ipl-logo

Analyzing Jennifer Jackson's Article 'Telling The Truth'

1111 Words5 Pages

Telling the Truth Abstract: In this article, the author, Jennifer Jackson, raises questions about how obliged the people in medical profession are to practice honesty. Roger Higgs, in his article, says that a doctor is justifiable in lying only during a crisis when life is running away or during a petty situation which does not impact anyone. Otherwise doctors are also obliged to tell the truth, but how it is told in a painful situation is also important to learn.
Also, as per Higgs, the method taken by doctor to deceive the patient- absolute lying, partial lying, avoiding or misleading etc makes no difference. The purpose behind these different kinds of deception is all the same and hence shall be seen as lying. This may hold true if …show more content…

In 1980, an abstract clause was added, which mentioned “honest dealings” to be carried by doctors. This clause however did not mention the extent of these dealings. Doctors were free to interpret this in their own way and continue with their intentional …show more content…

Doctor can deceive me to into following a healthier lifestyle, which is a deliberate deception. Involuntary deception is not to mislead people and happens accidentally. Voluntary deception can further be intentional or non-intentional. If Doctor’s sole objective is to mislead B, then it becomes intentional. However, if patient is worried by the look on doctor’s face, even though doctor’s objective is not to mislead, then it becomes unintentional deception. In contrast, Lying is not a sub-set of intentional deception because, when A lies, B may not be mis-led, unlike in case of deception. Hence, A may lie but B is not deceived. The point is that, all liars want to actually deceive by saying false things, but all intentional deceivers may not be actually lying. It is not necessary to communicate or tell false things to deceive someone. As an example, doctor may take advantage of the patient’s worrisome nature and ask him to follow a healthy lifestyle. Here, the Doctor is deceiving the patient without telling any lie. PART-II: Truth as General

Show More
Related

Summary Of Stephanie Ericsson The Ways We Lie

185 Words | 1 Pages

The essay targets the general public, since Ericsson aims to make the average person aware of the role that lying plays in daily life. To accomplish

Read More

Should Doctors Tell The Truth Joseph Collins Analysis

364 Words | 2 Pages

In Joseph Collins article, “Should Doctors Tell the Truth?” he states that doctors shouldn’t tell the truth to their patients that deals with their life and death. Collins argued that doctor should withhold the truth on any circumstances. For example, when Collins blamed himself because of the death of a lawyer who suffered from kidney disease, only if he had lied to the lawyer about his health issue, the lawyer still could have been alive. However, I believe that doctors should always tell the truth to their patients regardless of the circumstances because withholding information violates patient’s autonomy and harms the doctor-patient relationship.

Read More

Brad Blanton: Honestly, Just Tell The Truth

422 Words | 2 Pages

Dictionary. Com defines lying, as a false statement made with a deliberate intent to deceive; and intentional untruth; a falsehood. I believe lying is only acceptable to protect and care for others. Certain lies are okay, if they are used correctly.

Read More

The Ways We Lie By Stephanie Ericsson

835 Words | 4 Pages

Ericsson states, “It is an act of subtle arrogance for anyone to decide what is best for someone else” (Ericsson, 2004, p 121). Good intentions mask the reality of lying. While an individual may mean no harm in their deceit and may even reason that the receiver does not desire the truth, a lie still remains a lie. A continuous vicious cycle results from one small falsehood. Individuals see it all the time; one little white lie results in a larger lie, then ends in a destructive lie.

Read More

Why Is Henrietta Lacks Unethical

1416 Words | 6 Pages

One of the most fundamental trust relationships is between a patient and their doctor. Physicians have supposedly earned their trustworthy title because of their extended education and desire to help others. However, this perception is being shattered by physicians violating patients’ trust by not providing all the information needed for making a responsible decision for a person’s health and performing unimaginable procedures. “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks” provides multiple examples of the unethical practice of doctors. When scientists do not recognize their subjects as human beings and their relationship results in an unbalanced power dynamic, their advantageous position often leads to the unethical treatments of subjects, especially

Read More

Stephanie Ericsson The Way We Lie Analysis

539 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout life, we sometimes don't take the time to think about what comes out of our mouth. We feel the need to tell a falsehood to make ourselves look better or feel better. After all, we don't want to accept the harsh truth of reality that is lives are not perfect. Sometimes we even forget why we're even lying at all. However, we are not alone as human begins it's in our nature to lie.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Ways We Lie

1285 Words | 6 Pages

Nicholas Martin Ms.Williams English 111 D-35 14 December 2015 The Allure Of Lying Stephanie Ericsson is an American screenwriter and author, Ericsson’s piece “The Ways We Lie” (1993) uses classification to display different types of lies people use and the way lies affect people. Richard Gunderman is a doctor and professor at Indiana University, Gundermans essay “Is Lying Bad For Us?” (2013) uses a broad and casual view to support the claim that lying affects people's health. The classification that Ericsson uses in its entirety is a collection of short personal allusions describing a few of the many types of lying, this method is not the best way to persuade someone that lying is unacceptable.

Read More

Deception Is A Shield Of Lies By Howard Thurman

224 Words | 1 Pages

Deception is the action of deceiving someone. However it is a trick or scheme used to get what you want. Deception is perhaps the oldest of all the techniques by which the weak, untruthful, under-minded, have protected themselves against the strong. Through the ages, at all stages of sentient activity, the weak have survived by fooling the strong.

Read More

Sir Gawain And The Green Knight Deception Analysis

1719 Words | 7 Pages

Deception is a powerful tool in seeking a certain motive; therefore,

Read More

Ethics In David C. Thomasma's Moral Dilemma

589 Words | 3 Pages

A moral dilemma that arises in a doctor-patient relationship is whether or not the doctor should always tell their patient the truth about their health. Although withholding information was a common practice in the past, in today’s world, patient autonomy is more important than paternalism. Many still are asking if it is ever morally permissible for a doctor to lie to a patient, though. David C. Thomasma writes that truth-telling is important as a right, a utility, and a kindness, but other values may be more important in certain instances. The truth is a right because respect for the person demands it.

Read More

Easter Island Construction Research Paper

844 Words | 4 Pages

Construction projects are all around us, whether it be your house, or the building you work at, even canals and statues are construction projects. Each construction project has a purpose, a meaning behind everything. Take the Panama Canal for instance, it was made for ships to get to get from one ocean to another without the trouble of going around South America. Also, take Easter Island’s one and only moai, a structure of art that puzzled millions to this day not know how or why the ancient people of Easter Island made these structures. As you can see, these 2 very different structures, but at the same time they are very similar to each other in some sort of way.

Read More

Ethical Issues In Grey's Anatomy

1736 Words | 7 Pages

It is very clear to most that Grey ’s Anatomy is an inaccurate depiction of medicine and the healthcare industry. Though heavily dramatized and ‘doctored’, there have been moments of learning, especially with this ethical issue.

Read More

Surgical Ethics Personal Statement

692 Words | 3 Pages

The primary motivation that has led me to pursue an advanced degree in bioethics at Columbia University is the direct applicability the field has to my interests in medicine. Today, the physician needs to contend with an increasingly pluralistic and multicultural society that can create pressure to compel him or her to accommodate patients ' diverse values. Each person and each physician who come together in the medical relationship have expectations, hopes, and needs. Only after these are understood and respected can appropriate technical measures be applied. My decision to apply to Columbia University is based on the belief that this program provides the optimal environment for me to investigate ethics as it pertains to medicine to prepare myself for the ethical requirements of a physician.

Read More

Use Of Deception In Hamlet

1295 Words | 6 Pages

Deception comes in many forms and can be seen in all kind of ways but mainly when someone purposely causes someone to believe something that isn 't true to gain a personal advantage. Many authors use this tactic in their plays books and other literary work like in the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare, the author uses the technique of deception to mislead Claudius, Gertrude, himself, Ophelia and his friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to spare their feelings and to carry out a crime. Hamlet uses deception throughout the novel, but one way is to distract everyone from his true intention which is to gather information against Claudius to prove he killed his father. Shakespeare contributes all this back into his work by making each character in the play enact on some form of deceit to uncover the obscure truth.

Read More

Stephanie Ericsson The Ways We Lie Essay

1190 Words | 5 Pages

Stephanie Ericsson begins her explorative essay, “The Ways We Lie,” with a personal anecdote of all the lies she fabricated in one day. She told her bank that a deposit was in the mail when it was not, told a client that the traffic had been bad when she was late for other reasons, told her partner that her day was fine when it was really exhausting, and told her friend she was too busy for lunch when she just was not hungry, all in the course of a day. She shifts from talking about herself to talking about everyone, claiming that all people lie, exaggerate, minimize, keep secrets, and tell other lies. But, like herself, most still consider themselves honest people. She describes a week in which she tried to never tell a lie; it was debilitating, she claims.

Read More

More about Analyzing Jennifer Jackson's Article 'Telling The Truth'

Related Topics

Open Document