ipl-logo

Compare Christian Responses To Black Death

458 Words2 Pages

The responses to the Black Death by Christians and Muslims were majorly different. These two religions handled the plague oddly in some cases, but each hoped to find a cure I their faith. Christians turned to blame when looking for an explanation for the Black Death. Although, in the Muslim community, some decided to come together to find a remedy. One may think one of the religions responded correctly to the Great Pestilence, but living in a time when your society is apart it could be hard to be rational. Christian responses are seen to be greatly different from Muslim reactions. Christians perceived the plague as a curse from God. Believed to have committed too many sins, the Christians prayed and pleaded to be forgiven. Once the plague had overtaken the Christians lives, they decided to flee and morals began to break down because they realized the church was not helping them get better. The most major part in some opinions was the burning of the Jews. Christians accused the Jews of poisoning their wells- which spread the plague, some think this was revenge leading back to the crucifixion. One may think the Muslims acted in a more conventional manor compared to the Christians. Islam took the Black Death as a blessing from God as opposed to a curse. The Muslims also brought the Christians and the Jews together that lived within their …show more content…

In some areas Christians, Jews, and Muslims came together and hoped for a cure. The ones in their community without the disease fasted and also prayed together. Each of these religions were different in rationalization but overall, they each went through hardships of the Black Death. Even though the Muslims kept a cool exterior, I am sure some of them- just like Christians- thought it was caused by someone for revenge or rather a punishment from

Show More
Related
294 Words | 2 Pages

The Black Plague was a horrible epidemic that killed between 25 and 45% of the populations it encountered. The plague spread from China to Europe and the Middle East quickly. While the Black Plague hit the Middle East and Europe, Christianity and Islam were the dominant religions. Though they both lived through the horrifying experience of the Black Plague, they had different responses, and Muslims had the most reasonable one.

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

This Primary Source is an excerpt from "The Cremation of Strasbourg Jewry, St. Valentine's Day, February 14, 1349—About the Great Plague and the Burning of the Jews" This document talks about how the Jews were blamed for the spread of the plague by putting poisons into water and wells. Because of this it was decided that all Jews would be burned to death and none would be allowed to enter specific cities for 200 years. Our primary source gives us an idea of what people thought started the plague. Many people blamed the Jews saying that they had killed christ and that they poisoned the water and the wells with the plague. The Black Plague allowed a new wave of Anti-Semitism to spread through Europe.

Read More
843 Words | 4 Pages

Most of the known world was devoured by the most notorious epidemic in history. In the 1351 , the infamous Black Death began to chew up and spit out Europe along with Asia and Africa as if being a victim of the Black Death once wasn’t horrific enough, The Great Pestilence hit Europe for the second time in the 18th century, along side that, in the 20th century Asia and Africa were revisited by The Great Plague. According to the background essay, “In five short years, the plague killed between 25 and 45% of the population it encountered.” During the time of the gruesome Black Death, two religions were widely practiced in this region of the world, Christianity and Islam. These were two religions with some different views and reasoning for this merciless period of terror and death.

Read More
1303 Words | 6 Pages

During the thirteenth century, a disease known as the Black Death spread from Asia to Europe at an alarming speed. It travelled through the trade routes, in the form of infected fleas carried from town to town on rats causing catastrophic loses of population . The Black Death consisted of two forms of the disease; the pneumonic plague, and the bubonic plague . Since it was unknown as to what caused the disease at the time, their responses to the plague’s outbreak were almost entirely futile. Since religion was a big factor in nearly everybody’s lives, the records of the Black Death that we do have are heavily influenced by religion, and as such, their views strongly swayed things like treatments and medicine that were used against the plague.

Read More
441 Words | 2 Pages

But there was other theory about the source of the disaster claimed that the Black Death is not the punishment from god, but the plot of Jewish. During middle ages, there were more than 1.5 million of Jews lived in Europe. Most of them were follow financial careers. So that, they had large amount of property, which were more than all other social classes, include clergies and nobles. That made people suspected that they used illegal measures or witchcraft to earn their money.

Read More
348 Words | 2 Pages

The Black Death had a big impact on European religion. Because people could not understand the plague, they strongly believed that the plague was a punishment sent by God. The church claimed that God was punishing people because of the sins they have committed. They organized religious marches and told people to pray to get rid of the horrible disease. However, around 1348, Christians started accusing the Jews of bringing and spreading the plague to Europe.

Read More
684 Words | 3 Pages

Both the Christians and muslims had similar beliefs. The death rate of both places was very similar the European death rate was from 31-33% , while the Eastern death rate was about 25-33%.Both Europeans and middle-easterns thought that the plague was caused by miasma ,shooting starts and sins like outrageous clothing, alcohol and prostitution. Both religions thought that by building fires and drinking American clay solutions they could prevent the plague. While the both have similar beliefs the two faiths did not act siimilarly. Based on document three the europeans ' 'abamdoned family members ' ' however the muslims became scared when they saw the effects of the plague , but at least they acted with mosre acceptance which drew them closer to their faith.

Read More
1471 Words | 6 Pages

However, during the Middle Ages, bacteria was an unknown concept and the Jews were the easiest explanation. The Black Death was a plague caused by disease spreading

Read More
1314 Words | 6 Pages

The calamities of the 14th century challenged European society and forced it to develop coping mechanisms to deal with such disastrous situations. In the case of the black death, an epidemic which resulted in the death of a third of the European population, European Christians coped by blaming an isolated group: the Jews, who were persecuted harshly. One of the main allegations for anti-semitic persecution involved rumors of Jews poisoning Christian wells. However, this argument proves inadequate and unconvincing. In addition, it further highlights the social strain between European Christians and Jews.

Read More
469 Words | 2 Pages

The Black Death The two faiths, Christianity and Islamic, approach the black death in similar ways religiously, medically, and in dealing with the Jews. Religiously the faiths saw the plague as a curse. The Muslims thought of the black plague as a blessing from god. (Document 4, 6, 8) the Muslims and the Christians have their own opinions of what they think the Black Death is.

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

They believed the resurrection would come, and that means the deserving dead would resurrect, on this day everyone prayed. Some of the Muslim society at this time would have considered the Black Death an apocalypse. (DBQ: The Black Death, 2010) The Black Death was a tragic, scary time for everyone who lived in it, But the responses from the Muslims and the Christians were much different. The plague ended in 1351, as a result of the plague the people fasted for 3 days, afterward assembling in the Great mosque, and spent the night there in prayers.

Read More
815 Words | 4 Pages

Christians devoted themselves to the church, giving up every aspect of their life for God. People converted to Christianity because of the dark times; a religion made them feel safe in hopes of getting to a better place to escape their hard lives (Doc 10). During the medieval period, an epidemic called the Bubonic Plague killed one-third of Europe's population. The people were so unsanitary that is spread easily, but they blamed it on the Jews alleged revenge plans against them (Doc 6). Conditions in Europe during the 800’s were full of fear and unceasing terror.

Read More
777 Words | 4 Pages

Muslims did not believe in the idea of ordinal sin. They did not believe humanity had committed a great act of sin, and therefore they did not believe that God created the Black Death as a means of punishment. Muslims viewed the Black Death as more of a natural disaster in which God did not try to prevent. Additionally, Muslims believed that the Black Death served as a martyrdom for those individuals who were truly committed to their faith. Ibn al-Wardi, of Aleppo, Syria states in an essay on the Report of the Pestilence “When a Muslim endures misfortune, then patience is in his worship.”

Read More
2635 Words | 11 Pages

power(Green). People started to rely on the church a lot less and instead decided to make groups based on different beliefs and ultimately changed the culture of the people during the black death. During the plague, because of the deaths that happened people also created many groups and movements that changed the culture of the people. These people started to rise up in the year 1348. These people tried to appeal to god by committing different acts for the forgiveness of god.

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

“You have to make choices even when there is nothing to choose from” – Péter Zilahy. Every day brings new choices and we either learn to make them, or let someone else make them for us. Maturity plays a part in the decisions we make and whether we take the role of the maker or the follower. Being afraid, but acting anyways is a true sign of courage and maturity, a topic which both Scout and I faced in our younger years. Scout goes through a journey to bravery from carelessness, while I go through the same journey through the context of kindergarten.

Read More

More about Compare Christian Responses To Black Death

Related Topics

Open Document