ipl-logo

Chamberlain V Queen Essay

498 Words2 Pages

Few cases have generated as much public interest and controversy in Australian history as the Chamberlain v Queen. The case revolves around the disappearance of a 9 week old Azaria on a family camping trip near Uluru. The parents maintained that a dingo took the infant with witnesses supporting this version of the story. The prosecution claimed this was a ‘fanciful lie’ and claimed Azaria was murdered by her mother Lindy. This essay reflects upon the ‘trial’ as a process taken place within a community, where the accused is being tried by both the legal system and the public simultaneously. The trial that takes place within a community is reflective of the community standards. The values of justice and fair trial are of important for the community …show more content…

The paper is divided into three time frames providing a better framework by which one can understand the conversations that take place in different periods of the trial. Firstly, I will be exploring the Australian society of the 1980’s whereby retelling the story of Australian identity and exploring the themes of family, attitudes to bush, religion and legal system of Australia. This will set the context of the time and the cultural beliefs that were prevalent in making this trial one of the more infamous public trials. Secondly, the event of the crime and trial proceedings will be of primary focus which lasts from 1980 to 1986. This period will be examined through the scope of legal framework and that of the society and media. This trial will be examined using two sets of contrasting written records, the trial of the law using court documents and trial commentaries. The other is the trial by the media in extension the community, exploring different viewpoints on media’s portrayal of the case over the years. Finally, the time after 1986, upon new evidence, Lindy was pardoned and released with the legal system rectifying their error by exonerating Lindy of the

Show More
Related

Racial Profiling Case: The Lloyd Rayney Case

852 Words | 4 Pages

On the 14th of October 2011, Mr Rayney had submitted an application for a trial which only involved a judge without a jury present. This was due Mr. Rayney assuming that a strong bias had been manifested pre-trial as a result of the subjective publicity revolving around the death of his wife, Corryn(The Conversation, 2012). Therefore, the jury and any member of the public would already have preconceived views in favour of Mr Rayney being guilty of murdering his wife. The trial was successful for Mr Rayney where he was acquitted of murdering his wife. Similarly, this issue is somewhat common as it had also occurred in the case Evans v The State of Western Australia [2011] WASCA 182, in which both appellants had made appeals after being convicted for murder.

Read More

Annotated Bibliography: Australian Court System

595 Words | 3 Pages

Annotated Bibliography: Australian Court System Annotated Bibliography Opeskin, Brian. 2013. The state of the judicature: A statistical profile of Australian courts and judges. The Sydney Law Review, 35, (3): 489-517. This article by Opeskin (2013) aims to provide a detailed account of Australian courts that accurately reflects how it functions today.

Read More

What Is The Christine Jessop Case

1340 Words | 6 Pages

“On July 30, 1992, an innocent person was convicted of a heinous crime”. Guy Paul Morin, an ordinary man, was arrested, imprisoned and convicted of first degree murder. The victim was Christine Jessop, a nine-year-old girl from Ontario, Canada. She was found murdered in a field about fifty kilometres from where she lived. Due to the investigation team’s carelessness and tunnel vision, the systematic failure of the justice system, and the poor handling of evidence by the crown there was not only one, but two victims in this case.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Juries In Australia

1543 Words | 7 Pages

The jury bench should also be filled with a proper representation of the public for a non-biased verdict to be able to be formed (Forum,

Read More

The Death Of Zachary And Andrew Bagby

1677 Words | 7 Pages

The death of both Zachary and Andrew Bagby is a tragedy that will never be forgotten. It can not be said enough that both of their deaths were avoidable from the start and that the justice system of Canada should be held responsible for allowing the murderer known as Shirly Turner to walk free after she slaughtered a completely innocent person and then as a result of her freedom, murdered that person's son in a murder-suicide. Kurt Kuenne, the producer of this documentary, did an excellent job in shedding light on the fact that there are immense consequences to letting violent offenders roam the streets. Although Andrew Bagby’s death was less avoidable in comparison to Zachary’s, there certainly should have been more public information about

Read More

Mcmartin Day Care Abuse In The Crucible

773 Words | 4 Pages

Innocent people who are incriminated under improper evidence are hanged. Parallel in the McMartin day care abuse case, the McMartin family, who administrate the establishment, and other members are accused illegally of having abused sexually numerously of the children under their vigilance. The accusations used against the McMartin

Read More

The Letters Of John Chamberlain Concerning Life In England

1163 Words | 5 Pages

Bibliography Caraman, Philp. Henry Garnet. New York: Farrar, Straus & Company, 1964. Caraman writes a detailed biography of Henry Garnet, a Jesuit Priest involved in conspirators of the plot, from the early life to his execution in 1606. The author extensive research provides detailed report for a Catholic clergymen.

Read More

Injustice In The Crucible Essay

660 Words | 3 Pages

We must go and overthrow the court, he says!’” (Miller 119). Miller gives insight into how the accusations around 1950-1954 may have also included the pressure of higher authority forcing someone (of the lower authority) with power, money, and etc. to testify false accusations. The author presents an interesting story that mirrors and represents a different time period, displaying the social injustice of people as they are motivated by fear, jealousy, hatred of one another, and more.

Read More

Examples Of Abuse Of Power In The Great Gatsby

2246 Words | 9 Pages

’”(Lu 218-219). The trials are a way to reinforce the publics control over their life and decision making, the trials are an abuse of power, forcing every individual of any class to take part to determine whether or not they can be useful or not is an act of abuse to retain absolute control over the population much like the Hunger Games, the trials are a separate scheme to remind everyone who decides every aspect of their life, corrupt societies try to remove the option of freedom from every aspect of an individuals life and only prefer those who are in power and despise the powerless since they have no say or way to stop the

Read More

Flawed Jury Essay

705 Words | 3 Pages

Having a trial in the accused hometown where they have people coming from the same location or them being on the jury can help protect the defendant from unfair or excessive sentencing. Having a jury that can represent from where the accused’s community is what demonstrates a balanced and equal system where it can show others their trust and confidence towards the justice

Read More

Jury System: 19th And 20th Centuries

1912 Words | 8 Pages

He wrote that “the existence of trial by jury helps to ensure the independence and quality of the judges” and that it “gives the protection against laws which ordinary man may regard as harsh and oppressive.” This insight sheds light on the constitutional aspect of the trial by jury, highlighted by the view that trial by jury affords the common man participation in judicial proceedings and the comfort it affords a defendant to be tried by his peers. It is noted that the trial by jury, involves the common citizen in the decision-making process where participation is viewed as an integral part of a democratic

Read More

Social And Cultural Values Of Entexualization Within The Trial System

435 Words | 2 Pages

The study investigates how the narrative tactic termed “Entexualization” is used through language ideology as a socially, culturally, and historically driven factor in controlling defendants and witnesses not only within the trial system, but also across social contexts via the influence of mass media. The term “Entexualization” has been defined as “the process of rendering discourse extractable of making a stretch of linguistic production into a unit a text that can be lifted out of its interactional setting” (Eades 2012: 475). During the process of “Entexualization”, various social and cultural factors have a great influence on shaping and creating assumptions on ideologies, which lead the jury perceiving or coming to a decision based on claims that may have been influenced by the imbalanced social views of the prosecutions. These biased assumptions eventually contribute to the “inequality” and “imbalance” of social justification.

Read More

Justice In The Film A Few Good Men

1035 Words | 5 Pages

Justice may sometimes be cruel and harsh, in being so, however, it is universal for each and every one of us and we defend our rights in the name of it. When certain violations of justice occur individual entities are charged with different cases for which they are called up on a trial. For everyone to get a fair trial, there are some aspects to the law that need to be respected. The likes are: the phenomena of the “due process”, questioning the credibility of the witnesses and the role of advocates' persistency when defending their clients. All of these, together with a great deal of other principals, have to be there for justice to be done to the whole society.

Read More

Literary Nationalism: Australian National Identity

871 Words | 4 Pages

(Ward, 1989) The literary and general imagination saw the bushmen as the “culture-heroes”. Many Australians saw them as role models and wanted to achieve their characteristics as their attitudes. (Hodges,

Read More

Trial By Jury Advantages And Disadvantages

1472 Words | 6 Pages

In this paragraph, the advantages and disadvantages of trial by jury will be discussed. The main advantages are that juries introduce community values into the legal process and can influence the system (Joyce, 2013); they can achieve a sense of equity and fairness without enforcing unjust laws; in addition, juries are independent and neutral (Davies, 2015). Moreover, they guarantee participation from the public in a democratic institution (Hostettler, 2004), and represent the population thanks to the randomness with which jurors are decided (Davies, 2015). On the other hand, the most important disadvantages are that jurors have no prior contact with the courts, no training (Hostettler, 2004) and therefore they lack knowledge of law, courtroom proceedings (Joyce, 2013), and lack of ability to understand the legal directions (Thomas, 2010). Moreover, they must face evidence which is highly technical (Hostettler, 2004).

Read More

More about Chamberlain V Queen Essay

Related Topics

Open Document