ipl-logo

Analysis Of Lionel Shriver's 'We Need To Talk About Kevin'

1713 Words7 Pages

Public debates on school shootings seeking answers to the question of “why” often place singular blame on the shooter’s mother. Lionel Shriver’s “We Need to Talk About Kevin,” told from the eyes of one such mother, Eva, resists this mother-blaming. In this paper, I will argue that Eva is not to blame; rather we must blame the mask of motherhood and the wife role, which force her to engage in inauthentic parenting that is harmful to her and her son’s relationship. I will show this by examining how she plays the wife role, by discussing the presence of the mask in her life, and then by looking at the effects of inauthenticity on Kevin.
Firstly, I will argue that Eva, constrained by the wife role, wears a mask to maintain the performance of the …show more content…

While Franklin does fun activities with the children, he never has to do the actual work of mothering; his wife carries that burden for him. Consequently, his imposition of the wife role on Eva forces her to engage in deception to maintain his fantasy of a happy family. Controlled as a wife and a mother, Eva’s repressed resentment builds unabated. Through the cracks of her mask, it leaks into all aspects of her life, including her attitude towards her son. Franklin’s possessive control makes her feel as though the baby is not truly hers, as though it had been “appropriated” (Shriver 62).
Secondly, I will utilize Maushart’s theory of the mask of motherhood to analyze its presence in Eva’s life. This theory argues that there exists a conspiracy of silence, which obscures the realities of motherhood (462). The mask of motherhood is the visible symptom of this conspiracy, existing as a “repertoire of socially constructed…fronts…that [mothers] use to disguise the chaos and complexity of [their] lived experience” (Maushart …show more content…

Although Eva and Franklin were both unprepared for parenthood, the wife role allowed Franklin to keep living his fantasy, while she had to confront the gruelling reality. The mask of motherhood she wears minimizes the enormity of her work (Maushart 461). Eva describes how she had to disguise her true feelings about motherhood, though she “daily…faced…insatiable fury while rehearsing to [herself]…I’m supposed to enjoy this” (Shriver 93). The mask of motherhood silences and represses her rage (Maushart 463). Describing her routine visits to Kevin in prison, she admits, “there may…be an element of theater” (Shriver pp. 39-40). At first, she plays the role of the “loyal mother,” asking him about the food and how he’s being treated (Shriver 40). Kevin, aware and contemptuous of her inauthenticity, throws this back in her face: “You may be fooling the neighbors… but you’re not fooling me…I hate you” (Shriver 43). While the mask of motherhood and the wife role erode Eva’s personhood, so too is her relationship with Kevin

Show More
Related

Left Neglected Summary

286 Words | 2 Pages

In Left Neglected, Sarah Nickerson lives a fast paced life where she juggles her role as a mother, wife, and vice president of Berkley consulting. She strives to please everyone in her life yet she is completely unaware of the negative consequences that this lifestyle may cause. In her attempt to be a “good” mother, Sarah focuses on devoting her time to her children, attending every possible game and assisting them with their homework. (Genova, Lisa, 2011, p.15). Moreover, she senses that her personal relationship needs improvement because the overall chemistry has condensed.

Read More

Summary Of Sleeping Funny By Miranda Hill

693 Words | 3 Pages

The barrier between her and the neighbours after her husband’s death forced her to become reserved and quiet. Her and her son only went into town if they had to. They preferred to stay close to the garden where they felt safe. The death of the husband is the cause of the mothers’ complete change in character. The death let the audience connect with her on a deeper level to understand her pain and suffering.

Read More

Gender Roles In Bastard Out Of Carolina By Dorothy Allison

994 Words | 4 Pages

l throughout the novel Bastard out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison, the women of the Boatwright family, despite their capabilities, tough shells, and tenacity, bow down to the men of the family. While these tough southern women are not afraid to take their brothers to task or yell at their husbands, they still subscribe to the gender roles expected of all women, roles that place them in a submissive position to the men in their lives. Women take care of the children, the home, and clothe their children and men. The place in the family that women are allowed to occupy is a place in the home, as a caretaker and nurturer. This role is often one that doesn’t satisfy women.

Read More

The Role Of Marie Lazarre Kashpaw In Love Medicine

1818 Words | 8 Pages

In a way it is like a cyclic recurrence where she finds that she must transform the image of herself yet again for she is not fulfilled by her own role as a woman. By becoming a biological mother for five children and a mother substitute to numerous others not her own, Marie Lazarre begins to encompass this maternal ideal, a person that has adopted the “mystique of feminine fulfillment [...], the cherished and self-perpetuating core of contemporary American culture. ” We witness Marie’s capacity, resilience, and strength to fulfill the role of Nokomis and the stereotypical woman during the birth of her first born son, Gordie. Marie movingly depicts the pain that she suffered during labor, describing the contractions as if she was allowing her “body to be driven by waves, like a boat to shore, like someone swimming toward a very small light.” And it is after the birth of her son that we observe this connection between her mother in that they “shared the same boat, where [Marie] had labored.”

Read More

Sedgland Tale Sacrifice

1017 Words | 5 Pages

In Sedgwick’s A New-England Tale, Mrs. Wilson is the classic representation of a novel’s antagonist, especially in regards to how she treats protagonist, Jane Elton. However, it is the parenting, or lack thereof that has the greatest impact on the lives of Elvira and David Wilson, who despite being prohibited from engaging in sinful behavior, do just that. Sedgwick demonstrates that Mrs. Wilson’s salvation may have given her an authority over others, but when she failed to teach her children the ways of the Lord, her responsibility abandonment led to her children’s act of sin.

Read More

Mad Shadows Character Analysis

995 Words | 4 Pages

The role of a mother is crucial in shaping the foundation of the household. In the novella, Mad Shadows by Marie-Claire Blais, two women, Isabelle-Marie and Louise play the important role of the ironic mother as they shape Patrice. Whilst both Isabelle-Marie and Louise play the role of the ironic mother, they essentially destroy Patrice physically, mentally, and emotionally. Isabelle Marie physically tortures him whilst Louise continuously favors him destroying him mentally. However, as Patrice begins to show his ugly side, both of the women choose to neglect him therefore emotionally destroying him.

Read More

Kurt Vonnegut's Role In The Ghost Shirt Society

1548 Words | 7 Pages

There is satire on people by comparing them with machines. According to them most of the engineers and managers resemble Grath and Kroner in the United Nations. They express their aims of society to the engineers and the managers. But Paul cannot show his feeling even though he is a leader of the Ghost Shirt Society.

Read More

What Is The Mental Health Issue In Wally Lamb's The Hour I First Believed

2061 Words | 9 Pages

Wally Lamb’s The Hour I First Believed depicts a tragic school shooting in which two murderers killed thirteen people and injured many more. Maureen, the school nurse, was present during the shooters' rampage and battled mental health issues for the remainder of her life. The Columbine shooting and Maureen’s illustrate the many school shootings that have occurred in the United States, causing an increase in deaths, mental health issues in survivors, and structural changes in the education system.

Read More

Examples Of Selfishness In The Farmer's Children

1120 Words | 5 Pages

She went to find an extra quilt to put over Lea Leola, Rosina and Gracie Bell, sleeping in one bed in the next room” (Bishop 291). The mother sends the boys at the barn in the severe cold without any proper clothing and here in the house, she is providing the the daughters with an extra quilt to protect them from the cold. This also shows how she discrimination between the stepchildren. Therefore, the author states the selfish nature of mother using

Read More

Gender Roles In Like Water For Chocolate

1151 Words | 5 Pages

She is a mother based on the birth of her children, but she does not possess the nurturing qualities of a mother. However, she exemplifies a masculine role through ruling by fear and dominance and not

Read More

Silence Broken Analysis

2122 Words | 9 Pages

On April 20, 1999, a massacre happened at Columbine high school in Littleton, Colorado. It took 17 years after the tragedy for one of the gunman’s mother, Sue Klebold, to come forward and speak about the incident. In the video documentary, Silence Broken: A Mother’s Reckoning, she is interviewed by Diane Sawyer on 20/20 and discusses her relationship with her son, what happened inside her home leading up to the tragedy, and about the victims. Diane Sawyer also discusses teenage mental health, the warning signs of a child in crisis, and what can be done to prevent the next shooting. Dr.Gregory Fritz, President of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, and FBI agent, Mary Ellen O’Toole, give their insight on those things in the

Read More

Short Story Of Mr. Haley

623 Words | 3 Pages

Tom and Eva form a close relationship. They do this by Eva reading to Tom from his Bible. Eva starts to grow to understand and love

Read More

The Importance Of Motherhood In Peter The Rabbit

1565 Words | 7 Pages

Through the endless journey, she consumes her real, metal and emotional power and energy for the sake of her own children’s comfort and happiness. Strangely, if asking any mother about her life as a mother? She would happily say that being a mom is the most satisfying feeling she has ever had. Most important chore in motherhood trip is to teach a child to grow up, as nothing equals the happiness of a mother when finally, she knows that she raised a successful human being. As we will learn in this essay, how is Peter’s mother in “Peter the Rabbit” is different than Charles’s mother in “Voices in The Park”.

Read More

Mrs. Bennet In Charles Dickens Great Expectations

781 Words | 4 Pages

Elizabeth, despite the fact that she still fulfills her societal roles to a slight extent, still contrasts her mother in that she balances care for others with her own well-being, indicating that she remains sympathetic without sacrificing her own needs to fit the expected role of women at the time. In contrast, both Elizabeth and the rest of her sisters are limited by Mrs. Bennet’s influence on their life decision. Author Sylvia Myers takes a far more critical approach on the role of Mrs. Bennet in comparison to her daughters in deeming her the “bad mother” through hindering the lives of her daughters. Myers asserts that Mrs. Bennet desires only for her daughters to fulfill their societal expectations, rather than reach their own full potential (Myers 228). She lacks the same free will which Elizabeth displays in her growth as a character, and therefore directly opposes Austen’s vision of an ideal woman.

Read More

Sigmund Freud's Analysis Of The So-Called Oedipus Complex

1053 Words | 5 Pages

By configuring for mothers a much more significant role in society at large, the main exponents of this movement provide a challenge to the mother figure outlined by Freudian psychoanalysis. French feminist Luce Irigaray, for instance, stresses the importance of mother-child separation after the initial phase of complete dependence of the infant on the maternal figure, during which she constitutes ‘the feeder and food’ of the newborn. According to Irigaray, maternal self-sacrifice can be evaluated positively only insofar as the mother sacrifices herself to fulfil her child’s needs, rather than holding the child within her power. However, the detachment from the maternal figure is seen as a necessary stage in order to prevent the child from developing feelings of ‘emotional suffocation, paralysis and loss of identity boundaries’.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Lionel Shriver's 'We Need To Talk About Kevin'

Related Topics

Open Document