ipl-logo

Compare And Contrast What Happened To Lani Garver And 13 Reasons Why

2056 Words9 Pages

Henry Hewitt
Ms. Salgado
Language Arts 8 Period 8
6 March 2023
Book Bundle Comparative Analysis Essay
“How can some people’s lives look so good when they’re so foul underneath?” (Plum-Ucci 1) In the small town high schools of What Happened to Lani Garver and Thirteen Reasons Why, there is a dog-eat-dog system of popularity. People only rise to the top in this system by pushing others down through bullying and harassment. The bullies are unredeemable, static characters, but the bystanders and ordinary kids are the foundation of the system. In the novel, Thirteen Reasons Why, by Jay Asher, and the novel What Happened to Lani Garver by Carol Plum-Ucci, the authors raise the idea of how the prejudice and gender stereotyping associated with bullying and harassment are caused by toxic social systems. However, the way they present this idea differs.
In both novels, the authors utilize social settings to demonstrate the toxic social systems. In What Happened to Lani Garver, the setting is that of a small town high school on a distant island. Since everyone knows everyone, conformity is one of the most valued traits in this setting. This is displayed by the description of the social climate, stating, “There was a kind of hope whizzing around the corridors. Joe Hunk could ask you out …show more content…

At the beginning of this novel, this man, whose name is Charlie, undergoes a medical experiment to increase his IQ. Throughout the following chapters, this experiment appears to work as Charlie develops stronger social and intellectual skills. Charlie states that he still struggles with connecting with others. However, Charlie makes a discovery towards the end of the book that his intelligence is beginning to degrade. Hurt by this knowledge, he says his farewells to his friends and family and regresses to his previous

Show More
Related
1100 Words | 5 Pages

The most hated plot in America is the underdog’s demise- the empathetic pain of scrutiny, and the failure we all miss to escape. The scrawny, glasses-wearing outsider is often the underdog, the hero we all cheer for. The one who makes all the refinements in a society that is stagnant to change. And his most successful storytelling, or retelling, is that in the setting of high school. He walks awkwardly down the hall with his shoulders slightly hunched inward and mouth slightly ajar.

Read More
1633 Words | 7 Pages

Miller’s revelation of a book shows young people’s obstacles, self-centrism, sexual harassment, school systems, distant emotions, lack of trust, and reforms. As Jody Miller countlessly proves to us, in chapter 2, that no one feels safe in these neighborhoods we are faced with the inevitable fact that these young people have the odds towering against them. In these neighborhoods, guys have the audacity to hit and abuse girls; being a girl in these areas is extremely dangerous and in some aspects, a curse. Girls are never safe; they can get shot or raped. Guys get much more respect on the street and have overall more

Read More
1652 Words | 7 Pages

“The girl poked me harder. ‘Aren’t you the one who called the cops at Kyle Rodger’s party at the end of the summer?’” (27) Melinda is harassed about the party. The people heckling Melinda think it is alright to pester and bully her about that night, showing questionable judgement about the choices of her peers. It seems in this case that they do not take into consideration Melinda’s feelings and are not questioning if their choices are good or bad.

Read More
1681 Words | 7 Pages

Alexandra Robbins, a choice award winning author, discusses high school life and the ‘cafeteria fringe’, or the outcasts in school who often sit on the outskirts of the cafeteria during lunch, separated from the populars, in her non-fiction novel, The Geeks Shall Inherit the Earth. In her book, she elaborates on why outcasts are often excluded and she comes to the conclusion that, “Like most outcasts in school—including many of the thousand-plus people I contacted for this book—these “characters” were

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

Looking through the eyes of her classmates, Melinda is a social reject, a freak, a target. “The girl behind me jams her knees onto my back…the girl with the arrested brother…yanks my hair…”(29). In a feeble attempt to get revenge, two students used childish antics to get their message of anger across to Melinda. They expressed their resentment for Melinda for ruining a party, but their actions had been influenced by a tiny puzzle piece of information that they had believed to be the bigger picture. They neither witnessed nor asked what happened to Melinda as to why she called the police during the party.

Read More
658 Words | 3 Pages

His intelligence came with a price that made him rethink his entire situation. Charlie was happier with an IQ of 68 because he was oblivious to what was going on around him, people would treat him differently after the surgery, and he struggled with his identity. Charlie was happier when he was oblivious to what was going on around him. Being oblivious and ignorant is not a good thing, but in Charlie's case, not knowing

Read More
1199 Words | 5 Pages

In Michael Lehmann’s facetious Heathers, various characters display their perspectives on the complications and difficulties of navigating the dynamics of adolescence. The teenage years are known throughout American culture to be some of the most trying times in one’s life. The pressures of fitting in, being popular, and feeling loved can become so important to teens, often close to obsessions. JD is someone who sees the falsehood behind these needs and looks down on those who epitomize them. While shown in an exaggerated form, JD’s animosity towards those in the popular clique reveals itself to the extreme.

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

It is is a mixing pot for all types of individuals. As Rose observes his schoolmates, he gives a brief background of what types of people they are. A trend becomes apparent. Generally, the “coolest” and most popular people are the ones that get in the most trouble. By Rose’s analysis of the individuals on the bus, the kids that have more physical prowess and better looks than most are highly valued in the school community.

Read More
607 Words | 3 Pages

Charlie was a man young aged at thirty-seven with an IQ score of sixty-eight. All he wanted was to be intelligent. Charlie finally got this opportunity when two doctors decided he was a perfect candidate for a surgery that would greatly improve his intelligence. However, Charlie Gordon's doctors did not act ethically when they performed the surgery

Read More
620 Words | 3 Pages

Firstly, Charlie’s progress in intelligence hurt other's lives. For example, Charlie broke Ms. Kinnian’s heart after he rejected her proposal, and became more distant from her. “Miss Kinnian came to the door but I said ‘go away, I don’t want to see you.’ She cried and I cried too

Read More
1279 Words | 6 Pages

Whitney, a popular girl, says that “the prep description didn’t fit the “real” Whitney” (Robbins 31). She feels that the things people think about her aren’t true just because of her clique in school. She goes on even further, saying that if she could’ve chosen a to be part of the punks she would have. This proves the idea further that popularity doesn’t equal social success, and even people who are popular are still unhappy with their social standing in school. Due to the widespread belief that achieving popularity is the same as achieving social success, many students sacrifice their own individuality in hopes of achieving what they believe is social success.

Read More
1053 Words | 5 Pages

Hanaa Hameed 2009 Adversity Both biologically and psychologically speaking, some people are more equipped to deal with trauma and adversity than others. Although class and prosperity can aid someone’s character, there is nothing more formative to a person than the adversities they face in life. While it’s true that some folks develop traits or ‘talents’ that aren’t necessarily used well, all people- to some degree- will change in the face of adversity. In the case of What Happened to Lani Garver?, Lani remains pure, happy, and lighthearted despite the constant stream of bullying from their classmates.

Read More
809 Words | 4 Pages

Like everybody around here’s been saying, Charlie, it’s not right.” Charlie’s response to that was, “But how can you say that, Fanny? What’s wrong with a man becoming intelligent and wanting to acquire knowledge and understanding of the world around him?”Charlie was disappointed in Fanny when she said that it wasn’t very possible for Charlie to become smart that quickly. This is another very important event that happens in this story because Charlie tries to change himself to fit in and then realizes that’s not what matters. What matters is that he’s happy and it doesn’t matter what other people

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

The novel portrays the alienation and loneliness individuals go through and how they react to being isolated when trying to be accepted by society. Charlie desired to be intelligent so he could have a lot of friends and so people would like him yet when he had surgery to triple his i.Q he finds that he is singled out and isolated from others around him. Charlie’s limited emotional maturity also creates a barrier between him and others around him which disables him to understand and connect with others. People around Charlie are having trouble relating to him as they are alarmed at his new found intellect. The techniques which represents this theme are rhetorical question and rhyme .The

Read More
435 Words | 2 Pages

Charlie gains intelligence like he always wanted, but only to have it be taken away in a time frame of a couple months. Charlie states that, “The hypothesis here proven may be described simply in the following terms: artificially increased intelligence deteriorates at a rate almost proportional to the quantity of the increase.” With realizing the cost of the surgery, he states, “Now that it’s definite, I don’t want it to happen.” Charlie experienced emotions such as anger, sadness, and even love with his intelligence. Now all this will be taken away; like taking away a favorite toy from a child.

Read More

More about Compare And Contrast What Happened To Lani Garver And 13 Reasons Why

Related Topics

Open Document