ipl-logo

Comparison Of Flaws With Collective Governments In Anthem And Catch-22

599 Words3 Pages

Flaws with Collective Governments in Anthem and Catch-22
Without systems of government or leadership, the world would crumble into an anarchic chaos, leading to a dangerous environment for its citizens. However, oftentimes governing bodies lean the other direction, with laws and enforcement so strict their people become oppressed. Ayn Rand and Joseph Heller explore the negative consequences of oppressive dystopias in their novels Anthem and Catch-22, respectively, which describe two men’s struggle against their governments. Ayn Rand, staunchly against collectivism in her own life, wrote the allegory Anthem to reflect her anti-collective sentiment. In Anthem, the central character, Equality 7-2521, describes growing up in a collectivist society …show more content…

In this society, all personality is relinquished to the rulers, singular pronouns are banned, and people are assigned to houses based on occupation to maintain order and reinforce the strict set of legal codes everyone is required to follow. Equality 7-2521 chronicles the struggles he faces with the Council, the ruling body, and his relationship with Liberty-3000, a farmer in the House of the Peasants and the female protagonist. Joseph Heller’s novel, Catch-22, is a similar story, but takes place in Europe during World War II. The main character, Yossarian, is a captain in the 256th squadron of the Air Force, but he despises his missions and dreams of being released home, leading to issues between him and his superiors. Throughout the story, Heller reveals corruption in the government and the restrictions it often places on the individual, causing conflicts in the story and exposing problems with collective-style governments. The two authors describe a similar conflict between the main characters and the hierarchical systems that control them. The novels Anthem by Ayn Rand and Catch-22 by Joseph Heller demonstrate the flaws in the collective system of government, with its closed ruling body that emphasizes equality yet ultimately restricts citizens’ rights to

Show More
Related
902 Words | 4 Pages

Many encounter the beneficial effects of communism encouraged within world-wide governments; however, its negative outcomes are also revealed to the members in these societies. Communism is commonly described as a political theory that advocates social organization in a way that controls the economic and social activity as to make each member of society equivalent to their peers while highlighting the lives of its’ creators. In Ayn Rand’s novella, Anthem, each character faces the influences from this type of governing from the way they dress to their everyday professions. In addition to this novella, “Survival Ship”, by Judith Merril, also has a similar way of controlling the passengers harbored on the ship.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

How Does One Lead a Rational Life in the Great Rebirth Ayn Rand is an illustrious writer, known for many of her works including the short novella Anthem and her short essay How Does One Lead a Rational Life in an Irrational Society. In Anthem, she speaks of a dystopian world set in the future with primitive technology. The Council expects everybody to look, act, and generally be the same as one another; however, Equality, the main character of Anthem, does not conform to the social norm. He rebels from the cookie-cutter system and learns to see the deep err in the way of the Council and finally realises the effects that the abusive treatment of the citizens creates.

Read More
500 Words | 2 Pages

“Repent Harlequin Said the Tictockman” by Harlan Ellison wrote in 1965 is about a time keeping government trying to achieve complete efficiency. The 1961 science fiction short story “Harrison Bergeron,” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr., is about complete equality, disabling humanity from success. By examining elements of character analysis, tone, plot, setting, and diction, readers can see that these two dystopian stories can be compared and contrasted. “Repent Harlequin…” and “Harrison Bergeron” take place in alternate futures where the government has either taken control of everyone’s schedules or removed things that would make them unequal. Both stories are led by an antagonist and by someone who rebelled against them, but eventually, the rebellion fails and as far as we know the oppression goes on.

Read More
527 Words | 3 Pages

Equality for all “No two leaves are alike, and yet there is no antagonism between them or between the branches which they will grow”(Mahatma Gandhi) The book Anthem by Ayn Rand and Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut are both dystopian pieces which display equality in different ways. Although Harrison Bergeron by Kurt Vonnegut and Anthem by Ayn Rand are both pieces of dystopian literature their portrayal of family differs greatly. In Harrison Burgeron, people have a families and marriage. Harrison Bergeron differs from Anthem because they have more freedom when dealing with family.

Read More
446 Words | 2 Pages

As dystopian novels, Anthem by Ayn Rand and Unwind by Neil Shusterman are bound to have similarities within their driving forces. Despite taking place in disparate societies, what links these two novels together is the concept of insubordination and resilliance. Within Anthem, the protagonist, Equality 7-2521, blindly walks through a post-modern, underlying oppressive society where individualism is bracketed off with evil or selfish ideas and commodities that led the previous world to crumble; thus leading to a civilization lacking self-awareness. A place where all citizens of the society refer to themselves as "we", are given names which lack much personality, and are indistinguishable to one another. "We are one in all and all in one.

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

Collectivism is the idea that a group 's needs must be put before the needs of oneself and the society functions as “we” rather that “me”. Throughout the stories one sees how each author portrays the use of a collectivist society though uniqueness, equality, and transgression. There are many similarities between the novella Anthem by Ayn Rand and the story “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. In Anthem and “Harrison Bergeron” one could see that a similar theme is that going against the grain causes consequences. According to “Harrison Bergeron” a ballerina states that “ ‘Harrison Bergeron age fourteen,’ she said in a grackle squawk, ‘has just escaped from jail, where he was held on suspicion of plotting to overthrow the government.

Read More
332 Words | 2 Pages

The novel, Anthem by Ayn Rand, represented a collectivist society, which can be directly compared to

Read More
707 Words | 3 Pages

Her society gives its citizens little to no freedom with extremely harsh punishments for even the slightest acting out of line. Anthem’s depiction of a collectivist society is far more extreme than that of “Harrison Bergeron.” To quote Anthem’s protagonist, Equality “The first blow of the lash felt like our spine had been cut in two. The second blow stopped the first and for a second we felt nothing.

Read More
594 Words | 3 Pages

Collectivism and Selfishness in Anthem Imagine living in a world where everybody's lives are completely mapped out by the government. Where every decision is made without the input of the citizens it affects. In the novella Anthem, Ayn Rand depicts a completely collectivist society, where every idea, action, and invention is purely for the benefit of society as a whole. Everything is done with the entire population in mind, and individuality is extremely frowned upon.

Read More
463 Words | 2 Pages

Why Anthem is a Dystopia The story Anthem is a bias and raw story. It has many ups and downs and life lessons to learn. Ayn rand is trying to tell the reader that being a follower cannot benefit you all the time. Anthem is definitely a dystopia. It is a dystopia because the way the people were treated, the setting is in the future and it is a collectivist society.

Read More
1219 Words | 5 Pages

Victory Over Collectivism “I”, one of the only one-letter words in the English language. Yet its power and meaning do not match its quantitative value. In the collectivist dictatorship found the in the novel Anthem by Ayn Rand, this word has disappeared and consequently, society has fallen into a dark age, all because of the loss of a single-lettered word. However, the hero of this time, Equality 7-2521, breaks down the barrier of the collectivist society and allows him to make advances that show him the power of the word “I” and the idea of individualism in government and in society. Although the word “I” has vanished from society, Equality is able to free himself from the collectivist government through the use of science and free thought,

Read More
750 Words | 3 Pages

Catch 22 Paper In Catch 22 by Joseph Heller the book is a complex novel. Heller uses many themes, does not have the storyline in chronological order and often uses irony in his descriptions. Many of the themes can be compared to other literature. One of the themes that can be compared is fear in war.

Read More
827 Words | 4 Pages

Mariah Addington Mr. Jones English 11 6 January 2017 Catch-22 Heller wrote Catch-22 to educate readers on the lack of morality in the struggle and use of power in society and bureaucracy. When given a position of power, or in the struggle to get power, morality begins to dwindle and corruption begins to emerge as shown in Catch-22 through the use of characters, sanity and insanity, and absurdity. The first way readers are introduced to the corrupt society and bureaucracy is through the characters used in Catch-22. Almost every character in Heller’s novel is corrupt or affected by corrupt officials.

Read More
1479 Words | 6 Pages

Heavily critiqued but widely honored as one of today’s most captivating and literary intriguing books of the past century, Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 presents a story displaying one of the more forgotten aspects of WWII which is base life. Catch-22 is a book set during World War II where an American B-52 bombardier named Yossarian communicates his experiences and life at a U.S. Air Force base on a small island named Pianosa located west of Italy. Catch 22 is renowned by many who have enjoyed the book’s realism and use of satire, but some people mainly teachers believe the book to be to mature for students of the high school age. In some cases the book has been outright banned such as the case in Strongsville, Ohio where the school district banned the book from school libraries due to the use of profanity and racial slurs repeated often throughout the

Read More
312 Words | 2 Pages

Dystopian novels tend to discuss how the adult world controls a contemporary society with any extreme ruling and viewpoint while the younger generation is forced to abide by the rules set forth leading them to a grossly unjustified system. A Contemporary

Read More

More about Comparison Of Flaws With Collective Governments In Anthem And Catch-22

Related Topics

Open Document