ipl-logo

Comparing The Colombian And Brazilian Free Womb Law

851 Words4 Pages

Free Womb Laws and Preservation of Slavery The Colombian and Brazilian Free Womb Laws were two legal initiatives aimed at ending slavery in Latin America. Essentially both laws would free the children of slaves, but not the mother. However, both laws contained provisions that allowed for the preservation of slavery. This paper will argue that free womb laws were manipulated to preserve slavery by comparing and contrasting the two laws. This paper will first explain the free womb law in Columbia. The Colombian Free Womb Law was a legal initiative aimed at ending slavery in Colombia. It declared that any child born to a slave mother would be considered free from birth. However, the law allowed owners to keep the children with their mothers until …show more content…

The Colombian Free Womb Law was enacted in 1821, while the Brazilian Free Womb Law was enacted in 1871. Both countries wouldn’t abolish slavery until a decade or more after these free womb laws were passed. One can already see how entrenched slavery was in Brazil when simply comparing those dates. It wasn’t until 50 years later after Columbia’s for Brazil to pass a free womb law. Both laws allowed owners to keep the children with their mothers until they reached a certain age. Columbia allowed owners to keep their slaves until they were 18, while in Brazil they were kept until they were 21. Each law allowed slave owners to profit from supposed “free” children for decades. The Columbian law allowed the slave to buy their freedom, unlike the Brazilian law. However, as is the nature of slavery, they did not get paid causing this provision to be practically useless. This provision also meant that owners could keep them in bondage until they had extracted enough value from their labor to justify the cost of purchasing their freedom. By doing so, owners could continue to profit from the labor of enslaved individuals while appearing to adhere to the law. The Brazilian law did allow for slave owners to be paid 600 dollars but paid over 30 years when a slave turned 8. However, would a slave owner take payment over 30 years instead of two decades of free labor? Most likely not. In conclusion, both the Colombian and Brazilian Free allowed for the preservation of

Show More
Related
1541 Words | 7 Pages

With their Catholic faith, many slaves designed a “soft” space of expression in the face of their participation in the “hard” institution of slavery. Racial fluidity in the colonial Peruvian institution of marriage sharply contrasts with the widespread conformity by people of color to the draconian judiciary system in league with influential planters in the southern United States. O’Toole argues that indigenous, African and mixed-race Peruvian laborers and slaves made use of familial and organizational networks to self-advocate for civil liberties within the semi-permeable Spanish colonial structure. Conversely, American slaves generally could not work within governmental bounds to fight for their rights, dishonorably shut out from society under the legal discourse of “social death.” In the southern United States, as Orlando Patterson articulated in Slavery & Social Death, the government used its code of “natal alienation” to force blacks to fall victim to its subordination of them.

Read More
1157 Words | 5 Pages

Many enslaved men and women were treated very cruelly by the Portuguese men and it was almost impossible for enslaved men to become free in the same manner as enslaved woman were. Sometimes enslaved women would try and reproduce with white masters as a way of giving themselves or their children a better social status but this wasn’t always consensual. Most enslaved women were segregated against, abused, and raped by their masters, especially those of pure African ancestry. Mixed slaves such as Afro-Brazilians were treated a little better and more likely to achieve freedom as in Chica da Silva’s case. Free women were treated better than slaves in 18th century Brazil but were still segregated against.

Read More
1278 Words | 6 Pages

In this case, legislation written during Spanish independence movements favored slaves. This was in large part due to Spain’s direct opposition to losing their Atlantic colonies. Ultimately, the Patronato law of 1880 sparked the end of slavery in Cuba and Spanish America

Read More
1211 Words | 5 Pages

The new Constitution proposes to count slaves as three-fifths of a person. While most people will still not count slaves as people who can exercise free will, the simple truth is that the power is given so that people who own slaves have more power (Doc. C). The significance of the geographical and historical context of this document is important. Given in New York, many of the people in the audience do not hold such deep roots with slavery. Many even oppose the idea.

Read More
792 Words | 4 Pages

They were simply seen as property owned by individuals, who were free. The basis that an owned can’t be denied his right to own property is considered unfair by government rules. The slave who is a human is considered property, but his master

Read More
1388 Words | 6 Pages

There is a very general similarity in this however; in both sides, slaves were not free and they had to obey their masters and work. Document 9 outlines observations by Hans Sloan concerning punishment of slaves on the island of Barbados. The punishments were very cruel, ranging from whippings for the smallest offenses to burning alive for

Read More
555 Words | 3 Pages

One cannot stop slavery without freeing the

Read More
928 Words | 4 Pages

In the Americas, the main exports were silver and cash crops, both of which required work that was terribly tedious and exhausting. This led to the overwhelming predominance of slavery in the Americas, since the Europeans were not willing to carry out the hard work themselves. When the Europeans found they lacked a workforce, the sought slaves elsewhere. While the people who were called slaves changed, the institution never did. The same mistreatment, torture, and horrible conditions were evident in American slavery until it was abolished centuries later.

Read More
306 Words | 2 Pages

Slavery was a big thing in America since Christopher Columbus. I believe that the benefits did not outweigh the consequences. This is why. First of all, The Columbian Exchange was an exchange between America (New World) and Europe (Old World). Document D shows that Europeans brought animals,wheat, sugar,coffee, and rice.

Read More
1038 Words | 5 Pages

Women who are victims of rape will always be in remembrance of their terrifying experience, which sometimes result in neglect and unfair treatment of the child due to the woman’s rape trauma syndrome. Women who are not financially stable that are pregnant and oppose abortion live in poverty. If abortions were banned it would increase illegal abortions which have critical effect to the woman’s health. Statistics estimate that the risk of death from an abortion is 0.6 in 100,000. The risk of death childbirth is 14 times higher, 8.8 in 100,000.

Read More
1759 Words | 8 Pages

Additionally, I have identified two propositions that may be decent approaches at addressing this nightmare. In order to successfully address this issue, Latin America needs to implement stricter laws and regulations pertaining to feminicidio. Recently, more laws and regulations have been incorporated in attempts to decrease the amount of killings. Although they continue to expand these laws, I think they can achieve better results through harsher punishments, stricter regulations, and advertising the significance of the issue. Implementing harsher punishments will serve a useful purpose and help rid the country of several criminals.

Read More
174 Words | 1 Pages

In the Dominican Republic, abortion is illegal. Article 37 of their constitution states that “the right to life is inviolable from the moment of conception and until death”. When a pregnant sixteen-year-old girl was admitted to the hospital, diagnosed with acute leukemia, doctors were hesitant to administer the chemotherapy treatment needed to try to save her life. Chemotherapy usually has adverse effects on a fetus and can lead to termination of the pregnancy, and since no exemptions were made on the ban on abortion, doctors did not want to take the chance and treat her for fear of legal repercussions if the fetus were to die from complications of said treatment. After many appeals to the government and the medical staff by the girl’s mother,

Read More
624 Words | 3 Pages

Slavery in Africa and in Latin America was distinct, despite being connected through the Atlantic slave trade. While traditional African slavery was practiced largely by communities to help produce food or for prestige, slave labor in Latin America was practiced on a much larger scale, for it was central to the colonies’

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

With the passage of a ban on abortion in Brazil, there are a number of possible outcomes which would greatly affect the Unites States. Given past incidents of American citizens leaving the United States (U.S.) due to disagreement with certain laws, it is not unreasonable to this that individuals might migrate to Brazil. Recently a large number of immigrants have begun to seek asylum in Canada, for fear of being deported. In a similar vein, there is also the possibility of a movement of Brazilian citizens to the U.S. Such an incident could cause further strain to immigration.

Read More
1021 Words | 5 Pages

“Abortion -should it be a right of every woman in the present context- A critical analysis” 1. Introduction I elected to present my dissertation on a topic based on ‘abortion’ since it is a hidden social menace in our society. It is like an iceberg. The tip represents the reported abortions, which everyone sees.

Read More

More about Comparing The Colombian And Brazilian Free Womb Law

Related Topics

Open Document