ipl-logo

Annotated Bibliography: Mass Incarceration Of The Mentally Ill

670 Words3 Pages

Annotated Bibliography Mass incarceration of the mentally ill: Should we revert back to Institutionalization? Etter, Gregg W. Sr., et al. "The Jail as a Dumping Ground: The Incidental Incarceration of Mentally Ill Individuals." Criminal Justice Studies: A Critical Journal of Crime, Law & Society, vol. 21, no. 1, Mar. 2008, pp. 79-89. Gregg W. Etter Sr. et al. describes how deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill has unintentionally increased the number of individuals with mental illness that are incarcerated. They argue that interactions between police and the mentally ill have grown as mental health service facilities have been closed. The patients of these closed facilities have been sent out into society without suitable support. They …show more content…

This is important information to understand and be aware, due to the increased number of mentally ill jailed, in life imprisonment, or on death row. Understanding the history of the problem and how it came to be can help the system gain knowledge on how to find a solution. The authors citing statistical information helped reinforce their argument however some information was observational. Observational information is good data however it cannot be used to determine causation. More information on the mental patient’s rights movement would have helped to understand a different aspect of the argument but overall an insightful …show more content…

Incarceration has become a revolving door for the mentally ill that arguably began with deinstitutionalization. The facility closes, the mentally ill individual is out on the street, individual acts in a perceivably deviant manner, get arrested, jailed, released and round and round they continue until they end up in a prison or on death row. The point of view of a 30-year law enforcement veteran is a welcome sight. Rather than continue to be part of a problem Kincaid has taken initiative to help create a program to divert the mentally ill from the system and get them help. In the first 18 months of the program, it was reported that 584 people were diverted from potential arrest. This is a large number of individuals able to avoid incarceration due to behavior associated with mental illness and they were also able to get professional help. I am curious about other statistics such as the impact it has had on the higher levels of crime such as assault and homicide. It’s also worth noting that the article did not disclose the costs of running this program or how it is being funded. I feel that Fairfax County has a good idea and with more details, it may be useful across the

Show More
Related

Summary Of The Documentary The New Asylums

602 Words | 3 Pages

Many psychiatric hospitals have closed down, which the only option left for the mentally ill was to be taken in jails and prisons. In the documentary we learn

Read More

The Wrongfully Imprisoned Holy Angels Middle School: Just Mercy By Bryan Stevenson

713 Words | 3 Pages

Lizbeth George English 8-2 The Wrongfully Imprisoned Holy Angels Middle School April 17, 2024 The Wrongfully Imprisoned A big issue I’m noticing in the novel Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson is that mass incarceration occurs not only due to misguided drug policy or excessive sentencing but also due to the number of people who are declared as poor or mentally ill and are just thrown into jail as their next resort instead of sending them to therapy to guide them. Furthermore, sometimes prisons are used as a substitute for therapy when someone has what is deemed as a mental illness. Consequently, prisoners often come out with their mental health worsened, creating more chances of that prisoner going back to jail again.

Read More

Examples Of Inhumane Conditions In Prisons

1115 Words | 5 Pages

Brennan Center for Justice, 23 Aug. 2021, https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/how-atrocious-prisons-conditions-make-us-all-less-safe. “Mental Health Treatment While Incarcerated.” NAMI, 2022,

Read More

Mental Health In America Essay

726 Words | 3 Pages

“There are approximately twenty percent of jail inmates and fifteen percent of state-prison inmates with severe mental illnesses” (Torrey and Satel). Individuals with mental disorders are often characterized to be vicious, threatening, and unpredictable. Mentally ill people are often more vulnerable to violent behaviors if they are unable to receive the appropriate treatment. Those who suffer with serious mental health problems are not all dangerous, and should be institutionalized before incarceration "Severely mentally ill people are the ones who are populating our jails, unfortunately because our system clearly has problems'' (Stepman). If the United States focused more on mental health treatment and prevention, there would be a decreased population in our prison

Read More

Mentally Ill In Prison Analysis

1906 Words | 8 Pages

What do 24% of jail inmates and 20% of homeless people in the United States have in common? According to Liz Szabo and Rick Jervis, the answer is severe mental illness (“Mental Illness: the Cost”; “Mental Disorders Strand Thousands”). The government has steadily been cutting the budget for mental health care for many years, closing down state mental hospitals and leaving community-based treatment programs starved for funds. As a result, many mentally ill people end up incarcerated or homeless. Most of these people are being punished for symptoms that they can not control.

Read More

Mental Illness In Prison Essay

1094 Words | 5 Pages

This reveals that, the enormous increased of the mentally ill person in the criminal justice is a crucial problem. Jailing people with mental illness is true because jails and prisons have

Read More

Mental Health In Prison Essay

788 Words | 4 Pages

Mental Health and Prisons An estimated 450 million people worldwide suffer from mental or behavioral disorders. These disorders are pretty common within prison populations. This extremely high rate of mental disorders in prison is closely related to several factors: the misconception that all people with mental disorders are a danger to the public, the failure to promote treatment, care, and rehabilitation, and the lack of access to mental health services. Many of these disorders are present before prison however, mental health disorders can also be developed during imprisonment due to human rights violations. From overcrowding, various forms of violence, enforced solitude, lack of privacy, concerns about the future, and inadequate health services in prisons its no secret that the mentally ill are mistreated and fallen through the cracks of the system.

Read More

Mental Health In Prison Essay

747 Words | 3 Pages

Too frequently, incarceration takes place as a result of root-cause neglect. According to Elisa Jácome, "Previous research suggests that enhancing access to behavioral health services can be an effective method to reduce criminal activity" (Jácome, July 2021) in the article How better access to mental health care can reduce crime. If those with mental illnesses had better access to and availability of resources, they might have been able to escape the treacherous path that lay ahead. It has been discovered through social study and observation that "people with greater mental health are more likely to recognize — and be deterred by — the repercussions of illegal action" (Jácome, July 2021). This suggests that we are more likely to be successful in lowering criminal activity if we recognize the source of the issue and better equip convicts.

Read More

Mental Illnesses In Prisons

892 Words | 4 Pages

Not only are individuals with mental illnesses blamed for how their brain works under certain circumstances, but they are also punished as a way to prevent them from committing a similar crime in the future. However, most people can agree that these serious mental illnesses should be cared for and attempted to be cured, not only for health reasons, but also for overall safety in society. In fact, studies show that many criminals that are in prison today are actually suffering from a serious mental illness.

Read More

Mental Illness And Criminal Behavior Essay

994 Words | 4 Pages

The negative connotations associated with mental health concerns and insufficient awareness surrounding such issues often act as deterrents for individuals who may require treatment. Moreover, inadequate insurance coverage, a shortage of mental health professionals, and insufficient funding allocated toward mental health services compound the problem further. Consequently, numerous individuals suffering from mental illness are left without access to the care they require to manage their symptoms and behaviors, thereby increasing the possibility of criminal

Read More

Mental Illness In Prison Essay

1408 Words | 6 Pages

In some areas, programs allow certain criminals to engage in psychiatric treatment rather than serve jail time. However, a main issue concerning this solution is that many people fail to recognize the severity of the situation and additionally do not recognize that mental illness frequently leads to crime. In a recent analysis, Robert Byron states that “public knowledge of and support for such programs are essential to breaking the cycle of crime that the current prison system perpetuates” (Byron). To move towards a more productive society, people need to become aware of this connection and therefore contribute to the change in prison systems. Additionally, many do not believe that there is a connection between mental illness and the conviction of violent crimes.

Read More

Essay: Do Criminals Have Mental Illnesses

1832 Words | 8 Pages

As citizens of the United States, contributing to the building of this nation is a major priority. Part of this, is doing as much as one can to help deter crime rate. In the process of doing so, however, it is possible that hundreds of lives could be put at risk. These are the lives of those who commit the wrongdoing but do not obtain the mental capacity to comprehend the severity of their actions. Throughout the years, there has been an up rise in the debate concerning whether or not criminals who have been diagnosed with, or show symptoms of having mental illnesses should be treated or incarcerated.

Read More

Thesis Statement For Mental Institutions Essay

590 Words | 3 Pages

Thesis Statement: Mental institutions had destructive impacts on humans in past encounters through the chosen methods of treatment for convalescents, the actions taken to obscure these individuals attributable to discrimination, and the detrimental effect it has portrayed on society today as well as historically. Introduction: “Some people still hold [the] view that restraints help psychiatric patients feel safe. I’ve never met a psychiatric patient who agreed,” (Saks). Guidance of our nation to people who pertain challenges of the mind have not been properly pursued over time.

Read More

Recidivism In Rehabilitation

93 Words | 1 Pages

In order to improve recidivism and increase positive experiences in rehabilitation more programs need to be available to mentally ill offenders. However, the programs must be altered in order to provide the best possible outcome for the type of mental illness being treated. This could become a difficult task because not all mental illnesses are the same and there is a lack of funding for the improvements and additions of programs in correctional settings. It may be more effective and efficient to look at others options for mentally ill offenders that are non-violent.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Recidivism

1705 Words | 7 Pages

This study used a whole-of-population design to examine the prevalence, type and pattern of offending across all psychiatric diagnoses, including schizophrenia, compared to the general population. “It seems that being arrested and being diagnosed with severe mental illness are not independent events. On the one hand, arrest may bring an offender with incipient mental illness to the attention of mental health services whereas, on the other, events related to a psychiatric admission may bring a person with a mental illness to the attention of the criminal justice system.” (Morgan, Valuri, Ferrante, Castle, 2013, pg. 1869) This concludes the fact that people with mental illness are treated differently in the court system than people without mental illness, so how does this affect recidivism?

Read More

More about Annotated Bibliography: Mass Incarceration Of The Mentally Ill

Open Document