ipl-logo

Augustine Vs Descartes

1499 Words6 Pages

Throughout all of history, humans have been trying to understand what is true. From Plato's conceptions of the Forms to modern day speculations about space, everyone searches for some type of truth that accounts for their experiences, their thoughts, and what they see around them. Augustine and Descartes, two figures separated by over one thousand years of human development and change, are no exception. Although Augustine and Descartes approach the search for truth in very different ways, with each step an essential part of the process, they both arrive at knowledge of the same final truth, God. An important starting point for understanding Augustine's process is that his entire life is essentially devoted to finding what is most meaningful. …show more content…

To Augustine, God is the most important. This, like Augustine's questioning, is clear when reading Confessions. In his opening sentences, Augustine declares, "our heart is restless for You" (3). This statement illustrates how Augustine's whole journey towards truth is directed at finding God and peace in him. When embarking on his search for truth, he consistently describes how he is only satisfied when what he finds is consistent with God. For example, as Augustine describes the trouble he has with understanding his desire to sin even as an infant, he claims that "neither custom nor reason" could explain (29). Here we see a shift away from reason, the one thing that has been heralded as the most perfect thing about human beings by thinkers all the way back to Plato and Aristotle. However, this shift does not mean that Augustine negates reason on all levels, only that reason is not the highest authority in his search for truth. That position remains with God. According to Dr. Carl Vaught, a professor at Baylor University who specializes in the philosophy of religion, Augustine believes that our desire for truth is really a desire for God (Vaught 23). Since when one is looking for truth, one is really looking for God, Augustine has yet another reason to keep God as the most important authority during this process. In addition, Augustine struggles to understand how his heart was motivated to evil actions "by wickedness itself" (Augustine 29). While most philosophers try to reason their ways into understanding issues such as this, Augustine approaches God and cries out to him in anguish (Augustine 29). This tendency to turn to God as the only source of truth is evident throughout Confessions. Augustine's highest authority, the most important thing, is undeniably

Show More
Related
1813 Words | 8 Pages

Before meeting Lady Continence, Augustine feels torn “between [the lust] against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh”; he wants to harmonize his feelings so he can “become [Y] our soldier” (VIII.11), who is not “bound to the earth… afraid of being rid of all my burdens” (VIII.11). Augustine feels guilty for being between a righteous life with God and an imperfect life with his secular desires, because he has acknowledged that a better life exists than he is living. However, he has not been able to make the full jump to being right with God. As a result of his internal dissonance, Augustine’s guilt manifests in a physically as Lady Continence. She appears to Augustine as “serene and cheerful without coquetry”, and tells Augustine to join the others who have already relinquished their earthly desires: “Cast yourself upon him, do not be afraid… Make the leap without anxiety; he will catch you and heal you” (VIII.27).

Read More
477 Words | 2 Pages

3. Discuss Augustine’s Confessions as a spiritual autobiography, a personal narrative of one’s spiritual journey. Note that Augustine addresses God himself, not a human audience. (The first paragraph of the excerpt in our book begins with “What have I to say to Thee, God, save that I know not where I came from…” [Vol. 1, p. 834]).

Read More
1274 Words | 6 Pages

This was the first dilemma that Augustine had to face. God is the ultimate being and is Infinite. Language is a human institution and it deals with finite things. That is why rhetoric cannot be used in the concept of God. Augustine’s response to this dilemma was to introduce or to develop such rhetoric that could be used in explaining the concept of God.

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

It is said that Lennie causes the tragic ending of the book and that it is his own fault for killing the puppy, Curley’s wife, and for getting himself killed. However, you cannot blame someone for something they have no control over. Lennie didn’t do any of those things with the intention of a bad outcome. It is proven that it is not Lennie’s fault because of the effect Curley’s wife’s persistence has on him, the temptation she forced on him, and the fact that Lennie knows the differences between right and wrong.

Read More
1035 Words | 5 Pages

Augustine’s Confessions is “‘a gift to those who learn to read him like a friend’. ”(Villanova 14 Rev. Allan Fitzgerald) Instead of considering him as an unreachable saint, this way of reading the text allows the reader to better relate to Augustine. It permits a college student to recognize a more personal connection to Augustine. Confessions serves as an exceptional introduction to Villanova through its ability to present a myriad of thematic concepts and characteristics that coincide with principals that are crucial for a first-year student.

Read More
208 Words | 1 Pages

From Augustine’s standpoint all human life will naturally live in unavoidable

Read More
767 Words | 4 Pages

When Augustine said that people were born fundamentally flawed, he also thought that we have the ability to choose the good and to resist temptation by turning to God. He saw the human will as being able to be reformed and strengthened through a process of moral

Read More
416 Words | 2 Pages

In Saint Augustines Confessions, Augustine struggles with identifying himself with the one “true” religion. His search leads him to many different religions, as well as numerous introspective reflections on his infancy. This search poses the question: What does Augustines search for the one true religion have to do with my own search for my vocational/ career calling in life? As a whole, I feel that the two compare in the sense that Augustines journey in search of religion and my own search for my vocational calling both require acceptance that the journey does not end once we find “it”, in fact, its just the beginning.

Read More
2121 Words | 9 Pages

Augustine faces many decisions in his life which lead to him feeling grief or sorrow about the decisions he makes. This allows the reader to relate to Augustine because many people have felt the same way before about their own life. The emotions that Augustine feels and the struggle he has with his belief in God and the Christian belief are very relatable to many people. I mean in today society many people struggle with their own standing with the Christian

Read More
1249 Words | 5 Pages

Next we will look at how Augustine interprets the phrase “God made heaven and earth.” For verse two we will divide it into two portions as well, the first “Now the earth was invisible and unorganized” and the second, “and darkness was above the abyss.” All of this examination should give us a heightened understanding of how Augustine views creation.

Read More
630 Words | 3 Pages

Compare/Contrast To Helen vs Helen We are all passionate about something in life, whether it be our values, politics, or circumstances. Something these poets are passionate about is Helen and what her beauty symbolizes to them. In the poems “To Helen” by Edgar Allen Poe and “Helen” by Hilda Doolittle, the authors have views of Helen that differ, while Poe sees Helen’s beauty as light, strength, and patriotism, Doolittle sees her beauty as war and hate. The speaker’s attitude, tone, and themes portray physical beauty as a force to be reckoned with and are passionate while doing it.

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

Augustine was a saint and philosopher of Christian Doctrine in the fourth century. He wrote many works that helped the followers of Christianity to better understand God and his power. In one of his most famous works, The City of God, he discusses the idea of peace and its part for the basis of politics. While Augustine discusses the commonality of peace in all humans, each human’s version of peace differs from another. Not only are their editions of peace different, their peace-seeking actions can be either good or limited.

Read More
1224 Words | 5 Pages

Augustine’s Confessions contains a pithy account of his life including his struggles with God and religion. Throughout his book, Augustine attempts to expose and substantiate answers to questions concerning topics including evil, free will, and friendships. Because many strong arguments are made, the casual reader might be lured into the trap of embracing everything Augustine says as normative instruction. However, it is essential to critically assess new information.

Read More
1600 Words | 7 Pages

Moreover, Augustine argues, since it is “God who made human beings good, it is God, not human beings, who restores human beings so that they are good. He sets them free from the evil that they have brought upon themselves, if they will it, believe, and call upon him.” Since we have by our own will brought upon ourselves sin; we cannot be healed from our sin without the grace of

Read More
1117 Words | 5 Pages

He is beginning to realize that he has to change his ways in order to reach absolution. In the ninth book, Augustine shows how he was able to finally connect with God through his books and teachings. “I read on: Tremble and sin no more, and this moved me deeply, my God, because now I had learned to tremble from my past, so that in the future I might sin no more.” (Book IX, Section 4, Page 187) This shows that Augustine was finally able to find God through the readings of the Bible.

Read More

More about Augustine Vs Descartes

Related Topics

Open Document