ipl-logo

Case Study: Burwell V. Hobby

1454 Words6 Pages

Business Law Case Study Essay: Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, 573 U.S (2014) Facts: The Green family runs and owns Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., a national arts and skills chain that has over 500 stores and they have over 13,000 employees. Other facts of the case are that the Green family has been able to organize the business around the values of the Christian faith and has explicitly expressed the desire to run the company as told by Biblical principles, one of which is the belief that the utilization of contraception is wicked. Also, the facts show that under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), occupation -founded group health care plans must offer certain sorts of preventative care, for example, FDA-accepted contraceptive approaches. …show more content…

Issue: Does the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 allow a for-revenue business to refute its employees ' health attention of contraception to which the workers would then be allowed based on the religious oppositions of the company 's …show more content…

Opinion: I believe with the ruling. I am on the same page with Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. I agree 100% with his writing for the court, which stated that family-owned companies like Hobby Lobby should not be enforced to recompense for insurance coverage for contraception for workers over their religious oppositions. I believe that this ruling is accurate because it means that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 is efficient and does what it says that it does. With a lot of things going on in the land and not very many laws being enforced , it was good to see that this one was applied correctly to the case. I agree with Justice Alito when he writes that there are other means that the government could guarantee that women will have admission to the four contraceptives which were a problem in the case in court. In fact, Justice Alito transcribes, the system the government arranged to permit workers of religious nonprofit administrations to get some access to these contraceptives would serve the world of for-profit companies also. Going forward it also sends a message to other corporations that might be going through a similar

Show More
Related
104 Words | 1 Pages

A recent federal lawsuit has been filed by the American Civil Liberties Union’s (ACLU) challenging the constitutionality of three provisions of the Setonia’s Abortion Laws. The three provisions ACLU are challenging are as follows (McCauliff): • Law which prevents state health officials from renewing or issuing licenses to abortion clinics located with 2000 feet of an elementary school (McCauliff). • Law which requires physicians performing abortions to complete 10 hours annually of continuing medical education on abortion procedures (McCauliff). • Law which requires abortion providers to give every patient a copy of her medical records, regardless of whether the patient requests such records (McCauliff).

Read More
139 Words | 1 Pages

Obviously the Hobby Lobby won the case for a reason. The Green family prior to this case had settled with the Affordable Healthcare Act that they would not support for the payment of certain birth control supplements due to their religious beliefs. All other Hobby Lobby employees using this health care had no problem with this, except Ms. Burwell. Ms. Burwell did have a problem with this; so she decided to sue, and overall lost her case. Due to the fact the Green family religious beliefs go against these certain birth controls U.S. could not deny their right’s, seeing as America was founded on the belief of religious freedom.

Read More
830 Words | 4 Pages

In the majority opinion, Justice Alito found that these corporations of the Hobby Lobby plaintiffs could assert religious rights. He wrote that because they were privately owned by family members, it was like a small group of people who joined together to pursue a common goal, despite being sizeable businesses. Meaning in this Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and First Amendment, Free Exercise case, it was decided that the entity, individuals or corporation, is acting or not acting upon sincere religious beliefs and that the regulations of the ACA significantly burdened that entity’s religious beliefs (Greendorfer,

Read More
1872 Words | 8 Pages

56. Webster v. Reproductive Health Services (1989): The Court upheld Missouri restrictions on abortions that “public employees and public facilities were not to be used in performing or assisting abortions unnecessary to save the mother 's life; encouragement and counseling to have abortions was prohibited; and physicians were to perform viability tests upon women in their twentieth (or more) week of pregnancy.” It was a fractured decision that seemed to contradict Roe v. Wade but the court decided to not revisit any parts of Roe v. Wade after this case. The Missouri restrictions did not violate the right to privacy or the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.

Read More
642 Words | 3 Pages

2. There are other approaches through which the government can provide affordable/free contraceptive coverage to female employees, without involvement from the Little Sisters and their health

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

The Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the physicians’ rights to inform women about birth control. Sanger tried to test the Comstock law by ordering diaphragms from Switzerland. US Customs confiscated and destroyed the diaphragms. Sanger took the case to court, claiming that US Customs was interfering with doctors’ rights’ to server their patients. The Court told US Customs that they must hand over the diaphragms.

Read More
1735 Words | 7 Pages

In certain cases, the government allows certain groups to express their religious views. In Georgette Bennett’s article, Abortion: Whose Religious Beliefs Should Prevail?, she asks, “Should the beliefs of one religion be imposed on those who may hold other sincerely held beliefs?” (Bennett). In this article, she discussed Hobby Lobby’s religious beliefs on abortion and contraceptives. In Hobby Lobby’s case, the Supreme Court ruled that they were allowed to practice their Christian beliefs and did not have to provide insurance for contraceptives.

Read More
1038 Words | 5 Pages

With almost half the nation divided among their views, abortion remains one of the most controversial topics in our society. Since Roe v. Wade, our views in society as well as following court cases have been progressing toward the woman’s right to choose. The precedent set by Roe v. Wade made the Supreme Court acknowledge that it cannot rule specifically when life begins and it also affirms that it is the woman’s right to have an abortion under the 14th Amendment. In the 1st Amendment, the Establishment Clause forbids the government from passing laws “which aid one religion, aid all religions, or prefer one religion over another”. Many Christian pro-lifers use their religious beliefs to dispute when life begins.

Read More
1097 Words | 5 Pages

Hobby Lobby ruled in favor of Hobby Lobby giving family owned businesses the right to be exempted from laws for religious exceptions. This lawsuit was in response to the Affordable Care Act’s insurance mandate of providing birth control to female employees. But some strict Christians are against certain methods of contraception due to the belief that the contraception prevents fertilized embryos from implantation. By allowing a business owner to remove the birth control methods that do not follow their Christian faith, the government is opening the door for other religious groups and businesses to reject other government mandated decisions. These decisions differ from the current conscientious objection laws that prevent healthcare providers from having to participate in procedures, such as abortions, if it goes against their moral beliefs (Harris, 981).

Read More
1555 Words | 7 Pages

The Right to Abortion On January 22, 1973, in a 7-2 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down it’s landmark decision in the case of Roe v. Wade, which recognized that the constitutional right to privacy extends to a woman’s right to make her own personal medical decisions — including the decision to have an abortion without interference from politicians (Planned Parenthood). There are many moments in history when Roe v. Wade has been so close to being overturned, yet it is still in place. Abortion should stay legal, or not overturned, for the health of women everywhere. First, this important case took place at the time of abortion being illegal in most states, including Texas, where Roe v. Wade began.

Read More
893 Words | 4 Pages

Annotated Bibliography "Abortion ProCon.org." ProConorg Headlines. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Apr. 2016.

Read More
1113 Words | 5 Pages

The United States Supreme Court recently established the standards that all female employees that are pregnant must meet in order to file a discrimination claim under the Pregnancy Discrimination Act of 1978. A claim can only be filed when the employer is providing accommodations to other employees that are not pregnant, and are not offering the same accommodations for the pregnant employees. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission played a significant part in this Act generating significant attention due to the aggressive position that was being taken by various employees. The EEOC claimed that any time an employer offered an accommodation to another employee with similar physical limitation, the employer had an absolute obligation to also offer the pregnant employee the exact same accommodations. This would have to be done without regard to reason the employer had provided the accommodation in one situation but not another.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

As a woman, I believe that my rights should not be determined by some man in Washington DC. Instead, everyone should be entitled to their own opinion. Abortions and contraceptives are not procedures or medications that women usually advertise and frankly, it is none of government’s business what women choose to do with their own bodies. They are not the property of men or the

Read More
1407 Words | 6 Pages

The perfect example of this issue is the Hobby Lobby case (Source #1). The issue started after the company refused to provide healthcare for their employees that support abortions. The government immediately stepped in even though it was the company 's religious beliefs. This decision should have been left to the church. The Hobby Lobby company has the right as a Christian ran business, to refuse any non-biblical procedures the government is trying to force upon

Read More
1444 Words | 6 Pages

By removing this support, women who choose or have chosen abortion now feel as though they are the ones in the wrong, not the law. There is no doubt this law was set in place in hopes women would feel guilty and change their minds about abortion. Even if the women still choose to abort after this, they will feel more uncomfortable and ashamed about their

Read More

More about Case Study: Burwell V. Hobby

Open Document