ipl-logo

Comparing Brutus Diving Into Antony's And

1066 Words5 Pages

Brooklyn Hunt Mr. Ioannidis, 5th Hr. English 10B 21 May 2024 Antony vs. Brutus Diving into Antony’s and Brutus speeches. Brutus’ speech had been given after he and the conspirators had killed Caesar. Brutus talked rudely about Caesar, while Antony praised Caesar. Brutus stated that Caesar was ambitious and was a tyranny. Antony stated that Caesar was a great person, and had good intentions and leadership. But in the end it was who manipulated the Roman people better and got them on their side. “Caesar was ambitious” said Brutus, which was said in many different ways. Brutus wanted to manipulate the crowd, but so did Antony. “As Caesar loved me, I weep for him; as he was fortunate, I rejoice at it; as he was valiant, I honor him; but as he was ambitious, I slew him” …show more content…

“Even putting irrelevant details into an argument to distract from the real issue (red herring)” (Huff and Geis). Antony could counter what Brutus could say with ethos, the people of Rome trust Antony more so they would believe what Antony would say over anyone else because he has more credibility than anyone. “Ethos, in summary, are the guiding beliefs and principles we subscribe to as people, a community, an organisation or what have you” (“THE ART OF RHETORIC - HOW TO SPEAK MORE PERSUASIVELY”) Caesar was ambitious, but he was also loving and caring. Antony and Brutus had won the crowd over, but Antony spoke more truth than Brutus did and had a lot more emotion and connected with the crowd better. Brutus spoke a lot of facts and used a lot of logos, and ethos. He used some pathos, but not enough to convince the crowd to trust him over anyone else. Antony had persuaded the crowd in a whole different way than Brutus did and that’s what made the crowd side with Antony. But the crowd didn’t have their own opinion and was easily swayed/manipulated by the both of

Show More
Related

Rhetorical Devices Used In Brutus And Antony's Speech

721 Words | 3 Pages

The appeals in Antony’s speech were persuasively better than the use of them in Brutus’s speech. Marc Antony uses all three appeals in his speech to make a very sturdy argument. An example of logos in his speech is when he states, “He hath brought many captives home to Rome Whose ransoms did the general coffers fill: Did this in Caesar seem ambitious?” This speech is Antony stating facts of Caesar’s work which proves that he is not ambitious and does not deserve to be killed. Antony also uses ethos and pathos when he says, “He was my friend, faithful and just to me.”

Read More

Julius Caesar Syntax Analysis

942 Words | 4 Pages

Brutus’ main argument was that Caesar was ambitious, and Antony purposely disproved his main argument so that the crowd would have no choice but to support

Read More

Persuading A Crowd Like Brutus And Antony Do?

454 Words | 2 Pages

This is proven because in brutus speech he is able to turn all of Rome against Caeser. In section three of Brutus’s speech he says “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more. Had you rather Caesar were living and die all slaves, than that Caesar were dead, to liveall free men”. Although Brutus was able to change the way the Romans viewed Caeser, Antony was able to rechange the way the Romans viewed Caeser and the way they viewed Brutus making them turn on Brutus and go against him. That is another reason why Antony’s speech is better at persuading the audience then Brutus’s

Read More

Antony's Ethos In Julius Caesar

683 Words | 3 Pages

Antony’s speech is more effective than Brutus’ because of the use of a couple literary devices. Antony's was more effective because he used pathos in his speech. He also used verbal irony and rhetorical questions so that way he was not going directly against Brutus and the conspirators. In Brutus’ speech he used Gravitas and logos which is why Antony appealed to people over him.

Read More

Use Of Ethos In Julius Caesar

705 Words | 3 Pages

Why Antony’s Eulogy Was Superior to Brutus’ Speech In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Antony’s speech is more effective than Brutus’s because Antony utilizes emotions in order to stir up the people and start a riot and speaks in a way that the people can understand, whereas Brutus talks above the people, using prose like the nobility used, and uses ethic and logic to reason with the people why killing Caesar was justified. Brutus’ use of ethos and logos makes the most sense to knowledgeable thinkers and well educated individuals, however to the uneducated people of Rome, using pathos as Antony did would prove more successful. Brutus failed to recognize the most important aspect of speech and presentation, the audience.

Read More

Antony's Ethos In Julius Caesar

627 Words | 3 Pages

Brutus, throughout his speech, focuses too much on justifying his actions, while Antony focuses on angering the audience and turning them against the conspirators. Antony also is able to connect on a personal level with the audience by saying, “My heart is in the coffin there with Caesar” (3.2.106), rather than on a patriotic level like Brutus does. They both use repetition in different ways to prove something to the audience, Brutus repeats that he loves Caesar, and that he was a good man, trying to show that audience that he didn’t kill Caesar because he hated him. Antony however uses repetition to antagonize Brutus without saying it out right, by repeating that Brutus is an honorable man and changing the way he says it each time, it causes the audience to rethink their opinion on

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Antony's Speech

591 Words | 3 Pages

In Brutus’ speech, he uses logic rather than emotions like Antony does. Brutus feels like people’s opinions can be changed if there is reason behind it, and is very rational, but Antony is an extrovert and uses sense rather than changing people’s opinions, he appeals to their senses. Antony’s speech starts out showing this, when he says “You all did love him once, not without cause; What cause withholds you then mourn for him? O judgement, thou art fled to brutish beasts, and men have lost their reason. Bear with me; My heart is in the coffin there with Caesar, and I must pause till it come back to me” Antony’s speech wasn’t very organized like Brutus’ was.

Read More

Antony And Butus In Julius Caesar's Speech

998 Words | 4 Pages

Although Antony and Brutus made a lot of strong and similar convincing points in their rhetoric speeches to get people on their side Antony’s rhetoric speech was more powerful and more convincing because of his strategic use of logos, pathos and ethos, to win the crowd over Brutus. In the play “Julius Caesar” by William Shakespeare, he shows us just how powerful words are. William Shakespeare shows the speeches of Antony and Brutus and how they convince the crowd by using nothing more than pathos, logos and ethos. As mentioned, Antony and Brutus had a lot of similarities in their speech. They both used Pathos to get the crowd on their side.

Read More

Antony Vs. Brutus

550 Words | 3 Pages

Antony vs. Brutus In the play Julius Caesar Marc Antony and Brutus both give a speech to the Roman people after the death of Julius Caesar. Brutus gave his speech first and he did a good job at showing the people his reasons for killing Caesar. But Marc Antony used Brutus’s words against him. He manipulated the crowd to think that Brutus was actually a bad person and that Caesar was an amazing leader.

Read More

Mark Antony And Marcus Brutus Speeches At Caesar's Funeral

152 Words | 1 Pages

Brutus was not a mind-capturing speaker, he spoke very simple-tongued. Antony's speech was very different, he appeals to the crowds emotions. Antony said that Caesar had the best intentions and

Read More

Antony And Brutus Arguments In Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

645 Words | 3 Pages

Now that we covered Antony’s method now we need to look at why Brutus’s argument isn’t as convincing. One thing that I have learned about Brutus just in general is that he is a very blunt person. So one thing that Brutus does that Antony does not is making an excuse for himself while making himself seem honourable. He tells people that he loved caesar but that he loved Rome more(2.2.20-21). It shows that maybe Brutus is having slightly harder time accepting it.

Read More

Brutus Vs Antony Analysis

711 Words | 3 Pages

The Speeches of Noble Men: Brutus vs Antony In the play Julius Caesar by Shakespeare, two characters, Brutis and Antony, both present speeches to the Plebeians regarding Caesars death. One, of course, is more convincing than the other, and the more convincing one was Antony’s. Although the speeches differ in the usage of logos and pathos, they are similar because they both use rhetorical questions to prove their points, and they both manage to sway the crowd to their side.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Brutus And Antony's Speech

884 Words | 4 Pages

Brutus delivers his speech in a laudatory manner by conveying Caesar’s deeds and claiming he was ambitious, although Antony contradicts Brutus’ claims and says Caesar spurned the crown with the intent to merely rule as a de facto dictator. Brutus’ speech reveals his motives were truly for the benefit of Rome given his nationalistic tone and Antony’s speech was merely used to obscure his true motives, which was to embroil Rome in a series of civil wars to attain power. Brutus and Antony’s speeches consisted predominantly of Pathos and Ethos, but it is Antony who ultimately it is Antony who prevails because of his almost disingenuous attitude and even use of Logos which is seen when claims that reading Caesar’s will would dishonor his compeers and even Caesar

Read More

Brutus Speech In Julius Caesar Essay

701 Words | 3 Pages

In the play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, Brutus has been manipulated into believing that Caesar must be taken down. Brutus and the conspirators come up with a plan and eventually execute Caesar. Antony pretends to not be angry, so that he will be allowed to speak at Caesar’s funeral. In Antony and Brutus’s discreet fight of rhetoric, Antony is declared victorious. While Brutus’s speech was satisfactory, in no way can it be compared to Antony’s.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Brutus And Antony Speech

824 Words | 4 Pages

Julius Caesar Speech Comparison Essay Brutus and Antony have prepared a speech about Julius Caesar is to convince the citizens of Rome to agree and be by their side. Brutus is the person talking about how it was good for their leader to die. While Antony talks about how it wasn’t good for Julius Caesar to die. It was not a very good idea to kill Caesar, Antony convinced many citizens of Rome. This is why Mark Antony gave a better speech than Brutus.

Read More

More about Comparing Brutus Diving Into Antony's And

Open Document