ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast The Armenian Genocide And The Holocaust

1238 Words5 Pages

"Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?" - Adolf Hitler Obersalzberg Speech, August 22, 1939
The Armenian Genocide and Holocaust were similar in that their main goal was to eliminate an entire religion, however there are far more differences in the cause, course, and effects. The Armenian Genocide was carried out by the Young Turks, a Turkish Nationalist reform party in the 20th century, who favored reformation of the absolute monarchy of the Ottoman Empire.[1] To do so, they believed that one particular group/religion was weighing them down: non-Muslim Armenians. With these (mostly Christian) Armenian civilians gone, the Ottoman Empire would gain the power it once had and have a say in the war. In many opinions, …show more content…

In 1915, the Armenian Genocide really started off when the Young Turks took action against young Armenian men in the Ottoman Army. The men were disarmed, and eventually taken out of the army and brought to hard labor camps, where they were either immediately killed or worked until they died. This concept was also later seen in the Holocaust, where the Jews were separated into two groups: those who could work, and those who could not. Those who could not work would be sent into the “showers” and be …show more content…

These convicted killers were given the task to kill Armenian civilians. This also included the raiding of Armenian towns and villages, similar to Kristallnacht, or “Night of Broken Glass” in Germany, where the civilians of the targeted race were attacked. Following this paramilitary attack was a test run of deportations, where the Young Turks tried to deport the Armenians out the Ottoman Empire, and into Syria, south of the Empire. The Armenians managed to resist the deportations, as it was just a test run. However, the slaughter of civilians was still carried out by the paramilitary, and could not be stopped. This differs from the deportation of Jews in the Holocaust because Germans did not immediately kill them. They just isolated them in places such as ghettos, and later concentration camps like

Show More
Related
513 Words | 3 Pages

Mary Roach begins her analysis of human cadavers by attending a facial anatomy and facelift course, wherever surgeons observe new techniques on the freshly cut heads of human cadavers. Roach learns that surgeons cope by objectifying human remains, wilfully seeing them as objects. The author sees the plain good thing about learning surgical techniques mistreatment cadavers. Since they feel no pain and can't die thanks to complications, cadavers provide immediate edges for surgical study. She sees this as an excellent improvement over, however surgery was Once schooled on live patients while not the good thing about anaesthesia.

Read More
340 Words | 2 Pages

The genocide of the Jews was a culminaion of a decade of German police. The Jews were dehumanized in many different ways. One way they were dehumanized was by the Hungarian police and they were yelling “Faster, Faster! Move, you lazy good- for nothing!”

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

For example, during World War I, the Turkish nationalist government oversaw the deportation and killing of an estimated 1.1 to 1.8 million “to put an end to the Armenian question. The means for this are quite simple and consist of the extermination of the Armenian nation” (“Past Genocide”). Armenians in Eastern Turkey. April 24, 1915 was the beginning of the Armenian Genocide. Armenians were deported from cities and towns in Asia Minor and Turkish Armenia.

Read More
1774 Words | 8 Pages

They were murdered in either massacre and individual killings, or from systematic ill-treatment, exposure, and starvation. In the novel Forgotten Fire, the main social issue, the Armenian Genocide, compares to the Holocaust as they both were caused by a hatred of a specific race, they both resulted in extreme violence and immense casualties, and they both had many heroes who made considerable sacrifices on behalf of those being persecuted. The Holocaust and the Armenian Genocide were sparked by the hatred of a specific minority race, the Jews, and the Armenians. The leaders of the countries involved in genocides often promoted them and contribute to the heinous crimes.

Read More
751 Words | 4 Pages

Many people would argue the deportation and mass killing of the Jews, or non-liable, noncombatants, is an objectively impermissible act. However, deportation and mass killing did not begin until late 1940, thus at the time the men of battalion 101 joined the army they had no justifiable reason to believe they would later be expected to senselessly commit mass murder of non-liable,

Read More
904 Words | 4 Pages

Hitler is known to have been the leader behind the Holocaust and he admits that he took inspiration from the Armenian Genocide to conduct his own plan for the Jewish people. In document 8 we can directly see the use of military soldiers to enact the killing of Armenians. This is a prime example of the use of soldiers by the government in a genocide. It also shows us the government using the law to their advantage. If anyone else had done something like this, especially in public, they would be tried for their crimes but because the victims are Armenian, it is seen as

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

The Armenian Genocide caused generations of pain and loss of the rich heritage of the Armenians. Not only did the genocide cause major human losses, but also caused a major psychological and moral blow at the attempt to exterminate the Armenian nation from the root. The Armenian Genocide resulted with around 1.5 million Armenians massacred, with only around half a million surviving the genocide. The loss of family, friends and the Armenian community, the genocide had a staggering blow on the Armenian race. The survivors escaped with merely their lives and the horrid memories of the cruel and inhumane nature of the Young Turks.

Read More
1367 Words | 6 Pages

Night is just one of many memories written by Elie Wiesel. Who survived the Holocaust. In Night he narrates the experience of the deaths of his family members, the death of his adolescence and the death in his naive belief in man’s innate goodness. The power of the genre of the memoir is that it captures experience and insists that forgetting about such crimes against humanity is not an option, neither for Wiesel no for the reader. A key point is Dehumanization, dehumanization is to deprive human qualities.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

A genocide is the the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic group or nation, the Holocaust and the Cambodian Genocide are examples of this. After the Holocaust, in 1945 the United Nations realized that genocides were a continuously happening. They realized they needed to prevent genocides and global conflict in general. The Holocaust began on January 30, 1933 when Adolf Hitler became chancellor of Germany and ended May 8, 1945 when the war officially ended.

Read More
703 Words | 3 Pages

Genocides, the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular group or nation, has affected various countries. Genocide not only brings a war but also problems like decreasing economic affairs and social problems. When genocide starts, society overlooks economic affairs like their agriculture since they focus on the war. In the case of Rwanda, once the genocide had begun many farmers fled or were killed. "All was

Read More
1494 Words | 6 Pages

They were persecuted for their beliefs, and at the beginning of the Armenian Genocide, younger males were placed in labor camps after they were checked for weapons. Here they were either worked to death or killed (Ward 46). The Ottoman Empire did not care what happened to the Armenians because they thought they were inferior to them. Similarly, during the Holocaust, the Germans treated the Jews like animals, and they forced the Jews to do whatever they wanted, or else they got killed. Elie Wiesel demonstrated this when he had described what it was like to be controlled by people whose mindset was to kill you.

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

After the liberation of the concentration camps there were many Anti-Jewish riots, especially in Poland. One riot that occurred in Poland resulted with the deaths of 42 people and many more wounded. Many others, now homeless, emigrated to the west and were housed in refugee centers. In the aftermath of the war the former prisoners were not the only mass of people to suffer. “Meanwhile, the Allies forced the local German Population to confront the crimes committed on their doorstep.”

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

However, the Armenians were not treated as harshly and not all Armenians were relocated. Only largely populated cities of Armenians were subject to relocation in order to stop them from rebelling. Additionally, contrast can be seen in the documentation of both genocides. For instance, during the Holocaust Allied soldiers had video of the death camps and mass graves. Many photos were taken and even civilians were shown the horrors of the concentration camps after they were liberated.

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

The Rwandan genocide vs. the Holocaust “Genocide is an attempt to exterminate a people, not to alter their behavior.” Jack Schwartz. Genocide is mass murder, it happens in all parts of the world. A common known genocide is the Holocaust. Where a group known as the“Nazis” (lead by Hitler) murdered more than six million people (many were Jewish).

Read More
1178 Words | 5 Pages

The Armenian Genocide occurred during the First World War when the Ottoman Empire was experiences the pressures of war from the Triple Entente. In 1915, the ANZAC forces had landed in Gallipoli and the Russian forces were advancing down from the Caucasian fields. During this time, the Ottoman Empire displaced and forced millions of Christian minorities to march through the desert. Historically, it had been Muslims who victims of violence in the area. However, Christian minorities were in a vulnerable position due to the decline of the Ottoman Empire and impending revolutionary violence (Jones 155).

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast The Armenian Genocide And The Holocaust

Related Topics

Open Document