ipl-logo

Anti Imperialism Analysis

663 Words3 Pages

The opposition to the Spanish American war was too little to deter the inevitable American success that came as a direct result of fighting the glorious war. However, there were some American congressmen, political organizations, and other American citizens that did not see eye to eye with the imperialist values that allowed for our triumph as it pertains to this glorious and successful war. The Anti-Imperialist American League which began in 1898 in direct contradiction to the war and included people such as Mark Twain, Grover Cleveland, Samuel Gompers, Jane Addams, and Andrew Carnegie, were opposed to gaining resources and serving prosperity to all along the way. Many of those who simply were resistant to change were not afraid to voice their opinions through items such as Anti-Imperialist manifestos. Such manifestos of course denounced the advancement of prosperity for both, in this case, the Cubans and the Americans as a needless horror. These anti-Imperialists failed to recognize just exactly what our soldiers were fighting for on behalf of this great nation, and thus evidenced a general lack of knowledge as it pertains to the additional freedom and prosperity both sides were …show more content…

Many liberals noted that imperialism directly contradicted the Farewell Address of George Washington and Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence especially. They saw imperialism as a torture method used by America to hold true American values as prisoner. Louis Freeland Post demonstrates this concept in a political cartoon drawn to support the Anti-Imperialists. The cartoon, much like the Anti-Imperialist ideology proves yet again, however, that these people never attempted to accept the prosperity that imperialism has brought our nation as a result of this glorious

Show More
Related
741 Words | 3 Pages

In the late 1800s, Europe was scrambling to conquer vast amounts of land. Imperialism had swept the continent by storm, with many countries vying for pieces of Africa and Asia to control. From 1880 to 1900, Britain, France, Germany, and Italy fought for African possessions and by 1900, nearly the whole continent had been split and placed under European rule. There was plenty of motivation for Europeans to conquer the world, and while some supported it, others didn’t. Most people in Europe at this time held ethnocentric views toward the “uncivilized” cultures in the world.

Read More
1007 Words | 5 Pages

When America, as we know it today, was created, it had just freed itself from an unwanted, suffocating European power. The people wanted nothing to do with foreign affairs and their presidents’ policies reflected that. As America moved forward and established themselves as a world power, they began to want more. At the turn of the twentieth century, this want for more hit its peak and because of other circumstances, more was just within reach. America had always prided themselves in staying out of foreign problems and focusing inward, but now a new age was dawning.

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout American History, imperialists and anti-imperialists ideals have opposed each other, but each for a valid reason. The imperialists were for expanding the United States and for spreading their ideas of government. The anti-imperialists wanted to play it safe and prevent any conflict that could have risen. It is also existent in today's world with modern day conflicts about the current imperialistic values. The views of American Imperialism were similar about the concerns for racism, but the views also differed because some believe the US was strong when others do not.

Read More
603 Words | 3 Pages

Jane Addams, the speaker in Document 4, criticized the Spanish-American War and the militarism it encouraged in the United States. This gave many people the idea that maybe imperialism wasn’t such a great idea. They shunned the idea of using violence in order to grow the American Empire. William Graham Sumner, also criticized imperialism (Document 2). He believed that assimilating people to American culture through military force would cause the United States to seem violent like Spain.

Read More
151 Words | 1 Pages

The American Anti-Imperialist League was an organization established in 1898, to battle the American takeover of the Philippines as an isolated area. The Spanish-American War and the U.S. colonial occupation of the Philippines led to the greatest American anti-war movement up until that time. The growth of the Anti-Imperialist League from a small group of intellectuals and businessmen in Boston to a large nationwide movement was a reaction to the mounting casualties in the Philippine War. The major reason why the American Anti-Imperialist League opposed the conquest of the Philippines was that the Philippine War was bloodier. Philippines lost up to 600,000 dead in the war, so letters were arriving in the U.S. from American troops indicating

Read More
1357 Words | 6 Pages

However when it came to America’s decision to annex the Philippines, the despotism that came with it appeared to not be an issue to them at first, but anti-imperialists strongly gave their statements as to why it was a bad idea. For a first example, in October of 1899, the American Anti-Imperialist League created a platform, which was a series of beliefs that the entire party supported. The platform advised against the United State’s dictatorial presence in the Philippines, stating “We earnestly condemn the policy of the present national administration in the Philippines. It seeks to extinguish the spirit of 1776… We protest against the extension of American sovereignty by Spanish methods…We hold with Abraham Lincoln, that “no man is good enough to govern another man without that other’s consent” (Document A).

Read More
1080 Words | 5 Pages

He mostly supported imperialism for economic reasons. He also thought American imperialism was benefitting the countries affected by it. He thought the building of schools and roads improved the lives of the natives. Despite being ordered to by the US government while he was governing the Philippines, he refused to segregate official gatherings. Spanish-American War Taft supported the Spanish-American War.

Read More
1381 Words | 6 Pages

The Spanish-American War was heavily supported by pro-imperialists looking to expand America’s power. Anti-imperialists believed in their cause because they thought it was a violation of self-determination, too expensive, and would get America too involved foreign affairs. Support for the Spanish-American War was not seen from many anti-imperialists. These opposing viewpoints on imperialism are seen in Editha through the characterization of Editha and George. Editha supports the Spanish-American War and represents the pro-imperialist view.

Read More
430 Words | 2 Pages

Imperialism is a policy by a stronger nation to create an empire by dominating weaker nations economically, politically, culturally, or militarily. There are many that are for imperialism but also many who are against it. After hearing from both sides of the argument about imperialism, I feel that imperialism is wrong because of moral and political, racial and economic reasons. Some that are for imperialism may think that it is a good thing for us because it makes the U.S bigger and stronger. I feel as though we already have enough responsibilities and difficulties as it is so why should we want to expand and dominate when that is only going to add onto the responsibilities and difficulties.

Read More
778 Words | 4 Pages

Through examination of current and past textbooks, and comparing how they describe what caused America’s involvement in Cuba, one can be seen how America has slowly come to terms with its imperialistic past. Shortly following the Spanish American War, Americans chose to overlook the mistakes their country had made during the war. They insistently held on to their belief that America was the heroic force of the war, freeing defenseless Cubans from the oppressive rule of Spain.

Read More
729 Words | 3 Pages

Ava Walker Mr. Wormell USHH1 8 May 2023 Spanish American War Essay Throughout the history of the United States of America, the Spanish-American war has been illustrated as the United States stepping in and assisting Cuba in a time of need. The United States offered their aid to Cuba to obtain freedom and independence just like they had received from France in the Revolutionary War. However, this illustration is not universally perceived. As, the United States of America wrongfully forced themselves into Cuba's fight for independence against Spain and consequently stole land and power.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

Imperialism is a policy of extending a country's power and influence through diplomacy or military force. It is a great way to strengthen the economy and gain power and territory for countries that practice it, though it often failed and resulted in war and the deaths of innocents. Four intellectuals that played a big part in influencing American imperialism were Frederick Jackson Turner, Alfred T. Mahan, Herbert Spencer and John Fisk. All of these influencers had different ideologies and came together to justify American imperialism. They believed America needed to expand power and gain territories.

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

In being an anti-imperialist the worrisome is not that one opposes the idea of expansion of religion, commercial, and constitutional. It’s that with the annexing of these tropical islands would come to a result of the American system of self government would be that America might abandon this idea that makes America that nation it is to this point. Three reasons why the U.S should avoid imperialism is because it fails to follow that criteria of the constitution, could lead to tyrants like behavior, and could lead to conflict One argument that can’t be missed is the fact that the constitutions sets forth a principle that states “consent of the governed” after further research this means that to imperialize and annex other islands would violate

Read More
1223 Words | 5 Pages

Following the end of the Industrialist Era and the emergence of countless technological advancements, the United States entered the world stage. The United States was attempting to create an empire by expanding to land outside of its own borders in order to benefit the country’s economic interests. Many citizens, whose views were greatly influenced by their understandings of national identity, saw this overseas expansion in conflicting ways. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, these groups differed in their opinions on the idea of expansion due to either their wanting to remain a democratic country built on the ideals of freedom and liberty to preserve their sense of national identity, or their wanting to expand for economic reasons and nationalism. Imperialism, which is the extension of a country’s power and influence through expansion, began as early as the 17th century, when Britain colonized the New World in order to expand economically and gain natural resources for manufacturing.

Read More
548 Words | 3 Pages

The historiography for American intervention into the War of 1898, contains a paradigm shift produced by different schools of thought. The paradigm was derived when debating the purposes for Americans intervening in Cuba, whether it be through policy or physical action, the two sides that evolved from this debate were: the sole reason for American intervention into the war of 1898 were for business and economic gain and religious expansion. Having the ability to use this new-found platform, colonial expansion into Cuba, was needed to expand economic capital in Cuba. In opposition to this collection of studies was one of social intentions. More specifically, religious groups having convictions utilize the claims for humanitarian aid in order to help the destitute Cubans from the disasters of the Spanish-American War.

Read More

More about Anti Imperialism Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document