ipl-logo

Comprehending The Calamity By Burke Analysis

1013 Words5 Pages

The San Francisco earthquake of 1906 had a magnitude of 7.9. This devastating event killed thousands. It was a normal day, people did not prepare for this, it just happened. Despite a quick response from San Francisco's large military population, the city was devastated. The earthquake and fires killed an estimated 3,000 people and left half of the city's 400,000 residents homeless. This is shown through two eye witness accounts.““Comprehending the Calamity” by Emma Burke and “Horrific Wreck of the City”By Fred Hewitt are very similar;these eye witness accounts of the San Francisco earthquake of 1906 talk of the horror, but in different ways. One is optimistic and the other is pessimistic.
“Comprehending the Calamity” and “The Horrific Wreck …show more content…

This is recording the 1906 earthquake by explaining the noises and how the shock grew.This shows how the disasters that happened on that day. These things included a fire, people being trapped, and people losing their homes. This shows the similarity through the author's horrible experiences and losses.“Comprehending the Calamity” and “The Horrific Wreck of the City” are different because one author is optimistic, where the other is not.Emma Burke shares her thoughts when she says“After a half-hour we came up to our flat to take an inventory of the situation. I walked over the remains of my personal possessions, without a feeling of regret or a sigh or tear. Everything seemed so insignificant, and the world so far away. That is, the world we had lived in. Human life seemed the only thing worth consideration.” on page …show more content…

It made me think of the loved ones across the country. It turned my stomach, gave me a heartache that I will never forget and caused me to sink upon my knees and pray to the
Almighty God that me and mine should escape the awful fate I knew was coming to so many thousands.” on page 2Emma Burke says “All day I had been feeding homeless ones who had drifted out from the Mission district, where great clouds of angry smoke were rising and large areas had already been devastated. and as night came on, we gathered some bedding together and went into the Park, the Mecca of all the city, All day I had been feeding homeless ones who had drifted out from the Mission district, where great clouds of angry smoke were rising and large areas had already been
Devastated.” on page 2

Just like how Fred Hewitt explains “It is impossible to judge the length of that shock. To me it seemed an eternity. I was thrown on my back and the pavement pulsated like a living thing. Around me the huge buildings, looking up These two pieces of evidence show the different perspectives of the authors.

Emma see’s a world where you need to help others, she is

Show More
Related
489 Words | 2 Pages

The narrator describes the

Read More
418 Words | 2 Pages

He couldn 't even scream because he was choking on dust and barley move because he was being crushed be falling bricks. This book is about the massive earthquakes in San Francisco that occurred at 5:12 am on April 18th, 1906. The earthquakes terrified hundreds of thousands of people instantly. Thousands of people were killed, crushed to death by houses, buildings,

Read More
759 Words | 4 Pages

Within multiple occasions, the writer adds the emotional effect to grab the reader’s attention and to make one aware of the sacrifice the first responders contributed. Now that the writer has caused the audience to feel emotional or uneasy of the matter, the writer then states, “I showed him a photo of my brother, FDNY Capt. Billy Burke, Engine Co. 21, who perished in the North Tower after refusing to leave

Read More
738 Words | 3 Pages

(Dwyer and Flynn). By showing the perspectives of the people in and around the towers with further information gathered afterwards layered in with the 1st hand accounts it provides a full circle analysis of the events. Another example of this style of writing is on page 130, “Martin Wortley of Cantor Fitzgerald told his brother over the phone he was hoping to leave by helicopter, and would head up the stairs in the north tower.” (Dwyer and Flynn). This is ironic in the most tragic way as the chapter is titled “The doors are locked”.

Read More
505 Words | 3 Pages

Page

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

“Comprehending the Calamity” by Emma Burke and “Horrific Wreck of the City” by Fred Hewitt are two historical articles that both describe the destruction of the San Francisco earthquake in 1906 and how it affected the people. Hewitt says on page 1, “No pen can record the sufferings of those who were crushed to death or buried in the ruins that encompassed them in an instant after 5:13 o’clock Wednesday morning.” Likewise, Emma Burke says on page 2, “The fallen chimneys had torn through the ceilings into two of our rooms; the flat tin roof had thus been bent down, and now acted as a funnel. We heard an ominous drip, drip, and then a steady splash.” These pieces of evidence show both of the authors believe that this horrible earthquake destructed the city of San Francisco.

Read More
1484 Words | 6 Pages

(page

Read More
842 Words | 4 Pages

Fort mason was luckily saved from the fire as were some of the people who were trapped. The Great Fire spread across town overnight and then changed it’s path to the southern part of the city. Fire Chief Engineer Dennis T. Sullivan was announced dead at 1 am, April 22, 1906.By that time comes the earthquake has stopped and so have all the big aftershocks . Leaving San Francisco with little short tremors every now and then. Believe it or not this is just one of multiple natural Disasters and earthquakes that have hit San Francisco.

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

“Comprehending the calamity” by Emma Burke and Dragonwings by Laurence Yep both talk about one natural disaster they both have different point of views on it. Dragonwings is a book about a Chinese kid in america but there is one part of the book where they had to fight through an earthquake with no one willing to help. “Comprehending the calamity” is a passage specifically about an earthquake that caused a lot of destruction for days and about how it was bad but people were still there for one another. These are the two stories and this essay is about why they have these different point of views. Because they had different purposes for writing, Emma Burke’s point of view of the 1906 earthquake brung out the best in people, while Moon Shadow’s point of view was the

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

For example, when Jess, Eddie and Sam were in the abandon cabin they experienced an earthquake. The reader can sense the frightfulness they must have endured as trees tumbled down everywhere around them in the forest. The author also describes in detail how the heat from the blast felt so hot that every breath was like inhaling fire. Thankfully, Jess figured out that if she tucked her shirt over her mouth she could breath. This intrigues us to read on as the reader wants more details on what she is going through and how she survived.

Read More
2191 Words | 9 Pages

The sounds of Mexico City… rose through the open window into the waiting phone,” (Paragraphs 15-18). The Colonel has been waiting for this for the past ten years and when he finally hears it, he can just feel and sense what is going in the city. It is as if he knows and can picture the bustling city in his mind. His ears were aching for this day to come. The reader can understand Colonel Freeleigh’s pain that he must endure mentally and physically.

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

Imagine you are in bed when all of a sudden at at 5:12am, the earth begins to shake and the San Francisco 1906 Earthquake begins to rattle the city. The personal narrative “Comprehending the Calamity” by Emma Burke and the personal narrative “Horrific Wreck of the City” by Fred Hewitt both give you an idea of what the earthquake was like to wake up to. What do you think it was like? The personal narrative, “Comprehending the Calamity” tells the readers what the earthquake was like through the eyes of the author. Even though the event is bad, the author is optimistic and helpful and she continues to believe that god will help the people of San Francisco through hard times.

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

We witness a high angle view of the town as explosions ravage across it, and inside the house, the explosions cause

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

Walking through the city, Beller can effectively use images to capture the audience’s attention. The author uses a variety of diction to allow the audience to picture what has happened:......” At Thomas Street, about six blocks north of the World Trade Center, the nature of the crowd on the street changed. There was more urgency and less mirth. Cop cars parked at odd angles, their red sirens spinning.

Read More
1548 Words | 7 Pages

In the process of making this project, Ai Weiwei along with a couple other decided to undergo their own personal investigation of the incident. The media and authorities at the time, refused to give up any information on the true number of student who died during the earthquake and failed to report on any information about the construction flaws of the school building. Fearing, the incident, would quickly be undermentioned and forgotten through the media, Ai Weiwei’s team decided to record every single child that went missing during the disaster and posted their names on social media, so that each children would be recognized. Two months before the opening of “So Sorry”, Ai Weiwei went to testify for his friend, investigating the disaster.

Read More

More about Comprehending The Calamity By Burke Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document