ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast My Papa's Waltz And Those Winter Sundays

648 Words3 Pages

Abbas Mohamed-Saeed
Ms. Volkening
ENG4U0
10 March 2023
Poetry Comparative Essay Theodore Roethke's "My Papa's Waltz" and Robert Hayden's "Those Winter Sundays" are two poems that explore the theme of family relationships and the complex emotions that arise within them. Both poets use various literary devices to express their ideas and feelings about their respective fathers and the impact that they have had on their lives. This essay will compare and contrast the two poems, examining the similarities and differences in the use of literary devices.
Firstly, both poems use imagery to create vivid pictures in the reader's mind. Roethke's poem is full of sensory descriptions, such as "The whiskey on your breath / Could make a small boy dizzy," …show more content…

Roethke's poem is structured around the metaphor of the waltz, which is used to represent the relationship between the father and son. The dance is described as "clinging" (Roethke, line 16) and "waltzing,"(Roethke, line 4) suggesting a close physical bond between the two. However, the dance is also described as rough and scraping which can also be seen as a metaphor for the difficult and sometimes painful interactions between fathers and sons. Similarly, Hayden's poem uses the metaphor of fire to represent the father's love and sacrifice for his family. The father's early morning efforts to warm the house are described as cracking and firing, which can be seen as a metaphor for his own inner strength and determination to provide for his family. The use of this metaphor emphasizes the depth of the father's love, despite his struggles and sacrifices. Another literary device that both poems use is tone. Roethke's poem has a playful and nostalgic tone, with the use of words like "romped" (Roethke, line 5) and "clinging" (Roethke, line 16) suggesting a fond memory of his father. However, the tone also has a hint of darkness and danger, with the description of the "battered" (Roethke, line 10) knuckles and the "ear-scrap(ing)" (Roethke, line 12) dance. This shows that the father-son relationship was not always easy or …show more content…

The use of the phrase "Sundays too my father got up early" (Hayden, line 1) creates a sense of routine and repetition, emphasizing the father's commitment to his family. The tone is also tinged with regret, as the speaker reflects on how he never “thanked" (Hayden, line 5) his father for his sacrifices. This suggests a sense of missed opportunities and a deeper complexity to the father-son relationship. Lastly, both poems use sound devices to enhance the emotional impact of the language. Roethke's poem uses alliteration, with the repeated "w" sounds in "waltzed me off to bed" (Roethke, line 15) creating a sense of movement and rhythm. The use of internal rhyme in "We romped until the pans / Slid from the kitchen shelf" (Roethke, line 5-6) also adds to the playful tone of the poem. Similarly, Hayden's poem uses repetition, with the repeated phrase "What did I know" (Hayden, line 13) emphasizing the speaker's regret and sense of

Show More
Related

Why Does Theodore Roethke Use Ambiguous Language

119 Words | 1 Pages

In “My Papa’s Waltz,” poet Theodore Roethke uses sensory details and ambiguous language to persuade both the boy and the reader that the boy still loves his father, despite him being an alcoholic. On the third sentence of the first stanza, Roethke uses ambiguous language by stating: “But I hung on like death. Such waltzing was not easy.” Although this plainly means that the boy was holding onto his father without ease, it can be interpreted in another way; the boy still loves his father, even though it is hard to love him with his alcoholism at times, and the boy still loves his father very much. The boy is reflecting on this idea while waltzing with his

Read More

My Papa's Waltz Literary Devices

551 Words | 3 Pages

In the beginning of the poem Roethke describes what a child thinks about their father’s life. “The whiskey on your breath / could make a small boy dizzy; / But I hung on like death:/ Such waltzing was not easy”. The first stanza shows the way the child describes this father’s life. The first two lines talk about, “whiskey” and, “make a small boy dizzy” this shows that people like the child 's father cannot take such a difficult life like the child 's father does.

Read More

Essay Comparing My Papa's Waltz And Those Winter Sundays

277 Words | 2 Pages

Time drastically shifts the way one views the world and those he encounters. "My Papa's Waltz," by Theodore Roethke, and "Those Winter Sundays," by Robert Hayden, are poems which reminisce of the past and contrast how they felt about a specific childhood experience, and how that view has changed with time. Additionally, the painting "Father and Son Dancing," by Brian kershisnik, elegantly portrays an adult's perspective on an experience he had with his father. These wor after a long day of work in the familiy greenhouse: "The hand that held my writst/ Was battered on one knuckle," and "You beat time on my head/ With a palm cakedhard by dirt.

Read More

My Papa's Waltz And Those Winter Sundays

683 Words | 3 Pages

Every story consists of different elements, such as characters, plotlines, and settings. Nonetheless, many stories portray the same messages or ideas. “My Papa’s Waltz,” by Theodore Roethke, depicts a reckless father who is loved by his child, while “Those Winter Sundays,” by Robert Hayden, depicts a hardworking father whose child is indifferent to him. Though the poems depict exceptionally different childhoods, both contribute to the idea that perceptions of parents alter as one grows into adulthood. Both poems use harsh words and critical tones in order to convey this notion, however in “My Papa’s Waltz,” they signify the recklessness of the father and how the narrator perceives his father as an adult, while in “Those Winter Sundays,” they

Read More

Analysis Of My Papas Waltz By Theodore Roethke

764 Words | 4 Pages

In the final analysis, most readers of this poem tend to deduce a dark theme of physical violence due to its tone, word choice and imagery. Nonetherless, Roethke balances positive and negative tones of the poem to give it a rich and ambiguous quality. The exceeding tendency to paint the picture of child abuse deprives it, of this quality. “My Papa’s Waltz,” illustrates a special and powerful moment, shared between a father and a son through a waltz.

Read More

Theodore Roethke My Papa's Waltz Interpretation

516 Words | 3 Pages

Also, Roethke used “unfrown” to show that the situation wasn’t super serious and it was just that the mother was just upset. Although, the author used words that may contain two meanings with different connotations, the meaning of the words became clear when it was apply to the text. Therefore, the author’s choice of diction help clarify the overall meaning of the poem and allows the readers the understand the poem more clearly. Roethke elaborates on his purpose through the context of his time and childhood

Read More

My Papa's Waltz Literary Devices

190 Words | 1 Pages

I have chosen Theodore Roethke's poetry, "My Papa's Waltz," for this discussion board. - The poem's use of imagery serves as its first literary component, and it uses sensitive language to create a clear visual image for the reader. We can see that the father's hand was described as "battered," while the hanging procedure was described using the word "waltzing." - Rhyming is the second literary technique utilized in the poem. The poem contains a unique form of lyricism.

Read More

My Papa's Waltz By Theodore Roethke

575 Words | 3 Pages

Roethke uses a confused tone to show the reader how the little boy is confusing his father’s dark actions with a misleading waltz. After the beating/abuse the father gave, his son it is now time for bed. The dad takes him to his bedroom, but since the dad is still

Read More

Connotation In My Papa's Waltz

902 Words | 4 Pages

The use of positive connotation in the text is utilised to illuminate the positives of the relationship, as they “romp” and “waltz” their way through a fun life. However, Roethke intentionally included those words with negative connotation to show the constant complexity and imperfect nature of their relationship. In lines 3-4, Roethke states “[b]ut I held on like death:/[s]uch waltzing was not easy,” which is the first metaphor for their relationship. In this quote from the text, as Roethke preaches the difficulty of the waltz, he is really writing about the relationship between his father and son as being “not easy.” And although their relationship is not easy as it goes through life, the boy still “hung on like death,” showing his love for his father and another positive for the relationship.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Sylvia Plath And My Papa's Waltz

846 Words | 4 Pages

In Roethke’s “My Papa’s Waltz”, the speaker seems to be an adult reminiscing his childhood through a metaphor of a dance. The poem suggests that the boy was abused and the mother stood by without doing much about it. Three topics that

Read More

My Papa's Waltz And Those Winter Sundays Analysis

871 Words | 4 Pages

Both sons understand their fathers efforts but they are shown in

Read More

Imagery In My Papa's Waltz

898 Words | 4 Pages

It reads as follows, “the hand that held my wrist was battered on one knuckle;” (9-10) again, we see the choice of words. Roethke did not use the words “calloused hands, rough hands,” He chose “battered.” As in, this was not the first time the father had struck his son. Upon the ending of stanza four, we come across these lines, “at every step you missed, my right ear scraped a buckle.” (11-12)

Read More

Figurative Language In My Papa's Waltz

588 Words | 3 Pages

In the poem, My Papa’s Waltz, the speaker, Theodore Roethke, writes about a father and son waltzing. Further investigation suggests there is more going on than a waltz. The poet utilizes figure of speech and a negative toned vocabulary throughout the poem. Thus, alleviating the reader of the harsh truth of an abusive relationship whilst never dehumanizing the father.

Read More

My Papa's Waltz Literary Analysis

533 Words | 3 Pages

Roethke places a historical experience to address a social and cultural issue found in drunkenness, which abstracts the harmful nature he once experienced through a vivid psychological approach. For example, lines 5-8 “We romped until the pans. Slid from the kitchen shelf; my mother’s countenance, Could not unfrown itself,” one recognizes the boy enduring a dance by his father that seems to have already been endured by his mother for a long time [5]. The mother’s tone is perceived with anger and depression, but despite her husband’s drunkenness she ignores all that occurs as she continues her regular household work. The rhythm of the poem is cheerfully written only to mask and disguise the resentment truly felt by the author of the poem.

Read More

My Papa's Waltz Imagery

676 Words | 3 Pages

Roethke uses both olfactory and visual imagery to give the reader a sense that boy’s father might be intoxicated and clumsy by stating “The whiskey on your breath/could make a small boy dizzy” (1-2). The poem’s visual imagery also indicates that the boy may be in fear of getting hurt by his father’s clumsiness “but I hung on like death” (3). The poet of “My Papa's Waltz” uses several examples of imagery to describe a father and son's close bond by dancing throughout their house playfully, but because the father was drunk, the child was also scared that his father might unintentionally hurt him by his

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast My Papa's Waltz And Those Winter Sundays

Related Topics

Open Document