ipl-logo

Beowulf Compare And Contrast Gawain And Portia

1530 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Compare and contrast beowulf and gawain as heroes

Brian Baglioni
Professor Tague
BRL: Epic to Novel-01
10-23-15
The Notion of a Hero:
Comparison and Contrast of Beowulf, Gawain and Portia

A “hero” can mean many things; it is subject to interpretation especially when taken into account that what defines a person as a hero is dependent on his or her relationship to the society in which he or she lives. In general, heroes strive for some form of perfection, to be something greater than they already are. They wish to help the people around them in whatever ways they can, often sacrificing their time and effort to do so. Beowulf, Sir Gawain and Portia are three characters that contain within them the inherent qualities of a hero. They are all heroes in that they willingly rise up to the occasion …show more content…

“The captain of evil discovered himself in a handgrip

harder than anything he had ever encountered in any manon the face of the earth. Every

bone in his body quailed and recoiled, but he could not escape. He was desperate to flee

to his den and hide with the devil 's litter, for in all his days he had never been clamped or

cornered like this. (749-756, Beowulf) As seen in his fight against Grendel, his strength is

“mythological” in scope and ultimately superior to Grendel’s. Beowulf is not really

tested intellectually per se; he is not the subject of someone else’s deceptive practices like

Gawain is or subject to social/ethical problems that Portia is embroiled in. He is a hero in

the sense that he is called into action and responds willingly and enthusiastically without

retort; he is unmoved in his pursuit of the objective placed upon him. "Often, for

undaunted courage, fate spares the man it has not already marked." (572-573, Beowulf) In

other words, if fate does not intervene, a means to an end can be achieved via courage

and strength alone. This is Beowulf’s outlook on the notion of a hero. Even after death it

is surmised that he buries the treasure with him so that it would not corrupt anyone …show more content…

A hero in this context would not employ physical means of survival like Beowulf or Gawain did because the dangers present aren’t of a combative nature but rather an intellectual framework involving deception, justice and mercy. The origin of the main conflict stems from an ethical dilemma, of debts that are yet to be paid and does not necessarily condone the use of physical aptitude to achieve such means like it does for Beowulf and Gawain. Portia is the heroine of The Merchant of Venice and she transforms the notion of a hero into something more than just a prominent, masculine entity or force. In the words of Joseph Campbell, “The hero […] is the man or woman who has been able to battle past his personal and local historical limitations to the generally valid, normally human form” (20, Joseph Campbell). This is precisely what she does in the court procession by turning a problematic social situation into a solution that not only resolves the main conflict of Antonio’s debt but also displays her capacity for compassion, mercy and

Show More
Related
469 Words | 2 Pages

The idea of a hero is explored differently in the ancient Anglo-Saxon text Beowulf and John Gardner’s Grendel. During the time period of both of the stories being a hero is very important to everyone. Beowulf is not a true hero, even if he tries to make himself out to seem like a true hero, based on modern ideas of the Hero. In the poem Beowulf being a hero is very important to the main character Beowulf.

Read More
1044 Words | 5 Pages

The hero in the epic poem Beowulf is the main character, Beowulf. He demonstrates heroic qualities as soon as the readers are introduced to his character. Beowulf proves himself to be courageous and brave by voluntarily fighting the “undefeatable” monster, Grendel. He is greatly admired by both the Danes and Geats for his courageous acts. Although his motivation is altered to only benefit himself with the title of the greatest warrior, his plan to save the Danes is greatly appreciated by all in the land.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

Heroism is multifaceted and varies in size and form. Heroism is represented differently within the epics "Beowulf" and "Sir Gawain and the Green Knight." "Beowulf" is set in 1066 and tells the story of Beowulf, a hero, who willingly fights a monster to save a kingdom. " Sir Gawain and the Green Knight" is set during the medieval period at King Arthur’s court and tells the story of Sir Gawain, a knight of the aforementioned Court, who sacrifices himself to save his king and peers. Beowulf shows his heroism through physicality, while Gawain shows his heroism through mentality.

Read More
1273 Words | 6 Pages

Heroes are a major part in any story no matter how clear their heroism is. In the case of the characters, Beowulf and Sir Gawain, they are considered to be heroes. However, they are two different types of heroes even though they both show the key attributes that make them considered to be heroes; Beowulf is the brave idealistic hero whereas Sir Gawain is a noble knight who is also modest and cares a lot about what people think of him so much so that he tells a lie to keep up his reputation. In the epic poem Beowulf, the character Beowulf hears about a monster named Grendel tormenting the land Heorot, so “he announced his plan: to sail the swan’s road and seek out that king, the famous prince who needed defenders” to help fight the monster. (David and Simpson, Beowulf 46)

Read More
486 Words | 2 Pages

Beowulf: Epic Hero or Proud Fool? So what exactly is a hero? A hero to most is a person idealized for their courage and their outstanding achievements and qualities. Some may even consider Beowulf a hero due his never backing down and risking his own life for the safety of his people.

Read More
626 Words | 3 Pages

From all this, we know that the perception of a hero from Beowulf’s time differs from our perception today. As we feel that the intentions define a hero while in Beowulf’s time the reputation and accomplishments are what makes a

Read More
1269 Words | 6 Pages

Not all heroes are perfect, but some are nobler than others. In the story of Sir Gawain, we find out that even legends, such as Sir Gawain made mistakes. In today’s time, most heroes are thought of as militaristic accomplishments, such as badges, wars won, and saving lives. Sir Gawain was a hero, not because of great accomplishments but because he was driven by his bravery, nobility, and virtue.

Read More
427 Words | 2 Pages

Beowulf makes known that “no man but [himself] could hope to defeat this monster, [and] no one could try.” Beowulf wants to have this fight all to himself, so he can take all of the glory. He is too selfish to conclude that only he could defeat the monster alone. Beowulf cannot be thought of as a hero because “Beowulf only longed for fame.” Beowulf does not perform heroic deeds just to save the citizens, but to receive more admiration from the citizens.

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

Indeed, though they put on a heroic front, Beowulf, Sir Gawain, and Brutus are internally broken and sensitive. Extraordinary men such as themselves suffer from the ordinary problems of self confidence and struggle to overcome their insecurities. They, like all humans, strive for perfection, but, in pursuing this perfection, fall far from it. Thus, these trials and uncertainties allow these noble heroes to relate to the common man. However, despite these setbacks, each of these three protagonists are able to use their weaknesses to their advantage.

Read More
821 Words | 4 Pages

Beowulf possessed the poised demeanor necessary to defeat all evils by the arrogant swing of his sword. The commitment shown by lending his life to the welfare of his people was imperative in order to be called a flawless warrior. Beowulf embodied the determination that Anglo-Saxons saw as unmeasurably valuable. If nothing more than just fiction, Beowulf is the ideal hero of the people from who he originated. “They said that of all the kings upon the earth he was the man most gracious and fair-minded, kindest to his people and keenest to win fame.”

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

Beowulf the hero undertakes a long, perilous journey, often involving a descent into the Underworld, which tests his endurance, courage, and cunning. The tests that Beowulf faces will not only provide bravery and leadership, but more so a reason to call him a true epic hero. Through his journey there are many barriers he must overcome in order to succeed in battle. “He leaped into the lake, would not wait for anyone's Answer; the heaving water covered him Over. For hours he sank through the waves; At last he saw the mud of the bottom” (570-574).

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

A hero does not fight for fame and glory but for the greater good. A hero is someone who goes through adversity to help others in desperate times. A hero fights evil, and defends people. Beowulf should be considered a hero because he is a strong, brave warrior who defended his people and slayed evil monsters. Beowulf proves himself to be a strong, brave warrior by killing Grendel the monster.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Questions of Honor: Beowulf Beowulf’s honor and integrity can be questioned throughout the entirety of the epic poem, Beowulf. Whether or not his actions are inspired by his own pompous arrogance or confidence, one can argue that he is a hero nonetheless. Evidence and experience prove that Beowulf is more of a fearless hero than an excessively prideful man, and his hubris is more than justified due to the formidable duties he is able to execute. Throughout the poem, Beowulf expresses his intense strength and courage to the fearful people in the poem. His daring sense of self-assurance is backed by his victories against all three monsters, (even though he suffers a tragic death after facing the dragon, it is a defeat nonetheless).

Read More
300 Words | 2 Pages

In the story Beowulf they make Beowulf out to be the hero. I believe that he is the hero because of his way that he presents himself when he gets to as his crewmen walked off the boat and they looked bad in clothes Beowulf looked very nice and very manly other than his crewmen looked bad and also he was a hero because he was the only one to come to and help the town. Defeating the monsters which was mother dragon and the last reason that he was considered a hero because after all the monsters he killed he decided to give all of the gold and supplies that he won from the battle with the monsters to all the people in herot and also he was reconized as a hero because he let God decide his Faith during the battle with the monsters.

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

The Webster's definition of a hero is “A person who is admired for great or brave acts or fine qualities”, this also happens to be one of the qualifications of being an epic hero. There are many things that can be used to compare and contrast Beowulf as an epic hero and a modern day hero, but you’ll find that the human idea of a hero was primarily the same in 700 CE as it is now although the job descriptions of hero’s have changed. In today’s time a person is usually considered a hero if they help the public good, like a police officer, soldier, firefighter and so on. In Beowulf’s time a person was considered a hero if they were a great warrior. When looking at the characteristics of what makes Beowulf an epic hero and the characteristics

Read More

More about Beowulf Compare And Contrast Gawain And Portia

Related Topics

Open Document