ipl-logo

Comparing In Flanders Fields 'And Dulce Et Decorum Est'

807 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Wilfred Owen poems unromanticised views of war

Thesis: McCrae and Owen both use rhetorical aims talking about either the glory or horrificness of the war, both authors persuade their readers.
John McCrae and Wilfred Owen are two of the most renowned poets of World War I. They both witnessed the horrors of the war and expressed their experiences through their poetry. "In Flanders Fields" is a poem by John McCrae that was written during the First World War, while "Dulce et Decorum Est" is a poem by Wilfred Owen, written after the war. Both poems depict the harsh realities of war, but they differ in their approach to imagery, syntax or rhyme scheme, and figurative language. This essay will compare and contrast how the poets use these literary devices to further their rhetorical aims.
McCrae's …show more content…

The poem is composed of three stanzas, each with a similar rhyme scheme: ABABCC. The repetition of the last line in each stanza, "We shall not sleep, though poppies grow/In Flanders fields," creates a refrain that reinforces the message of remembrance. In contrast, Owen uses syntax to convey the chaos and confusion of war. The poem is composed of four irregular stanzas, with no consistent rhyme scheme. The disjointed structure of the poem reflects the disorientation and disorder of the soldiers' experiences. Owen also uses enjambment to create a sense of urgency, such as in the line "Gas! Gas! Quick, boys! – An ecstasy of fumbling," which creates a frenzied and urgent tone.
McCrae's "In Flanders Fields" uses figurative language, such as personification, to emphasize the soldiers' bravery and the importance of remembrance. The first stanza personifies the poppies as "blow[ing] between the crosses," representing the soldiers' sacrifice and the continuity of life. The second stanza uses the metaphor of the soldiers as "the torch," which they pass on to the living to continue the fight. Owen's "Dulce et Decorum Est" uses figurative language to emphasize the brutality of war and to subvert the traditional notion of glory and heroism. The poem's title, which translates to "It is

Show More
Related
679 Words | 3 Pages

The metaphor "an ecstasy of fumbling" depicts the chaos and confusion of the soldiers at this moment. The repetition of "Gas! GAS!" creates a sense of urgency and terror as the soldiers try to save themselves from the poisonous gas. The third stanza describes the death of a soldier from the gas attack. The metaphor "watch the white eyes writhing in his face" creates a haunting image of the soldier's pain and suffering.

Read More
1571 Words | 7 Pages

This metaphor displays his uncertainty as per his crucial part in that moment in time. The soldier pictures himself as the hand on a clock, subject to the inevitable force of a clockwork motor that cannot be slowed or quickend. He realises that he does not really know why he is running and feels “statuary in mid-stride”. However, towards the end of the poem, all moral justifications for the existence of war have become meaningless- “King, honour, human dignity, etcetera Dropped like luxuries in a yelling alarm”, which is extremely dismissive of all the motives people provide for joining the army, explicitly stating that those motives do not justify and do not withstand the war. Disorientation is also highlighted in the line “Stumbling across a field of clods towards a green hedge That dazzled with rifle fire” where the confusion between the natural world and man-made world is expressed.

Read More
2092 Words | 9 Pages

There has been war as far back as recorded history and even further as far back as man. Dulce et Decorum Est, written by Wilfred Owen, describes the horrors seen in World War II specifically through the first-person perspective of a US Soldier. The poem follows a strict meter while incorporating figurative language and graphic imagery conveying the soldier's trauma and desire in battle. The poem is accompanied by The Naming of Parts by Henry Reed, which is a WWII poem that dives into the mind of a soldier during training. The poem is a free verse that changes between the third and second person as it shows the interactions between a cadet and his commanding officer.

Read More
1647 Words | 7 Pages

Wilfred Owen’s “Dulce et Decorum est” shows what life was like for soldiers in WWI. The poem discusses a soldier's point of view of losing someone they knew on the battlefield and their thoughts about the worthiness of the sacrifice after the fact. The speaker uses diction and imagery to show their disdain for war in the poem through a series of negative emotions such as fatigue, and sadness. The speaker uses diction to show their disdain toward the harsh reality of living on a battlefield and the mental toll it takes.

Read More
2085 Words | 9 Pages

In the poem the persona is Wilfred Owen, who fought in the war. This gives the readers a real perspective on the war and what it is like to be the soldier.

Read More
996 Words | 4 Pages

In “Dulce et Decorum Est,” Wilfred Owen exposes his readers to the harsh and quite graphic reality of a soldier in World War I. The title is ironic; excerpted from the saying referenced at the end of the poem, “Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori,” which translates to “It is sweet and glorious to die for one's country,” the poem exists to argue against that precise notion: that death on a battlefield is in any way “sweet.” His audience, then, is those people who believed at that time that war was something glorious - people who upheld the idea of war as something exciting and glorious. He opens the poem with a simile, “like old beggars under sacks,” painting these soldiers not as men but as the poor who have little dignity left.

Read More
1158 Words | 5 Pages

‘Your country is up to her neck in a fight, And she’s looking and calling for you.’ This quote is from Jessie Pope’s pro-war poem, ‘Who’s for the game’. Poems like this and other propaganda at the time of World War 1 had built a facade that glorified war and overlooked the casualties caused by it. The poem ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’ (written by Wilfred Owen), however, contested these views, uncovering these lies and revealing the true horrors of war to the public. In a direct response to Jessie Pope, coming from his own personal experiences, Owen conveys the message: war is not an exciting adventure but an extremely horrific and painful experience, with the use of several language techniques implemented throughout the poem, such as metaphor, personification

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

Wilfred Owen’s poems aim to represent the futility and waste of war through depiction of the feelings, sights and sounds of the time. This was done as part of Owen's attempt to overturn the ideas of the time, that war was a great honour and a good thing. After his experience on the front in the first years of the war, Owen was injured and hospitalised. During this time, he turned his back on his life as a priest and started to write poetry. Owen’s personal experiences with the war, as well as poetic skill and clever use of imagery and other devices, allows him to accurately represent the experiences of soldiers on the Western front.

Read More
1096 Words | 5 Pages

How is war represented in ‘Suicide in the trenches’ and ‘Dulce et Decorum est’? ‘Dulce et Decorum est’ is a poem written by Wilfred Owen between the years 1917 and 1918. It describes the life on the battlefield and how it impacted the life of the soldiers. Owen most likely used his first hand experiences from when he was a soldier in World War 1. This poem describes the soldiers personal perspectives of war using the bare naked truth, not glorifying it in anyway.

Read More
366 Words | 2 Pages

Physical suffering is a crucial theme illustrated throughout Owen’s poetry. This is evident in the poem “Dulce Et Decorum Est”. Owen recounts the dreadful experience of a gas attack endured by many soldiers during the Great War. The visual imagery presented in the line “Bent double, like old beggars under sacks” describes the physical suffering of the soldiers. Owen is stressing the conditions of the soldiers being exhausted, barely walking and overall deformed, unlike what the propaganda posters showed.

Read More
1755 Words | 8 Pages

In addition, showing how even when there is happiness, blessings it will always end in a tragic end. Owen employed the repetition technique several times throughout the poem. As “Happy are these who lose imagination” and “happy the soldiers home, with not a notion” expressing the life past and the qualities that each soldier will lose due to the horrors of war; and how every positive sense and emotion will be faded by the war effects. Also, the end of the fourth stanza tautology were used “From larger

Read More
1153 Words | 5 Pages

Finishing on the third stanza, Owen has used colour once again. “ purple spurted from his thigh”, it illustrates the bruises he had gotten from war and the deep impact on him, a colour signifying life and languor. Ending the poem with soldiers in the institute waiting for people to come emphasizes the fact that he is dependent and helpless. Also it reflected back to the start of the poem where he was waiting for death to come. “ How cold and late it is!

Read More
303 Words | 2 Pages

The poem aims to glorify soldiers and certain aspects of war, it goes on to prove that in reality there really isn 't good vs bad on the battlefield, it 's just a man who "sees his children smile at him, he hears the bugle call, And only death can stop him now—he 's fighting for them all.", and this is our hidden meaning.

Read More
3085 Words | 13 Pages

Laurel Lee 10D2 Does Owen want us to sympathize with the protagonist or criticize him? ‘Disabled’ is a narrative poem written by an English war poet Wilfred Owen showing his own traumatic war experiences as a soldier. It is an anti-war poem and it shows the horror of the First World War. His poem effectively compares the soldier’s current life and his past and shows the contrast between those two times very well. In this essay, I will be talking about Wilfred Owen’s method of creating sympathy and criticism for the protagonist of the poem and analyze the language and literary and structural devices that he uses.

Read More
1433 Words | 6 Pages

The ‘Anthem for Doomed Youth’ is a poem written by Wilfred Owen on September 1917. Wilfred Owen was born on 18th March 1893, in Oswestry, United Kingdom, and his poems are famous through the use of descriptive words to portray the pity of the war, which is a common theme throughout all of his poems. Owen wrote most of his poems between August 1917 to September 1918 before he was killed on 4th November at Sambre-Oise canal in France. ‘Anthem for Doomed Youth’ is a poem about a soldier dying in foreign country, and no one is praying for them; at the same time, the family in home country just can pray and do nothing other than that. Owen describes the theme of this poem agony of forgotten soldiers by using several literary devices such as imagery,

Read More

More about Comparing In Flanders Fields 'And Dulce Et Decorum Est'

Related Topics

Open Document