ipl-logo

Comparing The Yellow Wallpaper And The Birthmark

2004 Words9 Pages

Yellow Wallpapers and Crimson Hands: Feminist Critical Approach on “The Yellow Wallpaper” and “The Birthmark”
The feminist critical approach is very commonly used to critique both modern and outdated literature, to emphasize the oppression of, and prejudiced societal standards of women. Taking a feminist critical approach, the stories “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, provides underlying areas of similarities with the societal role and expectations of women being portrayed. Both stories display the conventional role imposed on women of being the less dominant spouse. In “The Yellow Wallpaper”, John takes control over his wife, portraying the subordination of women in marital relationships. …show more content…

In “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman the subordination of women is portrayed through the main character, Jane. She is shown to be quite docile in comparison to her husband, John: “There comes John, and I must put this away, he hates to have me write a word” (Gilman 4). John is displayed as a very dominant male and prefers to have control in every situation, so when he finds that Jane is writes about her feelings, he senses a loss of control and disapproves of Jane doing so. Another example of Jane being a subordinate spouse is after she tells him about her sickness, and he responds with a laugh, treating her as an inferior: “John laughs at me, of course, but one expects that in marriage” (Gilman 1). Jane proves herself to be very submissive, by brushing aside his dominance, saying that it typical behaviour in a marriage and accepting his dominance over her . In “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne the main character, Georgiana, also lives up to the female stereotype by being submissive and obedient to her husband. Aylmer, Georgiana's husband believes that his wife is not perfect, due to the small defect that is upon her face, but being a scientist he assures that he can try to remove the imperfection. Georgiana portrays her female stereotypes by being submissive and allowing her husband to remove the mark: “I know not what may be the cost to …show more content…

Jane in “The Yellow Wallpaper” is suffering from nervous depression and Georgiana in “The Birthmark” suffers from a fatal birthmark that looks like a crimson hand. In the “Yellow Wallpaper” Jane's husband tells her that the treatment to her nervous depression is to do nothing active and stay in a room all day. “I have a schedule prescription for each hour in the day” (Gilman 3). As a doctor Jane’s husband gives her appropriate treatments by supplying her with prescriptions and telling her to rest in her room. She abhors the wallpaper that is in the room she is forced to stay in the wallpaper symbolizes her mental degeneration as a result of the captivity ensued on her by her husband. Over time she begins to see hallucination of people trapped in the walls. “The paint and paper look as if a boys' school had used it. It is stripped off - the paper in great patches all around the head of my bed, about as far as I can reach, and in a great place on the other side of the room low down. I never saw a worse paper in my life.” (Gilman 3). The wallpaper in her room leads to her madness throughout the story and instead of curing her, this makes her symptom of nervous depression even worse than it already is. The story portrays that the female character has very unstable mental health, implying that females are weaker than men emotionally.

Show More
Related

Yellow Wallpaper Diagnosis

588 Words | 3 Pages

She proceeds to explain the contributing factors of the narrator succumbing to her “disease” of hysteria which was isolation from social interaction and the restriction of her own thoughts. She points out that the narrator is confined to a simple square room with nothing to offer in terms of mental health therapy. The narrator’s lack of the ability to interact with anything or anyone leads to infatuation with the wallpaper, which turns out to be “the

Read More

Comparing Women In The Yellow Wallpaper And The Birthmark

801 Words | 4 Pages

In the nineteenth century, woman had no power over men in society. They were limited in their freedom, as their lives were controlled by their husbands. Some women did not mind this lifestyle, and remained obedient, while some rebelled and demanded their rights. “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, and “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, are short stories that exposes the lifestyle women lived in the nineteenth century. The protagonists from both stories, Jane and Georgiana, similarly lived a male dominated lifestyle.

Read More

How Does Withington Treat Women In The 19th Century?

717 Words | 3 Pages

She slowly starts to fear her Husband, she notes how there is an odd smell that accumulates in her room, and she always references the yellow wallpaper, in that it changes in certain ways. She began to comment on how some parts of the wallpaper was torn, then she progressed to how there were bouts of fungus growing on the walls until she begins to speak of how the pattern on the wallpaper shakes because of the “woman behind it.” “Sometimes I think there are a great many women behind, and sometimes only one, and she crawls around fast, and her crawling shakes it all over,” this is when her sanity is clearly broken. She moves on from talking about her husband, the daylight, and the room itself to only speaking of the women and how she moves around. This clear descent into madness is a byproduct of how she is often dismissed by her husband and brother concerning her

Read More

Comparing The Tell-Tale Heart And The Yellow Wallpaper

483 Words | 2 Pages

At first glance, she seems like an ordinary woman going through something heartbreaking, but she slowly loses more and more of her senses throughout the story, mainly because of the prison-like room she's trapped in. She's being kept captive against her will in a dimly lit room with iron bars on the window frames and most notably, with musky yellow wallpapers on every wall. The wallpaper's seemingly never-ending patterns seem to take the greatest toll on her psyche and as a result, her condition gradually worsens. However, the setting of The Yellow Wallpaper isn't the only variable that affects the narrator's mental

Read More

Examples Of Sexism In The Yellow Wallpaper

300 Words | 2 Pages

Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s short story “The Yellow Wallpaper” strongly reflects the marital sexism in the late nineteenth century. Throughout the story, Perkins Gilman describes the mistreatment and gender discrimination she faces, which encourages her path to feminine equality. Due to her husband John taking on a roll of a misogynistic physician, as opposed to a doting spouse, the newly post-partum woman attempts to break through the chains of feminism, due to her beliefs being dismissed as she was deemed uncredible and less intelligent for being a woman. Throughout the story, the new mother and wife who narrates, exudes her bashfulness and cowering personality that allow a lack of feminism and independence.

Read More

The Themes Of Oppression In Hawthorne's The Yellow Wallpaper

871 Words | 4 Pages

Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” and Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark” were both written back in the nineteenth century and have characteristics of the way relationships used to be back then. " The Yellow Wallpaper" addresses the theme of women’s oppression through disregard and isolation, but "The Birthmark" presents the theme of women’s oppression through perfectionism and jealousy.

Read More

Rest Cure The Yellow Wallpaper

1129 Words | 5 Pages

She starts to see hallucinations as movement and the form of a woman appears in the wallpaper. “I can see a strange, provoking, formless sort of figure, that seems to skulk about behind that silly and conspicuous front design” (Gilman 212). The narrator believes she sees a woman trapped behind all the designs in the wallpaper and she wants nothing more than to get her

Read More

Gender Roles In The Yellow Wallpaper

1012 Words | 5 Pages

She is not only alienated from the world surrounding her, which hinders her ability to improve, but she spends most of her time analyzing the wallpaper and the woman trapped behind it. She begins to identify with the woman, as she herserlf is bound to this room and unable to engage outside of it. As she is spiraling into madness, we become detached from the narrator as she has now become unreliable. It’s evident that her mental health is detirtating, but in the scene where she is peeling off the wallpaper, there is a sense of clarity. This moment symbolizes her drastic and desperate attempt to escape the confinements of her room and in a way, the control of her husband.

Read More

Mental Health In The Yellow Wallpaper By Charlotte Perkins Gilman

1248 Words | 5 Pages

Finding something she can feel strongly about, that she understands fully, is something that she has been denied all of her life, and it becomes an addiction. As she becomes more and more dependent on loathing the wallpaper, her desperation is mistaken by her husband and Jennie as motivation and they begin to see it as an improvement. As they continue to refuse to attempt an understanding of the woman, she grows restless and begins hallucinating further. Seeing the wall move, seeing a woman moving in the patterns. She recognizes the image of a woman “skulk(ing) about behind that silly and conspicuous front design” (Gilman 4).

Read More

The Oppression Of Women In Charlotte Perkins Gilman's The Yellow Wallpaper

1067 Words | 5 Pages

As we look at marriages in today’s day and age, it is difficult for a man to be more dominant over his wife. Women are allowed to work in any profession they choose, and do not need to rely on a man for money. However, centuries ago in the progressive era, men were superior and dominant over their wife. Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s novel “The Yellow Wallpaper” portrays this type of image where a woman is controlled and trapped in her marriage by her husband John. In this era, they considered articles exposing issues like this as muckraking.

Read More

The Yellow Wallpaper Cause And Effect Essay

797 Words | 4 Pages

Not following the instructions given to her by her doctor and being confined in this area has caused some sort of mental build up. The wallpaper driving her crazy, suffering a mental illness, and having such an isolated lifestyle in a house isolated from the main villages has put thoughts into her head that she believes, like being the woman in the wall. That was the effect; the cause of all of this is simply because she wanted something to do after having her whole life changed for a few months, so she went to the

Read More

Identity In The Yellow Wallpaper

1008 Words | 5 Pages

However, we later see a shift in her feelings towards the wallpaper as she states that she is growing “really fond of the room in spite of the wallpaper” and comes to a realization that it may be “because of the wallpaper” (Par 94) As her opinions on the wallpaper begin to change, the progression of her mental instability becomes increasing visible. She begins to build a relationship with the wallpaper and claims that “There are things in that paper that nobody knows about” (Par 22) her. As this relationship with the wallpaper builds, her sanity begins to slip, and the hallucinations begin in a somewhat minor manor. In her first mention of “the woman” she says that the pattern on the

Read More

Charlotte Perkins Gilman's Portrayal Of Victorian Women

774 Words | 4 Pages

She wrote “The Yellow Wallpaper” in an effort to open the public’s eyes to the unfairness of this treatment. By infusing Jane’s narrative with childish language and actions without ever actually calling “Jane” by her name, Gilman creates a universal experience any woman of the time could insert herself into. This allowed women to fully realize the injustice they faced. John’s belittlement of Jane also serves to create both a universal and eye opening experience for the women reading it. Additionally, for those who were willing to read into the symbolism, the nursery and the meaning underlying it added to the injustice Gilman conveys.

Read More

What Is Feminism In The Yellow Wallpaper

1155 Words | 5 Pages

Enclosed to the four wall of this “big” room, the narrator says “the paint and paper look as if a boy’s school had used it” because “it is stripped off” indicating that males have attempted to distort women’s truth but somehow did not accomplish distorting the entire truth (Perkins Gilman, 43). When the narrator finally looked at the wall and the paint and paper on it, she was disgusted at the sight. The yellow wallpaper, she penned, secretly against the will of men, committed artistic sin and had lame uncertain curves that suddenly committed suicide when you followed them for a little distance. The narrator is forced to express her discomfort with the image to her husband, he sees it as an “excited fancy” that is provoked by the “imaginative power and habit of story making” by “a nervous weakness” like hers (Perkins Gilman, 46). Essentially, he believes that her sickness is worsening and the depth of her disease is the cause of the unexpected paranoia.

Read More

The Yellow Wallpaper Gender Inequality Analysis

1091 Words | 5 Pages

Gender Inequality: A Woman’s Struggle in “The Yellow Wallpaper” In “The Yellow Wallpaper”, Charlotte Perkins Gilman captures the lives of women in a society based on societal expectations during the late nineteenth century. She focuses on the issue of gender inequality where women were often discriminated against and expected to fulfill the role of a perfect wife and mother. The narrator is based on on Gilman’s personal experience of suffering from her treatment for postpartum depression due to the social restrictions on women which represents a reflection on women's social status in society. The narrator, who remains anonymous, is depicted as a depressed and isolated prisoner who is oppressed under her husband’s control and struggles to break free.

Read More

More about Comparing The Yellow Wallpaper And The Birthmark

Related Topics

Open Document