ipl-logo

Prohibition's Positive Effects On Society

822 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Economic effect of prohibition

In his 1924 article, John Gordon Cooper claims that Prohibition had been an overall net positive force on society. According to Cooper, this force manifests itself in three ways. The first of these is the fact that many lives that would have been lost due to alcoholism and alcohol-related incidents have been saved as the cause of death was removed before it became a threat. Secondly, Cooper observes that the crime rate had gone down by 5.8 in 100,000 since Prohibition had been enacted (p. 193). He links this decrease directly to the absence of alcohol as a contributing factor to society. Finally, Cooper claims that Prohibition brought about a better economic situation for the nation as a whole. Cooper hypothesizes that since a significantly …show more content…

Stayton argues that Prohibition has had the opposite of its desired effect on the morals of the nation. Stayton claims that consumption of alcoholic beverages was at a higher point in 1925 than its peak pre-Prohibition. Stayton presents several facts to support his claim, showing a rise in consumption among not just men, but women and children, combined with an increase in moneys spent on alcoholic drinks to the tune of four-fold (p. 195). Furthermore, Stayton cites that the drinks available in the time of Prohibition have a substantially greater alcohol content than those that were served pre-Prohibition. This allows alcohol to be more readily abused and caused an observable increase in public drunkenness. Finally, Stayton counters the pro-Prohibitionist’s argument that prohibition has led to an increased spending in other markets and therefore, produced a stronger economy, with a two-pronged argument. First, Stayton appeals to the fact that Prohibition was enacted not to improve the nation’s economy, but rather its morality, which Stayton has thoroughly proved was degraded throughout the time of Prohibition. Secondly, he argues that the observed increase in consumer spending is due in fact to the wide availability of items which can be purchased in installments and owes nothing to

Show More
Related
950 Words | 4 Pages

Okrent pushes the idea that Prohibition was an “Anglo-Saxon-Protestant issue” (192) and they were proven to continuously push for the cause. Politics and alcohol held close ties during the push for Prohibition (47), and Protestant “aristocrats” such as Roosevelt disliked this relationship, viewing it as corrupt. (48) Protestant women, like the Daughters of Temperance (15), were a force to be reckoned with. The biggest issue Protestant’s had though, according to Okrent, was the immigrant population and their usage of the saloons. (48) Okrent highlights that one of the forces in favour of Prohibition was the mindset held by many Americans.

Read More
1110 Words | 5 Pages

The Eighteenth Amendment which instituted prohibition in America and its territories was an interesting attempt at using the constitutional amendment process to shape social and moral behavior in America. Until the Twenty-First Amendment which repealed prohibition, the road to prohibition in America dates back to colonial days. Although the amendment did not last as it was reversed by the Twenty-First Amendment less than 15 years later, along the way, the battleground for prohibition grew from local organizations to a national political party and set new interpretations for the Constitutional amendment process and played an important role in in American history. The Eighteenth Amendment was the high-water mark for what is often referred to

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

”Why did America change its mind on prohibition”? One main reason is because of it’s impact on law abiding citizens, another, is the effect of prohibition on people in government positions, and final is its’ influence on America’s economy.

Read More
517 Words | 3 Pages

Prohibition: Failures and Success By Jayden A. Mendoza "Prohibition only drives drunkenness behind doors and into dark places, and does not cure it or even diminish it." (Mark Twain). This quote perfectly encapsulates the impact and outcome of prohibition, and why it was bound to fail. Prohibition was not only a period of crime and homicide, but an experiment to see how Americans would respond to drastic change. Prohibition was a failure due to how difficult it was to enforce, illegal activity was on the rise, and that it was untaxable.

Read More
471 Words | 2 Pages

In 1919, Congress passed the 18th Amendment which banned the sale and consumption of alcohol in America (Doc B). Prohibitionists overlooked the tenacious American tradition of strong drink and of weak control by the central government. Thus, there was tension between the modernists and the traditionalists. Although the amendment was passed, alcohol was still distributed illegally. Actually, prohibition spawned many crimes, such as illegal sale of alcohol and gang wars.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

The country was trying to control America’s alcohol problems by law. The ban on alcohol worsened America’s alcohol problem, in fact, it did quite the opposite of its intention. All caused by prohibition, America had an increased crime rate, death rate, and to top it off, America was losing slathers of money.

Read More
625 Words | 3 Pages

Alcohol was immensely important to immigrants that came to the United States from Europe in the 1600’s. A few centuries later, specifically 1917, many Americans believed that alcohol consumption was a problem. An eighteenth amendment was assembled and passed by congress which banned production, transport, and marketing of alcohol. Even a drink consisting of over 1 percent alcohol was considered an alcoholic beverage. America was officially a “dry” country.

Read More
325 Words | 2 Pages

enforcing the Prohibition would decrease crime rates. On the contrary, they increased. Franklin D. Roosevelt pledged to the end the Prohibition. Shortly after, in 1923, the 21st Amendment was put into place. The 21st Amendment repealed the ban on alcohol.

Read More
1361 Words | 6 Pages

This ban helped improve the workers lives because they did not have to spend money they did not necessarily have on drinking. Additionally, this law improved women’s lives because they did not have to worry about drunk husbands who are not contributing to the family. Moreover, the prohibition lowered the crime rate and created a better family structure. Nevertheless, certain places sold alcohol secretly. For instance, in document F two chickens represents the Republican and Democratic parties, and both are fighting over the prohibition concept.

Read More
58 Words | 1 Pages

With careful input, after more than 10 long years of trying to enforce the unrealistic law, the government acknowledge that prohibition was a grand loss. The 21st amendment, approved in 1933, finished the failed experiment and reestablished Americans’ legal right to drink whatever they would please. Prohibition should have educated the government about attempting to readjust personal

Read More
917 Words | 4 Pages

Kyvig brings up the point that a significant amount of the drinking after prohibition laws were passed was done by the upper class. This is probably because the lower classes were no longer able to afford it, which raises the question: would alcohol consumption still have decreased if its price had not been driven up by prohibition laws? It is also worthwhile to note that (because of the law’s malleability and nature’s constant class inequality) it is possible that the upper class were able to get away with breaking the law. Furthermore, laws surrounding prohibition were somewhat difficult to enforce. Many people only drink in their own homes, and it is difficult to monitor what people do in private.

Read More
462 Words | 2 Pages

Prohibition led to the rise of organized crime and failed as a policy due to many loopholes and large numbers of corrupt officials. Though started with good intentions it was not a good policy because it destroyed jobs and attempted to destroy an industry. These reasons lead to Prohibition’s failure and the repealing of the 18th Amendment in

Read More
1921 Words | 8 Pages

Prohibition’s Effect on Crime Rates in America Before the Temperance Movement began in the United States, consuming alcohol was a common pastime that most Americans enjoyed. However, after a sweeping craze of religious revivalism known as the “Second Great Awakening” had befallen the nation, more citizens began to believe that alcohol could be bad for them. Religious leaders had preached to Americans that drinking alcohol would prevent them from getting salvation and ascending into heaven upon their death. They were also told that nationwide sobriety would cause the nation’s crime rates to decrease, as well as making the United States a more peaceful, polished country.

Read More
630 Words | 3 Pages

During the 1920’s alcohol was beginning to be viewed as a problem. Many groups complained about the various effects it had on culture. Women complained that their husbands would get drunk and beat their wife or children. In the business world managers and company owners complained that alcohol was the cause of men coming in late and coming in drunk or hungover which directly affected

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

The 1920s was a time of entrepreneurship, big spending, and partying. At the heart of these parties was the popular 1920s activity of drinking, Which was threatened by prohibition. The law of prohibition came into effect on January 16, 1920 and was intended to end drinking and drunkenness. However this policy backfired and sent the American alcohol industry into black market functions.

Read More

More about Prohibition's Positive Effects On Society

Related Topics

Open Document