ipl-logo

Sturken And Cartwright's Commodity Analysis

1237 Words5 Pages

The main argument in this essay will be formed around a critical analysis of a commodity and the way in which it is sold in today’s typically capitalist consumer culture, which is manufactured through desire.
I will start of by defining key terms such as Marxism and Marxist theory (which consists of consumer culture, commodity advertising and commodity fetishism, use and exchange value, commodity sign and ideology) in order to develop an understanding that will aid in justifying my argument.
“Practices of Looking” by Sturken and Cartwright (2001), Ideology In Critical and Cultural Theory: Thematic Variations by Cavallaro (2001) and “Subjectivity in a bottle: Commodity Form and Advertising as Social Practice” by Goldman (1992) are readings …show more content…

Sturken and Cartwright (2001: 51) explain that “ideologies define ideas of how life should be”, in other words superstructures determine the ideology and impose this on the masses, who then live by and believe in these ideologies on a day to day basis. Karl Marx (referenced in Sturken & Cartwright 2001: 51) defined ideologies as a “kind of false consciousness” that the dominant powers persuaded the masses to believe in, giving way to capitalism. Marx’s (Sturken & Cartwright 2001: 51) theories about ideologies showed that people are forced in to being a part of an economic system despite their …show more content…

Thus it will create a social value to the object. For instance looking at a specific brand no one knows about the production of the clothing, but it is bought because of the brand identity.
Use and Exchange Value
Sturken and Cartwright (2001: 199) explained the Marxist critique of capitalism as “advertising to be a means to create demand for products, which makes people buy more than they really need”. Marxist theory analyzed a particular relationship between exchange value and use value in capitalism. “Exchange value refers to what a particular product costs in a given system of exchange. Us value refers to its use within that society” (Sturken and Cartwright 2001: 199).

“Marxist theory critiques the emphasis in capitalism on exchange over use value, in which things are valued not for what they really do but for what they’re worth in abstract, monetary terms” (Sturken and Cartwright 2001: 199). This means that if something takes twice as long to produce, it will be twice as expensive as something that would take one day to

Show More
Related
1133 Words | 5 Pages

The environment is pledging an elitist appeal but the warm colors found in the image attract the populist group. In Jack Solomon’s “Masters of Desire the Culture of American Advertising” he explains a paradox in the American psyche. He argues that Americans simultaneously desire superiority and equality, as a result, advertisers create images that exploit those opposing conditions. He emphasizes that America is a nation of fantasizers. He sums up that advertisers create consumer hunger by working with our subconscious dreams and desires in the marketplace.

Read More
898 Words | 4 Pages

A capitalist society encourages exploitation of workers through consumerism. This can be observed in Mardi Gras: Made in China (2005) by recognizing how use-value, exchange-value and surplus-value in our society promotes exploitation. The documentary provides insight that the usefulness of a thing, or the use-value, is often disregarded when people purchase commodities to keep up with trends rather than for its use. Exchange-value exists within capitalism, where consumers are not as interested at an item’s usefulness. Rather, they are more interested in its monetary value and what they can obtain in exchange for the

Read More
702 Words | 3 Pages

The documentary Surplus: Terrorized into Being Consumers portrays both America and Cuba’s views on consumerism, including both the absurdities that differ between each country as well as the similarities. In America, happiness is most likely dependent on materialistic items; “a culture in which people will do most anything to acquire the means to consume- working slavish hours, behaving rapaciously in their business pursuits, and even bending the rules in order to maximize their earnings” (The Crisis of American Consumerism). Things that our society deems necessary do not actually fall under the category of basic needs, however our society is so drawn into consumerism that many mistake needs for wants. In addition, people also find

Read More
1423 Words | 6 Pages

Michael Parenti’s essay, “Institutions and Ideologies,” demonstrates how these ideologies are literally “a way of life, a glorification” (557). Parenti is trying to convey how over time these ideologies become a natural routine to us. With this routine of ideologies, it becomes glorifying since we continue to practice and live hegemonic ideals. Parenti discusses how ideologies are socially constructed and implemented, and how these social practices become a form of living. This has turned to repetitive living and demonstrate how these ideologies have been used to justify why certain groups are treated this way because the majority view this a way to ensure that they will always maintain control in society.

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

In the article accepting or rejecting innovation, the author mentioned that some of the people will pay double price for the designer jeans. Although the jeans without designer have the same quality as the designer one and people will only need to pay half of the price compared to the designer jeans. As a result, many people will still choose to pay double price for the designer jeans. However, the people who bought the designer jeans are only because of social value. They might want to show off in front of other people.

Read More
2359 Words | 10 Pages

Individuals even in a state of zombification are looking for self-definition in the shopping mall. The commodity fetishism empowers the capitalist system and allows the individuals to live a utopian fantasy of autonomy (Bishop 2010: 247). People believe that they are free when they buy an object of their desire. However, in a sense they indirectly fall victims of exploitation, which is the purpose of the bourgeoise (Bishop 2010: 247). Just as zombies never satisfy their appetite for human flesh, consumers cannot restrain themselves from buying.

Read More
1444 Words | 6 Pages

Everyone in the world in the world seems to know who the Kardashians are, wherever you look they seem to appear, on billboards, magazines, in salons, on the internet, pictures of them are plastered everywhere. The Kardashian family is popular culture. In this essay I will be discussing consumerism, the role of technology in consumer culture and materialism in accordance to the show Keeping Up With The Kardashians and the Kardashian family, and explaining it through conflict theory. Conflict theory dictates ideas coined by Karl Marx (1818-1833) who has divided the social groups into two classes, the bougeousie and the proliteriate. He states that because of the inequality in the power balance and the bourgeousie having a capitalist hold over the proletariates, they abuse their power over the proletariates.

Read More
760 Words | 4 Pages

Consumption In Aldous Huxley’s “Brave New World”, the concepts of consumerism and utopia are continuously compared and discussed in tandem with one another to decide if any correlation between them is present. Although people may argue that the humans belonging to the World State are happy, their lack of simple human pleasures such as love, religion, intellect, free will, etc, denies the people of actual joy. Since the government is what controls these pleasures by glorifying consumption, the World State’s culture and consumerism must interrelate. The government's control of common human experiences and characteristics such as love, pain, religion, and free will result in the total dependence on the state.

Read More
685 Words | 3 Pages

Dorothy Smith conceives of ideology as a mode of reasoning, or creating knowledge which abstracts away from lives individuals engaged in everyday social interaction. It Is through ideology, hegemony and discourse that people become convinced to accept systems of social inequality as acceptable and immune from social transformation. It remains obvious that to state that the working class by virtue of its place in the social relations of capitalist production, has a fundamental interest in socialism, and is to attribute to a determined place at the economic level. But through the indoctrination by the capitalist classes, the working class comes to conclude that the dominate form of social structure is not subject to change. “Necessity is blind until it becomes conscious.

Read More
701 Words | 3 Pages

Does Victor Frankenstein do God and nature’s job, throughout the story? When he creates this creature he seems to be doing God's job by creating a living form. In the story nature is used sometimes, to help and hurt the characters. Shelley wants nature to symbolize a god because in the story there is no supernatural being. Mary Shelley implements nature as a type of god through grief, isolation, and healing powers.

Read More
1320 Words | 6 Pages

Commodity fetishism refers to the transformation of human relations formed from the exchange of commodities in the market. Human relations form between people of trade in goods and services in the market expressed in terms of the objectified economic relations among currency. Commodity fetishism allows the ability to transform individuality, conceptual aspects of financially viable value into objective and real things that people think have intrinsic value. (Rubin, 1990,5) Karl Marx states social relation between people assumes in their eyes to form a relation between things therefore commodity fetishism is religious due to the involvement of supernatural status to assume a belief in something not there. Humans use their brains to create commodities

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

To which the economy influences these aspects of society. Marx, comparatively to Plato and Hegel, emphasizes material reality over the ideal reality. Individual consciousness comes from the ruling class, the bourgeoisie. To Marx, the ideas of the bourgeoisie that trickles down to the proletariats, are from the "dominant material relationships" (169) in society. In summary, Marx inverts Plato and Hegel 's ideologies by rejecting the concept of God and that it is only human nature that drives

Read More
1584 Words | 7 Pages

This sociological study will analyze the problem of commodity fetishism in American consumer culture. Karl Marx’s theory of commodity fetishism is a major problem in the United States due to the inability of consumers to see the intrinsic value of a commodity. American consumer culture tends to become trapped in the “magical qualities” of a product, which makes them unable to understand the object as it was made by a laborer. This abstraction of the commodity is part of Marx’s analysis of capitalist products that is separated from the labor and become valuable objects in and of themselves. This is an important sociological perspective on commodities, which creates an irrational consumer culture in the American marketplace.

Read More
527 Words | 3 Pages

Klein is able to prove her claim by using historical evidence and well-known companies to prove her claim that businesses have left behind selling products in exchange for selling brands. Klein most effective method of proving her claim in this essay is her use of historical evidence. She begins by explaining how things were in the original days of advertising. Klein describes this, not as branding, but as a way of making their products known. The next big step in the history of branding came during the industrial revolution.

Read More
1513 Words | 7 Pages

This is related to individuals need for counter-conformity (moving away from conformity) which is defined as the establishment of a group opinion norm and the tendency of individuals to comply with that norm (Burnkrant & Cousineau, 1975; Nail, 1986). It was seen that consumers buy and use possessions to develop a personal image that is different from others in the society (Lynn & Harris, 1997; Richins, 1994). This need for being different and unique manifests itself in the search for and the use of unique possessions. The acquisition of unique and scarce products is an on-going process because when scarce products become more available in the market and more people use them, they lose their unique scarcity attribute. Accordingly, uniqueness is related with the scarcity of a product (Snyder, 1992, p. 20; Tian & McKenzie, 2001) and consumers continuously look for other products to differentiate themselves from

Read More

More about Sturken And Cartwright's Commodity Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document