ipl-logo

Comparing Melville's Benito Cereno And Minding The Body

1202 Words5 Pages

Melville 's “Benito Cereno, published in Putnam’s Monthly Magazine in 1855, has been considered “‘one of the most sensitively poised pieces of writing’ that Melville ever conceived” (Feltenstein, 246). The intricacy of Melville’s story holds many hidden meanings and varied readings. Rosalie Feltenstein, Max Putzel and Matthew Rebhorn have taken it upon themselves to uncover some of these mysteries in their respective articles, “Melville’s ‘Benito Cereno’”, “The Source and the Symbols of Melville 's ‘Benito Cereno’ and “Minding the Body: ‘Benito Cereno’ and Melville’s Embodied Reading Practice”. While these authors develop different interpretations, the recurrence of motifs concerned with evil, its persistence, symptoms, causes and ambiguity …show more content…

What stands out are Melville’s uses of symbolism to explore themes of matter and spirit, bridging the inner and outer worlds through symbols (Feltenstein, 250). Furthermore, symbols become an extensional device that can encompass a wider range of reality, going beyond “the Emersonian doctrine that natural facts correspond to spiritual facts” —physical descriptions become spiritual ones as well (Feltenstein, 250). The analysis of these symbols is complicated in that they avoid universals, with Melville offering no key to begin unravelling the layers of meaning (Feltenstein, 251). However, in relation to his other work, “Benito Cereno” seems preoccupied with the themes of “the nature of evil and the ambiguity of appearances, especially as related to evil” (Feltenstein, 251). Feltenstein believes there is friction between truth and appearance in this text, with appearances disguising the truth, usually with negative outcomes (251). By making Babo the primary evil operative of the story, Melville is reinforcing the ambiguity and non-discriminative nature of evil, even victims can be evil (Feltenstein, 255). In conclusion, Melville is “examining in the actions of the Negroes how evil operates and, in Don Benito and Delano, what it’s effects are”, discovering that it is …show more content…

Matthew Rebhorn’s analysis argues that ‘Benito Cereno’ offers both an ‘inside narrative’ to be analyzed, as well as a guide on how to properly read analytically (157). Melville is using our hunger to understand the truth as a tool to display the negative effects of such an appetite, like Delano’s quest to understand the mysterious intentions of Cereno blinds him to the reality of the situation aboard the ship, in this sense, he traps the reader in this ambiguity in order to guide the reader out of it (157-8). Melville uses language to tangle and subvert meaning, challenging our “logocentric reading practices” and highlighting the “[in]adequacy of rational discourse” (Rebhorn, 158-9). ‘Benito Cereno’ discredits an objectivist reading practice, and replaces it with what Rebhorn identifies as an embodied reading practice. (161). Melville understood how physiological processes are vital to consciousness and communication, and how “we lay the foundation for our consciousness not through abstract thought but through our body’s reaction to external stimuli” (Rebhorn, 160). Furthermore, body language should be given more recognition, since “we are not simply embodied minds but also cognitive bodies, bodies that use nonverbal communication to elaborate verbal discourse as well as to explore alternative ways of decoding our reality” (Rebhorn, 162) The issues arise as Delano dismisses Cereno’s body language only as “symptoms of an absent or moody mind”, instead of considering them

Show More
Related
452 Words | 2 Pages

Viramontes used imagery while describing Estrella’s “dirty fingernails” and the “chalky lines on the blackboard”. Estrella had not been able to read anything on the chalky blackboard until she changed her views on learning English. Estrella’s growth as a character is illuminated through Viramontes’ use of figurative language. Viramontes uses tone and figurative language to show Estrella’s development as a character. Estrella changes from distressed to being joyful because her understanding of the tools grew which showed her that she can learn English.

Read More
135 Words | 1 Pages

The use of diction and syntax in this section creates an irritating atmosphere to stress the annoyance of the Columbian Guards. Larson’s evocative word choice for “disease” emphasizes the visitors' contagious curiosity as if they were part of a newspaper press. This displays to the readers as a stressful event for the Columbian Guards as they’re continuously “hammered with questions.” Furthermore, syntax was used in “the fair was so big, so beyond grasp” to create a fragmented and tiring effect for the readers due to the unimaginable pool of people inside of the fair. The fragmented phrases were embedded again in “it was a disease, a rhetorical smallpox” to convey the Columbian Guards harsh depiction of the visitors' nuisances.

Read More
1453 Words | 6 Pages

It is true that Delany’s “We, In Some Strange Power’s Employ” is not a story that is “balanced between two polar options” (Harbage 19). Instead, it is a story that takes a stance against colonialism. But how does Delany depict his negative stance? Harbage claims that Delany’s illustration of Blacky wearing Roger’s “marvelous ring” highlights the fact that the colonization of the angels is wrong, because its main goal is “selfish exploitation” (Delany 133) (Harbage 19). However, I will argue that Delany indicates that their colonization is wrong, because it was the purposeful eradication of one group’s way of life without a justifiable cause.

Read More
127 Words | 1 Pages

The worst bearing of both Rowlandson and Equiano has to face was being separated from their own love ones. Rowlandson was separated from her family and relations when her village was attacked then eventually lost her only child that was with her. Nevertheless, Equiano also endured tormented pain when he was parted from his sister while she was the only comfort to him at once. He was a young boy in a fearful atmosphere with nothing to convey a positive perspective. “It was vain that [they] besought than not to part us; she was torn from [him], and immediately carried away, while [he] was left in a state of distraction not to be describe”.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

As a result to the use of these literary elements, Bloor, can use natural phenomenon to show a different figurative meaning. By reading Tangerine, I have realized how authors can creatively use language to have entirely different

Read More
516 Words | 3 Pages

Choose a complex and important character in a novel or a play of recognized literary merit who might on the basis of the character’s actions alone be considered evil or immoral. In a well-organized essay, explain both how and why the full presentation of the character in the work makes us react more sympathetically than we otherwise might. Avoid plot summary. I. Introduction: A. In Mary Shelly’s novel, Frankenstein, the reader is tasked with answering the central question of who is the truest evil.

Read More
874 Words | 4 Pages

Melville displays allusions to Andrew Jackson in various instances throughout Moby Dick and certainly for good measure. The significance itself, though lies in the fact that Andrew Jackson and Ahab, the infamous ship captain, are both merciless towards the minorities. With an imagination, arguments can be proposed that Andrew Jackson and Ahab are the same person. In order to back up the argument one must understand Andrew Jackson’s presidency, the two’s personalities, Ahab’s role in the novel, and the hickory pole. Andrew Jackson, the seventh president of the United States, possesses the reputation of being a ruthless, barbarous, and ignorant man.

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

Herman Melville’s background had a great impact in writing Moby Dick, specifically using events that happened in that period of time. Melville was born in New York City in 1819. Initially, his family was wealthy for some time until one year after Melville was born, they had to move to Albany trying to regain their fortune. Consequently, of so much work, his father, Allan Melville dies. When this occurs Melville needed to do a lot of changes in his life.

Read More
1366 Words | 6 Pages

From everyday experience, readers know how things usually happen and how people react. A distortion of action or an understatement of effect gets a special response from readers, because they consider these changes improbable or the unexpected. The reader has to be alert to the actions of character because actions are the author’s way of showing, not telling, what the characters are like Appearance may be taken as a due to the nature of a character if the author leads the reader to attaché significance to it. Literary analysis is not pure description or a summary of the action, although it may include these elements.

Read More
333 Words | 2 Pages

Both “Frankenstein” and “The Tempest” have had an insurmountable influence on the way literatures developed. This is largely due to the similar compelling theme of the oppressor and the oppressed, a theme which is widely represented in novels today. The themes and the character relationships are extremely similar to one another. This is conveyed through the relationships between Dr. Frankenstein and his creature, as well as the relationship between Prospero and Caliban.

Read More
1081 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout Miguel de Cervantes novel, Don Quixote, there is a fine line between reality and illusion that seems to vanish portraying a prominent theme in the novel. Don Quixote de La Mancha, a fifty-year-old man, has an insane obsession in reading chivalry books; he is so absorbed in reading these books that he decides to become a knight-errant himself that will set off on adventures for his eternal glory. These books of chivalry have left Don Quixote so deep within his fantasy that there is no risk of him perceiving true reality. There are a plethora of examples where Don Quixote 's perceived reality is his idealistic fantasies. Cervantes expresses these complexities so much that we begin to notice the social criticism Don Quixote receives from people he encounters.

Read More
1857 Words | 8 Pages

Lieutenant Frederic Henry and Catherine Barkley are the protagonists of Ernest Hemingway’s novel A Farewell to Arms. Although there aren’t any other characters in the majority of the novel, there are a few that make an appearance every so often, like Rinaldi, The Priest, Helen Ferguson and Miss Gage. For the sake of this paper I will only be looking at the minor character Helen Ferguson, who is close friends with Catherine. Helen, who is often referred to as Ferguson or Fergy, is the voice of reason in regards to Henry and Catherine’s relationship.

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

From the twentieth century on, Herman Melville’s Moby Dick has been considered a masterpiece of literature and a landmark in

Read More
977 Words | 4 Pages

In order to consent with Alleline’s allegations, the reader must interpret the text as being anti-slavery oriented, given what was called the “immorality of slavery”. In accordance with Alleline, I agree that Melville was making a statement against the institution of slavery in his writing of Benito Cereno. Whereas Alleline’s interpretation of Benito Cereno is distinctly about one effect of slavery, general American shallowness; My interpretation differs in regards to what I think is Melville’s overarching theme of the countless detrimental effects of slavery on an entire population. While J. G Alleline’s critique of Melville’s story, serving as vehicle to highlight American superficiality is slightly narrow, his general ideas that Benito Cereno is a subtle anti-slavery work of literature is accurate, as portrayed through the ignorance of Captain Delano and

Read More
1807 Words | 8 Pages

The main character, Marlow, in Joseph Conrad’s 1910 novel The Heart of Darkness begins his journey into Africa skeptical of what might occur, but naive to the true horrors that were in stake for the young man. Marlow’s detailed descriptions of the sights and torturous actions towards the natives he witnesses along his journey lead to many literary critics to deem Conrad a racist. One author notorious for calling Joseph Conrad out on his racist remarks is Chinua Achebe who gained fame from his article “An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness”.

Read More

More about Comparing Melville's Benito Cereno And Minding The Body

Related Topics

Open Document