ipl-logo

Captain John Prior's The Moral Logic Of Survivor Guilt

711 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The moral logic of survivor guilt theme

I think people shouldn’t be held accountable for their actions in life or death situations. Everyone has accidents and everyone is somewhat clumsy. And when the casualty rates grow just because people fear rescue cost, or have guilt just for something they had nearly no control over, you know there’s something that can and will be done with an easy solution that honestly, should be no debate. For example, in “The Moral Logic of Survivor Guilt”, It discusses how an Army officer, Captain John Prior, felt responsible for the death of a soldier when a gun misfired and hit him in the head. When in reality, he had nothing to do with the firing of the gun but only the placement of the gun, and the placement of the victim, Joseph Mayek. Another example …show more content…

These people rescue and help people for a living, and wouldn’t be doing it if they feared the consequences of an accident on the job. One piece of evidence from “The Cost of Survival” sums it up. As quoted by a California Air National Guard who helped save the sick child at sea, “We’re out there to save lives. You can’t put a price on that.” Clearly, the officer enjoys what he does and is proud of it. He doesn’t mind saving them. This man trained for around 2 months and spent likely years given his rank of second lieutenant doing this, so it’s not something he’s getting sick of. Another argument you might bring up is that people purposely put themselves in dangerous situations while in national parks and similar places. Again, we have people who spend their lives rescuing people. They victim might have done what they did to be in the situation but obviously weren’t expecting their predicament. Everyone has accidents and everyone has been in a difficult situation before. When it’s like this, why should they pay? If everyone has accidents wouldn’t it make sense for everyone (as in taxpayers) to help them? They might not appreciate paying extra money to the government, but when they get in trouble themselves and don’t have a 500,000 dollar bill, they’ll be glad that they do pay the extra

Show More
Related
349 Words | 2 Pages

I don’t want somebody to die trying to rescue me. The rescuers shouldn’t have to risk themselves because some climbers take advantage or harsh conditions make it harder. People who put themselves at risk don’t have the right to rescue services. One reason why people should not get rescue services is, a rescuer might die just because a climber takes advantage or the climber isn 't careful.

Read More
403 Words | 2 Pages

Elie Wiesel and Gerda Weissmann were both Jewish prisoners that were taken from their homes and forced to work in factories with terrible conditions for Nazi Germany. They both had very different experiences during their time in concentration camps and slave labor facilities, but after watching the documentary, “One Survivor Remembers,” and the memoir Night, one can determine the differences and similarities between Weissmann’s story and Wiesels’s story in terms of driving motivations in the will to survive. To start, one similarity is that both Wiesel and Weissmann had a family figure that kept their motivation strong and prevented them from committing suicide. In both accounts, the family figure happens to be their fathers. In the documentary,

Read More
556 Words | 3 Pages

He does not think about how much danger he might be in when he is trying to save his men. (Myers 39). He willingly went out into open fire to try to save them. (Myers 39). Lieutenant Carroll would put his life on the line just so his soldiers could live.

Read More
1119 Words | 5 Pages

The justice system is responsible for the error, they should be responsible for the effects of their

Read More
801 Words | 4 Pages

This is a great example of how training is key to becoming a better person. The training soldiers go through before heading to war is separating themselves from being human to acting as a true soldier in combat. Since there is training going into battle field there should be training coming out of battle field, and learning how to be in the real world once again. This training could help many countless veterans who currently suffer from PTSD to help them gain their peace of

Read More
1152 Words | 5 Pages

Whether you were responsible for the death of a person or it was something that was put into your head, you still have the belief that the death was caused on your behalf. “Even now I haven’t finished sorting it out. Sometimes I forgive myself, other times I don’t. In the ordinary hours of life I try not to dwell on it, but now and then, when I’m reading a newspaper or just sitting alone in a room, I’ll look up and see the young man step out of the morning fog” (O’Brien, 128). Tim O’Brien killed a man while he was on guard although it was to protect the rest of the soldiers he was fighting in the war with he still felt guilty.

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

The Excruciating Scourge of The Jews Art Spiegelman, in the Graphic Novel Maus, and Tadeusz Różewicz, in the poem The Survivor, together introduce the impairment of the Jewish people, showing how they were brutally murdered, and treated like animals. The Jewish people were blamed for everything wrong that happened in Germany, according to Adolf Hitler. Leading the Third Reich, he explained to all of Germany of what the Jews had done, claiming that they had caused the Great Depression. They used the Jewish people as a scape goat to all their problems, and that is what led to such disastrous consequences.

Read More
767 Words | 4 Pages

Jaxon Bruzgul Mr. Frederick AP English 11 12 February 2023 The Consequences of Victim Mentality In his essay "Epidemic of Accusations," William Shermer explores the phenomenon of mass accusations and how they can spiral out of control. In many ways, this essay serves as a useful lens through which to interpret Arthur Miller's play, The Crucible. The events depicted in the play are seen as a manifestation of the kind of mass hysteria and false accusations that Shermer describes.

Read More
137 Words | 1 Pages

These people are the police officers and military who sacrifice their personal

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

These people are soldiers. Those who serve our country always have,and always will stand as role model for me. The way that they are able to risk their lives shows a bravely that I can only hope to one day have. When you are watching the news and you hear about the soldiers who throw themselves over grenades, you realize how much bravery that soldiers must have.

Read More
501 Words | 3 Pages

In the “Cost of Survival,” an argumentative essay, in which; voices the opinion of Theo Tucker, an individual that believes that some people “willingly put themselves into life-or-death situations,” (126) also he explains, how if these risky decisions end in needed rescue missions. Therefore, said people should pay for the cost of their rescues, because individuals that do things like “mountain climb and base jump, knowingly face danger.” (126) The author stands on the side of the argument that, these rescue missions or “efforts, can cost a lot of money, and that “The adventurer should be the one to foot the bill” (126)

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

Firstly, there are rescue workers whose job is to save people in danger. According to Ranger Killed During Rescue of Climbers on Mount Rainier, “Hall, a native of Patten, Maine, had been with the park’s climbing program for four years, the release said” This explains why rescue workers have the job to save people because this is an example of one worker who had worked for a climbing program. It was specifically made for the purpose of rangers to be there in case a climber would have an accident and not be able to recover by themselves. However, rescue workers also have a high chance of being injured or even dying along with the people who were already in danger. While the rescue workers could also be injured or lose their life, rescuing people is their job.

Read More
777 Words | 4 Pages

Should people in life or death situations be held accountable? Yes and no, it is and isn’t that person 's fault it’s they could have thought about it and realized that he could get hurt and die or live it’s like mountain climbing it’s like what if you fall off and hit your head.it depends on how you think of it, wheather you want to doecause its dangerous or you may not know if it is dangerous yet you do it anyway. Likewise it can be where you get hurt and will be held accountable even though you know that you can get hurt and die.

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

“...We often take responsibility in a way that goes beyond what we can reasonably be held responsible for”(Sherman 154), says Nancy Sherman in “The Moral Logic of Survivor Guilt.” Sherman believes that people blame themselves too much when something goes wrong in a dangerous situation; and even when something happens that is out of their control, they cannot forgive themselves for the outcome of the event. Should people in life-or-death situations be held accountable for their actions? Someone might argue that people should take responsibility for what they do, even in survival mode. However, in life-or-death situations, people should not accuse other, and make them feel remorse for their actions, because, in survival mode, a person wants to save themselves before anyone else.

Read More
1707 Words | 7 Pages

Events that occur randomly and that are traumatic can take a toll on all aspects of an individual that endure them, what if an individual were in a gruesome situation and the lives of human beings were lost under their unintentional control? How would they feel for the rest of their lifetime? In the article “The Moral Logic of Survivor Guilt” by Nancy Sherman, she describes the emotional reality of soldiers in their home are often at odds with the civilian public, and are struggling to carry the burden of feeling responsible of traumatic situations. Survivor’s guilt is the bold feeling that survivors have after a tragic event taking place when others have passed away. Soldiers in battle experience losses during combat.

Read More

More about Captain John Prior's The Moral Logic Of Survivor Guilt

Related Topics

Open Document