarring due to her unracialized upbringing, and she challenges this conviction to its essence. Instead, she bases her identity on the environmental factors that occur around her.

Read More
811 Words | 4 Pages

In the 1980’s black women are faced with a lot pressure in society, Because women of color are both women and racial minorities, they face more pressure in which lower economic opportunities due to their race and their gender. This pressure is reflected both in the jobs available to them and in their lower pay. Also because they are women of color they are likely to be the giver of the house and also within the families. Through the use of anecdotes,rhetorical questions, anaphora, ethos and metaphors, "In The Uses of Anger: Women Responding to Racism, Audre Lorde argues that women of color need to respond to racism with anger spurred from their fear and that not a bad thing depends on how anger is portrayed.

Read More
418 Words | 2 Pages

As a child, she recognized that her imitation of ‘White” afforded opportunities of mobility, education, acceptance and privilege. Her mother’s appearance as “Black” afforded opportunities of poverty, inferiority, and inequality. So, she fails to mention her mother’s identity and occupation to classroom peers and teacher. Sarah Jane wants cultural assimilation and white privilege.

Read More
759 Words | 4 Pages

Tatum even illustrates the racism on the gender, mostly on

Read More
1276 Words | 6 Pages

How others see you is influenced by material, social, and physical constraints. This causes a tension between how much control you have in constructing your own identity and how much control or constraint is exercised over you. How we see ourselves and how others see us differ in many ways, but is an important factor of our identity. “A Lesson Before Dying”,

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

The topics of racism and identity are not brought to light often enough. Social construction, dehumanizing biases, discrimination, and social groups are important aspects that play big parts in day-to-day life whether or not you realize it. We must consider these concepts in our daily life. Social construction plays a large role in identity in relation to race.

Read More
999 Words | 4 Pages

People throughout their lives are constantly discovering who they are and who they want to grow into. The same statement accurately describes Maya Johnson, a strong woman who wrote about her life in her autobiography, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. As a little girl, her mother’s ex-boyfriend raped and she had to rediscover herself whilst navigating through the grim veil of trauma - a process that burdened her for many years. Throughout her life, she encountered many different people, some good, others bad, but they each helped her eventually discover her identity. ‘Identity’ is how people define themselves as a human being, and, therefore, nobody else can dictate it.

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

The identity a person holds is one of the most important aspects of their lives. Identity is what distinguishes people from others, although it leaves a negative stereotype upon people. In the short story Identities by W.D Valgardson, a middle-aged wealthy man finds himself lost in a rough neighborhood while attempting to look for something new. The author employs many elements in the story, some of the more important ones being stereotype and foreshadow. For many people, their personal identity is stereotyped by society.

Read More
535 Words | 3 Pages

Identification is the act of identifying yourself with a group and incorporating another person’s personality. This essay will be focus on uncertain identity theory (Hogg 2000) and social identity theory (Tajfel and Turner 1986), commenting on how effective these two theories are in explaining identification within conformity. Uncertain Identity Theory (Hogg 2000) is one approach to conformity, suggesting that in times of uncertainty, we identify and conform to the group to reduce our uncertainty in that situation. Hogg, Hohman and Rivera (2008) argue that self-uncertainty is a key aspect for identification to occur.

Read More
683 Words | 3 Pages

These identities are one of the biggest challenges people in our society face in their lives. They not only affect ones social life but also their daily interactions. I will also discuss two examples that support this statement, one of them being from the reading of “The complexity of identity” by Daniel Tatum. Now a days, dominant and subordinate identities are two very different identities, who play a very important part in our everyday lives. The dominant group being the one with the most power and influence from society or politics.

Read More
885 Words | 4 Pages

As I mature, my perspective of life and what it is to be a unique individual is ever changing. I believe that an individual’s environmental and surrounding contributes to their identity greatly. The culture in which one grows up in is a element that shapes one’s beliefs. When I was younger, my friends aided to shape my identity. My peers had a great influence on how I defined myself in early childhood because I deeply valued and cared about what others thought of me.

Read More

More about An Analysis Of Tatum's The Complexity Of Identity

Related Topics

Open Document