ipl-logo

Argumentative Essay: Should The Electoral College Be Preserved?

897 Words4 Pages

Div Dasani Mrs. Stauffer AP Lang- 4 17 October 2014 Government Should the Electoral College be preserved? Four presidential elections in the United States have resulted in a candidate winning the presidential elections without actually managing to acquire a plurality of the popular vote. Normally this is not justifiable in any democracy; however it has happened numerous times in America due to the Electoral College. The Electoral College violates the democratic principles it seeks to maintain and should not be preserved. In the United States, the Electoral College is a collection of people who represent each individual state, who cast votes to elect the president and vice president. This body is currently comprised of 538 people; …show more content…

According to Source D, All states are guaranteed at least 3 votes in the Electoral College, regardless of size, and only after this is populace considered. This disproportionate distribution radically skews the power in the favor of small states. Low population states like Wyoming for example, have one congressional representative for every 200,000 people, while states with high populations, such as Texas, have only one congressional member for every 670,000 people. Furthermore, consider the case of the all-or-nothing allocation issue. In this method of election, a state gives all of its votes to the candidate who garners the largest plurality of the popular vote in that state, regardless of the proximity of the difference in popular vote. For example, a candidate would reap all 21 votes from Illinois, regardless of whether the competitor won 51% of the popular vote or 99% of it (Source B). This system is impractical and unjust as it nullifies the voice of the populace voting for the minority candidate in that state, which allows for almost half the people of a state not having a say during an …show more content…

According to Source G, when the Electoral College was first created by our founding fathers, the average voter had little opportunity to learn about presidential candidates or their policies, and thus the job was given to the Electoral College. These select individuals were far better educated in the field of politics and were more capable of making an informed choice than the average citizen. In modern times however, with an educated population and mass media, voters can learn about candidates themselves and thus be trusted to choose their president. Furthermore, in the early years of the nation, travel to the Washington D.C. could take as long as two weeks, and new policies or events that were revealed during this time could alter a voter’s decision on his preferred candidate. Thus it was necessary for a body of representatives to make decisions on the behalf of the people they represented in real time. In today’s age however, with data carried through fiber optic cables adept at transmitting information in mere seconds, the general public is capable of making decisions on policies as they are being presented regardless of their location, making the middlemen representatives that embody the Electoral College an unnecessary violation of democratic

Show More
Related
1953 Words | 8 Pages

When it comes to population, it is not about what is fair. It is about what is mathematically the most equal. Document D’s chart comparing population and electoral votes shows that a state with a larger population has less electoral votes than twelve states that have less population than the sum of those states (Document D). Not only is this demonstrating how the electoral college has unequal representation of states, but it also shows that smaller states have over representation. This is simply a numbers error that needs to be fixed.

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

For instance, California has the most electoral votes, 55 votes, opposed to the least number a state could have which is three. Smaller states are at a 52 vote disadvantage. There are 29 states that have less than 10 electoral votes which is more than half of the United States. (Document A) The Electoral College gives the more populated states more power and votes to control the election.

Read More
1100 Words | 5 Pages

By relying on this method of distribution, and capping the number of electors allowed, the Electoral College causes inaccurate representation. States that require more representatives to represent the votes of their larger populations cannot receive them due to smaller states taking up the minimum requirement of three votes, no matter how small their populations may be. Not only this, but a combinations of thirteen states and regions, whose combined population is only 12,500,722, receives 44 electoral votes, while a state like Illinois with a population of 12,830,632 receives only 20 (Document D). Thus the Electoral College gives more power to smaller states and less to larger states due to its requirements. This means that some citizens are favored over others in the electoral vote, based solely upon the population of the state in which they live.

Read More
1206 Words | 5 Pages

Supporters of the continuation of the Electoral College assert that this institution brings forth equal importance among all states and that the voting of the president is the hands of a well educated body who will choose what is best for the country. In a letter written by Alex Hamilton to the state of New York, he praises the Electoral College in that the electoral body is composed of “men most capable of analyzing the qualities needed to be president… [and] will most likely possess the information and judgment needed for such complicated investigations” (Source A). The modern era today leaves no one uninformed especially when it comes to politics. The fact that the Electoral College wants the decision to be made by credible officials is commendable, but in the current world any civilian can access the most up to date information about presidential candidates with a click of a button. This entails that there is in fact no need for a separate party to carry out a decision for the citizens of America.

Read More
931 Words | 4 Pages

One of the United States’ fundamental beliefs is the idea that fair taxation with equal representation. Author of, “5 Advantages and Disadvantages of Electoral College”, Louise Gaille, elaborates, “In national representation, each state and population district receives equal representation, in either the house or the senate, and that allows individual voters to still have a say in what happens” (Gaille). The Electoral College was built on compromises the Founding Fathers made to ensure the equal ability for everyone to impact the decisions made in the country. Without national representation, states with smaller populations won’t have their votes as considered as the votes from larger states. For example, although Wyoming makes up about .18% of the population, they still control .56% of all electoral votes.

Read More
1501 Words | 7 Pages

This is where opponents of the College find fault. The prime example is a comparison of Alaska, Delaware, D.C., Hawaii, Idaho, Maine, Montana, North and South Dakota, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Wyoming to the single state of Illinois. These twelve states and the district account for forty-four electoral votes, and 12,500,000 people live there. Illinois, with a population of 12,830,000, only gets twenty electoral votes (Document D). Here, it seems as if the 12,500,000 people of the District and the twelve states are essentially getting over double the representation than the people of Illinois.

Read More
472 Words | 2 Pages

The Electoral College has been a cornerstone of the American presidential election process since the founding of the nation. Designed as a compromise between election of the President by a vote in Congress and election by popular vote, it has faced increasing scrutiny and calls for abolition in contemporary times. This essay examines the arguments both for and against abolishing the Electoral College, weighing the democratic principles of fairness and representation against the practical implications of its continued existence. One of the primary arguments in favor of abolishing the Electoral College is its potential to undermine the principle of one person, one vote. Critics argue that the winner-takes-all allocation of electoral votes in most states can lead to

Read More
1267 Words | 6 Pages

However, this is not entirely the case. Smaller states are actually given more electors than they otherwise should have, and larger states are short a few electors. If a candidate wins the majority of the citizens’

Read More
1048 Words | 5 Pages

The creation of the Electoral College was the result of one of the many compromises of our Founding Fathers. The intentions of such a system were developed to create fairness for smaller states and to prevent an unsuitable candidate from acquiring the office. Although it has been rare, the possibility that the Electoral College and not the popular vote would decide a presidential election was intended in its creation. The pros and cons of such a system have changed over time and are heavily debated in our current circumstances. Due to advancements in technology not envisioned by the founders, alternatives have been suggested to resolve the conflicts of what some feel is an outdated system.

Read More
904 Words | 4 Pages

Several years after the United States came to be, the Constitutional Convention met to determine how the new nation should govern itself. The delegates saw that it was crucial to have a president and vice president, but the delegates did not want these offices to reflect how the colonies were treated under the British rule. The delegates believed that the president’s power should be limited, and that he should be chosen through the system known as the Electoral College. The Electoral College is a body of people who represent the states of the US, who formally cast votes for the electing of the president and vice president. Many citizens feel that the Electoral College goes against our nation’s principle of representative democracy, while others

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

Electoral college has been with us since the birth of the constitution, and to this day we are still using this type of system to this day. The Electoral College is a system that the United States uses to elect our upcoming presidents and vice presidents. Each state has electors equal to their senate member and house of representatives, however who ever gets the highest popular vote in the state gets the electoral vote. The issue is the Electoral College do not give votes to the people, but to the states. Which has some unfair consequences.

Read More
612 Words | 3 Pages

The electoral college also helps the small states have an opinion that actually is heard in the presidential election. In class, it was discussed that Wyoming, Montana, North Dakota, and South Dakota together, though their combined population is less than that of Oklahoma, each of those states has three electoral votes, whereas Oklahoma just has seven votes. Going by electoral votes, a candidate would have a better chance at winning the election if they won over Wyoming, Montana, North Dakota, and South Dakota versus Oklahoma. With the electoral college, a candidate could win over all thirty-nine small states and win the entire election. Though the candidate could be supported by less than a quarter of the population,

Read More
1026 Words | 5 Pages

In 1787, years after the founding of the United States, the Constitutional Convention met to decide how the new nation would govern itself. The delegates understood that the need for a leader was necessary but still bitterly remembered how Britain abused of its power. The delegates agreed that the President and Vice President should be chosen informally and not based on the direct popular vote, thus gave birth to the Electoral College. The Electoral College is defined as “a body of people representing the states of the US, who formally cast votes for the election of the president and vice president.” Since 1787 the Electoral College has been the system for voting in the United States, but with our nation ever more changing and growing it

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

The Electoral College is a longstanding organization in place in the United States of America that was originally established by the Founding Fathers in create equality in presidential elections has become a topic of harsh criticism and controversy over the years. The Electoral College was established by the Founding Fathers of the United States at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 in order ensure there was representation of the people while keeping the best interests of the nation in mind (“What is the Electoral College?”). At the time of the writing of the Constitution, there were two main ideas on how to elect a president. The first was that there should be a simple vote of all eligible people and who ever gets the most votes becomes

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

The Electoral College is the process to which the United States elects the President, and the Vice President. The founders of the Constitution came up with this process. This was done to give additional power to the small states, and it was done to satisfy them. It works by the citizens of the United States electing representatives called electors. Each state is given the same amount of electors, as they are members of congress.

Read More

More about Argumentative Essay: Should The Electoral College Be Preserved?

Open Document