ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast Generals Die In Bed And Flyboys

644 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: World War 1 narrative Essay

WWI was a terrifying and brutal war in which many innocent men gave their lives. The book “Generals Die in Bed” and the movie “Flyboys” are both about WWI, and they both show how WWI devastated many young men. The book “Generals Die in Bed” represents WWI better than the movie “Flyboys” because the movie is unrealistic and mostly fictional, the book was written by a man who was in the war himself, and the movie demonstrated the fights in the air, while most of the fighting actually happened on the ground, and in the trenches.
“Flyboys” is unrealistic, and mostly fictional and does not do a good job of showing the suffering of the men. In the movie, there is a scene in which the main character lands his plane in the middle of no man’s land (the spaces in between trenches) and runs through it to rescue his comrade. This scene is probably added for show, and to dazzle the audience with the courage of the main character. In this scene the main character is forced to cut off his comrade's hand, to release him from being stuck under the wing of the plane. If you look at the man's hand, you can tell if he needed to he could have just slipped off his glove to escape. “Generals Die in Bed” has none of this unrealistic dazzle and unnecessary exaggeration, and just shows the ground view of what …show more content…

The book was written about his experiences in the war. Although we cannot assume that everything in “Generals Die in Bed” is true and happened exactly as it was described, we can believe that since it was written by a man who was in the war himself, it may be a little more accurate than a movie whose only historical advisor was charged with fraud. Even if “Flyboys” was based on true events as it claims to be “based on a true story,” it would still be polluted with exaggerations of graphics, special effects and some events that never happened, just to make the movie look

Show More
Related
832 Words | 4 Pages

The Unbeatable Souls The Lost Battalion is based totally on a real story of an American battalion that was sent out to battle during the World War I. Major Charles Whittlesey, a New York lawyer, who ends up in the trenches of France having under his command mostly young, unexperienced men. When Whittlesey and his battalion of five hundred men are ordered to advance into the Argonne Forest they find themselves surrounded by Germans troops when the other battalions instantly withdrew, leaving Whittlesey’s battalion on his own. Confined behind enemy lines, Whittlesey’s battalion turned into the only force in the German army’s plans to move forward. Trapped and with no other way to rescue, Whittlesey is given an opportunity to surrender, but chose to continue fighting and keep his men together.

Read More
654 Words | 3 Pages

Fallen Angels Have you a reader ever wondered about the realistic depiction of war: how the war is romanticized and how it can be an awful place to be? The author Walter Dean Myers shows us the depiction of the war in Vietnam the main character in the book Richard Perry a young boy from Harlem being thrown into the war because of his life at home and doesn't want to really deal with people. The book Fallen Angels is a realistic depiction of war. The book shows us some untimely deaths, graphic violence and the main protagonist inner thoughts and doubts. Through the novel Fallen Angels the depiction of war is shoved into the main characters face with graphic violence untimely deaths that occur and the

Read More
322 Words | 2 Pages

When comparing and contrasting the two short stories “Battle Royal,” written by Ralph Ellison, and “Everyday Use,” written by Alice Walker, it is important to understand the time period in which the short stories took place. Battle Royal takes place during the 1940s. During this time period African Americans were trying to find their place in society after slavery. In the white’s eyes African Americans were free, but in reality blacks were still segregated and had no wealth, educational, economic, or social privileges. African Americans had to conform to white society to fit in, do as the white man says and be what the white man allows you to be, and you will do just fine in life.

Read More
1810 Words | 8 Pages

The brutality was too much and too potent. The rape of women, torture and complete removement of all possessions of any human is something mankind must avoid for its own benefit. Hopefully William Golding’s novel and the brutal events of WWII will continue to inform and influence people in the name of

Read More
894 Words | 4 Pages

Disillusionment in All Quiet on the Western Front and Grand Illusion When World War I is featured in literature, at many times the theme of disillusionment appears. In All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Maria Remarque shows the illusion of war through the elderly and leaders of the war, whereas the soldiers portray the disillusionment of it. On the other hand, In the Grand Illusion, Jean Renoir assumes that the illusion is already understood; instead he focuses on depicting the disillusionment through the soldiers as well. Overall, the life of a soldier wasn't what it was depicted to be.

Read More
1102 Words | 5 Pages

Gladys is brainwashed by propaganda and so believes that killing an enemy soldier in combat is not really murder and that the narrator is a “silly boy” for thinking so. Since the narrator had been harshly emotionally affected by his murder of the German soldier, it would have irritated him that Gladys so easily dismissed it. Furthermore, Generals Die in Bed manages to convey that the feeble benefits of war do not outweigh the immense suffering of the soldiers. The soldiers try to calculate the amount of money that the war is costing and are only able to conclude that it is a lot of money. The soldiers are upset that people are profiting off of their anguish .

Read More
1109 Words | 5 Pages

If I Die in a Combat Zone, depicts a soldier’s internal battle whether to enter the war or to escape, once the soldier is in the army, the book tells of his experience in Vietnam. Tim O’Brien believes the war in Vietnam is unethical and unjust through his experience upon being drafted, depictions of the battlefields, and how fellow soldiers acted. Tim O’Brien felt as if the war was unethical and unjust upon being drafted into the army. O’Brien attends basic training and finds out at the end, that he and a few others will become foot soldiers (pg. 56). This was what O’Brien had feared.

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

Gods and Generals is a novel written by Jeff Shaara, the prequel to his father’s prize winning novel The Killer Angels. This is a story about the lives, passions, and careers of the military leaders from the first gathering of the Civil War, starting in 1858 and goes to the eve of the Battle of Gettysburg. This story follows four main characters, Robert E. Lee, Thomas J. Jackson, Winfield Scott Hancock, and also Joshua Lawrence Chamberlin. Robert E. Lee is a cavalry officer in Texas, on his 30-year in the U.S. Army.

Read More
2042 Words | 9 Pages

Lord of the Flies dates back to 1954 when a famous novelist, William Golding decided to write a book which could show an unusual version of the human beings. Born into an environment where his mother was a suffragette and later experiencing World War II where human ruthlessness was at its peak, made him better inclined in to writing a piece where he could explain his readers how human beings react in different situations. The setting of the novel depicts a situation where the human behavior is rational. The novel hence persuades the readers to realize the importance of ethics and civilization and how their absence can disrupt the society .Furthermore, the novel shows a negative aspect of the mankind and explains the reason it develops savagery

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the ages, wars have wreaked havoc and caused great destruction that lead to the loss of millions of lives. However, wars also have an immensely destructive effect on the individual soldier. In the novel All Quiet on the Western Front written by Erich Maria Remarque, one is able to see exactly to what extent soldiers suffered during World War 1 as well as the effect that war had on them. In this essay I will explain the effect that war has on young soldiers by referring to the loss of innocence of young soldiers, the disillusionment of the soldiers and the debasement of soldiers to animalistic men. Many soldiers entered World War 1 as innocent young boys, but as they experienced the full effect of the war they consequently lost their innocence.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

“Imagine yourself in the pitch dark, after two or three days of wet, cold, hunger, sleeplessness, staggering down a trench, knee-deep in mud, carrying various burdens that almost equal your own body-weight” (Ellis, 48). This was the everyday life of the typical soldier involved in the World War I trench warfare. During WWI trench warfare was common. It began in September 1914 with the German army digging themselves in for a battle that would last what seemed like a life time for the soldiers involved. Soldiers on either side alike lived in deplorable conditions.

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

Unbroken Laura Hillenbrand, the author of Unbroken, wrote the book about Louis Zamperini’s fight to survive though tortured, beaten, and a barrage of gunfire. After surviving a plane crash in the middle of the ocean, where he spent forty-seven days slowly dying of intense hunger and thirst, the book shows Louis Zamperini’s quick wit and will to survive despite being tormented as a Japanese POW (prisoner of war). The author uses rhetorical devices such as syntax, diction, imagery, and tone to amplify certain moments, Hillenbrand uses imagery to convey the scene and appeal to the reader’s senses and uses precise diction to elaborate on certain scenarios. She uses tone to convey the characters’ attitudes and to give the feel of certain moment.

Read More
1087 Words | 5 Pages

The movie Flyboys is historically inaccurate with its props, characters, and events that used in the movie to portray the dogfights, lives, and situations of the pilots of the Lafayette Escadrille squadron during WWI. In the movie Flyboys the characters they use are based off of real life people that flew and fought in the war, but the characters do not have any relation to the where they are from in the movie to where they are at in real life. The main character who it is based off of was born in Phoenix, Arizona but in the movie it says he is originally from Aberdeen, Texas. The character that the movie is based off of his name is Frank Luke.

Read More
1377 Words | 6 Pages

Flyboys is a movie which is fairly accurate for the most part but there are still few inaccuracies which are why it is considered only fairly accurate. Flyboys does a good job in an accurate portrayal of the Lafayette Escadrille and the other fighter pilots values, beliefs, training and the toll of tragedies on them mentally, but when it comes down to their military strategy, airplanes and different modes of transportation, it begins to become somewhat inaccurate. From the beginning of the movie you can begin to see the men’s values and the heavy drinking did and also promoted. This is very accurate as alcoholism was a very big problem throughout WW1.

Read More
1857 Words | 8 Pages

Lieutenant Frederic Henry and Catherine Barkley are the protagonists of Ernest Hemingway’s novel A Farewell to Arms. Although there aren’t any other characters in the majority of the novel, there are a few that make an appearance every so often, like Rinaldi, The Priest, Helen Ferguson and Miss Gage. For the sake of this paper I will only be looking at the minor character Helen Ferguson, who is close friends with Catherine. Helen, who is often referred to as Ferguson or Fergy, is the voice of reason in regards to Henry and Catherine’s relationship.

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast Generals Die In Bed And Flyboys

Related Topics

Open Document