ipl-logo

Comparing Gilgamesh And Achilles 'Free Will In Iliad'

696 Words3 Pages

 The Iliad and the Hebrew bible go into the theme of free will, but in some ways they differ from each other. The Hebrew bible for example focuses on free will, because God has free will. This causes humans to have access to free will, because in the Hebrew bible’s creation story we are mad from the image of God (158-159). It is interesting though because although humans are granted free will in the Hebrew bible, God seems to interact not by force, but by leading humans to where he wants them to go. For instance, after Adam and Eve were punished by god for eating the forbidden fruit he led them out of the Garden of Eden away from the tree of eternal life (161). I personally think he did this for the reason of keeping his status of higher power. …show more content…

A similarity that they share is they both have goddesses as mothers. I find this important because their mothers are the reason they are both part divine. Gilgamesh specifically is “two-thirds divine” (100). One other interesting similarity is that they both have a specific best friend who tries to help guide them. Gilgamesh’s best friend is Enkidu and Achilles’s is Patroclus. They also both lose their friends to selfishness, but grieve with no shame.
The main difference in the two is heroism. Gilgamesh wants heroism and thinks of it very highly, but Achilles questions the idea of heroism. Achilles even mentions that he would rather get half the honor by not fighting then to die for a great honor (270). Gilgamesh on the other hand is obsessed with the fame of heroism. He completed each of his task with the determination to reach heroism, and failing wasn’t an option for him. Similar or different they both are very well developed …show more content…

The Trojan War was all started because of a women. Helen, the wife of Menelaus, gets token from her husband as a prize for Paris, because Paris chose Aphrodite to receive a golden apple (223). This in return starts the Trojan Wars. The power of women plays a big role even in that small excerpt. Helen is being treated as an object, but at the same time valuable enough to start a war. Also, we see Aphrodite, who is a goddess, having enough power to take away Helen from her husband. Here we see that Aphrodite held greater power over a mortal man. That not only shows the power of women, but shows there is a hierarchy of women. Throughout The Iliad women are getting referred to as prizes and objects of war but then at the same time they are running their own show. I think that Homer purposely let the different values of women interact throughout the play to create a deeper characterization for women overall. Hera for example is a goddess feared and respected by Zeus (243), but Briseis is just a prize wife that gets taken from Achilles as a punishment to him (238-239). Briseis would not be taken away from Achilles if she didn’t hold value, but she is still definitely no Hera. This Hierarchy of women shows that they are powerful. I think also that Homer had to integrate some submissiveness to men, because of the time frame he was writing in. Overall the role of women being subject to men has no specific

Show More
Related

Double Standard Of Women In The Odyssey

432 Words | 2 Pages

In The Odyssey, Homer puts strong emphasis on the different roles of women through the characters. Homer uses mature women to show how strong women can still be weak, and he uses sexually active women to show the double standard between men and women. Women are portrayed to be nothing but housewife’s and used for sex, yet there is still emphasis that they need men around in order to be strong and kept together. Women are seen as nothing more than housewives and for sex and are seen as nothing more than an object.

Read More

Homeric Hymns: Ancient Stereotypes Of Women

1499 Words | 6 Pages

The Homeric Hymns portray Aphrodite, Athena, Artemis and Hestia as strong females who uphold their own beliefs; challenging the “typical” gender stereotypes of the time period. Women in antiquity were expected to follow and uphold certain societal rules, most of these rules emphasized the gender stereotypes that women were perceived as being. The use of the goddesses powers challenge these societal rules and ideas about women. Aphrodite, Athena, Artemis, and Hestia are portrayed in the Homeric Hymns in contrast to ancient stereotypical roles of women being confined to the household; as a result this contrast emphasizes that women can showcase strength, intelligence, and power within society. A women’s life in antiquity was constricted by

Read More

Summary Of The Centaur May Swenson

263 Words | 2 Pages

In the poem “The Centaur” May Swenson writes about a woman reminiscing her childhood, back to the summer when she was a ten year old girl riding her wooden horse. The imagery and language in this poem leads me to believe that while riding her horse the child experiences something she hasn't before. In the lines “the willow knob with the strap between my thighs” the imagery and words used here are sexual in connotation. The innocent playful riding of the horse was replaced by something more sexual. Being a ten year old girl it is likely she is going through changes such as puberty.

Read More

Essay On Mortal Women In The Odyssey

739 Words | 3 Pages

The treatment of women has always been different in different societies, cultures, and time periods. In the Odyssey, the treatment of the female gods is different than the treatment of mortal women because the gods are a powerful being, but the mortal women are property and owned by their husbands. If a women marries a man who she has more money then, they will live in her house, but he will be in charge of everything, including herself. In book 21 and book 3 show the power of the mortal women compared to the power of the goddesses. In the Odyssey, the mortal women are treated and used differently from the way that the goddesses are worshiped because of the gender and societal roles that each group of women are assigned.

Read More

Oppression Of Women In Homer's Odyssey

780 Words | 4 Pages

In many societies today, individuals are led to believe that the concept of women possessing their own strength or independence is abnormal. As a result, women experience the world in a constrained way in comparison to men, even if they are in higher classes of society. However, these extensive aspects of females are contradicted in some ancient Greek literature. In the epic poem, The Odyssey, Homer portrays women as a vital and powerful force through the characters Penelope and Circe, who counter the normality of misogyny in Homer’s time. Penelope’s character displays how some women are able to exceed society’s standards and show strength and cleverness when it is necessary.

Read More

Odysseus Attention Of Women In Homer's The Odyssey

657 Words | 3 Pages

In The Odyssey, the female characters are not given as much of attention as men because the story focuses mainly on Odysseus’ adventures and point of view. During the ancient Greek era, men were seen to be more superior to women. Women we mainly judged on their looks. Their position in society is based on their husband’s success as a Hero or position in society. Penelope is more respected than other women due to her husband’s status as king.

Read More

Gender Roles In Homer's Odyssey

491 Words | 2 Pages

Women in The Odyssey Gender roles, specifically of women, were a little different back in 700 B.C. They played more of a typical role, expected to get married and have kids at a young age. They were expected to take care of the house and children, while their husbands were out fighting wars. However, while women in The Odyssey were greatly valued for their beauty, Homer reveals that they also had to be intelligent to be successful in their lives.

Read More

Differences Between Gilgamesh And Achilles

119 Words | 1 Pages

Gilgamesh was looking for immortality while Achilles wanted glory and fame. Although they both went  through similar ordeals they dealt  with in different ways. Each man was considered a heroic to their cultures for different reason.     We can tell a lot about the priorities and values of Gilgamesh’s and Achilles’ cultures through their heroic actions. It somewhat proved an answer to the way they did things and why

Read More

Beowulf And Gilgamesh Comparison

499 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout history epic tales have been told about heroes attempting to explain various occurrences such as the ones in the Gilgamesh and Beowulf. Gilgamesh and Beowulf compare and contrast in beliefs, their leadership styles, and the journeys they go on. Although both Beowulf and Gilgamesh can be compared to each other, because of their opposing locations and personalities, they are contrasting to each other. Beowulf and Gilgamesh leaderships styles, although very different, do have some similarities. Both Beowulf and Gilgamesh possess great physical strength, and courageousness as leaders of their respective cultures.

Read More

The Portrayal Of Women In The Odyssey

1401 Words | 6 Pages

Women are weak, helpless, and have no real purpose other than to serve men and take care of children. . . or so they were perceived in history. In the Odyssey, one can see that Homer’s portrayal of women challenges the depiction of women during that time period. Throughout the book, many women intervened in Odysseus’ journey home to Ithaca, for better or for worse. One will see Penelope, Athena, Circe, and other women impact Odysseus’ expedition home.

Read More

Comparing Homer's Iliad And The Code Of Hammurabi

704 Words | 3 Pages

To begin with, in the Iliad, a woman 's role depends on her beauty and position in the society, making them look more like a “prop”. For instance, Briseis used to be a respected princess and the wife of Mynes. However, her great beauty made herself became a reward between Achilles and other warriors in the Trojan War—she is no longer a dignified queen but a belonging whose role being manipulated by men. Another example is Helen. She was taken away from

Read More

Similarities Between Gilgamesh And Achilles

961 Words | 4 Pages

In comparison, it’s always observed on how different scholars find the similarity of especially marital settings, characters, and as well as the wanderings of the mythological world. Different events within the life of these characters cover broadly a huge range of epic encounters that are heroic. The character, emotional and psychological development of Gilgamesh can be borrowed especially from the ancient heroic perspectives of mortality and death while comparing with Achilles. Mesopotamian civilization has had several phases in which hero Gilgamesh has been in existence, however having similar attributes. One of the earliest stories of Gilgamesh is developed from Sumerian texts, one of the most influential and well-known poems (Michelakis & Pantelis 2007).

Read More

Essay Comparing Hamlet And Gilgamesh

720 Words | 3 Pages

Plenty of characters share traits that Hamlet, from the play Hamlet, written by William Shakespeare, possesses. A protagonist that shares traits with Hamlet, while also separating himself from this character is Gilgamesh, from The Epic of Gilgamesh, written by the ancient Sumerians. These two characters suffer from a tragic flaw, encounter a supernatural being, and change the way they view life after the death of a character close to them. However, these similarities contain major tweaks within them making them significant differences amongst the similar features. These two characters share more than one similar experience, in a broad sense, but one in particular allows for a comparison.

Read More

Similarities Between Gilgamesh And The Iliad

1519 Words | 7 Pages

But still there are certain differences that can be drawn between them. The epic of Gilgamesh depicts the Sumerian culture and on the other hand iliad poem is set in ancient Greek culture. Even though they both grieve for the loss of their best friends, the main contrast is in how they react with this loss. Both Achilles and Gilgamesh were worried about the mortality and did not wanted to die at once in their life.

Read More

The Objectification Of Women In Homer's The Iliad

1333 Words | 6 Pages

Known as an epic war poem, The Iliad delves into topics concerning masculinity, heroism, and bravery. Women play a modest but important role that forms the structure of the plot. Helen’s character aids in expanding Menelaus and Paris’ characters. Homer does not delve into the lives of women like he does with the men, speaking to the notion of inferiority between the sexes. Homer displays women as tangible items through male interactions with one another.

Read More

More about Comparing Gilgamesh And Achilles 'Free Will In Iliad'

Related Topics

Open Document