ipl-logo

Comparing The Lonely Land And The Pleasant Life In Newfoundland

737 Words3 Pages

The poems "The Lonely Land" by A.J.M. Smith and "The Pleasant Life in
Newfoundland" by Robert Hayman present contrasting perspectives on the natural beauty and solitude found in different landscapes. Hayman’s poem describes the beauty of the Canadian east coast as warm and inviting. Smith describes a cold and harsh landscape, unphased by the influence of humans, emphasizing beauty shown by the strength within. Although both "The Lonely Land" and "The Pleasant Life in
Newfoundland" focus on nature, they also use different tones and employ different techniques to express their emotions.

In "The Lonely Land," Smith describes a frigid and rugged Canadian landscape, focusing on the isolation and loneliness of the surroundings. In the first stanza, …show more content…

Newfoundland winters are said to be short, wholesome, constant and clear. The focus Of “The Pleasant Life in Newfoundland” is drawn to the vitality and abundance of the region.
Although the setting is similar, both poems explore different themes related to nature. Smith commonly refers back to the power and strength of nature. He talks about

“the beauty of dissonance”, which is the unwavering beauty found in unsuitable clashes or a lack of harmony. This leaves the reader with an overwhelming sense that they are
Isolated, out of place, and unwelcome. “The Pleasant Life in Newfoundland” shares a contrasting perspective centred around prosperity and vitality, where nature coexists with the inhabitants. In a symbiosis of sorts, humans take what nature has to offer, in return they treat the surrounding environment with respect. He talks about embracing
“Fire, Water, Earth, and Aire ”, stating these as distinct reasons for foreigners to experience the culture. Hayman allows the relationship between humans and nature to ebb and flow like the seasons, giving and taking from both sides.

Both "The Lonely Land" and "The Pleasant Life in Newfoundland" leave room for interpretation of underlying meanings. Smith’s work Indirectly references a sense

Show More
Related
1468 Words | 6 Pages

The Bird Artist Howard Norman is the author of the highly regarded novel THE NORTHERN LIGHTS (1987). In Norman’s second novel THE BIRD ARTIST, Fabian Vas lives in the remote village of Witless Bay, Newfoundland. As the narrator of the novel, the reader is presented with the matter-of-fact world that Vas inhabits. Because of the harshness of the environment, there is a toughness required of the citizens of Witless Bay. The terrain punishes anyone who is weak of body and/or of spirit.

Read More
708 Words | 3 Pages

Despite having an arduous life in Canada, he has in part fulfilled his idea of a personal heaven by living in an urban and developed setting; and primarily escaping the judgments of the apathetic islanders. Yet, this idea of a perfect life is incomplete; it lacks “some sweet island woman with whom he’d share his life, of having children and later buying a house” Many times in life, future gratification in unforeseeable, and occasionally — such as in the instance of Max — sacrifices may result in a sense of disillusioned inaptitude. Within this excerpt of the short story “Mammita’s Garden Cove” by Cyril Dabydeen, the author’s complex attitude towards place is conveyed by Dabydeen’s use of repetition, diction, and

Read More
497 Words | 2 Pages

Chris McCandless was introduced to the magic of nature at an early age although he was raised in a family that chose to live off their riches rather than their land. One of the largest influences to McCandless would have been his grandfather. “The old man’s backwoods savvy, his affinity for the wilderness, left a deep impression on the boy,” (Krakauer 109). Many of those who question McCandless’s dedication to the wilderness, had not understood his personal influences. McCandless had an interest for nature from a young age that flooded into his adolescent years that explains why he had such a fascination for leaving his home for Alaska.

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

Hours slide by like minutes. The accumulated clutter of day-to-day existence-- the lapses of consciousness, the unpaid bills, the bungled opportunities , the dust under the couch, the inescapable prison of your genes-- all of it is temporarily forgotten, crowded from your thoughts by an overpowering clarity of purpose and by the seriousness of the task at hand.” (142-143) The wilderness was perfect for McCandless; it gave him the peace of mind he needed to think clearly and gave him something to appreciate in

Read More
875 Words | 4 Pages

Carter stresses that this is a truly amazing piece of land with many aspects that make it worthwhile to leave it undisturbed. Starting off strong, Carter begins: “The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge stands alone as America’s last truly great wilderness.” Right away, Carter establishes rapport with the audience by describing the refuge as an alluring and unique wilderness. By using such powerful wording, Carter is able to provoke inside the reader a feeling of awe, as if they had experienced the magnificence of the refuge for themselves. Carter then goes on to describe the refuge with phrases such as “a once-in-a-lifetime wildlife spectacle” and “magnificent area as vast as it is wild”.

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

The feeling that can't be seen, called love, makes us irrational and helps us through tough times. In the Poem "Ode to Northern Alberta" by Billy-Ray Bellcourt we explore the pain and suffering conquered by love while also looking at how we make decisions based on emotions that may not be able to be explained. The poem's start introduces us to love and how people use it to cope without creating a setting. It states, "love keeps us busy while the smoke clears.". This starts off by showing the importance of love and how we use it to cloud our minds from pain and suffering, in this case, the hardships Indigenous people are going through caused by oppressors.

Read More
710 Words | 3 Pages

In some ways, Chris McCandless of Krakauer’s Into the Wild, acts as the epitome of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s ideals within his essay “Self-Reliance.” McCandless, who has grown into quite a celebrity, abandoned his family’s bourgeois values and sought to discover the terrain of his soul through an Alaskan Odyssey. Only months later, a moose hunter stumbled upon his corpse within a bus. Critics often chalk his death up as a warning to young adolescents looking for adventure, while the aforementioned adolescents idolize his journey. Despite the harsh denunciations and hero-worship, McCandless acted simply as his own person by disregarding society’s views and looking for his own thoughts in solitude, thus embodying Emerson’s “Self-Reliance.”

Read More
482 Words | 2 Pages

The innermost fragments of the soul are what makeup that we are, and many of us do not find out how to achieve every part within us for a long time. In Krakauer’s Into the Wild, he assembles a novel about Chris McCandless' life in an extraordinary way, outlining his various adventures throughout his short existence. Chris was a stubborn young man eager and bent on reaching spiritual haven in the Alaskan wilderness. His determination to fulfill his idealistic his idealistic dreams fueled his efforts elude conformist society. However, Chris would come to realize Alaska is a harsh, cold, and unforgiving landscape that misleads many dauntless individuals, like him.

Read More
456 Words | 2 Pages

In Jon Krakauer’s fiction narrative, Into the Wild, he portrays Chris McCandless as a self-reliant and thoughtless young man. Unfortunately, he sadly passed after a unprepared journey into the Alaskan wilderness. Through a closer examination on his actions and words it reveals he was a deeply appreciative and misunderstood person. McCandless showed his appreciation of the world with his love for nature.. During his travels he took great joy in the beauty of nature and the idea of living with such a gift.

Read More
859 Words | 4 Pages

According to John Krakauer in Into the Wild, he shows how McCandless and others have a unique perception of the wilderness because they have this awareness of free belonging to the wild. Their perspective has them in a reassurance of capturing their life in the wilderness, thinking about how it will change their whole perspective from daily struggles. In agreement with Leo Tolstoy in Into the Wild, “I wanted movement and not a calm course of existence. I wanted excitement and danger and the chance to sacrifice myself for my love. I felt in myself a superabundance of energy which found no outlet in our quiet life” (15).

Read More
90 Words | 1 Pages

In his 1995 essay “The Trouble with Wilderness,” William Cronon declares that “the time has come to rethink wilderness” (69). From the practice of agriculture to masculine frontier fantasies, Cronon argues that Americans have historically defined wilderness as an “island,” separate from their polluted urban industrial homes (69). He traces the idea of wilderness throughout American history, asserting that the idea of untouched, pristine wilderness is a harmful fantasy. By idealizing wilderness from a distance, he argues that people justify the destruction of less sublime landscapes and aggravate environmental conflict.

Read More
1239 Words | 5 Pages

Introduction: The Canadian landscape is a significant part of the Canadian imagination with many different novels being written through differing authorial interpretations over Canada’s written history. Despite these constant changing interpretations there retains some commonality between these descriptions of nature which are referred to as literary myths. The most prevalent of these myths is that of the Canadian landscape as the wild north. This myth of the north began its representation through 17th century explorer narratives which portrayed the land as a harsh and mythical landscape in which a man through his survival and endurance could prove their merit.

Read More
1197 Words | 5 Pages

The references made have a symbolic meaning that is deep, however small and minimalistic, to cause rejuvenation of nature which is seen in this particular essay. It is incomparable to a mere change in climate. Rather than just bringing warmth to Walden Pond, springtime bears a breath-taking renewal of life as well which is a

Read More
1072 Words | 5 Pages

“Death By Landscape.” Wilderness Tips, Doubleday, 1991, pp. 97-118 Brock, Richard. " Envoicing Silent Objects: Art and Literature at the Site of the Canadian Landscape. " Canadian Journal of Environmental Education, vol. 13, no. 2, 01 Jan. 2008, pp. 50-61.

Read More
907 Words | 4 Pages

As the second section of his essay goes on, he continues writing about the liveliness and inspiration that the West gives him because of the new chances and new concepts. To finish these thoughts, he writes, “Life consists of Wildness,” (Thoreau). To rephrase, he is saying that the wildness of nature and adventure is what life is all about. This theory is shown many times during the Westward Expansion and the expansion of the physical

Read More

More about Comparing The Lonely Land And The Pleasant Life In Newfoundland

Related Topics

Open Document