ipl-logo

Coming Of Age In Katherine Mansfield's The Garden Party

1260 Words6 Pages

The Growth of a Laurel There is more to Katherine Mansfield’s “The Garden Party” than meets the eye-it is not merely an account of a fête with fine china, sequined gowns and idle chatter. Contradictory to its lighthearted title, “The Garden Party” alludes to weighty themes such as social prejudice, isolation and change. The story centers around Laura Sheridan’s coming-of-age as she breaks away from societal norms of her bourgeois background. Her transition is at odds with her upper-status family, who chooses be blind to class distinctions. With Mr.Scott’s death, Laura’s realization amplifies into what propels her maturity and moral decency. In “The Garden Party,” Mansfield best conveys Laura’s sympathetic character through comparisons against …show more content…

With news of Mr.Scott’s death, Laura becomes hesitant to host the party, however, Mrs.Sheridan remarks on her daughter’s ridiculousness and absurdity. She states, “People like that don’t expect sacrifices from us” (Mansfields, 6), dismissing the need to be civil towards the low-class. It is not merely just that she refuses to express courtesy to the lower classes, but also that she believes it impossible of such people to possess expectations for the wealthy. Her mother’s impervious behavior stuns Laura and she becomes conflicted; where is the fine line between respect and power? In addition, Jose mindlessly assumes that Mr.Scott had been drunk and her insensitive comment visibly agitates Laura. Though she momentarily questions her sympathy when she catches sight of her “charming” (Mansfields, 6), lavishily beautiful self in the mirror, such doubts and reactions from Laura portray that, albeit young, she is affected by the blind eye her family turns to the lower-classes and that there is a conscious inside her. By elaborating on Mrs.Sheridan’s and Jose’s prejudice, Mansfield is successfully able to stress on Laura’s sympathetic …show more content…

The story ends on an ambiguous note when Laura fails to put her new-found knowledge into words. One can’t help but wonder if this experience will stay permanent or if it will be buried under societal prejudice later. Perhaps, this ambiguity is intended all along. From the start of the story, Laura is referred to as a flower, innocent and vulnerable. Whether if she will succumb and wither away or grow into a laurel is left to the

Show More
Related
183 Words | 1 Pages

Coming of age is an event that everyone must go through. There are many different types of coming of age events that can happen at many different times. Many different stories illustrate the process of coming of age. Through our studies of different texts we have learned that there is no wrong way to come of age. In “Marigolds” the main character Elizabeth Collier came of age by destructing something someone cared about.

Read More
1061 Words | 5 Pages

Capote illustrates such potential for the family, particularly that of the children who are both talented and exceptional in their own ways. This familiarity that Capote establishes allows for a sense of devastation and compassion to be felt by the reader in the wake of the murders. Compassion is naturally extended to those whom are close to the Clutters, Bobby Rupp and Susan Kidwell are poignant examples of this. For these young adults, and children of the school and community, the loss of Nancy and her family would be the first true tragic event that they have experienced in their lives. This experience of tragedy evokes sympathy naturally from the reader towards those close to the Clutter’s.

Read More
1277 Words | 6 Pages

In other words, Mrs. Hopewell does not recognize the fact that Mrs. Freeman desires to know everything about Mrs. Hopewell’s life, instead Mrs. Hopewell perceives the lower class Mrs. Freeman as just desiring to work hard; hence, Mrs. Hopewell ’s sense of superiority causes her to become ignorant of Mrs. Freeman’s true intentions, alike to

Read More
123 Words | 1 Pages

In Eugenia W. Collier’s short story “Marigolds”, Lizabeth and her family experience an external conflict against society when the Great Depression’s burdens fall onto them, creating both emotional and financial stress; in this, Collier reveals that external struggle may lead to reckless actions. Early on, Lizabeth describes poverty as “...the cage in which [her family] was trapped…”, alluding to her desire to be free from the bars of impoverishment (Collier 126). Towards the climax in the story, Lizabeth hears her father crying about his inability to support his family without a steady income, which leads to her “...feelings [combining] in one great impulse toward destruction” (Collier 126). In this, Collier projects the idea that strenuous

Read More
1375 Words | 6 Pages

Janes nearest of kin were her grandmother and her aunt, both of them lived a humble life and hardly had a sufficient income. Her aunt Miss Bates was a very popular and always welcomed person, although she was “neither young, handsome, rich nor married” (cf. Emma p.22). She cares for her mother, Jane’s grandmother, the widow of a former vicar of Highbury and together they live in a small and simple home.

Read More
147 Words | 1 Pages

Maggie on the other hand, is characterized by her unattractiveness and timidity. Her skin is scarred from the fire that had happened ten or twelve years ago. Those scars she has on her body in the same way have scarred her soul leaving her ashamed. She “stumbles” in her reading, but Mrs. Johnson loves her saying she is sweet and is the daughter she can sing songs at church with, but more so that Maggie is like an image of her. She honors her family’s heritage and culture, by learning how to quilt and do things in the household, like her mother views their heritage.

Read More
1101 Words | 5 Pages

As a matter of fact most frequently critics have looked at how prejudicial her mother’s philosophies have been for our character, and attributed to Editha Mowbray the “fallness” of her daughter. In her essay “The return of the prodigal daughter” Joanne Tong contemplates how “Mrs. Mowbray pays too little rather than too much attention to her daughter” (2004: 475) the outcome of which is a misunderstanding of her position in society with regards to the strict laws of etiquette and feminine ideology in eighteenth century England. Cecily E. Hill also blames Editha for Adeline and Glenmurray’s extramarital affair and their inevitable moral condemnation, and instead of accusing the lovers she sees Editha as the soul villain of the novel. Contrary to the typical concept of a mother who provides a safe education to Adeline, she experiments with dubious theories that ultimately foreground her daughter’s tragic

Read More
1279 Words | 6 Pages

The short story ‘Marigolds’ by Eugenia W. Collier is a coming-of-age narrative that focuses on the differences between innocence and compassion and focuses on themes of poverty and maturity as well. This story was written in 1969 and was set in a rural area of Maryland. Marigolds has fictional characters but derives from Collier’s life as a child during the Great Depression. This story is told from the perspective of a fourteen-year-old girl named Lizabeth. She was a bright young girl, however, she was sheltered and had the misconception that everyone lived in the same type of poverty as her, because that was all that she had been exposed to.

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

She identifies her feelings of desertion by her mother with Maggie. “Twyla and Roberta revise their memories of Maggie in order to transfer their anxieties and anger toward their mothers onto her…” (Androne 134). It is interesting to note that both the girls relate their mothers to Maggie even though Roberta’s mother is described as the opposite of Twyla’s

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

In “A Rose for Emily,” the author, Faulkner, describes the life of a women after the death of her family and the abandonment of her friends. The story is about a female named Emily whose father dies of natural causes, and she is left with little money except for her house and an African American manservant. The manservant is a very loyal person who stays by Emily’s side till her own death. This story is depicted from the neighbor’s point about the lady Emily. It recounts her life as she lived it from an external perspective.

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Miss Brill is lonely, has a completely messed up mind, and tries to hide her true self by trying to live other people’s lives. Miss Brill views each person at the garden differently. The people who are mostly like her are the ones she judges the most, “Miss Brill had often noticed-there was something funny about nearly all of them. They were odd, silent, nearly all old, and from the way they stared they looked as though they’d just come from dark little rooms or even-even cupboards!” (Mansfield 185).

Read More
1189 Words | 5 Pages

In William Faulkner’s short story, A Rose for Emily, Emily Grierson, a prominent member of her small town, dies alone in her home. Upon her death, curious townsfolk entered her home trying to learn her secrets. It was thought she was crazy. Emily Grierson was not crazy; she was isolated by her father, which led to her odd social tendencies and unique interactions with others. A Rose for Emily is a short story based in a small town.

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

The setting in “The Horse Dealer’s Daughter” continues to convey the theme that women have been oppressed by society. Mabel faces oppression in the small english town where the story takes place. She explains that being a women does not matter as much when a family has money, but when they are poor she has to walk down the streets with her eyes low and avoid eye contact as she buys the cheapest item in every store (Lawrence 458). This shows that when a woman is seen as being represented by someone with power, in this case it is her father, then they are given a little respect. However, when a women is looked at just as herself and not as a rich man’s daughter she is not seen a colleague to men but as an object that is to be pitied.

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Katharine Brush 's short story "Birthday Party" is about the perjury of a third person 's judgment about a birthday party thrown by a wife for her husband. Is truly a story with an objective to challenge defining how a man-woman relationship should function. This short story reveals how joyless a marriage can be when spouses are too unimaginative to stray from the bourgeois affection. The use of descriptions, perspective, diction and syntax portray the husband’s insolence so well that its purpose to induce the reader’s disgust is utterly achieved. Sensory details reveal how insignificant the celebration quickly rises into a heartbreaking emotional embarrassment.

Read More
520 Words | 3 Pages

When Richard’s heard the news of her husband’s death, he assumed Mrs. Mallard would be devastated. While everyone knew Mrs. Mallard was “afflicted with heart trouble” (57), him and her sister, Josephine, wanted to give her the news with “great care” (57). Josephine broke the news to Mrs. Mallard in “broken sentences”

Read More

More about Coming Of Age In Katherine Mansfield's The Garden Party

Related Topics

Open Document